A meta-analytic review of impact of measurement choice on RCTs to reduce appearance internalization.

OBJECTIVE: Prior reviews have shown that interventions targeting internalization of appearance standards are generally efficacious, though there is considerable heterogeneity in estimates across studies. This updated review of the literature evaluates whether efficacy estimates from RCTs systematically vary as a function of three related outcome measures (internalization, awareness, and perceived pressure regarding appearance standards). METHODS: Seven electronic databases were systematically searched from inception to February 8, 2023. The Cochrane Risk of Bias tool assessed each study's risk of bias. Studies included were randomized-controlled trials evaluating body image/eating disorder prevention or intervention programs targeting internalization as a focal point of treatment. Effect sizes were meta-analyzed and meta-regression analyses were conducted investigating the impact of outcome measure choice on study effect size at post-intervention and follow-up. RESULTS: Thirty-seven studies (N = 4809 participants) were included. The meta-analytic findings as expected found interventions efficacious at reducing internalization post-intervention (d = -0.47, 95% CI [-0.60 to -0.34], k = 44), and at follow-up (d = -0.28, 95% CI [-0.39 to -0.17], k = 43), but also highly heterogenous (I2 = 52-67%). Operationalization of internalization moderated results at follow-up but not post-intervention timepoints, with awareness measures (compared with internalization measures) producing weaker effect sizes. Exploratory analyses found bigger effects when internalization was compared with all other measurement categories combined, suggesting possible issues with statistical power in main analyses. DISCUSSION: Mixed present findings suggest need for further evaluation of measurement effects on efficacy, and possible caution in choice of outcome measure for internalization-based interventions. PUBLIC SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: This review provides some preliminary evidence that choice of survey measures used in randomized controlled trials can impact our judgments about whether a trial reduces the extent to which participants endorse unrealistic appearance standards. Accuracy in measurement of this efficacy of trials is crucial, given the role that internalized appearance standards play in onset and maintenance of eating disorders.

OBJETIVO: Las revisiones anteriores han demostrado que las intervenciones dirigidas a la internalización de los estándares de apariencia son generalmente eficaces, aunque existe una heterogeneidad considerable en las estimaciones entre los estudios. Esta revisión actualizada de la bibliografía evalúa si las estimaciones de eficacia de los ECA varían sistemáticamente en función de tres medidas de resultado relacionadas (internalización, conciencia y presión percibida con respecto a los estándares de apariencia). MÉTODO: Se realizaron búsquedas sistemáticas en siete bases de datos electrónicas desde su inicio hasta el 8 de febrero de 2023. La herramienta Cochrane Risk of Bias evaluó el riesgo de sesgo de cada estudio. Los estudios incluidos fueron ensayos controlados aleatorios (ECA) que evaluaron la prevención de la imagen corporal/trastornos alimentarios o programas de intervención dirigidos a la internalización como punto focal del tratamiento. Se metanalizaron los tamaños del efecto y se realizaron análisis de metarregresión que investigaron la repercusión de la elección de la medida de resultado sobre el tamaño del efecto del estudio después de la intervención y el seguimiento. RESULTADOS: Se incluyeron treinta y siete estudios (N = 4 809 participantes). Los hallazgos metaanalíticos como era de esperarse encontraron intervenciones eficaces para reducir la internalización después de la intervención (d = -0,47, IC del 95% [-0,60 a -0,34], k = 44) y en el seguimiento (d = -0,28, IC del 95% [-0,39 a -0,17], k = 43), pero también altamente heterogéneas (I2 = 52-67%). La operacionalización de la internalización moderó los resultados en los puntos temporales de seguimiento pero no en posteriores a la intervención, y las medidas de sensibilización (en comparación con las medidas de internalización) produjeron tamaños del efecto más débiles. Los análisis exploratorios encontraron mayores efectos cuando la internalización se comparó con todas las demás categorías de medición combinadas, lo que sugiere posibles problemas con el poder estadístico en los análisis principales. DISCUSIÓN: Los hallazgos actuales mixtos sugieren la necesidad de una evaluación adicional de los efectos de la medición sobre la eficacia, y la posible precaución en la elección de la medida de resultado para las intervenciones basadas en la internalización.

Validation of an Italian version of the Sociocultural Attitudes Towards Appearance Questionnaire-4-Revised (SATAQ-4R) on non-clinical Italian women and men.

Appearance-ideal internalization and appearance pressures are empirically-supported risk factors for body image disturbance and disordered eating in Western countries. Such a relationship has emerged also in the Italian context, where high rates of body dissatisfaction and disordered eating are present. The Sociocultural Attitudes Towards Appearance Questionnaire (SATAQ) and its revisions are among the most commonly used instruments to assess the role of sociocultural influences on body image. Two studies were conducted to examine the psychometric properties of the female (Study 1, N = 732) and male (Study 2, N = 364) Italian versions of the SATAQ-4-Revised (SATAQ-4R-Female, SATAQ-4R-Male). Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) indicated that the original seven-factor structure was replicated for women and men. The seven subscales (Internalization: Thin/Low Body Fat; Internalization: Muscular; Internalization: General Attractiveness; Pressures: Family; Pressures: Peers; Pressures: Significant Others; and Pressures: Media) showed good internal consistency and 4-week test-retest reliability. Associations between SATAQ-4R subscales and body dissatisfaction, eating disorder symptomatology, drive for muscularity, self-esteem, family influences, and peer influences, suggested good convergent validity among both women and men. The present study provides evidence for the validity and reliability of the male and female Italian versions of the SATAQ-4R.

Internalized weight bias and psychological wellbeing: An exploratory investigation of a preliminary model.

Although a growing body of literature demonstrates negative effects of internalized weight bias (IWB), the relationships between IWB and relevant social, psychological, and behavioral variables have not yet been evaluated systematically. The purpose of the present study was to create and assess a model of hypothesized risks and outcomes of IWB. In an online survey, 650 adult males and females completed self-report measures of IWB, self-esteem, weight-related stigma experiences, body-related shame, body satisfaction, societal influence on body image, appearance comparisons, binge eating, distress, and weight-related quality of life. The originally hypothesized model did not provide an adequate fit to the data. Iterative modifications were undertaken, and the resulting model, in which social factors were associated with IWB and body image-related constructs which were in turn associated with psychological and behavioral outcomes, provided excellent fit to the data (CFI > .99, SRMR = .02, and RMSEA = .03). Most model paths were similar for underweight or normal weight participants versus participants with overweight or obesity. This study represents an initial effort at constructing a comprehensive model of IWB that can be further refined in future research and used to help guide the development of related interventions.

Exploring enhanced menu labels' influence on fast food selections and exercise-related attitudes, perceptions, and intentions.

Labeling restaurant menus with calorie counts is a popular public health intervention, but research shows these labels have small, inconsistent effects on behavior. Supplementing calorie counts with physical activity equivalents may produce stronger results, but few studies of these enhanced labels have been conducted, and the labels' potential to influence exercise-related outcomes remains unexplored. This online study evaluated the impact of no information, calories-only, and calories plus equivalent miles of walking labels on fast food item selection and exercise-related attitudes, perceptions, and intentions. Participants (N = 643) were randomly assigned to a labeling condition and completed a menu ordering task followed by measures of exercise-related outcomes. The labels had little effect on ordering behavior, with no significant differences in total calories ordered and counterintuitive increases in calories ordered in the two informational conditions in some item categories. The labels also had little impact on the exercise-related outcomes, though participants in the two informational conditions perceived exercise as less enjoyable than did participants in the no information condition, and trends following the same pattern were found for other exercise-related outcomes. The present findings concur with literature demonstrating small, inconsistent effects of current menu labeling strategies and suggest that alternatives such as traffic light systems should be explored.

A content analysis of healthy living blogs: evidence of content thematically consistent with dysfunctional eating attitudes and behaviors.

OBJECTIVE: "Healthy" living blogs are a recent addition to internet media that offer advice on improving physical and mental health. Often, these sites include information on eating, exercise, and self-image. This study was a content analysis designed to evaluate the information included on these sites. METHOD: A sample of 21 blogs was selected from a larger sample for evaluation. These blogs were chosen based on two criteria: they had won an award for healthy blogs and they had a large number of pageviews (pageviews were calculated using a web analytics website). Two raters (kappa reliability = 0.82) rated these blogs on multiple variables related to the blogger's characteristics, the content provided by the blogger, and entries posted on the blog. RESULTS: Five of the bloggers self-identified as having had an eating disorder; seven mentioned difficulties with either menstruation or fertility; 11 referenced being on a diet; five indicated that they were using some form of dietary restraint; and 11 included some form of written negative/guilt-inducing message about food. Blog entries and About Me sections contained a variety of content indicative of problematic eating and body image information. DISCUSSION: These findings suggest the content of healthy living blogs might be problematic for viewers who have eating or body image issues. The content does not approach the inflammatory nature of pro-eating disorder websites, yet information promoted clearly indicates that future research should further evaluate these sites.

Fear of negative appearance evaluation: development and evaluation of a new construct for risk factor work in the field of eating disorders.

The psychometric properties and correlates of a measure designed to assess fear of negative appearance evaluation are presented. In Study 1, 165 college females completed the Fear of Negative Appearance Evaluation Scale [FNAES; Thomas, C.M., Keery, H., Williams, R., & Thompson, J. K. (1998, November). The Fear of Negative Appearance Evaluation Scale: Development and preliminary validation. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for the Advancement of Behavior Therapy, Washington, DC] along with measures of body image, eating disturbance, and depression. Results replicated previous analyses indicating the presence of a single factor, good internal consistency, and significant association with measures of body image and eating disturbance. Additionally, the FNAES accounted for unique variance beyond that explained by general fear of negative evaluation, and other measures of body image and eating disturbance, in the prediction of body shape dysphoria, dietary restraint, and trait anxiety. Study 2 further examined the validity of the FNAES, finding it to correlate significantly with measures of social physique anxiety, body image, eating attitude, and mood. The FNAES did not significantly correlate with body mass index (BMI). Regression analyses found the FNAES to predict levels of body image, eating attitude, and mood beyond variance explained by social physique anxiety. The FNAES appears to measure a conceptually unique aspect of body image that has not been indexed by previous measures and may serve a useful role in risk factor and preventive work.