Soluble ectodomain of rabies virus glycoprotein expressed in eukaryotic cells folds in a monomeric conformation that is antigenically distinct from the native state of the complete, membrane-anchored glycoprotein.

Rabies virus glycoprotein (G) is a trimeric type I transmembrane glycoprotein that mediates both virus receptor recognition and low pH-induced membrane fusion. G can assume three different states: the 'native' state (N) detected at the virus surface, which is responsible for receptor binding, the activated hydrophobic state (A), which interacts with the target membrane as a first step in the fusion process, and the fusion-inactive conformation (I). These three states, which are structurally different, are in a pH-dependent equilibrium. This equilibrium is shifted toward the I state at low pH. This paper includes an investigation of the structure of the ectodomain of the PV strain of rabies virus when it is synthesized as a soluble form (G1-439) lacking the transmembrane and intracytoplasmic domains (residues 440-505). It is shown that, whatever the extracellular pH, G1-439 is secreted as a monomer that has the antigenic characteristics of the I state. This I-like state is not acquired in the acidic compartments of the Golgi but directly in the endoplasmic reticulum. Finally, membrane anchorage by the G transmembrane domain (G1-461) is sufficient for the G ectodomain to be folded into the native N form. These results emphasize the role of the G transmembrane domain in the correct folding of the ectodomain.

Rabies virus-induced membrane fusion.

Rabies virus is a member of the rhabdovirus family. It enters cells by a process of receptor mediated endocytosis. Following this step, the viral envelope fuses with the endosomal membrane to allow release of the viral nucleocapsid into the cytoplasm. Fusion is induced by the low pH of the endosomal compartment and is mediated by the single viral glycoprotein G, a homotrimeric integral membrane protein. Rabies virus fusion properties are related to different conformational states of G. By different biochemical and biophysical approaches, it has been demonstrated that G can assume at least three different states: the native (N) state detected at the viral surface above pH 7, the activated (A) hydrophobic state which interacts with the target membrane as a first step of the fusion process, and the fusion inactive (I) conformation. Differently from other fusogenic viruses for which low pH-induced conformational changes are irreversible, there is a pH dependent equilibrium between these states, the equilibrium being shifted toward the I-state at low pH. The objective of this review is to detail recent findings on rhabdovirus-induced membrane fusion and to underline the differences that exist between this viral family and influenza virus which is the best known fusogenic virus. These differences have to be taken into consideration if one wants to have a global understanding of virus-induced membrane fusion.

Low-affinity nerve-growth factor receptor (P75NTR) can serve as a receptor for rabies virus.

A random-primed cDNA expression library constructed from the mRNA of neuroblastoma cells (NG108) was used to clone a specific rabies virus (RV) receptor. A soluble form of the RV glycoprotein (Gs) was utilized as a ligand to detect positive cells. We identified the murine low-affinity nerve-growth factor receptor, p75NTR. BSR cells stably expressing p75NTR were able to bind Gs and G-expressing lepidopteran cells. The ability of the RV glycoprotein to bind p75NTR was dependent on the presence of a lysine and arginine in positions 330 and 333 respectively of antigenic site III, which is known to control virus penetration into motor and sensory neurons of adult mice. P75NTR-expressing BSR cells were permissive for a non-adapted fox RV isolate (street virus) and nerve growth factor (NGF) decreased this infection. In infected cells, p75NTR associates with the RV glycoprotein and could be precipitated with anti-G monoclonal antibodies. Therefore, p75NTR is a receptor for street RV.

Neuronal cell surface molecules mediate specific binding to rabies virus glycoprotein expressed by a recombinant baculovirus on the surfaces of lepidopteran cells.

The existence of specific rabies virus (RV) glycoprotein (G) binding sites on the surfaces of neuroblastoma cells is demonstrated. Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf21) cells expressing G of the RV strain CVS (Gcvs-Sf21 cells) bind specifically to neuroblastoma cells of different species but not to any other cell type (fibroblast, myoblast, epithelial, or glioma). Attachment to mouse neuroblastoma NG108-15 cells is abolished by previous treatment of Gcvs-Sf2 cells with anti-G antibody. Substitutions for lysine at position 330 and for arginine at position 333 in RV G greatly reduce interaction between Gcvs-Sf21 cells and NG108-15 cells. These data are consistent with in vivo results: an avirulent RV mutant bearing the same double mutation is not able to infect sensory neurons or motoneurons (P. Coulon, J.-P. Ternaux, A. Flamand, and C. Tuffereau, J. Virol. 72:273-278, 1998) after intramuscular inoculation into a mouse. Furthermore, infection of NG108-15 cells by RV but not by vesicular stomatitis virus leads to a reduction of the number of binding sites at the neuronal-cell surface. Our data strongly suggest that these specific attachment sites on neuroblastoma cells represent a neuronal receptor(s) used by RV to infect certain types of neurons in vivo.

An avirulent mutant of rabies virus is unable to infect motoneurons in vivo and in vitro.

An antigenic double mutant of rabies virus (challenge virus standard [CVS] strain) was selected by successive use of two neutralizing antiglycoprotein monoclonal antibodies, both specific for antigenic site III. This mutant differed from the original virus strain by two amino acid substitutions in the ectodomain of the glycoprotein. The lysine in position 330 and the arginine in position 333 were replaced by asparagine and methionine, respectively. This double mutant was not pathogenic for adult mice. When injected intramuscularly into the forelimbs of adult mice, this virus could not penetrate the nervous system, either by the motor or by the sensory route, while respective single mutants infected motoneurons in the spinal cord and sensory neurons in the dorsal root ganglia. In vitro experiments showed that the double mutant was able to infect BHK cells, neuroblastoma cells, and freshly prepared embryonic motoneurons, albeit with a lower efficiency than the CVS strain. Upon further incubation at 37 degrees C, the motoneurons became resistant to infection by the mutant while remaining permissive to CVS infection. These results suggest that rabies virus uses different types of receptors: a molecule which is ubiquitously expressed at the surface of continuous cell lines and which is recognized by both CVS and the double mutant and a neuron-specific molecule which is not recognized by the double mutant.

Biological function of the low-pH, fusion-inactive conformation of rabies virus glycoprotein (G): G is transported in a fusion-inactive state-like conformation.

The glycoprotein (G) of rabies virus can assume at least three different conformations: the native (N) state detected at the viral surface above pH 7; the activated (A) hydrophobic state, which is probably involved in the first steps of the fusion process; and the fusion-inactive (I) conformation. There is a pH-dependent equilibrium between these states, the equilibrium being shifted towards the I state at low pH. It has been supposed that the transition from the N to the I state mediates membrane fusion. By using a lipid-mixing assay, we studied the kinetics of fusion and fusion inactivation for two rabies virus strains, PV and CVS. In addition, by using electron microscopy and a trypsin sensitivity assay, we analyzed the kinetics of the conformational change towards the I state for both strains. Although the PV strain fuses faster, inactivation and the conformational change of PV G occur more slowly than for the CVS strain. This suggests that the structural transition towards the I state is irrelevant to the fusion process. Immunofluorescence and immunoprecipitation experiments performed with infected cells and two different monoclonal antibodies, one specific for the N form of G and one which recognizes both the N and the I states, suggest that G is transported in an I state-like conformation through the Golgi apparatus and acquires its N structure only near or at the cell surface. We propose that the role of the I state is to avoid unspecific fusion during transport of G in the acidic Golgi vesicles.

Vaccination against rabies: construction and characterization of SAG2, a double avirulent derivative of SADBern.

A double avirulent mutant was isolated from the SADBern strain of rabies virus by two successive selection steps using neutralizing anti-glycoprotein monoclonal antibodies. Both mutations affect the triplet coding for amino acid 333 of the glycoprotein. The resulting virus, called SAG2, has a glutamate coded by GAA in position 333 instead of an arginine. This new codon differs by two nucleotides from all the arginine triplets. SAG2 is avirulent in adult mice by intracerebral and intramuscular routes and it protects mice against a challenge by the CVS strain. This double mutant is still avirulent after three successive passages in suckling mouse brain or after ten successive cycles of multiplication in cell culture. Because it is protective and genetically stable, SAG2 represents an improvement on SAG1 which is already used for oral vaccination of foxes in Switzerland and France. It could also be a candidate for oral vaccination of dogs against rabies.

Avirulent mutants of rabies virus and their use as live vaccine.

Oral vaccination of foxes against rabies began in Switzerland some 20 years ago and was later extended to several European countries. The vaccine strains, which were derivatives of the SAD strain of rabies, retain a non-negligible pathogenicity for rodents and nontarget species. Antigenic mutants of the SAD Bern vaccine strain, which are avirulent for adult mice, foxes and dogs, have been isolated and are presently under trial.

Rabies virus glycoprotein is a trimer.

The oligomerization state of the rabies virus envelope glycoprotein (G protein) was determined using electron microscopy and sedimentation analysis of detergent solubilized G. Most of the detergents used in this study solubilized G in a 4 S monomeric form. However, when CHAPS was used, G had a sedimentation coefficient of 9 S. This high sedimentation coefficient allowed its further separation from M1 and M2. Using electron microscopy of negatively stained samples, we studied the morphology of G on virus and after detergent extraction. End-on views of G on virus clearly showed triangles consisting of three dots indicating the trimeric nature of native G. End-on views of CHAPS-isolated G showed very similar triangles confirming that, using this detergent, G was solubilized in its native trimeric structure. Electron microscopy also showed that G had a "head" and a "stalk" and provided the basis for a low-resolution model of the glycoprotein structure.

Rapid sequence evolution of street rabies glycoprotein is related to the highly heterogeneous nature of the viral population.

The sequence of the glycoprotein gene of a street rabies virus was determined directly using fragments of a rabid dog brain after PCR amplification. Compared with that of the prototype strain CVS, this sequence displayed 10% divergence in overall amino acid composition. However only 6% divergence was noted in the ectodomain suggesting that structural constraints are exerted on this portion of the glycoprotein. A human strain isolated on cell culture from the saliva of a patient with clinical rabies had only five amino acid differences with the canine isolate, an indication of their close relatedness. These differences could have originated during transmission from dog to dog, or from dog to man, or during isolation on cell culture; they are nonetheless indicative of a genetic evolution of street rabies virus. This evolution was further evidenced by the selection of cell-adapted variants which displayed new amino acid substitutions in the glycoprotein. One of them concerned antigenic site III where arginine at position 333 was replaced by glutamine. As expected this substitution conferred resistance to a site IIIa monoclonal antibody (MAb), but surprisingly did not abolish neurovirulence for adult mice. However, a decrease in the neurovirulence of the cell-adapted variant in the presence of a site IIIa specific MAb was noted, suggesting that neurovirulence was due to a subpopulation neutralizable by the MAb. Simultaneous presence of both the parental and variant sequences was indeed evidenced in the brain of a mouse inoculated with the cell-adapted variant; during multiplication in the mouse brain, the frequency of the parental sequence rose from less than 10% to nearly 50%, indicating the selective advantage conferred by arginine 333 in nervous tissue. Altogether these results were suggestive of an intrinsic heterogeneity of street rabies virus. This heterogeneity was further demonstrated by the sequencing of molecular clones of the glycoprotein gene, which revealed that only one-third of the viral genomes present in the brain of a rabid dog had the consensus sequence. Two-thirds of the clones analyzed displayed from one to three amino acid substitutions. Such heterogeneous populations have been referred to as quasispecies, a concept which implies heterogeneous populations kept together in a dynamic equilibrium. This equilibrium could be rapidly displaced, giving the virus the capacity to adapt easily to new environmental conditions.

Reversible conformational changes and fusion activity of rabies virus glycoprotein.

In an attempt to understand the implication of the rabies virus glycoprotein (G) in the first steps of the viral cycle, we studied the pH dependence of virus-induced fusion and hemagglutination, as well as modifications of the structure and properties of the viral glycoprotein following pH acidification. Our results suggest that the G protein adopts at least three distinct configurations, each associated with different properties. At neutral pH, G did not fuse membranes or hemagglutinate erythrocytes. It was insensitive to digestion with bromelain and trypsin. At pH 6.4, the glycoprotein became sensitive to proteases. Hemagglutination was at its maximum and then sharply decreased with the pH. No fusion was detected. Aggregation of virus was also observed. The third configuration, at below pH 6.1, was associated with the appearance of fusion. Some neutralizing monoclonal antibodies were able to differentiate these three configurations. Preincubation of the virus at below pH 6 inhibited fusion, but this inhibition, like the structural modifications of the glycoprotein, was reversible when G was reincubated at neutral pH.

Fatty acylation of rabies virus proteins.

The fatty acylation of rabies virus (CVS strain) proteins was investigated. [3H]palmitic acid was found to be incorporated into the glycoprotein G and to a lesser extent into the membrane-associated protein M2. The fatty acid linkage on G was sensitive to sodium borohydride, mercaptoethanol, and hydroxylamine, indicating that the linkage was of the thiolester type. Bromelain digestion indicated that the palmitoylation site on G was located in the intracytoplasmic domain or in the transmembrane domain in which there is only one cysteine in position 461. Therefore, palmitoylation is likely to occur at this position. In the case of M2, the linkage was also sensitive to hydroxylamine and sodium borohydride and to a lesser extent to mercaptoethanol, suggesting that the linkage also occurred on a cysteine.

Antigenicity of rabies virus glycoprotein.

Although the number of antigenic sites on the rabies virus glycoprotein that have been described regularly increases with time, no attempt has been made to carefully evaluate the relative importance of each of these sites. Here we provide a more precise description of the antigenicity of the protein in mice of the H-2d haplotype; we developed this description by using 264 newly isolated monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) and a collection of neutralization-resistant (MAR) mutants. Most of the MAbs (97%) recognized antigenic sites previously described as II and III. One minor antigenic site separated from site III by three amino acids, including a proline, was identified (minor site a). Despite their proximity, there is no overlap between site III and minor site a; i.e., site III-specific MAR mutants were neutralized by the six MAbs defining minor site a, and vice versa. One of our MAbs, 1D1, reacted with sodium dodecyl sulfate-treated glycoprotein in Western blots (immunoblots) under reducing conditions and was therefore probably directed against a linear epitope, A MAR mutant selected with this MAb was still neutralized by MAbs of other specificities. This linear epitope was called G1 (G, Gif). As a general rule, we propose to reserve the term "antigenic site" (either major or minor) for regions of the protein which are defined by several MAbs originating from different fusions and to describe regions of the protein which are defined by a single MAb as epitopes. It would be interesting to test whether the same regions of the rabies virus glycoprotein are antigenic in mice of different haplotypes or in other species.

Oral immunization of foxes with avirulent rabies virus mutants.

SAG1, a rabies virus strain bearing one mutation which abolishes virulence for adult animals, was constructed from the SADBern strain of rabies virus which has previously been used as live vaccine for oral immunization of foxes. SAG1 also bears an antigenic mutation which serves as an additional marker of the strain. Studies on mice and four species of wild rodents showed that SAG1 is totally avirulent whereas SADBern is still pathogenic after intracerebral, intramuscular or oral inoculation and thus could cause cases of rabies. Trials of oral vaccination performed on foxes with SAG1 indicate that it is as effective as SADBern. The SAG1 strain represents a significant progress in the search for an efficient and safe live rabies for the oral immunization of wild animals.

Arginine or lysine in position 333 of ERA and CVS glycoprotein is necessary for rabies virulence in adult mice.

Fixed rabies virus strains (ERA and CVS) produce a fatal paralytic disease in mice after intracerebral or intramuscular injection. Some antigenic mutants of both CVS and ERA viruses with a substitution in position 333 of the glycoprotein (arginine is replaced either by a glutamine, a glycine, or an isoleucine) are totally avirulent for adult mice whatever the dose and the route of inoculation. Here we report an exhaustive investigation of the effect of amino acid 333 on viral virulence. New antigenic mutants were isolated from either CVS, CVS derivatives, or SADBern having arginine in position 333 encoded by CGG, AGG, CGU, or AGA respectively. This study shows that when arginine is replaced by either a leucine, an isoleucine, a methionine, a cysteine, or a serine, the antigenic mutant is also totally avirulent. But when arginine is replaced by a lysine it is still pathogenic although the LD50 by the intracerebral route is higher. Furthermore 41 independent virulent revertants were isolated from four avirulent mutants (with a glycine, a glutamine, a methionine, or a serine in position 333 of the glycoprotein). Thirty-nine regained an arginine at position 333 and 2 had a lysine. From this analysis it appears that the presence of a positively charged amino acid (arginine or lysine) in position 333 of the glycoprotein is necessary for viral virulence.

Direct adverse effects of Sendai virus DI particles on virus budding and on M protein fate and stability.

Upon infections of BHK cells with a mixture of Sendai standard and defective interfering (DI) viruses (mixed virus infection), viral budding was found to be restricted by factors ranging from 5 to more than 20. The reduced viral budding correlated with a high intracellular M protein turnover. M appeared to be degraded shortly after its synthesis, and seemed not to be able to self-associate in a stable way under the plasma membrane as it did in St virus-infected cells. These data, added to the previous findings that infection with DI particles allowed infected cell survival and favored the cell-surface turnover of the hemagglutinin-neuraminidase protein, led to the hypothesis that DI genomes directly act by preventing the stable formation inside the cells of a viral structure composed of M/HN/nucleocapsids. When involved in this structure M would be protected from degradation and HN would be stably anchored in the plasma membrane. Formation of this structure would be necessary for viral budding and would be damaging for the cells. Comparison with results published by other authors shows that such a model is consistent with other data. It can integrate, as well, data obtained in the analysis of mutant viruses involved in persistence.

Reduced temperature can block different glycoproteins at different steps during transport to the plasma membrane.

Reduced temperature has been shown to block the cell surface expression of Sendai virus haemagglutinin-neuraminidase (HN) and fusion (F0) glycoproteins at different steps of their intracellular transport. At 20 degrees C, HN was confined to the rough endoplasmic reticulum or cis Golgi compartment, while F0 acquired complete resistance to digestion by endo-beta-N-acetylglucosaminidase-H and therefore was blocked at a more distal location in the pathway of cell surface expression. The significance of these results for different pathways of transport to the cell surface is discussed.

The role of haemagglutinin-neuraminidase glycoprotein cell surface expression in the survival of Sendai virus-infected BHK-21 cells.

A temperature-sensitive mutant of Sendai virus with a lesion in the haemagglutinin-neuraminidase protein (HN) (ts 271) was used to study the effect of HN cell surface expression on the fate of infected BHK-21 cells. The total amount of HN was reduced in ts 271 virus-infected cells at the non-permissive temperature (38 degrees C) presumably due to degradation of the protein. At this temperature, neither HN nor a modified form of HN were found expressed at the surface of the infected cells. BHK-21 cells infected with ts 271 were nevertheless killed by the infection at 38 degrees C as well as at 30 degrees C. These results ruled out the hypothesis that the lack of HN cell surface expression could be the unique requirement allowing BHK cell survival.

Phosphorylation of the N and M1 proteins of rabies virus.

Phosphorylation of rabies virus proteins was followed in vivo and in vitro. The N and M1 proteins were both found to be phosphorylated. The M1 protein was present in the virion in two phosphorylated states, but only the hypophosphorylated form of M1 was found in infected cells. The hypothesis that some of the M1 molecules become hyperphosphorylated during the maturation process by a membrane-bound kinase was examined. The phosphorylation of the viral proteins by the kinase present in purified rabies virions was studied using an in vitro transcriptase assay: under the conditions of the assay, additional phosphate groups were rapidly attached to the N protein. The M1 protein was similarly hyperphosphorylated although more slowly. Whether the hyperphosphorylation of the N protein is responsible for the poor efficiency of the in vitro transcriptase reaction is not clear. No detectable change in the phosphorylation of cellular proteins was observed in the course of rabies virus infection.