Rational design of antiviral drug combinations based on equipotency using HCV subgenomic replicon as an in vitro model.

Combination therapy of directly acting antivirals (DAA's) for the treatment of chronic HCV infections has proven to be a highly effective strategy to cure chronic infections with this virus. Here we studied, using HCV as an example, how to best design in vitro studies that explore the combined antiviral efficiency of combinations of three or more DAA's. To that end we used a HCV NS3 protease inhibitor, a NS5A targeting compound and two non-nucleoside NS5B polymerase inhibitors (each one targeting a different drug binding site). We demonstrate, employing HCV subgenomic replicon containing Huh 9-13 hepatoma cells, that quadruple therapy with these 4 different DAA's each at 1x their EC75, results in a highly efficient inhibition of viral replication. This is further reflected in the rapid clearance of the HCV replicon from the host cell. By contrast, neither equipotent combinations that consist of either molecules alone at 4x EC75 nor triple combinations at 1.33x the EC75 resulted in clearance. In contrast to the quadruple combo, drug-resistant variants emerged under mono-treatment and in most triple combo's. These data thus demonstrate that quadruple combinations at total suboptimal concentrations [i.e. concentrations at which neither mono- nor triple therapy is sufficiently potent] result rapidly in a pronounced antiviral efficacy. Altogether, this work provides an example as to how to design studies to explore the antiviral efficacy of combinations of more than two compounds.

In vitro combinations containing Tegobuvir are highly efficient in curing cells from HCV replicon and in delaying/preventing the development of drug resistance.

Tegobuvir (GS-9190) is a non-nucleoside inhibitor of HCV RNA replication with proven antiviral activity in HCV-infected patients. The in vitro antiviral activity of Tegobuvir, when combined with one or two other direct acting antivirals (DAA) was assessed. When Tegobuvir was combined with either interferon α-2b, ribavirin, the protease inhibitor (PI) VX-950, the nucleoside polymerase inhibitor (NI) 2'-C-methylcytidine or various non-nucleoside polymerase inhibitors, an overall additive antiviral activity was observed. Adding Tegobuvir (at concentrations of 6, 30 or 150nM) to replicon-containing cells in the presence of suboptimal concentrations of the PI or of the various polymerase inhibitors either markedly delayed or completely prevented resistance development against these latter compounds. Tegobuvir (15nM), when combined with the PI, was able to cure replicon-containing cells from their replicon after a single passage, whereas either compound alone (at 2-fold higher concentration) was not. The triple combination of Tegobuvir (10nM), the PI and the NI resulted in clearance of replicon RNA after only two passages. In contrast, the inhibitors when used alone at 3-fold higher concentrations were not able to cure the cells from the replicon, after as long as 6 passages. Combinations containing low concentrations of Tegobuvir are thus highly effective in curing cells from HCV replicon and in delaying or preventing the development of resistance against other DAA.

Selecting and characterizing drug-resistant hepatitis C virus replicon.

The current standard of care (SOC) for hepatitis C virus (HCV) genotype 1-infected patients consists of telaprevir or boceprevir in addition to pegylated interferon and ribavirin treatment. Other selective inhibitors of HCV replication are being developed. Drug pressure may, depending on the class of inhibitors, (rapidly) select for drug-resistant variants. Here we describe four different approaches to select in vitro for drug-resistant HCV subgenomic replicons.

Hepatitis C virus-specific directly acting antiviral drugs.

The major targets for direct-acting antivirals (DAAs) are the NS3/4A protease, the NS5A protein, and the NS5B polymerase. The latter enzyme offers several target sites: the catalytic domain for nucleoside/nucleotide analogs and different allosteric sites for non-nucleoside inhibitors. Two protease inhibitors have already been approved and more than 40 new NS3/4A, NS5A, or NS5B inhibitors are in development pipeline. Not only these agents can achieve very high cure rates when combined with PEG-IFN and RBV, but have also started to provide promising results when combined in IFN-free, all-oral combinations. In addition to the more canonical drug targets, new alternative viral targets for small molecule drug development are emerging, such as p7 or NS4B. Current research is focusing on defining the most efficacious DAA combination regimens, i.e., those which provide the highest rates of viral eradication, broadest spectrum of action, minimal or no clinical resistance, shortest treatment duration, and good tolerability.

Coumarins hinged directly on benzimidazoles and their ribofuranosides to inhibit hepatitis C virus.

A new compound library that contained 20 hinged benzimidazole-coumarin hybrids and their ß-d-ribofuranosides was established. The anti-hepatitis C virus (HCV) activity of all novel coumarin derivatives, which were obtained by use of organic synthetic methods, was tested. Two of these hybrids exhibited appealing EC50 values of as low as 3.0 and 5.5 µM. The best selectivity index was 14. The incorporation of a d-ribofuranose into the hinged hybrids provided the corresponding nucleosides with the ß configuration, one of which inhibited HCV replication with an EC50 value of 20 µM. Additionally, the structure-activity relationship is elucidated on the basis of the functional groups that were attached to the nuclei of benzimidazole, coumarin, and ribofuranose of the hybrids.

In vitro selection and characterization of HCV replicons resistant to multiple non-nucleoside polymerase inhibitors.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: To delay or prevent the selection of HCV drug-resistant variants, combination therapy will be needed. Our aim was to determine the antiviral efficacy of various combinations of non-nucleoside polymerase inhibitors (NNI) (that have a different allosteric binding site) and the barrier towards resistance development of such combinations. METHODS: Short-term antiviral combination assays were performed in a checkerboard format. Resistance selection experiments employing HCV replicons were performed using two different protocols: (i) a short-term treatment with fixed concentrations and (ii) a long-term treatment with increasing concentrations. RESULTS: All pair-wise combinations of NNI resulted in an additive antiviral effect in short-term antiviral assays. Combination treatment of two NNIs markedly reduced or even prevented the emergence of double resistant colonies. However, double and even triple NNI-resistant variants emerged readily when relatively low starting concentrations were used in a long-term selection protocol. Genotyping confirmed the presence of the previously published resistance mutations. For some NNI, different signature mutations appeared depending on the other NNI in the particular combination. Remarkably, variants that were selected to be resistant to three different classes of NNIs [a thiophene carboxylic acid (TCA), a benzimidazole (JT-16), and a benzofuran (HCV-796)] proved resistant to yet a fourth class of NNIs (benzothiadiazines). CONCLUSIONS: Double and even triple NNI-resistant HCV replicons can be readily selected with a stepwise resistance selection protocol. Depending on the particular combination, different signature mutations may arise for some NNI. Resistance to three classes of NNI resulted in resistance to yet a fourth class.

Deletion of the vaccinia virus F13L gene results in a highly attenuated virus that mounts a protective immune response against subsequent vaccinia virus challenge.

Vaccinia virus F13L encodes the envelope protein p37, which is the target of the anti-pox virus drug ST-246 (Yang et al., 2005) and that is required for production of extracellular vaccinia virus. The F13L (p37)-deleted (and ST-246 resistant) vaccinia virus recombinant (Vac-ΔF13L) produced smaller plaques than the wild-type vaccinia (Western Reserve vaccinia). In addition, Vac-ΔF13L proved, when inoculated either intravenously or intracutaneously in both immunocompetent and immunodeficient (athymic nude or SCID) mice, to be severely attenuated. Intravenous or intracutaneous inoculation of immunocompetent mice with the ΔF13L virus efficiently protected against a subsequent intravenous, intracutaneous or intranasal challenge with vaccinia WR (Western Reserve). This was corroborated by the observation that Vac-ΔF13L induced a humoral immune response against vaccinia following either intravenous or intracutaneous challenge. In conclusion, F13L-deleted vaccinia virus may have the potential to be developed as a smallpox vaccine.

Mechanistic characterization of GS-9190 (Tegobuvir), a novel nonnucleoside inhibitor of hepatitis C virus NS5B polymerase.

GS-9190 (Tegobuvir) is a novel imidazopyridine inhibitor of hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA replication in vitro and has demonstrated potent antiviral activity in patients chronically infected with genotype 1 (GT1) HCV. GS-9190 exhibits reduced activity against GT2a (JFH1) subgenomic replicons and GT2a (J6/JFH1) infectious virus, suggesting that the compound's mechanism of action involves a genotype-specific viral component. To further investigate the GS-9190 mechanism of action, we utilized the susceptibility differences between GT1b and GT2a by constructing a series of replicon chimeras where combinations of 1b and 2a nonstructural proteins were encoded within the same replicon. The antiviral activities of GS-9190 against the chimeric replicons were reduced to levels comparable to that of the wild-type GT2a replicon in chimeras expressing GT2a NS5B. GT1b replicons in which the ß-hairpin region (amino acids 435 to 455) was replaced by the corresponding sequence of GT2a were markedly less susceptible to GS-9190, indicating the importance of the thumb subdomain of the polymerase in this effect. Resistance selection in GT1b replicon cells identified several mutations in NS5B (C316Y, Y448H, Y452H, and C445F) that contributed to the drug resistance phenotype. Reintroduction of these mutations into wild-type replicons conferred resistance to GS-9190, with the number of NS5B mutations correlating with the degree of resistance. Analysis of GS-9190 cross-resistance against previously reported NS5B drug-selected mutations showed that the resistance pattern of GS-9190 is different from other nonnucleoside inhibitors. Collectively, these data demonstrate that GS-9190 represents a novel class of nonnucleoside polymerase inhibitors that interact with NS5B likely through involvement of the ß-hairpin in the thumb subdomain.

Comparative study of the genetic barriers and pathways towards resistance of selective inhibitors of hepatitis C virus replication.

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) inhibitors include direct-acting antivirals (DAAs) such as NS3 serine protease inhibitors, nucleoside and nonnucleoside polymerase inhibitors, and host-targeting antivirals (HTAs) such as cyclophilin inhibitors that have been developed in recent years. Drug-resistant HCV variants have been reported both in vitro and in the clinical setting for most classes of drugs. We report a comparative study in which the genetic barrier to drug resistance of a representative selection of these inhibitors is evaluated employing a number of resistance selection protocols. The NS3 protease inhibitors VX-950 and BILN 2061, the nucleoside polymerase inhibitor 2'-C-methylcytidine, three nonnucleoside polymerase inhibitors (thiophene carboxylic acid, benzimidazole, and benzothiadiazine), and DEB025 were included. For each drug and passage in the selection process, the phenotype and genotype of the drug-resistant replicon were determined. For a number of molecules (BILN 2061 and nonnucleoside inhibitors), drug-resistant variants were readily selected when wild-type replicon-containing cells were directly cultured in the presence of high concentrations of the inhibitor. Resistance to DEB025 could be selected only following a lengthy stepwise selection procedure. For some DAAs, the signature mutations that emerged under inhibitor pressure differed depending on the selection protocol that was employed. Replication fitness of resistant mutants revealed that the C445F mutation in the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase can restore loss of fitness caused by a number of unfit resistance mutations. These data provide important insights into the various pathways leading to drug resistance and allow a direct comparison of the genetic barriers of various HCV drugs.

DEB025 (Alisporivir) inhibits hepatitis C virus replication by preventing a cyclophilin A induced cis-trans isomerisation in domain II of NS5A.

DEB025/Debio 025 (Alisporivir) is a cyclophilin (Cyp)-binding molecule with potent anti-hepatitis C virus (HCV) activity both in vitro and in vivo. It is currently being evaluated in phase II clinical trials. DEB025 binds to CypA, a peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase which is a crucial cofactor for HCV replication. Here we report that it was very difficult to select resistant replicons (genotype 1b) to DEB025, requiring an average of 20 weeks (four independent experiments), compared to the typically <2 weeks with protease or polymerase inhibitors. This indicates a high genetic barrier to resistance for DEB025. Mutation D320E in NS5A was the only mutation consistently selected in the replicon genome. This mutation alone conferred a low-level (3.9-fold) resistance. Replacing the NS5A gene (but not the NS5B gene) from the wild type (WT) genome with the corresponding sequence from the DEB025(res) replicon resulted in transfer of resistance. Cross-resistance with cyclosporine A (CsA) was observed, whereas NS3 protease and NS5B polymerase inhibitors retained WT-activity against DEB025(res) replicons. Unlike WT, DEB025(res) replicon replicated efficiently in CypA knock down cells. However, DEB025 disrupted the interaction between CypA and NS5A regardless of whether the NS5A protein was derived from WT or DEB025(res) replicon. NMR titration experiments with peptides derived from the WT or the DEB025(res) domain II of NS5A corroborated this observation in a quantitative manner. Interestingly, comparative NMR studies on two 20-mer NS5A peptides that contain D320 or E320 revealed a shift in population between the major and minor conformers. These data suggest that D320E conferred low-level resistance to DEB025 probably by reducing the need for CypA-dependent isomerisation of NS5A. Prolonged DEB025 treatment and multiple genotypic changes may be necessary to generate significant resistance to DEB025, underlying the high barrier to resistance.

Statins potentiate the in vitro anti-hepatitis C virus activity of selective hepatitis C virus inhibitors and delay or prevent resistance development.

UNLABELLED: Statins are 3-hydroxyl-3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A (HMG CoA) reductase inhibitors used for the treatment of hypercholesterolemia. It was recently reported that statins inhibit in vitro hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA replication. We here report that, of five statins studied, mevastatin and simvastatin exhibit the strongest in vitro anti-HCV activity, lovastatin and fluvastatin have moderate inhibitory effects, and pravastatin is devoid of an antiviral effect. A combination of statins with interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) or HCV nonstructural (NS)5B polymerase or NS3 protease inhibitors results in an additive antiviral activity in short-term (3 days) antiviral assays. Neither statins, at a concentration of five-fold their median effective concentration (EC(50)) value, nor polymerase, protease inhibitors, or IFN-alpha, at concentrations 10- or 20-fold their EC(50) value, were able to clear cells from their replicon following four or six consecutive passages of antiviral pressure. However, the combination of HCV polymerase or protease inhibitors with mevastatin or simvastatin resulted in an efficient clearance of the cultures from their replicon. In colony formation experiments, mevastatin reduced the frequency or prevented the selection of HCV replicons resistant to the nonnucleoside inhibitor HCV-796. CONCLUSION: A combination of specific HCV inhibitors with statins may result in a more profound antiviral effect and may delay or prevent the development of resistance to such inhibitors.

Substituted imidazopyridines as potent inhibitors of HCV replication.

BACKGROUND/AIMS: Following lead optimization, a set of substituted imidazopyridines was identified as potent and selective inhibitors of in vitro HCV replication. The particular characteristics of one of the most potent compounds in this series (5-[[3-(4-chlorophenyl)-5-isoxazolyl]methyl]-2-(2,3-difluorophenyl)-5H-imidazo[4,5-c]pyridine or GS-327073), were studied. METHODS: Antiviral activity of GS-327073 was evaluated in HCV subgenomic replicons (genotypes 1b, 1a and 2a), in the JFH1 (genotype 2a) infectious system and against replicons resistant to various selective HCV inhibitors. Combination studies of GS-327073 with other selective HCV inhibitors were performed. RESULTS: Fifty percent effective concentrations for inhibition of HCV subgenomic 1b replicon replication ranged between 2 and 50 nM and were 100-fold higher for HCV genotype 2a virus. The 50% cytostatic concentrations were > or = 17 microM, thus resulting in selectivity indices of > or = 340. GS-327073 retained wild-type activity against HCV replicons that were resistant to either HCV protease inhibitors or several polymerase inhibitors. GS-327073, when combined with either interferon alpha, ribavirin, a nucleoside polymerase or a protease inhibitor resulted in overall additive antiviral activity. Combinations containing GS-327073 proved highly effective in clearing hepatoma cells from HCV. CONCLUSIONS: GS-327073 is a potent in vitro inhibitor of HCV replication either alone or in combination with other selective HCV inhibitors.

Debio 025, a cyclophilin binding molecule, is highly efficient in clearing hepatitis C virus (HCV) replicon-containing cells when used alone or in combination with specifically targeted antiviral therapy for HCV (STAT-C) inhibitors.

Debio 025 is a potent inhibitor of hepatitis C virus (HCV) replication (J. Paeshuyse et al., Hepatology 43:761-770, 2006). In phase I clinical studies, monotherapy (a Debio 025 dose of 1,200 mg twice a day) resulted in a mean maximal decrease in the viral load of 3.6 log(10) units (R. Flisiak et al., Hepatology 47:817-826, 2008), whereas a reduction of 4.6 log(10) units was obtained in phase II studies when Debio 025 was combined with interferon (R. Flisiak et al., J. Hepatol., 48:S62, 2008). We here report on the particular characteristics of the in vitro anti-HCV activities of Debio 025. The combination of Debio 025 with either ribavirin or specifically targeted antiviral therapy for HCV (STAT-C) inhibitors (NS3 protease or NS5B [nucleoside and nonnucleoside] polymerase inhibitors) resulted in additive antiviral activity in short-term antiviral assays. Debio 025 has the unique ability to clear hepatoma cells from their HCV replicon when it is used alone or in combination with interferon and STAT-C inhibitors. Debio 025, when it was used at concentrations that have been observed in human plasma (0.1 or 0.5 muM), was able to delay or prevent the development of resistance to HCV protease inhibitors as well as to nucleoside and nonnucleoside polymerase inhibitors. Debio 025 forms an attractive drug candidate for the treatment of HCV infections in combination with standard interferon-based treatment and treatments that directly target the HCV polymerase and/or protease.

Comparative in vitro anti-hepatitis C virus activities of a selected series of polymerase, protease, and helicase inhibitors.

We report here a comparative study of the anti-hepatitis C virus (HCV) activities of selected (i) nucleoside polymerase, (ii) nonnucleoside polymerase, (iii) alpha,gamma-diketo acid polymerase, (iv) NS3 protease, and (v) helicase inhibitors, as well as (vi) cyclophilin binding molecules and (vii) alpha 2b interferon in four different HCV genotype 1b replicon systems.

Selective inhibitors of picornavirus replication.

Picornaviruses cover a large family of pathogens that have a major impact on human but also on veterinary health. Although most infections in man subside mildly or asymptomatically, picornaviruses can also be responsible for severe, potentially life-threatening disease. To date, no therapy has been approved for the treatment of picornavirus infections. However, efforts to develop an antiviral that is effective in treating picornavirus-associated diseases are ongoing. In 2007, Schering-Plough, under license of ViroPharma, completed a phase II clinical trial with Pleconaril, a drug that was originally rejected by the FDA after a New Drug Application in 2001. Rupintrivir, a rhinovirus protease inhibitor developed at Pfizer, reached clinical trials but was recently halted from further development. Finally, Biota's HRV drug BTA-798 is scheduled for phase II trials in 2008. Several key steps in the picornaviral replication cycle, involving structural as well as non-structural proteins, have been identified as valuable targets for inhibition. The current review aims to highlight the most important developments during the past decades in the search for antivirals against picornaviruses.

Synthesis of new benzimidazole-coumarin conjugates as anti-hepatitis C virus agents.

Nineteen new conjugated compounds were successfully synthesized by a one-flask method from benzimidazole and coumarin derivatives. A methylenethio linker was used to connect these two kinds of derivatives. In addition, substituted benzimidazol-2-thiones were also coupled with beta-D-glucose peracetate; the resultant glucosides were further converted to the corresponding 2-(methylthio)coumarin derivatives. Their activity against the hepatitis C virus was tested; two of the most potent compounds 2-[(6'-bromocoumarin-3'-yl)methylenethio]-5-fluorobenzimidazole (4i) and its derivative 1-[(2'',3'',4'',6''-tetra-O-acetyl)glucopyranos-1''-yl]-2-[(6'-bromocoumarin-3'-yl)methylenethio]benzimidazole (7c) showed EC(50) values of 3.4 microM and 4.1 microM, respectively. At a concentration of 5.0 microM, compound 7c inhibited HCV RNA replication by 90% and had no effect on cell proliferation. Given these data, a structure-activity relationship was established.

Hemin potentiates the anti-hepatitis C virus activity of the antimalarial drug artemisinin.

We report that the antimalarial drug artemisinin inhibits hepatitis C virus (HCV) replicon replication in a dose-dependent manner in two replicon constructs at concentrations that have no effect on the proliferation of the exponentially growing host cells. The 50% effective concentration (EC(50)) for inhibition of HCV subgenomic replicon replication in Huh 5-2 cells (luciferase assay) by artemisinin was 78+/-21 microM. Hemin, an iron donor, was recently reported to inhibit HCV replicon replication [mediated by inhibition of the viral polymerase (C. Fillebeen, A.M. Rivas-Estilla, M. Bisaillon, P. Ponka, M. Muckenthaler, M.W. Hentze, A.E. Koromilas, K. Pantopoulos, Iron inactivates the RNA polymerase NS5B and suppresses subgenomic replication of hepatitis C virus, J. Biol. Chem. 280 (2005) 9049-9057.)] at a concentration that had no adverse effect on the host cells. When combined, artemisinin and hemin resulted, over a broad concentration range, in a pronounced synergistic antiviral activity. Also at a concentration (2 microM) that alone had no effect on HCV replication, hemin still potentiated the anti-HCV activity of artemisinin.

Immune activation following cytomegalovirus infection: more important than direct viral effects in cardiovascular disease?

BACKGROUND: Over the last 30 years multiple micro-organisms have been associated with different types of vascular disease, like atherosclerosis, restenosis or transplant arteriosclerosis. Nonetheless, it is still ambiguous which molecular mechanisms are exactly involved in the exacerbating effect of microbes in these disorders. OBJECTIVES AND STUDY DESIGN: The present review summarizes sero-epidemiological, in vitro and animal data supporting the role of cytomegalovirus, a member of the herpes virus family, in vascular disease. Additionally, various ways by which the virus can potentially affect the disease will be discussed. RESULTS: Rodent models as well as in vitro studies suggested that CMV might enhance lesion formation in various ways, like augmentation of the oxLDL uptake, altering monocyte adhesion or increasing the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines. Nevertheless, recent data from our lab and others suggest that alternative mechanisms also may contribute to CMV induced. Inspired by this, we will hypothesise alternative mechanisms by which CMV might affect atherosclerosis. CONCLUSIONS: Although researchers have tried for many years to unravel the tactics by which micro-organisms, like CMV, aggravate atherosclerosis, so far most suggested mechanisms failed to fully explain both experimental and clinical observations. Therefore, new means to elucidate the observed effects are required.

Rapid identification of bacteria by real-time amplification and sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene.

To allow rapid identification of bacteria in pure cultures and blood culture bottles, an assay was developed which is based on real-time amplification and sequencing of bacterial 16 S rRNA genes. In principle, this assay allows identification of bacteria from pure cultures within 6.5 h, and from blood cultures within approximately 7 h.

Mouse cytomegalovirus antigenic immune stimulation is sufficient to aggravate atherosclerosis in hypercholesterolemic mice.

We have previously demonstrated that mouse cytomegalovirus (MCMV) infection aggravates atherosclerosis by stimulating the ongoing inflammatory process in the vascular wall. Here we investigated whether MCMV antigenic immune stimulation by UV-MCMV injection is sufficient to aggravate atherosclerosis. In addition we analyzed whether low viral doses are sufficient to stimulate atherosclerosis. Therefore, apoE(-/-) mice received a low dose injection with infectious virus (MCMV) or replication-deficient virus (UV-inactivated MCMV, UV-MCMV). Atherosclerosis progression, influx of inflammatory cells in atherosclerotic lesions and internal organs and the number of MCMV DNA copies in various organs were determined at 2 weeks after injection. After injection with infectious virus, MCMV DNA was present in internal organs, while no MCMV DNA could be detected after UV-MCMV injection. Interestingly, both MCMV and UV-MCMV significantly increased mean atherosclerotic lesion area and T cell number in the atherosclerotic lesions, while only MCMV infection increased T cell numbers in the internal organs. These data indicate that in apoE(-/-) mice both low dose infectious MCMV as well as MCMV antigenic injections are sufficient for atherosclerosis aggravation.