Increasing robustness, reliability and storage stability of critical reagents by freeze-drying.

Aim: Stabilization of critical reagents by freeze-drying would facilitate storage and transportation at ambient temperatures, and simultaneously enable constant reagent performance for long-term bioanalytical support throughout drug development. Freeze-drying as a generic process for stable performance and storage of critical reagents was investigated by establishing an universal formulation buffer and lyophilization process. Results: Using a storage-labile model protein, formulation buffers were evaluated to preserve reagent integrity during the freeze-drying process, and to retain functional performance after temperature stress. Application to critical reagents used in pharmacokinetics and anti-drug antibodies assays demonstrated stable functional performance of the reagents after 11 month at +40°C. Conclusion: Stabilization and storage of critical assay reagents by freeze-drying is an attractive alternative to traditional deep freezing.

Reply to the EFSA (2016) on the relevance of recent publications (Hofmann et al. 2014, 2016) on environmental risk assessment and management of Bt-maize events (MON810, Bt11 and 1507).

In this commentary, we respond to a report of the EFSA GMO Panel (EFSA EFSA Supp Publ, 1) that criticises the outcomes of two studies published in this journal (Hofmann et al. Environ Sci Eur 26: 24, 2; Environ Sci Eur 28: 14, 3). Both publications relate to the environmental risk assessment and management of Bt-maize, including maize events MON810, Bt11 and maize 1507. The results of Hofmann et al. (Environ Sci Eur 26: 24, 2), using standardised pollen mass filter deposition measurements, indicated that the EFSA Panel model had underestimated pollen deposition and, hence, exposure of non-target organisms to Bt-maize pollen. The results implied a need for safety buffer distances in the kilometre range for protected nature reserve areas instead of the 20-30 m range recommended by the EFSA Panel. As a result, the EFSA Panel revised their model (EFSA EFSA J 13: 4127, 4), adopting the slope of the empirical data from Hofmann et al. The intercept, however, was substantially reduced to less than 1% at one point by introducing further assumptions based on the estimates of mainly panel members, citing possible 'uncertainty'. Hofmann et al. (Environ Sci Eur 28: 14, 3) published extensive empirical data regarding pollen deposition on leaves. These results were part of a larger 3-year study involving detailed measurements of pollen release, dispersal and deposition over the maize flowering period. The data collected in situ confirmed the previous predictions of Hofmann et al. (Environ Sci Eur 26: 24, 2). Mean levels and observed variability of pollen deposition on maize and four lepidopteran host plants exceeded the assumptions and disagreed with the conclusions of the EFSA Panel. The EFSA Panel reacted in a report (EFSA EFSA Supp Publ, 1) criticising the methods and outcomes of the two published studies of Hofmann et al. while reaffirming their original recommendations. We respond here point-by-point, showing that the critique is not justified. Based on our results on Urtica leaf pollen density, we confirm the need for specific environmental impact assessments for Bt-maize cultivation with respect to protected habitats within isolation buffer distances in the kilometre range.

Erratum to: Reply to the EFSA (2016) on the relevance of recent publications (Hofmann et al. 2014, 2016) on environmental risk assessment and management of Bt-maize events (MON810, Bt11 and 1507).

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.1186/s12302-017-0106-0.].

Accumulation and variability of maize pollen deposition on leaves of European Lepidoptera host plants and relation to release rates and deposition determined by standardised technical sampling.

BACKGROUND: Risk assessment for GMOs such as Bt maize requires detailed data concerning pollen deposition onto non-target host-plant leaves. A field study of pollen on lepidopteran host-plant leaves was therefore undertaken in 2009-2012 in Germany. During the maize flowering period, we used in situ microscopy at a spatial resolution adequate to monitor the feeding behaviour of butterfly larvae. The plant-specific pollen deposition data were supplemented with standardised measurements of pollen release rates and deposition obtained by volumetric pollen monitors and passive samplers. RESULTS: In 2010, we made 5377 measurements of maize pollen deposited onto leaves of maize, nettle, goosefoot, sorrel and blackberry. Overall mean leaf deposition during the flowering period ranged from 54 to 478 n/cm2 (grains/cm2) depending on plant species and site, while daily mean leaf deposition values were as high as 2710 n/cm2. Maximum single leaf-deposition values reached up to 103,000 n/cm2, with a 95 % confidence-limit upper boundary of 11,716 n/cm2. CONCLUSIONS: Daily means and variation of single values uncovered by our detailed measurements are considerably higher than previously assumed. The recorded levels are more than a single degree of magnitude larger than actual EU expert risk assessment assumptions. Because variation and total aggregation of deposited pollen on leaves have been previously underestimated, lepidopteran larvae have actually been subjected to higher and more variable exposure. Higher risks to these organisms must consequently be assumed. Our results imply that risk assessments related to the effects of Bt maize exposure under both realistic cultivation conditions and worst-case scenarios must be revised. Under common cultivation conditions, isolation buffer distances in the kilometre range are recommended rather than the 20-30 m distance defined by the EFSA.

Epitope characterization of the ADA response directed against a targeted immunocytokine.

Targeted immunocytokines (TICs) display potent activity in selective tumor suppression. This class of multi domain biotherapeutics (MDBs) is composed of the three major domains Fab, Fc, and a cytokine which may induce a complex polyclonal anti-drug antibody (ADA) response. However, classical ADA assays usually are not suitable to specify ADAs and to identify the immunogenic domains of a TIC. The purpose of the present study was to establish epitope characterization of ADA responses in order to specify immunogenic responses against a TIC and their direct impact on the pharmacokinetic profile, safety, and efficacy. Based on standard ADA screening and confirmation assays, respectively, domain detection assays (DDAs) and domain competition assays (DCAs) were established and compared by the use of 12 ADA-positive samples obtained from a cynomolgus monkey study in early development. Both domain-specific assays were sensitive enough to preserve the positive screening assay result and revealed an overall accordance for the evaluation of domain-specific ADA responses. About half of the samples displayed one ADA specificity, either for the Fab or for the cytokine (Cy) domain, and the remaining samples showed a combination of Fab-specific and Cy-specific ADA fractions. Fc-specific ADAs occurred in only one sample. In-depth comparison of DCAs and DDAs showed that both assays appeared to be appropriate to assess multi-specific ADA responses as well as minor ADA fractions. An advantage of DCAs is typically a fast and easy assay establishment, whereas, DDAs in some cases may be superior to assess low abundant ADAs in multi-specific responses. Our results reveal that both approaches benefit from thorough reagent development as an essential precondition for reliable epitope characterization of ADA responses.

An immunodepletion procedure advances free angiopoietin-2 determination in human plasma samples during anti-cancer therapy with bispecific anti-Ang2/VEGF CrossMab.

Bispecific monoclonal IgG antibodies offer increased efficacy by antagonizing two different targets. Assessing drug mechanisms, target engagement and biomarker features, the quantification of free target levels is essential. The anti-Ang2/VEGF-CrossMab (anti-A2V) recognizes soluble vascular endothelial growth factor-A (VEGF-A) and soluble angiopoietin-2 (Ang2). However, an assay for reliable free Ang2 determination is missing. Here, we describe an immunodepletion procedure that allows for selective quantification of free Ang2 target levels by taking into advantage the bispecificity of the therapeutic antibody. The specificity for VEGF was utilized to efficiently eliminate drug-bound Ang2 from plasma samples prior to an established Ang2 measurement. The magnetic bead-based depletion procedure used an anti-idiotypic monoclonal antibody (mAb) specific for the VEGF binding site of anti-A2V (anti-Id-anti-VEGF mAb) to capture the drug along with drug-bound Ang2. High efficiencies of 99.9% were obtained for anti-A2V depletion (concentration range 300 ng/mL to 10(6)ng/mL) reflecting a 1000-fold reduction of drug-bound Ang2. A significant impact of the interaction of anti-Id-anti-VEGF mAb with anti-A2V on the Ang2 binding could be excluded. Moreover, reliable quantification of free Ang2 concentrations in plasma samples was assured by interference testing. Performing advanced free Ang2 determination including the immunodepletion step in parallel to established Ang2 measurement without immunodepletion, we compared free with total Ang2 concentrations in human plasma samples obtained from an anti-A2V Phase 1 clinical study. Samples from untreated patients displayed rather low and equal values for both free and total Ang2. In contrast, samples from drug-treated patients showed a significant reduction of free Ang2 accompanied by an accumulation in total Ang2. These results underline the value of the novel immunodepletion procedure for reliable discrimination of free vs. total target quantification with particular importance for pre-clinical and clinical development of anti-A2V. Moreover, this approach may serve as universal concept for the determination of free target levels of bispecific therapeutic antibodies.

Identification and monitoring of host cell proteins by mass spectrometry combined with high performance immunochemistry testing.

Biotherapeutics are often produced in non-human host cells like Escherichia coli, yeast, and various mammalian cell lines. A major focus of any therapeutic protein purification process is to reduce host cell proteins to an acceptable low level. In this study, various E. coli host cell proteins were identified at different purifications steps by HPLC fractionation, SDS-PAGE analysis, and tryptic peptide mapping combined with online liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LC-MS). However, no host cell proteins could be verified by direct LC-MS analysis of final drug substance material. In contrast, the application of affinity enrichment chromatography prior to comprehensive LC-MS was adequate to identify several low abundant host cell proteins at the final drug substance level. Bacterial alkaline phosphatase (BAP) was identified as being the most abundant host cell protein at several purification steps. Thus, we firstly established two different assays for enzymatic and immunological BAP monitoring using the cobas® technology. By using this strategy we were able to demonstrate an almost complete removal of BAP enzymatic activity by the established therapeutic protein purification process. In summary, the impact of fermentation, purification, and formulation conditions on host cell protein removal and biological activity can be conducted by monitoring process-specific host cell proteins in a GMP-compatible and high-throughput (> 1000 samples/day) manner.

Characterization of murine anti-human Fab antibodies for use in an immunoassay for generic quantification of human Fab fragments in non-human serum samples including cynomolgus monkey samples.

Generic immunoassay formats in animal serum have been described for pharmacokinetic (PK) analysis of human full-length antibodies, but not of human antigen binding fragment (Fab) proteins. Here we characterize two murine monoclonal antibodies (mAb) raised against human immunoglobulin G (IgG) which bind to unique epitopes in the Fab region of human IgG. mAb M-1.7.10 is directed against the constant domain of the kappa light chain and mAb M-1.19.31 binds to the constant domain 1 (CH1) of the heavy chain. Surface plasmon resonance analysis showed that mAb M-1.7.10 does not cross-react with sera from mouse, rat, rabbit, dog, marmoset, rhesus macaque, baboon and cynomolgus monkey, but binds to human and chimpanzee serum (dissociation constant K(D) of 6.8 × 10(-12) and 3.1 × 10(-11)M, respectively). mAb M-1.19.31 shows a higher K(D) for human and chimpanzee IgG (2.0 × 10(-9)M and 5.8 × 10(-10)M, respectively), but also does not bind to serum of the other species. Therefore, mAb M-1.7.10 was used as capture and mAb M-1.19.31 as detection reagent in a generic enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to quantify the human anti-IGF-1R Fab in mouse serum. The generic human Fab assay showed a limit of detection of 31.5 ng/mL anti-IGF-1R Fab. Intra- and inter-assay precision was less than 12% and the accuracy range for all controls was within ±20% of the target concentration. The generic human Fab ELISA was applied to determine serum levels of human anti-IGF-1R Fab after intravenous (iv) administration of 10mg/kg to mice. The resulting concentration-time profile was nearly identical to that obtained by analysis with a validated specific ELISA for anti-IGF-1R Fab. The mean relative concentration of anti-IGF-1R Fab analyzed by the generic assay was 82-118% of that of the specific assay. This equivalence was confirmed in a cynomolgus monkey study with the full length human mAb anti-TROP-2 IgG. Both specific ELISAs used mAb M-1.7.10 as detection reagent and their targets for capturing. In conclusion, the two murine anti-human Fabs are versatile tools as capture and detection reagents for human antibodies in generic and specific PK ELISA formats for animal studies. Their use in specific ELISAs as detection reagents allows the usage of Fc-fusion proteins as capture reagents.

Generic anti-drug antibody assay with drug tolerance in serum samples from mice exposed to human antibodies.

Knowledge of the anti-drug antibody (ADA) status is necessary in early research studies. Because specific assay materials are sparse and time is pressing, a generic assay format with drug tolerance for detection of ADAs in serum samples from mice exposed to immunoglobulin G (IgG) or antigen-binding fragments (Fabs) is highly desirable. This article describes a generic immune complex assay in the sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) format based on (i) transformation of free ADAs to immune complexes by preincubation with excess drug, (ii) the use of a murine anti-human Fab constant domain Fab as capture reagent, (iii) detection of the immune complexes by a peroxidase-labeled rabbit anti-murine Fc antibody, and (iv) ADA-positive control conjugates consisting of human Fab and murine IgG. Results of the experiments suggest that the generic immune complex assay for mouse serum samples was at least equivalent to specific ADA immune assays and even superior regarding drug tolerance. The generic immune complex assay confers versatility as it detects ADAs in complex with full-length IgG as well as with Fabs independent of the target specificity in mouse serum samples. These features help to save the sparse amounts of specific antibodies available in early research and development and speed up drug candidate selection.

Quality requirements for critical assay reagents used in bioanalysis of therapeutic proteins: what bioanalysts should know about their reagents.

Ligand-binding assays are the standard technology used for bioanalysis of therapeutic proteins, for example, for drug quantification (pharmacokinetics assays) and immunogenicity testing (antidrug antibody assays). Besides the selection of the most suitable technology platform (e.g., ELISA, electrochemiluminescence assays and surface plasmon resonance assays) and assay procedure, a pivotal prerequisite for good assay performance on any technology platform is the design, production and characterization of high quality reagents. To enable bioanalytical project support over the complete product life cycle, an appropriate long-term reagent supply is needed. This perspective describes our opinion on the requirements for generation and QC of critical reagents used in ligand-binding assays for drug quantification and antidrug antibody detection to enable high-quality assays and long-term supply, including reagent batch switches. The critical parameters during reagent design, production and long-term supply, along with the appropriate analytical methods for QC testing and appropriate certification, are discussed.

Evaluation of a generic immunoassay with drug tolerance to detect immune complexes in serum samples from cynomolgus monkeys after administration of human antibodies.

Current state of the art bridging ELISA technologies for detection of anti-drug antibodies (ADAs) against therapeutic antibodies bear the risk of false-negative results due to interference by circulating drug. Methods to remove the drug in the sample or sample pre-treatment techniques such as acid dissociation of the immune complexes are limited, laborious and may destroy ADAs resulting again in false-negative results. The immune complex ELISA described in this publication provides a simple solution. It is designed to analyze samples from cynomolgus monkeys dosed with human antibodies; it can be used for all human antibodies since it is independent of the specific antibody and its target. The generic applicability of the ADA assay is enabled by the use of (1) a murine anti-human Fc monoclonal antibody (MAb) as capture reagent; (2) a murine anti-cynomolgus monkey IgG MAb as detection reagent; and (3) an ADA positive control conjugate consisting of cynomolgus IgG complexed with human IgG. In its basic version, the generic ADA ELISA specifically detects only immune complexes formed in vivo. Validation of the ADA assay revealed a lower limit of quantitation of 15.6 ng/mL in serum samples. Intra-assay and inter-assay precision was characterized by a coefficient of variation of less than 10% and accuracy was within 8%. Matrix effects were low as evidenced by a mean recovery of 95%. In vitro pre-incubation of the serum samples with drug makes also the free ADA in the sample amenable to measurement by the immune complex ELISA as demonstrated by analysis of ADAs from two cynomolgus monkey studies with two different antibodies. The generic and versatile nature of this ADA assay favors its use in pilot pharmacokinetic and safety studies in cynomolgus monkeys during candidate selection of antibodies. The assay can help to explain unexpected drug clearance profiles, loss of efficacy or safety events caused by immune complexes and guide further development.

Evaluation of a biosensor immunoassay for simultaneous characterization of isotype and binding region of human anti-tocilizumab antibodies with control by surrogate standards.

This article describes the simultaneous Biacore analysis of human anti-human antibodies (HAHAs) with respect to the binding region and the isotype by a combination of 11 single measurements per sample. The multiplexing single assay setup made efficient use of the four parallel flow cells on one biosensor chip by immobilization of full-length antibody and its constant (Fc) and antigen binding (Fab) fragments for differential binding analysis of anti-drug antibodies (ADAs). Thereby, a complete time-specific immunogenicity profile (intensity, isotype, specificity, and kinetics) of a patient could be obtained by assessing the response patterns of serially collected samples analyzed in a single measurement run. The use of functionally active standard conjugates allowed control of the assay performance throughout the whole procedure. The positive control standard conjugates mimicking polyclonal human ADAs of different isotypes were obtained by conjugating polyclonal rabbit antibodies against the therapeutic antibody to human immunoglobulin (Ig) M, IgG, or IgE. In this article, the qualification of the assay is demonstrated and the application of the methodology to six representative rheumatoid arthritis patients treated with the therapeutic humanized IgG1 antibody tocilizumab (anti-IL-6R) is shown to illustrate the versatility of the assay. The presented method allows one to differentiate specific ADAs from drug-unspecific responses (e.g., rheumatoid factors). In addition, the method can be used to discriminate between isotype responses of the IgG, IgM, and IgE types and, thereby, allows one to describe the time course of specific ADA formation and its disappearance on the single patient level.