Harmonizing Global Biospecimen Consent Practices to Advance Translational Research: A Call to Action.

One of the many challenges of translational medicine is working with research participants to donate biospecimens through an ethical informed consent framework. The increasingly complex ethical and regulatory differences across jurisdictions translates into limitations on use and potential value of biological specimens and their associated data in clinical research. We introduce a call to action for more uniform global standards for collection of biological specimen informed consent data to enable greater advancements in medical research.

A question-based approach to adopting pharmacogenetics to understand risk for clinical variability in pharmacokinetics in early drug development.

Understanding genetic variations that influence pharmacokinetics (PK) in humans is important for optimal clinical use of drugs. Guidances for making decisions on when to conduct pharmacogenetic research during drug development have been proposed by regulatory agencies, but their uniform adoption presents problems due to an inherent lack of flexibility. A questions-based approach (QBA) was developed to enable drug development teams at Merck to iteratively and flexibly evaluate the potential impact of pharmacogenetics (PGx) on clinical pharmacokinetic variability.

PhRMA survey of pharmacogenomic and pharmacodynamic evaluations: what next?

Interindividual variation in pharmacodynamic (PD) response to drugs is an ongoing area of research for drugs in clinical development, pre- and postapproval. To characterize how pharmacogenomic (PG ) variations can serves a predictor of differences in PD outcomes, the pharmaceutical industry has incorporated PG /PD analysis into clinical drug development. The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA ) and the Industry Pharmacogenomics Working Group (I-PWG) conducted a survey of 16 pharmaceutical companies to ascertain to what extent PG/PD research is being incorporated into drug development. The survey results showed that, while the industry has made some attempt to incorporate PG/PD studies into drug development, application has been inconsistent. Nevertheless, several valid PG/PD markers have since emerged in drug labels. The I-PWG considers PG/PD research an important approach to improving success rates in drug development. This article reports the results of the survey and proposes steps toward increasing the use of PG/PD research by the industry.

Current practices for DNA sample collection and storage in the pharmaceutical industry, and potential areas for harmonization: perspective of the I-PWG.

Collection and storage of DNA samples in clinical drug development programs are an important investment for the pharmaceutical industry to allow efficient evaluation of observed variability in drug response. To enable collection and future use of samples, individual companies must define (i) processes to collect specimens worldwide, (ii) whether collection is optional or mandatory, (iii) conditions and duration of sample storage, (iv) whether research data can be returned to subjects, and (v) other logistical aspects. To determine current industry practices for collection and storage of these samples, the Industry Pharmacogenomics Working Group (I-PWG) conducted a survey of the industry (21 respondents) to identify areas of commonality and divergence. On the basis of the survey results, the I-PWG details areas of focus for harmonization of the industry's sample collection practices. A more unified approach would facilitate DNA sample collection, thereby contributing to the advancement of personalized medicine and more efficient development of safe and effective drugs.

Coding of DNA samples and data in the pharmaceutical industry: current practices and future directions--perspective of the I-PWG.

DNA samples collected in clinical trials and stored for future research are valuable to pharmaceutical drug development. Given the perceived higher risk associated with genetic research, industry has implemented complex coding methods for DNA. Following years of experience with these methods and with addressing questions from institutional review boards (IRBs), ethics committees (ECs) and health authorities, the industry has started reexamining the extent of the added value offered by these methods. With the goal of harmonization, the Industry Pharmacogenomics Working Group (I-PWG) conducted a survey to gain an understanding of company practices for DNA coding and to solicit opinions on their effectiveness at protecting privacy. The results of the survey and the limitations of the coding methods are described. The I-PWG recommends dialogue with key stakeholders regarding coding practices such that equal standards are applied to DNA and non-DNA samples. The I-PWG believes that industry standards for privacy protection should provide adequate safeguards for DNA and non-DNA samples/data and suggests a need for more universal standards for samples stored for future research.

Global requirements for DNA sample collections: results of a survey of 204 ethics committees in 40 countries.

The Industry Pharmacogenomics Working Group has an interest in attaining a better understanding of global requirements for sample collections intended for pharmacogenetics research. To have adequately powered pharmacogenetics studies representative of the clinical trial population, it is important to collect DNA samples from a majority of consenting study participants under many institutional review board/ethics committee (IRB/EC) jurisdictions. A survey was distributed to gather information from local and central IRBs/ECs. The survey included questions related to the approval of pharmacogenetics studies, collection and banking of samples, and return of data to subjects. A total of 204 responses were received from global IRBs/ECs with pharmacogenetic experience. The data show that requirements for approval of pharmacogenetic research differ between IRBs/ECs within and between countries but not between regions of the United States. A better understanding of differing requirements should facilitate global sample collection of DNA for pharmacogenetics research and may provide the basis for harmonized regulations for collection of genetic samples in the future.

Challenges in obtaining adequate genetic sample sets in clinical trials: the perspective of the industry pharmacogenomics working group.

Collection of DNA samples from subjects participating in clinical trials is vital to understanding variability in drug response. The purpose of this study was to assess pharmacogenetic sample-collection practices in the industry and to gather information on issues affecting collection. A survey questionnaire was developed and distributed to 20 pharmaceutical companies; 15 provided responses. Assessments included rate of DNA sample collection, reasons for low collection rates, reasons for rejection by health authorities (HAs) and institutional review boards/ethics committees (IRBs/ECs), and country-specific hurdles to sample collection. The results indicated that, although DNA samples are frequently collected, sample-acquisition rates remain lower than expected. Overall, the companies' experience has been that restrictions on sample usage are not consistently applied by regulatory bodies. This may reflect changing opinions/interpretations of HAs/IRBs/ECs. Collection of DNA samples in industry trials is still a challenge. Harmonization of sample-collection practices may facilitate the process.