Low-cost otolaryngology simulation models for early-stage trainees: a scoping review.

BACKGROUND: Medical simulation is essential for surgical training yet is often too expensive and inaccessible in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Furthermore, in otolaryngology-head and neck surgery (OHNS), while simulation training is often focused on senior residents and specialists, there is a critical need to target general practitioners who carry a significant load of OHNS care in countries with limited OHNS providers. This scoping review aims to describe affordable, effective OHNS simulation models for early-stage trainees and non-OHNS specialists in resource-limited settings and discuss gaps in the literature. METHODS: This scoping review followed the five stages of Arksey and O'Malley's Scoping Review Methodology. Seven databases were used to search for articles. Included articles discussed physical models of the ear, nose, or throat described as "low-cost," "cost-effective," or defined as <$150 if explicitly stated; related to the management of common and emergent OHNS conditions; and geared towards undergraduate students, medical, dental, or nursing students, and/or early-level residents. RESULTS: Of the 1706 studies screened, 17 met inclusion criteria. Most studies were conducted in HICs. Most models were low-fidelity (less anatomically realistic) models. The most common simulated skills were peritonsillar abscess aspiration and cricothyrotomy. Information on cost was limited, and locally sourced materials were infrequently mentioned. Simulations were evaluated using questionnaires and direct observation. CONCLUSION: Low-cost simulation models can be beneficial for early medical trainees and students in LMICs, addressing resource constraints and improving skill acquisition. However, there is a notable lack of contextually relevant, locally developed, and cost-effective models. This study summarizes existing low-cost OHNS simulation models for early-stage trainees and highlights the need for additional locally sourced models. Further research is needed to assess the effectiveness and sustainability of these models.

The World's consumption of free web-based Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery educational resources: A global assessment of video usage trends.

Objectives: Online educational platforms with open access have seen a growing adoption in the field of medical education. However, the extent of their global usage is still unclear. To fill this knowledge gap, our objective is to examine the usage patterns of two renowned open-access resources in Otolaryngology. This includes identifying the most sought-after topics and understanding the demographics of their users. Methods: Retrospective study of web analytics data between 2016 and 2021 extracted from the Headmirror.com and Mayo Clinic Otolaryngology YouTube channel platforms analyzing demographic and education topic trends via descriptive, geospatial, time-series, t-tests, and ANOVA analyses. Results: Viewership spanned 124 countries in 7 different geographic regions, with 72 countries comprising low- to middle-income countries, mostly represented ages of 25-34 years old, came from high-income countries rather than low-income (p < .001), and used mobile phones followed by computers for device access. Video-educational material comprised of subspecialty topics on Rhinology and Sinus Surgery (25%) at the highest end and Facial Trauma (1%) at the lowest. Controlling for the age of the video content, the most-accessed videos comprised of subspecialty topics on Head and Neck Surgery at the highest end and Laryngology at the lowest with significant differentiation across topics of interest (p < .044). Conclusions: This assessment of web-analytics platforms from two widely used otolaryngology free, online-access materials showed increasing global usage trends with significant differentiating factors along viewership demographics, as well as sought-after subspecialty topics of interest. In turn, our results not only lay the groundwork for characterizing the global otolaryngology audience but also for future development of targeted educational materials and accessibility initiatives aimed at ameliorating global educational disparities in the field.

Late recurrence in surgically managed pediatric atypical mycobacterial lymphadenitis: A case report and review of the literature.

Objective: The purpose of this study is to identify existing literature on recurrent atypical mycobacterial cervicofacial lymphadenitis to augment our understanding of a unique patient who presented to our tertiary-care center 5-years posttreatment with recurrence following curettage. Data Sources: OVID Medline, Scopus, and Web of Science. Methods: A literature search was conducted yielding 49 original articles which were screened twice by two independent reviewers resulting in 14 studies meeting inclusion criteria for data extraction using Covidence software. Two independent reviewers extracted data on recurrence of atypical mycobacterial cervicofacial lymphadenitis and consensus was reached on data points from all included studies. Results: This study illuminated the paucity of recurrence reporting in the literature regarding atypical mycobacterial lymphadenitis. Sixteen studies identified in our review included discussions on recurrence with few elaborating beyond the rate of recurrence to describe their management. Fourteen out of sixteen studies provided recurrence rates for their cohort, 11 out of 14 specified the initial treatment modality, and only five out of eight studies that described initial treatment with surgery differentiated recurrence rates between complete and incomplete excision. The mean length of follow-up in the included studies was 20 months. There was one previously reported case of late recurrence at 5-years. Conclusions: We identified few reports that discussed the management of recurrence of atypical mycobacterial cervicofacial lymphadenitis. There was minimal data on recurrence rates between surgical treatment modalities. The case discussed in our study showcases that treatment with curettage has the potential to present with late recurrence.

Low-Cost Otolaryngology Simulation Models for Early-Stage Trainees: A Scoping Review.

Importance: There is a notable lack of low-cost OHNS simulation models that are relevant for early medical trainees and students. By conducting this study, we will understand the current landscape of low-cost otolaryngology-head and neck surgery simulation for early medical trainees and students. Objectives: Medical simulation is essential for surgical training yet is often too expensive and inaccessible in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Furthermore, in otolaryngology-head and neck surgery (OHNS), while simulation training is often focused on senior residents and specialists, there is a critical need to target general practitioners who carry a significant load of OHNS care in countries with limited OHNS providers. This scoping review aims to describe affordable, effective OHNS simulation models for early-stage trainees and non-OHNS specialists in resource-limited settings and discuss gaps in the literature. Evidence Review: This scoping review followed the five stages of Arksey and O'Malley's Scoping Review Methodology. Seven databases were used to search for articles. Included articles discussed physical models of the ear, nose, or throat described as "low-cost," "cost-effective," or defined as <$150 if explicitly stated; related to the management of common and emergent OHNS conditions; and geared towards undergraduate students, medical, dental, or nursing students, and/or early-level residents. Findings: Of the 1706 studies screened, 17 met the inclusion criteria. Most studies were conducted in HICs. Most models were low fidelity (less anatomically realistic) models. The most common simulated skills were peritonsillar abscess aspiration and cricothyrotomy. Information on cost was limited, and locally sourced materials were infrequently mentioned. Simulations were evaluated using questionnaires and direct observation. Conclusion and Relevance: Low-cost simulation models can be beneficial for early medical trainees and students in LMICs, addressing resource constraints and improving skill acquisition. However, there is a notable lack of contextually relevant, locally developed, and cost-effective models. This study summarizes existing low-cost OHNS simulation models for early-stage trainees and highlights the need for additional locally sourced models. Further research is needed to assess the effectiveness and sustainability of these models.

Current management of cervicofacial nontuberculous mycobacterial infections in the pediatric population.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The purpose of this review is to analyze and consolidate recently published literature to provide updated guidelines on the diagnosis and management of nontuberculous mycobacterial lymphadenitis (NTM LAD) in the pediatric population and to suggest areas of further research. RECENT FINDINGS: Diagnosis of NTM LAD relies on a detailed clinical history, physical examination, laboratory tests, and imaging techniques. Treatment strategies vary widely, with a shift towards complete surgical excision being observed due to its higher cure rate, improved aesthetic outcomes, and lower recurrence rates. However, patient-specific factors must be considered. The role of genetic factors, such as Mendelian susceptibility to mycobacterial disease (MSMD), is being increasingly recognized and could lead to targeted therapies. SUMMARY: Despite strides in the understanding and management of NTM LAD, substantial gaps remain in key areas such as the role of diagnostic imaging, optimal treatment parameters, postoperative care, and surveillance strategies. In this article, we explain our approach to NTM using the most relevant evidence-based medicine while offering directions for future work.

Vagal nerve stimulator-associated sleep disordered breathing secondary to vagal-induced laryngospasm in pediatric populations: Case presentation and systematic review.

OBJECTIVES: Sleep disordered breathing (SDB) is a well-documented complication of vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) in the literature. Yet, a formal consensus on its management has not been established, particularly in the pediatric population. This study aims to evaluate the current literature on VNS-associated SDB in order to further characterize its presentation, pathogenesis, diagnosis, and treatment. METHODS: A literature review from 2001 to November 8, 2021 was conducted to search for studies on SDB during vagal nerve stimulation in pediatric populations. RESULTS: Of 277 studies screened, seven studies reported on pediatric patients with VNS-associated SDB. Several investigators found on polysomnogram that periods of apnea/hypopnea correlated with VNS activity. When VNS settings were lowered or turned off, symptoms would either improve or completely resolve. CONCLUSION: VNS-associated SDB is a well described complication of VNS implantation, occurring due to an obstructive process from vagal stimulation and laryngeal contraction. Diagnosis can be made via polysomnogram. Recommended treatment is through adjustment of VNS settings. However, those who are unable to tolerate this, or who have had pre-existing obstructive issues prior to VNS, should pursue other treatment options such as non-invasive positive pressure or surgery directed by DISE findings.

Female and low- and middle-income authorship trends in high-impact ENT journals (2011-2020).

Introduction: Despite a recent drive to increase diversity, the global academic workforce is skewed in favor of authors from high-income countries, and women are under-represented in the published medical literature. Objectives: To explore the trends in authorship of three high-impact otolaryngology journals over a ten-year period (2011-2020). Methods: Journals selected: JAMA Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, The Laryngoscope and Rhinology. Articles were reviewed from four issues per journal per year, and data was collected on: time of publication; subspeciality; number of authors; sex of first and last authors; country of practice of first author and country where each study was conducted. Trends were examined though univariate and multivariate logistic regression models. Results: 2998 articles were included. 93.9% of first authors and 94.2% of studies were from high-income countries.Women were first authors in 31.5% (n = 912) and senior authors in 18.4% (n = 524) of articles. Female first authorship significantly increased between 2011 and 2020 however female senior authorship remained the same. There have been no significant changes in the proportion of published articles from low-and middle-income countries (LMIC) over time (p = .65). Amongst the LMIC articles, 72% came from Brazil, Turkey or China and there were no published papers from countries with a low-income economy (gross national income per capita of $1085 or less). Conclusions: Although female first authorship has increased in the last decade, there has been minimal other demographic change in authorship over this time. High-impact otolaryngology journals poorly represent academia in low-and-middle income countries. There is a need for increased advocacy promoting gender and geographical research equity in academic medicine. Level of Evidence: III.

Barriers to head and neck cancer care in high-income and low- and middle-income countries: a scoping review.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Identify patient-perceived barriers to head and neck cancer care and compare differences in barriers by country income status. RECENT FINDINGS: Of the 37 articles, 51% ( n  = 19) were from low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), while 49% ( n =  18) were from high-income countries. Of the papers from high-income countries, unspecified head and neck cancer (HNC) subtype (67%, n =  12) were the most common cancer type, while upper aerodigestive tract mucosal malignancies (58%, n =  11) were more common in LMICs ( P  = 0.02). Based on World Health Organization barriers, level of education ( P  =  < 0.01) and alternative medicine use ( P  = 0.04) were greater barriers in LMICs compared to high-income countries. At least 50% of articles listed barriers at all three 'Three Delays' timepoints. There were no significant differences by country income status for the 'Three Delays' timepoints of deciding to seek care ( P  = 0.23), reaching the healthcare facility ( P  = 0.75), or receiving care ( P  = 1.00). SUMMARY: Patients face barriers to care for head and neck cancer regardless of country income status. There is overlap in several barriers and a need for systemic improvement in access. The differences in education and alternative medicine may guide region-specific interventions to improve the provision of head and neck services.

Developing Consensus on Priority Pediatric Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery Conditions and Procedures.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to develop an international expert consensus on priority pediatric otolaryngology-head and neck surgery (OHNS) conditions and procedures for which all national health systems globally should be capable of managing. STUDY DESIGN: The Delphi method is a multiround online questionnaire and was administered internationally to otolaryngologists with a focus on pediatric populations. This study was administered in parallel to a Delphi survey focusing on adult OHNS conditions amongst adult otolaryngology experts. SETTING: International online survey. METHODS: In round 1, participants listed the top 15 pediatric otolaryngological conditions and top 15 pediatric otolaryngology procedures for their World Bank region. In round 2, participants ranked round 1 responses in order of global importance on a 5-point Likert scale. In round 3, participants reranked conditions and procedures that did not achieve consensus, defined as at least 70% of the round 2 Likert responses being ranked as either "important" or "very important." Descriptive statistics were calculated for each round. RESULTS: The survey was distributed to 35 experts globally, with a 40% (n = 14) response rate. Fifty percent (n = 7) of participants were from low- and middle-income countries, with at least 1 participant from each World Bank region. A list of 28 consensus surgical procedures and 11 consensus conditions were identified. CONCLUSION: This Delphi survey method of world experts in pediatric otolaryngology identified a core list of medical conditions and surgical procedures that should be a part of every national health system's clinical goals of treatment, research, and capacity building.

Bidirectional needs assessment of otolaryngology-head and neck surgery short-term surgical trips to Ethiopia and Kenya.

Objectives: To create an otolaryngology-specific needs assessment tool for short-term global surgical trips and to describe our findings from its implementation. Methods: Surveys 1 and 2 were developed based on a literature review and disseminated to Low-Middle Income (LMIC) hosting institutions in Kenya and Ethiopia and to High-Income surgical trip participants (HIC), respectively. Respondents were otolaryngologists identified online, through professional organizations, and by word-of-mouth, who had participated in a surgical trip of <4 weeks. Results: HIC and LMIC respondents shared similar goals of expanding host surgical skills through education and training while building sustainable partnerships. Discrepancies were identified between LMIC desired surgical skills and supply needs and HIC current practices. Microvascular reconstruction (17.6%), advanced otologic surgery (17.6%), and FESS (14.7%) were most desired skills and high-demand equipment needs were FESS sets (89%), endoscopes (78%), and surgical drills (56%). Frequently taught techniques included advanced otologic surgery (36.6%), congenital anomaly surgery (14.6%), and FESS (14.6%) with the largest gap between LMIC-need and HIC-offerings being in microvascular reconstruction (17.6% vs. 0%). We also highlight the discrepancy in expectations of responsibility for trip logistics, research, and patient follow-up. Conclusion: We created and implemented the first otolaryngology-specific needs assessment tool in the literature. With its implementation in Ethiopia and Kenya, we were able to identify unmet needs as well as attitudes and perceptions of LMIC and HIC participants. This tool may be adapted and utilized to assess specific needs, resources, and goals of both host and visiting teams to facilitate successful global partnerships. Level of Evidence: Level VI.

Proximal Scar Progression in Idiopathic Subglottic Stenosis After Wedge Excision: Does it Happen?

OBJECTIVE: To compare the incidence of glottic stenosis in idiopathic subglottic stenosis (iSGS) patients with no prior surgical intervention to those with a history of endoscopic dilation and characterize the incidence of glottic involvement, changes in scar length, and progression of scar toward glottis following laser wedge excision (LWE). METHODS: A retrospective review of iSGS patients who underwent LWE between 2002 and 2021 was performed. Patients without prior airway surgery were labeled LWE primary (LWEP) and operative findings for LWEP patients were reviewed for glottic involvement, scar length (DL ), and distance from the glottis to superior-most aspect of scar (DGS ). Rates (in mm/procedure) of DΔL , reflecting an increase in length, and D-ΔGS , reflecting proximal migration, were calculated by dividing DΔL and D-ΔGS by the number of LWE procedures. RESULTS: 213 iSGS patients underwent LWE, with 132 being LWEP patients. LWEP had a lower incidence of baseline glottic involvement (n = 6, 4.5%) than LWE secondary (LWES; n = 6, 7.5%). Four new cases of glottic involvement were noted in LWEP patients following LWE, with only one being clinically significant resulting in permanently decreased vocal fold mobility. With each procedure, scar length increased by 1.0 mm and DGS decreased by 0.7 mm, reflecting a migration or decrease in DGS of 9.5% with each procedure with respect to initial DGS . Overall rates of glottic stenosis following operations were similar between LWEP and LWES cohorts, 7.6% and 7.5% respectively. CONCLUSION: There appears to be a low risk of glottic involvement resulting from the LWE procedure in iSGS patients. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4 Laryngoscope, 133:875-882, 2023.

Gender Disparities in Otolaryngology: A Case Report Reflecting Global Perspectives.

OBJECTIVES: To explore the impact of female sex on the experiences of trainees and surgeons in otolaryngology from LMIC and HIC. METHODS: This study includes perspectives of five consultants and two resident physicians from the United States, United Kingdom, Uganda, Kenya and South Africa. RESULTS: Six themes emerged from these interviews. Overall, LMIC and HIC women shared similar experiences of microaggressions during patients, working along ancillary staff, related to pregnancy, imposter syndrome, difficulties during job search, and unique barriers as consultant. CONCLUSIONS: The findings of this study highlight that gender disparities are present at all levels in Otolaryngology but can present differently depending on context. Laryngoscope, 133:547-551, 2023.

Feasibility of Instituting a Clinical Otolaryngology Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccination Program.

OBJECTIVES: To measure baseline human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination rates among tertiary and community-based Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery (Oto-HNS) clinic patients and to determine risk factors for under-vaccination. METHODS: Retrospective chart review of patients aged 9 to 26 years presenting to an Oto-HNS clinic from 2017 to 2019. Patients were considered complete for HPV vaccination if they received two doses of HPV vaccine with the first dose received before age 15 years or three doses of HPV vaccine otherwise. RESULTS: 8,532 unique patients met the criteria. At the index visit, 3,110 (36.5%) had completed the HPV series, 5,422 (63.5%) were due for one or more doses, with 4,981 (58.4%) eligible for vaccination at the time of their appointment. Of those dues, most (3,148/5,422 or 58%) were past due by age (≥13 years old). Of the 3,148 patients past due, 745 (23.7%) were partially vaccinated and 2,403 (76.3%) were vaccine naïve. Male sex and younger age were both independently associated with incomplete vaccination (p < 0.0001). CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that the implementation of on-site HPV vaccination has the potential to increase the opportunities for vaccination among vaccine-eligible patients, especially among young males. Otolaryngologists have the potential to provide meaningful preventive services in the fight against HPV-mediated disease. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3 Laryngoscope, 133:116-123, 2023.

The Clinical Utility of Continuous Laryngoscopy During Exercise: A Report of Two Cases.

Exertional dyspnea is a common and disabling symptom in otherwise healthy children and adolescents, as well as in children with baseline airway abnormalities. It impairs the quality of life and may be associated with fatigue and underperformance in sports. Exertional dyspnea can be caused by a wide variety of structural and psychogenic causes. Exercise-induced laryngeal obstruction (EILO) is a relatively prevalent entity in young people that usually presents with exertional stridor, coughing, and dyspnea caused by transient closure of the larynx. In more complex cases where conventional tests such as pulmonary function tests (PFTs), chest imaging, ECG, and echocardiography are unrevealing, continuous laryngoscopy during exercise (CLE) tests may provide diagnostic utility. In addition to the baseline abnormalities visualized by conventional laryngoscopy, CLE can assess dynamic laryngeal responses during exercise. This article describes the clinical characteristics of two pediatric patients with various degrees of laryngeal dysfunction at baseline and the utility of CLE testing in tailoring management strategies.

Hyena Bite Injury to the Neck Leading to Laryngotracheal Separation.

Animal-induced trauma can lead to severe injury and death, especially in medically isolated settings. Few reports of hyena attacks on humans have been reported in the literature. The goal of this report is to describe such an attack and the heroic efforts required to preserve life and function in a resource-limited environment. A 55-year-old female was attacked by a hyena in a rural region of Ethiopia. Despite delays in medical care, she was able to survive this attack and was successfully discharged after prolonged treatment efforts. Animal-induced trauma is a potential source of substantial and disfiguring injury, especially in resource-limited environments. Early transfer to tertiary care centers and creative solutions are needed to optimize outcomes in such environments.

Complications following laser wedge excision for idiopathic subglottic stenosis.

OBJECTIVES: Endoscopic laser wedge excision (LWE) is an effective treatment option for idiopathic subglottic stenosis (iSGS); however, data regarding complications following LWE are limited. The aim of the following analysis was to provide a review of frequency and type of complications that occur with LWE in patients with iSGS. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review. METHODS: Patients with iSGS undergoing LWE between January 2002 and September 2021 were performed. Demographic data were recorded. Complications were stratified into major and minor categories. The frequency of these complications and the respective treatment for them was analyzed. RESULTS: 212 patients within the study period underwent a total of 573 LWE procedures. All but two patients were female, with a median age of 54 years at time of LWE. Of these patients, 43 (20 %) patients experienced a complication. Of these, only 7 (15 %) of the reported complications were considered major while the rest were minor in nature. Major complications included 3 cases of post-operative hemoptysis, 1 case of tracheitis, and 3 cases of reduced vocal fold hypomobility with concurrent glottic stenosis. Minor complications consisted of 2 cases of tooth fracture and 34 cases of tongue paresthesia post-operatively that was self-limited. There were no mortalities. CONCLUSION: Major complications occur in <5 % of LWE procedures based off the analysis. All major complications were managed without significant long-term morbidity. Minor complications with the LWE are self-limited in nature. Our data supports the LWE as a safe treatment option for iSGS.

Cultural Competency and Surgical Decision Making in Otolaryngology.

Given the high prevalence of otolaryngology infections such as tonsillitis, otitis, and pharyngitis in low and middle income countries, the field of global otolaryngology continues to grow to accommodate patients around the world. This commentary focuses on best practices in transcultural communications between US doctors and foreign patients with an emphasis on cultural competency. We use alternative medicine as an exemplar for how to collaborate with patients to develop treatment plans that respect their cultural beliefs and lifestyles. Rather than assigning value to the patient's alternative medicine practices, we believe that instructing and counseling a patient on how to incorporate follow-up visits and rehabilitation after allopathic medical procedures such as surgical tonsillectomy should be done in a way that respects the patient's preexisting health regimen. By doing so, these new aspects of their health care will take a discrete place in their wellness practices and engender more trust and better health outcomes.

High-Fidelity Surgical Middle Ear Simulator: A Pilot Study.

OBJECTIVES: To assess a middle ear simulator as a surgical training tool among a cohort of novice trainees. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective pilot study. SETTING: The George Washington University Hospital (tertiary care academic hospital). PARTICIPANTS: Twenty one medical students and physician assistant students completed the protocol. Each student produced four recordings over 10 attempts. The two raters were attending surgeons from the George Washington University Hospital. INTERVENTIONS: Stapedotomies performed on a high-fidelity middle ear simulator. Participants were assessed at baseline with a Purdue pegboard test and trained with video and a low fidelity middle ear simulator. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Two experts rated recordings on scales based upon a validated objective skills assessment test (OSAT) format. RESULTS: Inter-rater reliability was strong across all stapedotomy skills scores and global rating scores. Participants demonstrated statistically significant improvement up to the third recording (seventh attempt), but the scores on the fourth recording (tenth attempt) were not significantly different from the third. One participant failed to improve in score over 10 attempts. Pegboard test performance was not correlated with score improvement. Low-fidelity trial time was significantly correlated to stapedotomy and global rating scores. CONCLUSIONS: This pilot study serves as the first investigation of this middle ear simulator amongst a cohort of trainees. A high-fidelity middle ear simulator may serve as a measurement tool to select future surgical trainees, customize training pathways, and assess surgical capacity before graduation.

Expert Technique: Pediatric Tracheal Surgery.

Substantial improvements in techniques of tracheal surgery for children have occurred in the past 20 years. Precise preoperative imaging with computed tomography clearly defines the anatomy for surgical planning and is assisted by on-the-table needle localization. The use of cardiopulmonary bypass greatly facilitates creation of an airtight, widely patent trachea. The use of Ciprodex as a postoperative nebulizer has significantly decreased granulation tissue along the suture line. Most important has been the adoption of slide tracheoplasty as the procedure of choice.