Human Ischaemic Cascade Studies Using SH-SY5Y Cells: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.

Low translational yield for stroke may reflect the focus of discovery science on rodents rather than humans. Just how little is known about human neuronal ischaemic responses is confirmed by systematic review and meta-analysis revealing that data for the most commonly used SH-SY5Y human cells comprises only 84 papers. Oxygen-glucose deprivation, H2O2, hypoxia, glucose-deprivation and glutamate excitotoxicity yielded - 58, - 61, - 29, - 45 and - 49% injury, respectively, with a dose-response relationship found only for H2O2 injury (R2 = 29.29%, p < 0.002). Heterogeneity (I2 = 99.36%, df = 132, p < 0.0001) was largely attributable to the methods used to detect injury (R2 = 44.77%, p < 0.000) with cell death assays detecting greater injury than survival assays (- 71 vs - 47%, R2 = 28.64%, p < 0.000). Seventy-four percent of publications provided no description of differentiation status, but in the 26% that did, undifferentiated cells were susceptible to greater injury (R2 = 4.13%, p < 0.047). One hundred and sixty-nine interventions improved average survival by 34.67% (p < 0.0001). Eighty-eight comparisons using oxygen-glucose deprivation found both benefit and harm, but studies using glutamate and H2O2 injury reported only improvement. In studies using glucose deprivation, intervention generally worsened outcome. There was insufficient data to rank individual interventions, but of the studies reporting greatest improvement (> 90% effect size), 7/13 were of herbal medicine constituents (24.85% of the intervention dataset). We conclude that surprisingly little is known of the human neuronal response to ischaemic injury, and that the large impact of methodology on outcome indicates that further model validation is required. Lack of evidence for randomisation, blinding or power analysis suggests that the intervention data is at substantial risk of bias.

Stem cell transplantation in traumatic spinal cord injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis of animal studies.

Spinal cord injury (SCI) is a devastating condition that causes substantial morbidity and mortality and for which no treatments are available. Stem cells offer some promise in the restoration of neurological function. We used systematic review, meta-analysis, and meta-regression to study the impact of stem cell biology and experimental design on motor and sensory outcomes following stem cell treatments in animal models of SCI. One hundred and fifty-six publications using 45 different stem cell preparations met our prespecified inclusion criteria. Only one publication used autologous stem cells. Overall, allogeneic stem cell treatment appears to improve both motor (effect size, 27.2%; 95% Confidence Interval [CI], 25.0%-29.4%; 312 comparisons in 5,628 animals) and sensory (effect size, 26.3%; 95% CI, 7.9%-44.7%; 23 comparisons in 473 animals) outcome. For sensory outcome, most heterogeneity between experiments was accounted for by facets of stem cell biology. Differentiation before implantation and intravenous route of delivery favoured better outcome. Stem cell implantation did not appear to improve sensory outcome in female animals and appeared to be enhanced by isoflurane anaesthesia. Biological plausibility was supported by the presence of a dose-response relationship. For motor outcome, facets of stem cell biology had little detectable effect. Instead most heterogeneity could be explained by the experimental modelling and the outcome measure used. The location of injury, method of injury induction, and presence of immunosuppression all had an impact. Reporting of measures to reduce bias was higher than has been seen in other neuroscience domains but were still suboptimal. Motor outcomes studies that did not report the blinded assessment of outcome gave inflated estimates of efficacy. Extensive recent preclinical literature suggests that stem-cell-based therapies may offer promise, however the impact of compromised internal validity and publication bias mean that efficacy is likely to be somewhat lower than reported here.

Meta-analysis of pre-clinical studies of early decompression in acute spinal cord injury: a battle of time and pressure.

BACKGROUND: The use of early decompression in the management of acute spinal cord injury (SCI) remains contentious despite many pre-clinical studies demonstrating benefits and a small number of supportive clinical studies. Although the pre-clinical literature favours the concept of early decompression, translation is hindered by uncertainties regarding overall treatment efficacy and timing of decompression. METHODS: We performed meta-analysis to examine the pre-clinical literature on acute decompression of the injured spinal cord. Three databases were utilised; PubMed, ISI Web of Science and Embase. Our inclusion criteria consisted of (i) the reporting of efficacy of decompression at various time intervals (ii) number of animals and (iii) the mean outcome and variance in each group. Random effects meta-analysis was used and the impact of study design characteristics assessed with meta-regression. RESULTS: Overall, decompression improved behavioural outcome by 35.1% (95%CI 27.4-42.8; I(2)=94%, p<0.001). Measures to minimise bias were not routinely reported with blinding associated with a smaller but still significant benefit. Publication bias likely also contributed to an overestimation of efficacy. Meta-regression demonstrated a number of factors affecting outcome, notably compressive pressure and duration (adjusted r(2)=0.204, p<0.002), with increased pressure and longer durations of compression associated with smaller treatment effects. Plotting the compressive pressure against the duration of compression resulting in paraplegia in individual studies revealed a power law relationship; high compressive forces quickly resulted in paraplegia, while low compressive forces accompanying canal narrowing resulted in paresis over many hours. CONCLUSION: These data suggest early decompression improves neurobehavioural deficits in animal models of SCI. Although much of the literature had limited internal validity, benefit was maintained across high quality studies. The close relationship of compressive pressure to the rate of development of severe neurological injury suggests that pressure local to the site of injury might be a useful parameter determining the urgency of decompression.

Systematic review and meta-analysis of therapeutic hypothermia in animal models of spinal cord injury.

BACKGROUND: Therapeutic hypothermia is a clinically useful neuroprotective therapy for cardiac arrest and neonatal hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy and may potentially be useful for the treatment of other neurological conditions including traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI). The pre-clinical studies evaluating the effectiveness of hypothermia in acute SCI broadly utilise either systemic hypothermia or cooling regional to the site of injury. The literature has not been uniformly positive with conflicting studies of varying quality, some performed decades previously. METHODS: In this study, we systematically review and meta-analyse the literature to determine the efficacy of systemic and regional hypothermia in traumatic SCI, the experimental conditions influencing this efficacy, and the influence of study quality on outcome. Three databases were utilised; PubMed, ISI Web of Science and Embase. Our inclusion criteria consisted of the (i) reporting of efficacy of hypothermia on functional outcome (ii) number of animals and (iii) mean outcome and variance in each group. RESULTS: Systemic hypothermia improved behavioural outcomes by 24.5% (95% CI 10.2 to 38.8) and a similar magnitude of improvement was seen across a number of high quality studies. The overall behavioural improvement with regional hypothermia was 26.2%, but the variance was wide (95% CI -3.77 to 56.2). This result may reflect a preponderance of positive low quality data, although a preferential effect of hypothermia in ischaemic models of injury may explain some of the disparate data. Sufficient heterogeneity was present between studies of regional hypothermia to reveal a number of factors potentially influencing efficacy, including depth and duration of hypothermia, animal species, and neurobehavioural assessment. However, these factors could reflect the influence of earlier lower quality literature. CONCLUSION: Systemic hypothermia appears to be a promising potential method of treating acute SCI on the basis of meta-analysis of the pre-clinical literature and the results of high quality animal studies.

Corticospinal tract sprouting in the injured rat spinal cord stimulated by Schwann cell preconditioning of the motor cortex.

UNLABELLED: Peripheral nerve preconditioning lesions have been shown to consistently enhance sensory nerve regeneration in the injured spinal cord. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to determine if the rat motor cortex could be preconditioned through the implantation of Schwann cells (SC), thereby stimulating sprouting and regeneration of the corticospinal tract (CST). METHODS: Schwann cells (cultured in vitro) were injected into the motor cortex and seven days post-surgery rats underwent a dorsal spinal hemisection injury. Eight weeks following spinal injury animals were perfused and the CST visualised by Avidin-peroxidase histochemistry for dextran-biotin. RESULTS: Results demonstrate substantially enhanced CST collateral sprouting in both the rostral grey and white matter of the injured spinal cord in animals with SC implanted into the motor cortex compared to control animals with and without cortical vehicle injections. Corticospinal tract peri-wound regenerative sprouting was also enhanced in animals implanted with cortical SC compared to controls, however, only a small degree of CST axonal regeneration was present in the grey matter beneath the injury site. In all groups, CST peri-lesional regenerative sprouting occurred in close proximity to macrophages. Complicated and intimate relationships between CST fibres and these cells were evident. DISCUSSION: Overall, our data demonstrates that preconditioning the motor cortex with SC prior to spinal injury results in greatly enhanced CST sprouting and that CST peri-wound sprouting takes place in juxtaposition to macrophages.

Intracanal pressure in compressive spinal cord injury: reduction with hypothermia.

Most cases of human spinal cord injury (SCI) are accompanied by continuing cord compression. Experimentally, compression results in rapid neurological decline over hours, suggesting a rise in intracanal pressure local to the site of injury. The aim of this study was to measure the rise in local intracanal pressure accompanying progressive canal occlusion and to determine the relationship between raised intracanal pressure and neurological outcome. We also aimed to establish whether hypothermia was able to reduce raised intracanal pressure. We demonstrate that, following SCI in F344 rats, local intracanal pressure remains near normal until canal occlusion exceeds 30% of diameter, whereupon a rapid increase in pressure occurs. Intracanal pressure appears to be an important determinant of neurological recovery, with poor long-term behavioural and histological outcomes in animals subject to 8 h of 45% canal occlusion, in which intracanal pressure is significantly elevated. In contrast, good neurological recovery occurs in animals with near normal intracanal pressure (animals undergoing 8 h of 30% canal occlusion or those undergoing immediate decompression). We further demonstrate that hypothermia is an effective therapy to control raised intracanal pressure, rapidly reducing elevated intracanal pressure accompanying critical (45%) canal occlusion to near normal. Overall these data indicate that following SCI only limited canal narrowing is tolerated before local intracanal pressure rapidly rises, inducing a sharp decline in neurological outcome. Raised intracanal pressure can be controlled with hypothermia, which may be a useful therapy to emergently decompress the spinal cord prior to surgical decompression.

Hypothermia prior to decompression: buying time for treatment of acute spinal cord injury.

Human spinal cord injury (SCI) is usually accompanied by persistent cord compression. Experimental data demonstrate that compression of the traumatized cord results in rapid neurological decline over hours. Undertaking decompression in humans within this time frame has proved impractical, with the time to surgery in studies of urgent decompression averaging between 10 and 24 h. There is, therefore, an important need for a therapy to prevent the neurological deterioration of patients prior to decompressive surgery. The aim of this study was to determine if hypothermia prevents compressive SCI, thereby limiting neurological decline. Rats were subjected to a moderate mid-thoracic SCI and spacers were inserted to compress the spinal cord by 45%. Decompression, by removal of the spacer, was performed immediately, and at 2 or 8 h post-injury. Hypothermia (33 degrees C) was commenced in half the animals at 30 mins post-injury and maintained for 7.5 h, with the other half remaining normothermic (37.3 degrees C). Motor recovery was assessed weekly, and the volume and area of tissue damage determined at the end of the 8-week study period. The results demonstrate that hypothermia significantly improves the behavioral and histological outcome of animals undergoing 8 h of compressive injury (the primary outcome measure). The hypothermia-treated group regained weight-supported locomotion (Basso-Beattie-Bresnahan [BBB] locomotor assessment score 9.5 +/- 0.9), while the normothermic group remained severely paraparetic (BBB score 5.3 +/- 0.6; p

Comparison of inflammation in the brain and spinal cord following mechanical injury.

Inflammation in the CNS predominantly involves microglia and macrophages, and is believed to be a significant cause of secondary injury following trauma. This study compares the microglial and macrophage response in the rat brain and spinal cord following discrete mechanical injury to better appreciate the degree to which these cells could contribute to secondary damage in these areas. We find that, 1 week after injury, the microglial and macrophage response is significantly greater in the spinal cord compared to the brain. This is the case for injuries to both gray and white matter. In addition, we observed a greater inflammatory response in white matter compared to gray matter within both the brain and spinal cord. Because activated microglia and macrophages appear to be effectors of secondary damage, a greater degree of inflammation in the spinal cord is likely to result in more extensive secondary damage. Tissue saving strategies utilizing anti-inflammatory treatments may therefore be more useful in traumatic spinal cord than brain injury.