A pervasive large conjugative plasmid mediates multispecies biofilm formation in the intestinal microbiota increasing resilience to perturbations.

Although horizontal gene transfer is pervasive in the intestinal microbiota, we understand only superficially the roles of most exchanged genes and how the mobile repertoire affects community dynamics. Similarly, little is known about the mechanisms underlying the ability of a community to recover after a perturbation. Here, we identified and functionally characterized a large conjugative plasmid that is one of the most frequently transferred elements among Bacteroidales species and is ubiquitous in diverse human populations. This plasmid encodes both an extracellular polysaccharide and fimbriae, which promote the formation of multispecies biofilms in the mammalian gut. We use a hybridization-based approach to visualize biofilms in clarified whole colon tissue with unprecedented 3D spatial resolution. These biofilms increase bacterial survival to common stressors encountered in the gut, increasing strain resiliency, and providing a rationale for the plasmid's recent spread and high worldwide prevalence.

A Label-Free Approach for Relative Spatial Quantitation of c-di-GMP in Microbial Biofilms.

Microbial biofilms represent an important lifestyle for bacteria and are dynamic three-dimensional structures. Cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP) is a ubiquitous signaling molecule that is known to be tightly regulated with biofilm processes. While measurements of global levels of c-di-GMP have proven valuable toward understanding the genetic control of c-di-GMP production, there is a need for tools to observe the local changes of c-di-GMP production in biofilm processes. We have developed a label-free method for the direct detection of c-di-GMP in microbial colony biofilms using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry imaging (MALDI-MSI). We applied this method to the enteric pathogen Vibrio cholerae, the marine symbiont V. fischeri, and the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa PA14 and detected spatial and temporal changes in c-di-GMP signal that accompanied genetic alterations in factors that synthesize and degrade the compound. We further demonstrated how this method can be simultaneously applied to detect additional metabolites of interest from a single sample.

Outer membrane vesicles and the outer membrane protein OmpU govern Vibrio cholerae biofilm matrix assembly.

Biofilms are matrix-encased microbial communities that increase the environmental fitness and infectivity of many human pathogens including Vibrio cholerae. Biofilm matrix assembly is essential for biofilm formation and function. Known components of the V. cholerae biofilm matrix are the polysaccharide Vibrio polysaccharide (VPS), matrix proteins RbmA, RbmC, Bap1, and extracellular DNA, but the majority of the protein composition is uncharacterized. This study comprehensively analyzed the biofilm matrix proteome and revealed the presence of outer membrane proteins (OMPs). Outer membrane vesicles (OMVs) were also present in the V. cholerae biofilm matrix and were associated with OMPs and many biofilm matrix proteins suggesting that they participate in biofilm matrix assembly. Consistent with this, OMVs had the capability to alter biofilm structural properties depending on their composition. OmpU was the most prevalent OMP in the matrix, and its absence altered biofilm architecture by increasing VPS production. Single-cell force spectroscopy revealed that proteins critical for biofilm formation, OmpU, the matrix proteins RbmA, RbmC, Bap1, and VPS contribute to cell-surface adhesion forces at differing efficiency, with VPS showing the highest efficiency whereas Bap1 showing the lowest efficiency. Our findings provide new insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying biofilm matrix assembly in V. cholerae, which may provide new opportunities to develop inhibitors that specifically alter biofilm matrix properties and, thus, affect either the environmental survival or pathogenesis of V. cholerae.IMPORTANCECholera remains a major public health concern. Vibrio cholerae, the causative agent of cholera, forms biofilms, which are critical for its transmission, infectivity, and environmental persistence. While we know that the V. cholerae biofilm matrix contains exopolysaccharide, matrix proteins, and extracellular DNA, we do not have a comprehensive understanding of the majority of biofilm matrix components. Here, we discover outer membrane vesicles (OMVs) within the biofilm matrix of V. cholerae. Proteomic analysis of the matrix and matrix-associated OMVs showed that OMVs carry key matrix proteins and Vibrio polysaccharide (VPS) to help build biofilms. We also characterize the role of the highly abundant outer membrane protein OmpU in biofilm formation and show that it impacts biofilm architecture in a VPS-dependent manner. Understanding V. cholerae biofilm formation is important for developing a better prevention and treatment strategy framework.

A label-free approach for relative spatial quantitation of c-di-GMP in microbial biofilms.

Microbial biofilms represent an important lifestyle for bacteria and are dynamic three dimensional structures. Cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP) is a ubiquitous signaling molecule that is known to be tightly regulated with biofilm processes. While measurements of global levels of c-di-GMP have proven valuable towards understanding the genetic control of c-di-GMP production, there is a need for tools to observe the local changes of c-di-GMP production in biofilm processes. We have developed a label-free method for the direct detection of c-di-GMP in microbial colony biofilms using matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry imaging (MALDI-MSI). We applied this method to the enteric pathogen Vibrio cholerae, the marine symbiont V. fischeri, and the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa PA14 and detected spatial and temporal changes in c-di-GMP signal that accompanied genetic alterations in factors that synthesize and degrade the compound. We further demonstrated how this method can be simultaneously applied to detect additional metabolites of interest in a single experiment.

The Rvv two-component regulatory system regulates biofilm formation and colonization in Vibrio cholerae.

The facultative human pathogen, Vibrio cholerae, employs two-component signal transduction systems (TCS) to sense and respond to environmental signals encountered during its infection cycle. TCSs consist of a sensor histidine kinase (HK) and a response regulator (RR); the V. cholerae genome encodes 43 HKs and 49 RRs, of which 25 are predicted to be cognate pairs. Using deletion mutants of each HK gene, we analyzed the transcription of vpsL, a biofilm gene required for Vibrio polysaccharide and biofilm formation. We found that a V. cholerae TCS that had not been studied before, now termed Rvv, controls biofilm gene transcription. The Rvv TCS is part of a three-gene operon that is present in 30% of Vibrionales species. The rvv operon encodes RvvA, the HK; RvvB, the cognate RR; and RvvC, a protein of unknown function. Deletion of rvvA increased transcription of biofilm genes and altered biofilm formation, while deletion of rvvB or rvvC lead to no changes in biofilm gene transcription. The phenotypes observed in ΔrvvA depend on RvvB. Mutating RvvB to mimic constitutively active and inactive versions of the RR only impacted phenotypes in the ΔrvvA genetic background. Mutating the conserved residue required for kinase activity in RvvA did not affect phenotypes, whereas mutation of the conserved residue required for phosphatase activity mimicked the phenotype of the rvvA mutant. Furthermore, ΔrvvA displayed a significant colonization defect which was dependent on RvvB and RvvB phosphorylation state, but not on VPS production. We found that RvvA's phosphatase activity regulates biofilm gene transcription, biofilm formation, and colonization phenotypes. This is the first systematic analysis of the role of V. cholerae HKs in biofilm gene transcription and resulted in the identification of a new regulator of biofilm formation and virulence, advancing our understanding of the role TCSs play in regulating these critical cellular processes in V. cholerae.

VxrB Influences Antagonism within Biofilms by Controlling Competition through Extracellular Matrix Production and Type 6 Secretion.

The human pathogen Vibrio cholerae grows as biofilms, communities of cells encased in an extracellular matrix. When growing in biofilms, cells compete for resources and space. One common competitive mechanism among Gram-negative bacteria is the type six secretion system (T6SS), which can deliver toxic effector proteins into a diverse group of target cells, including other bacteria, phagocytic amoebas, and human macrophages. The response regulator VxrB positively regulates both biofilm matrix and T6SS gene expression. Here, we directly observe T6SS activity within biofilms, which results in improved competition with strains lacking the T6SS. VxrB significantly contributes to both attack and defense via T6SS, while also influencing competition via regulation of biofilm matrix production. We further determined that both Vibrio polysaccharide (VPS) and the biofilm matrix protein RbmA can protect cells from T6SS attack within mature biofilms. By varying the spatial mixing of predator and prey cells in biofilms, we show that a high degree of mixing favors T6SS predator strains and that the presence of extracellular DNA in V. cholerae biofilms is a signature of T6SS killing. VxrB therefore regulates both T6SS attack and matrix-based T6SS defense, to control antagonistic interactions and competition outcomes during mixed-strain biofilm formation. IMPORTANCE This work demonstrates that the Vibrio cholerae type six secretion system (T6SS) can actively kill prey strains within the interior of biofilm populations with substantial impact on population dynamics. We additionally show that the response regulator VxrB contributes to both T6SS killing and protection from T6SS killing within biofilms. Components of the biofilm matrix and the degree of spatial mixing among strains also strongly influence T6SS competition dynamics. T6SS killing within biofilms results in increased localized release of extracellular DNA, which serves as an additional matrix component. These findings collectively demonstrate that T6SS killing can contribute to competition within biofilms and that this competition depends on key regulators, matrix components, and the extent of spatial population mixture during biofilm growth.

Mechanisms Underlying Vibrio cholerae Biofilm Formation and Dispersion.

Biofilms are a widely observed growth mode in which microbial communities are spatially structured and embedded in a polymeric extracellular matrix. Here, we focus on the model bacterium Vibrio cholerae and summarize the current understanding of biofilm formation, including initial attachment, matrix components, community dynamics, social interactions, molecular regulation, and dispersal. The regulatory network that orchestrates the decision to form and disperse from biofilms coordinates various environmental inputs. These cues are integrated by several transcription factors, regulatory RNAs, and second-messenger molecules, including bis-(3'-5')-cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP). Through complex mechanisms, V. cholerae weighs the energetic cost of forming biofilms against the benefits of protection and social interaction that biofilms provide.

Utilizing imaging mass spectrometry to analyze microbial biofilm chemical responses to exogenous compounds.

Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization imaging mass spectrometry (MALDI-IMS) is an appealing label-free method for imaging biological samples which focuses on the spatial distribution of chemical signals. This approach has been used to study the chemical ecology of microbes and can be applied to study the chemical responses of microbes to treatment with exogenous compounds. Specific conjugated cholic acids such as taurocholic acid (TCA), have been shown to inhibit biofilm formation in the enteric pathogen Vibrio cholerae and MALDI-IMS can be used to directly observe the chemical responses of V. cholerae biofilm colonies to treatment with TCA. A major challenge of MALDI-IMS is optimizing the sample preparation and drying for a particular growth condition and microbial strain. Here we demonstrate how V. cholerae is cultured and prepared for MALDI-IMS analysis and highlight critical steps to ensure proper sample adherence to a MALDI target plate and maintain spatial distributions when applying this technique to any microbial strain. We additionally show how to use both manual interrogation and statistical analyses of MALDI-IMS data to establish the adequacy of the sample preparation protocol. This protocol can serve as a guideline for the development of sample preparation techniques and the acquisition of high quality MALDI-IMS data.

Nitric oxide stimulates type IV MSHA pilus retraction in Vibrio cholerae via activation of the phosphodiesterase CdpA.

Bacteria use surface appendages called type IV pili to perform diverse activities including DNA uptake, twitching motility, and attachment to surfaces. The dynamic extension and retraction of pili are often required for these activities, but the stimuli that regulate these dynamics remain poorly characterized. To address this question, we study the bacterial pathogen Vibrio cholerae, which uses mannose-sensitive hemagglutinin (MSHA) pili to attach to surfaces in aquatic environments as the first step in biofilm formation. Here, we use a combination of genetic and cell biological approaches to describe a regulatory pathway that allows V. cholerae to rapidly abort biofilm formation. Specifically, we show that V. cholerae cells retract MSHA pili and detach from a surface in a diffusion-limited, enclosed environment. This response is dependent on the phosphodiesterase CdpA, which decreases intracellular levels of cyclic-di-GMP to induce MSHA pilus retraction. CdpA contains a putative nitric oxide (NO)-sensing NosP domain, and we demonstrate that NO is necessary and sufficient to stimulate CdpA-dependent detachment. Thus, we hypothesize that the endogenous production of NO (or an NO-like molecule) in V. cholerae stimulates the retraction of MSHA pili. These results extend our understanding of how environmental cues can be integrated into the complex regulatory pathways that control pilus dynamic activity and attachment in bacterial species.

Strategies and Approaches for Discovery of Small Molecule Disruptors of Biofilm Physiology.

Biofilms, the predominant growth mode of microorganisms, pose a significant risk to human health. The protective biofilm matrix, typically composed of exopolysaccharides, proteins, nucleic acids, and lipids, combined with biofilm-grown bacteria's heterogenous physiology, leads to enhanced fitness and tolerance to traditional methods for treatment. There is a need to identify biofilm inhibitors using diverse approaches and targeting different stages of biofilm formation. This review discusses discovery strategies that successfully identified a wide range of inhibitors and the processes used to characterize their inhibition mechanism and further improvement. Additionally, we examine the structure-activity relationship (SAR) for some of these inhibitors to optimize inhibitor activity.

Sensor Domain of Histidine Kinase VxrA of Vibrio cholerae- A Hairpin-swapped Dimer and its Conformational Change.

VxrA and VxrB are cognate histidine kinase (HK) - response regulator (RR) pairs of a two-component signaling system (TCS) found in Vibrio cholerae, a bacterial pathogen that causes cholera. The VxrAB TCS positively regulates virulence, the Type VI Secretion System, biofilm formation, and cell wall homeostasis in V. cholerae, providing protection from environmental stresses and contributing to the transmission and virulence of the pathogen. The VxrA HK has a unique periplasmic sensor domain (SD) and, remarkably, lacks a cytoplasmic linker domain between the second transmembrane helix and the dimerization and histidine phosphotransfer (DHp) domain, indicating that this system may utilize a potentially unique signal sensing and transmission TCS mechanism. In this study, we have determined several crystal structures of VxrA-SD and its mutants. These structures reveal a novel structural fold forming an unusual ß hairpin-swapped dimer. A conformational change caused by relative rotation of the two monomers in a VxrA-SD dimer could potentially change the association of transmembrane helices and, subsequently, the pairing of cytoplasmic DHp domains. Based on the structural observation, we propose a putative scissor-like closing regulation mechanism for the VxrA HK.IMPORTANCE V. cholerae has a dynamic life cycle, which requires rapid adaptation to changing external conditions. Two-component signal transduction (TCS) systems allow V. cholerae to sense and respond to these environmental changes. The VxrAB TCS positively regulates a number of important V. cholerae phenotypes, including virulence, the Type Six Secretion System, biofilm formation, and cell wall homeostasis. Here, we provide the crystal structure of the VxrA sensor histidine kinase sensing domain and propose a mechanism for signal transduction. The cognate signal for VxrAB remains unknown, however, in this work we couple our structural analysis with functional assessments of key residues to further our understanding of this important TCS.

Quantitative image analysis of microbial communities with BiofilmQ.

Biofilms are microbial communities that represent a highly abundant form of microbial life on Earth. Inside biofilms, phenotypic and genotypic variations occur in three-dimensional space and time; microscopy and quantitative image analysis are therefore crucial for elucidating their functions. Here, we present BiofilmQ-a comprehensive image cytometry software tool for the automated and high-throughput quantification, analysis and visualization of numerous biofilm-internal and whole-biofilm properties in three-dimensional space and time.

Roadmap on emerging concepts in the physical biology of bacterial biofilms: from surface sensing to community formation.

Bacterial biofilms are communities of bacteria that exist as aggregates that can adhere to surfaces or be free-standing. This complex, social mode of cellular organization is fundamental to the physiology of microbes and often exhibits surprising behavior. Bacterial biofilms are more than the sum of their parts: single-cell behavior has a complex relation to collective community behavior, in a manner perhaps cognate to the complex relation between atomic physics and condensed matter physics. Biofilm microbiology is a relatively young field by biology standards, but it has already attracted intense attention from physicists. Sometimes, this attention takes the form of seeing biofilms as inspiration for new physics. In this roadmap, we highlight the work of those who have taken the opposite strategy: we highlight the work of physicists and physical scientists who use physics to engage fundamental concepts in bacterial biofilm microbiology, including adhesion, sensing, motility, signaling, memory, energy flow, community formation and cooperativity. These contributions are juxtaposed with microbiologists who have made recent important discoveries on bacterial biofilms using state-of-the-art physical methods. The contributions to this roadmap exemplify how well physics and biology can be combined to achieve a new synthesis, rather than just a division of labor.

A tyrosine phosphoregulatory system controls exopolysaccharide biosynthesis and biofilm formation in Vibrio cholerae.

Production of an extracellular matrix is essential for biofilm formation, as this matrix both secures and protects the cells it encases. Mechanisms underlying production and assembly of matrices are poorly understood. Vibrio cholerae, relies heavily on biofilm formation for survival, infectivity, and transmission. Biofilm formation requires Vibrio polysaccharide (VPS), which is produced by vps gene-products, yet the function of these products remains unknown. Here, we demonstrate that the vps gene-products vpsO and vpsU encode respectively for a tyrosine kinase and a cognate tyrosine phosphatase. Collectively, VpsO and VpsU act as a tyrosine phosphoregulatory system to modulate VPS production. We present structures of VpsU and the kinase domain of VpsO, and we report observed autocatalytic tyrosine phosphorylation of the VpsO C-terminal tail. The position and amount of tyrosine phosphorylation in the VpsO C-terminal tail represses VPS production and biofilm formation through a mechanism involving the modulation of VpsO oligomerization. We found that tyrosine phosphorylation enhances stability of VpsO. Regulation of VpsO phosphorylation by the phosphatase VpsU is vital for maintaining native VPS levels. This study provides new insights into the mechanism and regulation of VPS production and establishes general principles of biofilm matrix production and its inhibition.

c-di-GMP inhibits LonA-dependent proteolysis of TfoY in Vibrio cholerae.

The LonA (or Lon) protease is a central post-translational regulator in diverse bacterial species. In Vibrio cholerae, LonA regulates a broad range of behaviors including cell division, biofilm formation, flagellar motility, c-di-GMP levels, the type VI secretion system (T6SS), virulence gene expression, and host colonization. Despite LonA's role in cellular processes critical for V. cholerae's aquatic and infectious life cycles, relatively few LonA substrates have been identified. LonA protease substrates were therefore identified through comparison of the proteomes of wild-type and ΔlonA strains following translational inhibition. The most significantly enriched LonA-dependent protein was TfoY, a known regulator of motility and the T6SS in V. cholerae. Experiments showed that TfoY was required for LonA-mediated repression of motility and T6SS-dependent killing. In addition, TfoY was stabilized under high c-di-GMP conditions and biochemical analysis determined direct binding of c-di-GMP to LonA results in inhibition of its protease activity. The work presented here adds to the list of LonA substrates, identifies LonA as a c-di-GMP receptor, demonstrates that c-di-GMP regulates LonA activity and TfoY protein stability, and helps elucidate the mechanisms by which LonA controls important V. cholerae behaviors.

c-di-GMP modulates type IV MSHA pilus retraction and surface attachment in Vibrio cholerae.

Biofilm formation by Vibrio cholerae facilitates environmental persistence, and hyperinfectivity within the host. Biofilm formation is regulated by 3',5'-cyclic diguanylate (c-di-GMP) and requires production of the type IV mannose-sensitive hemagglutinin (MSHA) pilus. Here, we show that the MSHA pilus is a dynamic extendable and retractable system, and its activity is directly controlled by c-di-GMP. The interaction between c-di-GMP and the ATPase MshE promotes pilus extension, whereas low levels of c-di-GMP correlate with enhanced retraction. Loss of retraction facilitated by the ATPase PilT increases near-surface roaming motility, and impairs initial surface attachment. However, prolonged retraction upon surface attachment results in reduced MSHA-mediated surface anchoring and increased levels of detachment. Our results indicate that c-di-GMP directly controls MshE activity, thus regulating MSHA pilus extension and retraction dynamics, and modulating V. cholerae surface attachment and colonization.

Development of Ratiometric Bioluminescent Sensors for in Vivo Detection of Bacterial Signaling.

Second messenger signaling networks allow cells to sense and adapt to changing environmental conditions. In bacteria, the nearly ubiquitous second messenger molecule cyclic di-GMP coordinates diverse processes such as motility, biofilm formation, and virulence. In bacterial pathogens, these signaling networks allow the bacteria to survive changing environmental conditions that are experienced during infection of a mammalian host. While studies have examined the effects of cyclic di-GMP levels on virulence in these pathogens, it has not been possible to visualize cyclic di-GMP levels in real time during the stages of host infection. Toward this goal, we generate the first ratiometric, chemiluminescent biosensor scaffold that selectively responds to c-di-GMP. By engineering the biosensor scaffold, a suite of Venus-YcgR-NLuc (VYN) biosensors is generated that provide extremely high sensitivity (KD < 300 pM) and large changes in the bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) signal (up to 109%). As a proof-of-concept that VYN biosensors can image cyclic di-GMP in tissues, we show that the VYN biosensors function in the context of a tissue phantom model, with only ∼103-104 biosensor-expressing E. coli cells required for the measurement. Furthermore, we utilize the biosensor in vitro to assess changes in cyclic di-GMP in V. cholerae grown with different inputs found in the host environment. The VYN sensors developed here can serve as robust in vitro diagnostic tools for high throughput screening, as well as genetically encodable tools for monitoring the dynamics of c-di-GMP in live cells, and lay the groundwork for live cell imaging of c-di-GMP dynamics in bacteria within tissues and other complex environments.

Reciprocal c-di-GMP signaling: Incomplete flagellum biogenesis triggers c-di-GMP signaling pathways that promote biofilm formation.

The assembly status of the V. cholerae flagellum regulates biofilm formation, suggesting that the bacterium senses a lack of movement to commit to a sessile lifestyle. Motility and biofilm formation are inversely regulated by the second messenger molecule cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP). Therefore, we sought to define the flagellum-associated c-di-GMP-mediated signaling pathways that regulate the transition from a motile to a sessile state. Here we report that elimination of the flagellum, via loss of the FlaA flagellin, results in a flagellum-dependent biofilm regulatory (FDBR) response, which elevates cellular c-di-GMP levels, increases biofilm gene expression, and enhances biofilm formation. The strength of the FDBR response is linked with status of the flagellar stator: it can be reversed by deletion of the T ring component MotX, and reduced by mutations altering either the Na+ binding ability of the stator or the Na+ motive force. Absence of the stator also results in reduction of mannose-sensitive hemagglutinin (MSHA) pilus levels on the cell surface, suggesting interconnectivity of signal transduction pathways involved in biofilm formation. Strains lacking flagellar rotor components similarly launched an FDBR response, however this was independent of the status of assembly of the flagellar stator. We found that the FDBR response requires at least three specific diguanylate cyclases that contribute to increased c-di-GMP levels, and propose that activation of biofilm formation during this response relies on c-di-GMP-dependent activation of positive regulators of biofilm production. Together our results dissect how flagellum assembly activates c-di-GMP signaling circuits, and how V. cholerae utilizes these signals to transition from a motile to a sessile state.