Stable carbon isotopic characterization of rice vinegar protein as an intrinsic reference for discriminating the authenticity of brewed rice vinegar.

Rice vinegar plays an important role in daily life. However, some unscrupulous manufacturers may deliberately add synthetic acetic acid in vinegar products to reduce fermentation time and save production costs. To protect the rights and health of consumers, vinegar authenticity must be controlled. The rice vinegar protein was used as an intrinsic reference and its stable carbon isotope ratio (δ13Cprotein) was analyzed by elemental analyzer-isotope ratio mass spectrometry. The stable carbon isotope ratio difference between the acetic acid and the rice vinegar protein (Δδ13Cacetic acid-protein) was calculated to evaluate vinegar authenticity. Sixteen rice vinegar samples were analyzed and a stable carbon isotopic pattern of rice vinegar was established by the 95% confidence interval for Δδ13Cacetic acid-protein (0.27‰-2.10‰). An acetic acid adulteration curve of Δδ13Cacetic acid-protein was also assumed according to the data from rice vinegar samples, and its validity was confirmed by rice vinegar deliberately blended with acetic acid at different ratios (25, 50, and 75%). The Δδ13Cacetic acid-protein values of the adulterated vinegars decreased with increasing amounts blended acetic acid, but the δ13Cprotein values did not, showing that rice vinegar protein could be used as an intrinsic reference for identifying the adulterated rice vinegar. The rice vinegar adulterated with acetic acid at higher than approximately 10% could be detected.

Simultaneous Analysis of the Stable Carbon Isotope Ratios of Acetoin and Acetic Acid by GC-C-IRMS for Adulteration Detection in Brewed Rice Vinegar Products.

In this study, we developed a method to simultaneously measure the stable carbon isotope ratio for acetic acid (δ 13Cacetic acid) and acetoin (δ13Cacetoin) in rice vinegar by gas chromatography-combustion-isotope ratio mass spectrometry. The method showed good precision and accuracy. With this method, data from 16 brewed rice vinegars and 10 acetic acid samples were used to evaluate the feasibility of adulteration detection. On the basis that all δ13Cacetoin values of brewed rice vinegars are nearly constant, a characteristic pattern of the stable carbon isotope in rice vinegar was built with the 95% confidence intervals for δ13Cacetic acid (-26.97 to -25.38‰), δ13Cacetoin (-28.14 to -27.09‰), and Δδ13C (0.61 to 2.27‰). An adulteration detection curve of Δδ13C was proposed based on the results of vinegar and acetic acid samples and confirmed by vinegar spiked with different amounts of acetic acid. This method could be useful in estimating the blending ratio of adulterated rice vinegar products. Products containing more than 10% of synthetic acetic acid could be possibly identified.