Vesicle aggregates as a model for primitive cellular assemblies.

Primitive cell models help to understand the role that compartmentalization plays in origin of life scenarios. Here we present a combined experimental and modeling approach towards the construction of simple model systems for primitive cellular assemblies. Charged lipid vesicles aggregate in the presence of oppositely charged biopolymers, such as nucleic acids or polypeptides. Based on zeta potential measurements, dynamic light scattering and cryo-transmission electron-microscopy, we have characterized the behavior of empty and ferritin-filled large unilamellar POPC vesicles, doped with different amounts of cationic (DDAB, CTAB) and anionic (sodium oleate) surfactants, and their aggregation upon the addition of anionic (tRNA, poly-l-glutamic acid) and cationic (poly-l-arginine) biopolymers, respectively. The experimental results are rationalized by a phenomenological modeling approach that predicts the average size of the vesicle aggregates as function of the amount of added biopolymers. In addition, we discuss the mechanism of vesicle aggregation induced by oppositely charged biopolymers. Our study complements previous reports about the formation of giant vesicle clusters and thus provides a general vista on primitive cell systems, based on the association of vesicles into compartmentalized aggregates.

Spontaneous encapsulation and concentration of biological macromolecules in liposomes: an intriguing phenomenon and its relevance in origins of life.

One of the main open questions in origin of life research focuses on the formation, by self-organization, of primitive cells composed by macromolecular compounds enclosed within a semi-permeable membrane. A successful experimental strategy for studying the emergence and the properties of primitive cells relies on a synthetic biology approach, consisting in the laboratory assembly of cell models of minimal complexity (semi-synthetic minimal cells). Despite the recent advancements in the construction and characterization of synthetic cells, an important physical aspect related to their formation is still not well known, namely, the mechanism of solute entrapment inside liposomes (in particular, the entrapment of macromolecules). In the past years, we have investigated this phenomenon and here we shortly review our experimental results. We show how the detailed cryo-transmission electron microscopy analyses of liposome populations created in the presence of ferritin (taken as model protein) or ribosomes have revealed that a small fraction of liposomes contains a high number of solutes, against statistical expectations. The local (intra-liposomal) macromolecule concentration in these liposomes largely exceeds the bulk concentration. A similar behaviour is observed when multi-molecular reaction mixtures are used, whereby the reactions occur effectively only inside those liposomes that have entrapped high number of molecules. If similar mechanisms operated in early times, these intriguing results support a scenario whereby the formation of lipid compartments plays an important role in concentrating the components of proto-metabolic systems-in addition to their well-known functions of confinement and protection.

Encapsulation of ferritin, ribosomes, and ribo-peptidic complexes inside liposomes: insights into the origin of metabolism.

Here we summarize the main results of our latest investigation on the spontaneous encapsulation of proteins (ferritin) and ribosomes inside lipid vesicles. We show that when vesicles form in a solution containing some macromolecules (even at low concentration), in contrast to the expectations, a few but measurable number of vesicles is able to capture a very high number of solutes, up to 60 times the external concentration. We also show preliminary evidences on the encapsulation of additional solutes (ribo-peptidic complexes, fluorescent proteins and enzymes), and shortly present our current approach aimed at exploiting this phenomenon. In particular, we would like to reveal how the formation of compartments can trigger effective intra-vesicle reactions starting from diluted solutions. Although the mechanistic details for this phenomenon are still missing, we claim that these new evidences are highly relevant for the origin of the first functional cells in primitive times.

Interfacial concentrations of chloride and bromide in zwitterionic micelles with opposite dipoles: experimental determination by chemical trapping and a theoretical description.

Interfacial concentrations of chloride and bromide ions, with Li(+), Na(+), K(+), Rb(+), Cs(+), trimethylammonium (TMA(+)), Ca(2+), and Mg(2+) as counterions, were determined by chemical trapping in micelles formed by two zwitterionic surfactants, namely N-hexadecyl-N,N-dimethyl-3-ammonio-1-propanesulfonate (HPS) and hexadecylphosphorylcholine (HDPC) micelles. Appropriate standard curves for the chemical trapping method were obtained by measuring the product yields of chloride and bromide salts with 2,4,6-trimethyl-benzenediazonium (BF(4)) in the presence of low molecular analogs (N,N,N-trimethyl-propane sulfonate and methyl-phosphorylcholine) of the employed surfactants. The experimentally determined values for the local Br(-) (Cl(-)) concentrations were modeled by fully integrated non-linear Poisson Boltzmann equations. The best fits to all experimental data were obtained by considering that ions at the interface are not fixed at an adsorption site but are free to move in the interfacial plane. In addition, the calculation of ion distribution allowed the estimation of the degree of ion coverage by using standard chemical potential differences accounting for ion specificity.

Vesicle behavior: in search of explanations.

In this paper we will present a series of experiments in the general field of surfactant aggregates and, in particular, in vesicle chemistry, which have found no definitive explanation until now. These experiments concern vesicle self-reproduction (in particular, the so-called matrix effect); the interaction between vesicle and RNA, where RNA appears capable of discriminating between vesicles differing slightly in size; the fusion of oppositely charged vesicles, which brings about unexpected behavior of size distribution; and some aspects of local concentration inside vesicles, which still lack clarification in terms of local versus overall concentration. The theoretical and experimental implications of this not yet understood behavior will be discussed, emphasizing that progress in the field must face the difficulty of applying thermodynamics to these kinetically trapped systems, and the general difficulty of understanding how kinetic and thermodynamic factors interplay with each other.