Advancing the Use of Passive Sampling in Risk Assessment and Management of Sediments Contaminated with Hydrophobic Organic Chemicals: Results of an International Ex Situ Passive Sampling Interlaboratory Comparison.

This work presents the results of an international interlaboratory comparison on ex situ passive sampling in sediments. The main objectives were to map the state of the science in passively sampling sediments, identify sources of variability, provide recommendations and practical guidance for standardized passive sampling, and advance the use of passive sampling in regulatory decision making by increasing confidence in the use of the technique. The study was performed by a consortium of 11 laboratories and included experiments with 14 passive sampling formats on 3 sediments for 25 target chemicals (PAHs and PCBs). The resulting overall interlaboratory variability was large (a factor of ∼10), but standardization of methods halved this variability. The remaining variability was primarily due to factors not related to passive sampling itself, i.e., sediment heterogeneity and analytical chemistry. Excluding the latter source of variability, by performing all analyses in one laboratory, showed that passive sampling results can have a high precision and a very low intermethod variability (

Quantifying the effects of temperature and salinity on partitioning of hydrophobic organic chemicals to silicone rubber passive samplers.

Nowadays, passive sampling is a widely applied technique to determine freely dissolved aqueous concentrations of hydrophobic organic chemicals (HOCs), such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). Crucial to the measurements are sampler-water partition coefficients, which are generally determined in the laboratory under "standard conditions" (in freshwater at 20 °C). Theoretically, however, the coefficients are dependent on environmental conditions, such as temperature and salinity. Yet, there are insufficient experimental data in the scientific literature to prove this for different polymers. Several polymers are already being applied during field monitoring, however, and neglecting any effects may lead to imprecise results. In the present study, we therefore quantified the effects of temperature and salinity on the sampler-water partition coefficients of PAHs and PCBs for silicone rubber, a material used in Dutch passive sampling monitoring campaigns. The results demonstrated a chemical-specific and hydrophobicity-dependent temperature effect, being independent of salinity, and a chemical- and temperature-independent salinity effect. Based on the obtained data, location-specific silicone rubber-water partition coefficients (Ksr-w; adjusted for temperature and salinity) can be calculated. The impact of applying such location-specific values was demonstrated using the Dutch passive sampling field monitoring database, covering ten years of PAH and PCB data for several locations. Adjusting the Ksr-w values resulted in aqueous concentrations that were lowered by a factor of 1.6 on average. The reduction was rather constant because of the manner of sampling (under nonequilibrium conditions and using performance reference compounds) and calculating. When sampling under equilibrium conditions in seawater at temperatures at about freezing, and/or applying different calculation approaches, the adjustment effect can potentially increase up to a factor of about 5-6 for the more hydrophobic PAHs and PCBs. Although this study exclusively focused on silicone rubber, qualitatively the results will also apply to other passive sampling materials.

Determining high-quality critical body residues for multiple species and chemicals by applying improved experimental design and data interpretation concepts.

Ecotoxicological effect data are generally expressed as effective concentrations in the external exposure medium and do thus not account for differences in chemical uptake, bioavailability, and metabolism, which can introduce substantial data variation. The Critical Body Residue (CBR) concept provides clear advantages, because it links effects directly to the internal exposure. Using CBRs instead of external concentrations should therefore reduce variability. For compounds that act via narcosis even a constant CBR has been proposed. Despite the expected uniformity, CBR values for these compounds still show large variability, possibly due to biased and inconsistent experimental testing. In the present study we tested whether variation in CBR data can be substantially reduced when using an improved experimental design and avoiding confounding factors. The aim was to develop and apply a well-defined test protocol for accurately and precisely measuring CBR data, involving improved (passive) dosing, sampling, and processing of organisms. The chemicals 1,2,4-trichlorobenzene, 1,2,3,4-tetrachlorobenzene, 2,3,4-trichloroaniline, 2,3,5,6-tetrachloroaniline, 4-chloro-3-methylphenol, pentylbenzene, pyrene, and bromophos-methyl were tested on Lumbriculus variegatus (California blackworm), Hyalella azteca (scud), and Poecilia reticulata (guppy), which yielded a high-quality database of 348 individual CBR values. Medians of CBR values ranged from 2.1 to 16.1 mmol/kg wet weight (ww) within all combinations of chemicals and species, except for the insecticide bromophos-methyl, for which the median was 1.3 mmol/kg ww. The new database thus covers about one log unit, which is considerably less than in existing databases. Medians differed maximally by a factor of 8.4 between the 7 chemicals but within one species, and by a factor of 2.6 between the three species but for individual chemicals. Accounting for the chemicals' internal distribution to different partitioning domains and relating effects to estimated concentrations in the target compartment (i.e., membrane lipids) was expected to but did not decrease the overall variability, likely because the surrogate partition coefficients for membrane lipid, storage lipid, protein, and carbohydrate that were used as input parameters did not sufficiently represent the actual partitioning processes. The results of this study demonstrate that a well-designed test setup can produce CBR data that are highly uniform beyond chemical and biological diversity.

Partitioning of polychlorinated biphenyls into human cells and adipose tissues: evaluation of octanol, triolein, and liposomes as surrogates.

Whereas octanol, triacylglycerides, and liposomes have all been proposed as surrogates for measuring the affinity of hydrophobic organic contaminants to human lipids, no comparative evaluation of their suitability exists. Here we conducted batch sorption experiments with polyoxymethylene passive samplers to determine the partition coefficients at 37 °C of 18 polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) from water into (i) triolein (Ktriolein/water), (ii) eight types of liposomes (Kliposome/water), (iii) human abdominal fat tissues (KAFT/water) from seven individuals, and (iv) human MCF-7 cells cultured in vitro (Kcell/water). Differences between KAFT/water among individuals and between Kliposome/water among liposome types were very small and not correlated to structural attributes of the PCBs. Similarly, the length and degree of saturation of the phospholipid carbon chains, the headgroup, and the composition of the liposome did not affect the partitioning of PCBs into the studied liposomes. Whereas Kliposome/water values were similar to literature values of Koctanol/water adjusted to 37 °C, they both were lower than KAFT/water and Kcell/water by a factor of 3 on average. Partitioning of PCBs into triolein on the other hand closely mimicked that into human lipids, for which triolein is thus a better surrogate than either octanol or liposomes. Previously published polyparameter linear free energy relationships for partitioning from water into storage lipids and liposomes predicted the measured partition coefficients with a root-mean-square error of less than 0.15 log units, if the chosen equations and solute descriptors do not allow chlorine substitution in the ortho-position to influence the prediction. By guiding the selection of (i) a surrogate for the experimental determination and (ii) a method for the prediction of partitioning into human lipids, this study contributes to a better assessment of hydrophobic organic contaminant bioaccumulation in humans.

Intra- and interspecies variation in bioconcentration potential of polychlorinated biphenyls: are all lipids equal?

The variation among bioconcentration factors (BCFs) available in the literature is commonly ascribed to experimental parameters and metabolic capacity. Though bioconcentration is generally considered to be governed by partitioning processes and therefore to depend on the composition of the partition phases, the effect of lipid composition on BCFs measured for hydrophobic organic chemicals has largely escaped attention. The reason may be that the effect cannot easily be studied separately in a conventional BCF test setup and that any subtle effects will often be obscured by the variation normally observed when working with living organisms. In the present study, this variation was circumvented by substituting biota with biological homogenates, which allowed measuring chemical partitioning in a fashion that has proved successful for many other environmental matrixes (e.g., sediments, soils, carbonaceous materials). The appropriateness of using a homogenate as a representation of the organism from which it was derived was demonstrated by a good agreement between homogenate-water partition coefficients (or necroconcentration factors; NCFs) and actual BCFs for PCBs and aquatic worms. Subsequent experiments focused on the intra- and interspecies differences in lipid-normalized NCFs. Intraspecies variation was studied for aquatic worms and sticklebacks, which were acclimatized at different temperatures (5-24 °C), whereas interspecies variation was investigated by determining NCFs for eight different aquatic species. Although temperature-induced intraspecies differences were subtle (<0.16 log units), interspecies differences among lipid-normalized NCFs were as high as 0.9 log units, with homogenates of "simple" organisms showing a lower sorption capacity than those of the more "complex" species. These results suggest that the variation observed in the literature BCFs may partly be caused by differences in lipid composition and contest the usefulness of the common practice of applying generic BCFs in risk assessment of chemicals.

Measuring picogram per liter concentrations of freely dissolved parent and alkyl PAHs (PAH-34), using passive sampling with polyoxymethylene.

Passive sampling with nondepletive sorbents is receiving increasing interest because of its potential to measure freely dissolved concentrations of hydrophobic organic compounds (HOCs) at very low concentrations, as well as its potential for both laboratory use and field deployment. However, consistent approaches have yet to be developed for the majority of HOCs of environmental and regulatory interest. In the present study, a passive sampling method was developed which allows the freely dissolved concentrations of 18 parent and 16 groups of alkyl polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA)'s "PAH-34" target compound list to be measured. Commercially available 76-µm-thick polyoxymethylene (POM) was placed in sediment/water slurries and exposed for up to 126 days, with 28 days found to be sufficient to obtain equilibrium among the sediment, water, and POM phases for the target 2- to 6-ring PAHs. The POM/water partition coefficients (K(POM)) necessary to calculate freely dissolved concentrations for parent PAHs were determined in two separate laboratories (one using pure standards, and the other using coal tar/petroleum-contaminated sediments) and agreed very well. Since the so-called "16" alkyl PAHs on the PAH-34 list actually include several hundreds of isomers for which no standards exist, sediments impacted by coal tar, or spiked with a coal tar/petroleum nonaqueous phase liquid (NAPL) were also used to measure K(POM) values for each alkyl PAH cluster. The log K(POM) values ranged from ca. 3.0 to 6.2 for 2- to 6-ring parent PAHs, and correlated well with SPARC octanol/water coefficients (K(OW)) (correlation coefficient of r(2) = 0.986). However, log K(POM) values for alkyl PAHs deviated increasingly from SPARC log K(OW) values with increasing degree of alkylation. A simple empirical model that incorporates the number of carbon atoms in a PAH gave a better fit to the experimental log K(POM) values, and was used to estimate log K(POM) for alkyl PAHs that could not be directly measured. Detection limits (as freely dissolved concentrations) ranged from ca. 1 part per trillion (ng/L) for the 2-ring PAH naphthalene, down to <1 pg/L (part per quadrillion) for the 5- and 6-ring PAHs. Sorption isotherms were linear (r(2) > 0.99) over at least 4 orders of magnitude.

Evaluation of liposome-water partitioning for predicting bioaccumulation potential of hydrophobic organic chemicals.

Considering the importance of bioaccumulation factors (BAFs) in risk assessment of chemicals and the ethical issues and complexity of the determination of these factors in standard tests with living organisms, there is a need for alternative approaches for predicting bioaccumulation. In this study, liposome-water partitioning coefficients as determined by using solid-phase microextraction (SPME) were evaluated for the cause of assessing bioaccumulation potential of hydrophobic organic chemicals (HOCs). To this end, the SPME method was mapped (in terms of mass balance, mode of spiking, kinetics, and reproducibility) and validated against literature data. Furthermore, the robustness of liposomes as partitioning phase was investigated (in terms of chemical loading, and pH and ionic strength of the medium), and finally liposome-water partition coefficients (K(lipw)) determined for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs; 4.5 < logK(ow) < 7.2) were compared with literature BAF values for several aquatic species. The results indicated that (i) SPME is a valid, fast, and reproducible method for measuring K(lipw) values; (ii) liposomes provide a very robust partitioning phase; and (iii) K(lipw) values agreed very well with literature PAH BAF values. SPME-derived K(lipw) values therefore seem a very promising predictor of bioaccumulation potential of HOCs. By including model- or in vitro-derived biotransformation rates, bioaccumulation potential estimates might be converted into surrogate BAFs, thereby extending the applicability of K(lipw) values to metabolizable chemicals and species with more advanced biotransformation capacity.

PAH bioavailability in field sediments: comparing different methods for predicting in situ bioaccumulation.

In situ exposure concentrations of chemicals in sediments and their depending risks are determined by site-specific parameters (e.g., sediment organic carbon composition), controlling bioavailability. Over the years, several analytical methods have been developed to assess bioavailable concentrations or fractions. Some of these methods have been successful in the laboratory, but few attempts have been made to test their potential for predicting actual in situ bioavailability. In this study, solid-phase microextraction (SPME)-fibers and aquatic worms (Lumbriculus variegatus) were exposed in situ at three locations. In addition, laboratory-based methods, i.e., methods with which sampling of the bioavailable fraction/concentration took place in the laboratory, being SPME, polyoxymethylene solid-phase extraction (POM-SPE), hydroxypropyl-beta-yclodextrin-(HPCD), and 6 h-Tenax extraction were applied to sediments collected at the locations. Using equilibrium partitioning-based calculations, biotic PAH levels were calculated from the concentrations or fractions extracted by the used methods. In general, method-predicted concentrations were within a factor of 10 of those measured in field-exposed oligochaetes, with in situ SPME and laboratory-based POM-SPE yielding the best results. As a reference, the currently used generic risk assessment approach overpredicted biotic concentrations by a factor of 10-100, which corresponded to in situ SPME-derived sediment-water distribution coefficients and biota-to-sediment accumulation factors being up to 2 orders of magnitude higher and lower, respectively, than generic values. These observations advocate site-specific risk assessment for PAHs, for which potential tools were evaluated in this study.

Bioconcentration factor hydrophobicity cutoff: an artificial phenomenon reconstructed.

The debate on whether highly hydrophobic organic chemicals (with log Kow > 5-6) bioconcentrate less than may be expected from their hydrophobicity is still not settled. The often-observed hydrophobicity "cutoff" might either be explained by artifacts occurring during bioconcentration factor (BCF) measurements or by a true mechanism, i.e., reduced uptake of larger molecules due to decreased membrane permeation. In this paper, we advocate there is no hydrophobicity cutoff, at least not for compounds with log Kow of up to 7.5. Data are presented on the uptake of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in the aquatic worm Lumbriculus variegatus. For this combination of chemicals/organism, BCFs were measured using several approaches, including traditional batch uptake kinetics measurements and alternative ones, involving solid-phase microextraction (SPME), polyoxymethylene solid-phase extraction (POM-SPE), field exposures, and the substitution of living worms by dead worm material or liposomes. A hydrophobicity cutoff was observed at two levels during the traditional approach only, whereas for the other approaches it was absent. The data were used to demonstrate the presence and impact of artifacts due to so-called "third phase effects" and nonequilibrium conditions that can obscure "true uptake". The experiments suggest that previously observed cutoff effects can be ascribed to artifacts, and that current risk assessment (often incorporating a BCF cutoff) as well as BCF measurement techniques of very hydrophobic chemicals should be revised.

Predicting PAH bioaccumulation and toxicity in earthworms exposed to manufactured gas plant soils with solid-phase microextraction.

Soils from former manufactured gas plant (MGP) sites are often heavily contaminated with polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Current risk assessment methods that rely on total PAH concentrations likely overstate adverse effects of such soils since bioavailability is ignored. In this study, solid-phase microextraction (SPME) was applied to estimate bioavailable PAH concentrations and toxicity in earthworms exposed to 15 MGP soils. In addition, PAH sorption to all soils (K0o values) was determined. The results showed a several orders of magnitude variation in Koc values, demonstrating that generic organic carbon-normalized sorption coefficients will typically be overconservative at MGP sites. SPME-predicted bioaccumulation generally was within a factor of 10 of measured bioaccumulation (in earthworm bioassays), in contrast to current risk assessment model estimates that overpredicted bioaccumulation 10-10 000 times. Furthermore, on the basis of estimated total body residues of narcotic PAHs, SPME correctly predicted worm mortality observed during bioassays in the majority of cases. For MGP sites where current risk assessment procedures indicate concerns, SPME thus provides a useful tool for performing a refined, site-specific assessment.