RESUMO
OBJECTIVES: To explore the effectiveness of two educational strategies for teaching empathy to medical students, focusing on their skills and on the theoretical knowledge and self-perception of empathy by patients, professors, and observers. METHODS: This is a randomized controlled study. Clerkship students were divided into two groups: an active group - Role Play and Reflection Group(RRG), and a more traditional group - Lecture Presentation Group(LPG). They were assessed pre- and post-intervention using the Jefferson Empathy Scale(JSPE), ESWIM Empathy Scale, CARE, empathic skills through simulated patient encounters, and a theoretical knowledge test. RESULTS: A total of 169 students were included. The RRG had higher scores (d=0.81) and greater gains (d=0.82) in empathic skills than the LPG. However, there were no significant differences in knowledge or other scales. Upon assessing skill acquisition (Post-Pre gains), there was a significant increase in both groups for all outcomes, except for JSPE in the LPG group and ESWIM for both groups. CONCLUSION: Medical empathy can be taught, and active learning methodologies can lead to better outcomes, especially on the ability to provide empathic care. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: These findings reinforce existing literature and helps medical schools make informed decisions regarding their teaching methodologies. TRIAL REGISTRY: https://ensaiosclinicos.gov.br/rg/RBR-8rwx89c.
RESUMO
Maritime traffic is essential for global trade but faces significant challenges, including navigation safety, environmental protection, and the prevention of illicit activities. This work presents a framework for detecting illegal activities carried out by vessels, combining navigation behavior detection models with rules based on expert knowledge. Using synthetic and real datasets based on the Automatic Identification System (AIS), we structured our framework into five levels based on the Joint Directors of Laboratories (JDL) model, efficiently integrating data from multiple sources. Activities are classified into four categories: illegal fishing, suspicious activity, anomalous activity, and normal activity. To address the issue of a lack of labels and integrate data-driven detection with expert knowledge, we employed a stack ensemble model along with active learning. The results showed that the framework was highly effective, achieving 99% accuracy in detecting illegal fishing and 92% in detecting suspicious activities. Furthermore, it drastically reduced the need for manual checks by specialists, transforming experts' tacit knowledge into explicit knowledge through the models and allowing continuous updates of maritime domain rules. This work significantly contributes to maritime surveillance, offering a scalable and efficient solution for detecting illegal activities in the maritime domain.
RESUMO
Resumo Objetivou-se analisar a percepção de estudantes e egressos sobre a utilização da Aprendizagem Baseada em Problemas (ABP) na formação do enfermeiro. Trata-se de um estudo qualitativo que utiliza a modalidade compreensiva e interpretativa proposta pela Hermenêutica-Dialética. Realizaram-se quatro grupos focais com a participação de 17 estudantes e 16 egressos de uma instituição de ensino superior que aplica a ABP na formação de enfermeiros. A análise dos resultados permitiu a definição de cinco categorias temáticas: dificuldade de adaptação em relação ao método; conquista de autonomia sobre o próprio aprendizado; incentivo ao desenvolvimento do raciocínio clínico; aprimoramento da comunicação e das relações interpessoais e integração entre teoria e prática. Evidencia-se que a utilização da ABP favorece a aproximação com as proposições das diretrizes curriculares para a formação do enfermeiro por meio do desenvolvimento de habilidades e competências como autonomia, comunicação, relações interpessoais e raciocínio clínico mediante práticas integrais e contextualizadas. Entretanto, os estudantes enfrentam dificuldades com as mudanças observadas ao serem inseridos nela ABP, as quais são superadas no decorrer do processo de implementação.
Abstract This study aimed to analyze students' and graduates' perceptions regarding the use of Problem-Based Learning (PBL) in nurse education. This is a qualitative study that employs the comprehensive and interpretative approach proposed by Dialectical Hermeneutics. Four focus groups were conducted with the participation of 17 students and 16 graduates from a higher education institution that implements PBL in nurse education. The analysis of results allowed for the identification of five thematic categories: difficulty in adapting to the method; attainment of autonomy in one's own learning; encouragement of clinical reasoning development; enhancement of communication and interpersonal relationships; and integration between theory and practice. It is evident that the use of PBL promotes alignment with the propositions of curriculum guidelines for nurse education by fostering the development of skills and competencies such as autonomy, communication, interpersonal relationships, and clinical reasoning through comprehensive and contextualized practices. However, students encounter challenges with the changes observed when introduced to PBL, which are overcome during the implementation process.
RESUMO
Active learning has consistently played a significant role in education. Through interactive tasks, group projects, and a variety of engaging activities, students are encouraged to forge connections with the subject matter. However, the pandemic has necessitated that educators adapt and refine their active learning techniques to accommodate the online environment. This has resulted in stimulating innovations in the field, encompassing virtual simulations, online collaboration tools, and interactive multimedia. The COVID-19 pandemic has rapidly transformed the landscape of teaching and learning, particularly in higher education. One of the most prominent shifts has been the widespread adoption of active learning techniques, which have increased student engagement and fostered deeper learning experiences. In this chapter, we examine the evolution of active learning during the pandemic, emphasizing its advantages and challenges. Furthermore, we delve into the role of advances in artificial intelligence and their potential to enhance the effectiveness of active learning approaches. As we once focused on leveraging the opportunities of remote teaching, we must now shift our attention to harnessing the power of AI responsibly and ethically to benefit our students. Drawing from our expertise in educational innovation, we provide insights and recommendations for educators aiming to maximize the benefits of active learning in the post-pandemic era.
Assuntos
COVID-19 , Educação a Distância , Pandemias , Aprendizagem Baseada em Problemas , SARS-CoV-2 , COVID-19/epidemiologia , Humanos , Aprendizagem Baseada em Problemas/métodos , Educação a Distância/métodos , Educação a Distância/tendências , Inteligência ArtificialRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: This study assessed 2 modalities for teaching responsible conduct of research and human subjects protection (RCR/HSP) to surgical residents in Guatemala-an "off the shelf" online curriculum and a new in-person curriculum specific to the local context. METHODS: In 2018, 160 surgical residents in 3 large urban hospitals in Guatemala City completed 2 online programs in RCR/HSP. Residents in the intervention arm also completed 7 weeks of in-person training. Pre- and post-assessments tested awareness of key concepts with particular attention to international and Guatemalan research regulations. Group differences in matched (pre- and post-) mean scores were analyzed using t-tests. RESULTS: One hundred forty residents completed pre- and post-training assessments and were included in the analytic sample. Overall mean scores improved modestly from 52.7 to 58.7 points out of 100. Intervention-arm trainees reported greater confidence in recognizing ethical issues, understanding legal and ethical requirements for research, and identifying, reporting and avoiding scientific misconduct than control-arm trainees. CONCLUSION: Given the limited availability of RCR/HSP faculty, financial resources, and time in the surgical training schedule, the investigators recommend that academic authorities in Guatemala consider online training programs in RCR/HSP in all surgical residency programs as an affordable and scalable strategy to build ethical research skills in its surgical workforce. Investment in human resources to support in-person ethics education as a way to build self-efficacy in ethical decision-making should be considered.
RESUMO
The COVID-19 pandemic has posed challenges for education, particularly in undergraduate teaching. In this study, we report on the experience of how a private university successfully addressed this challenge through an active methodology applied to a microbiology discipline offered remotely to students from various health-related courses (veterinary, physiotherapy, nursing, biomedicine, and nutrition). Remote teaching was combined with the "Adopt a Bacterium" methodology, implemented for the first time on Google Sites. The distance learning activity notably improved student participation in microbiology discussions, both through word cloud analysis and the richness of discourse measured by the Shannon index. Furthermore, feedback from students about the e-learning approach was highly positive, indicating its effectiveness in motivating and involving students in the learning process. The results also demonstrate that despite being offered simultaneously to students, the methodology allowed for the acquisition of specialized knowledge within each course and sparked student interest in various aspects of microbiology. In conclusion, the remote "Adopt a Bacterium" methodology facilitated knowledge sharing among undergraduate students from different health-related courses and represented a valuable resource in distance microbiology education.
Assuntos
COVID-19 , Educação a Distância , Microbiologia , Educação a Distância/métodos , Microbiologia/educação , Humanos , Universidades , SARS-CoV-2 , Estudantes , Pandemias , Instrução por Computador/métodosRESUMO
Endocrine physiology is a complex subject for students. Game-based learning (GBL) and case-based learning (CBL) are active methodologies that are widely used because of their potential for motivation and greater proximity to the reality of modern students. We evaluated the effectiveness of GBL and CBL among veterinary medicine students compared with a control group using peer tutoring. Students (n = 106) from two institutions volunteered to participate in this study. The participants were submitted to a pretest questionnaire and subsequently were divided into three paired groups by their performance on the pretest exam: 1) traditional class + peer tutoring, 2) traditional class + GBL, and 3) traditional class + CBL. After the students completed the activities, their performance was once again evaluated by applying a new test with the same initial 10 questions and another set of 10 different questions. The students' perceptions and satisfaction with the methodologies and learning strategies were assessed. Anxiety was assessed with the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory before and after the conventional class and after the active methodologies. The GBL group significantly improved their correct answers compared with the baseline (P < 0.05), with no significant difference from CBL and peer tutoring. Anxiety levels did not differ regardless of the time of evaluation or the teaching methodology applied. GBL promoted a greater perception of the stimulus for self-study and problem-solving ability and contributed to the development of group dynamics compared with the group who received CBL (P < 0.05). In conclusion, GBL showed better results than peer tutoring and CBL.NEW & NOTEWORTHY We compared the supplementary use of game-based learning, case-based learning, and peer tutoring in the study of endocrine physiology by veterinary students and observed a slight advantage for game-based learning over the other two methodologies. The game was developed by the authors and is an unprecedented tool that can prove useful to improve knowledge acquisition in students of veterinary medicine. Thus, game-based learning is an effective supplementary teaching strategy.
Assuntos
Aprendizagem , Estudantes , Humanos , Motivação , Resolução de Problemas , Inquéritos e QuestionáriosRESUMO
Resumo Introdução: A necessidade premente de formar médicos autônomos e proativos implica novas abordagens didáticas e formas de mediar o conteúdo. Nesse contexto, a utilização de métodos ativos de ensino e aprendizagem pode incrementar o perfil do novo profissional. A Aprendizagem Baseada em Casos (ABC) é uma estratégia fundamentada na capacidade de o estudante relacionar teoria e prática com autonomia e tomada de decisão. A disciplina de genética aborda conteúdos que podem parecer distantes do cotidiano e da prática profissional futura, e, por isso, a necessidade de utilizar estratégias de ensino que facilitem a compreensão da aplicação desse conhecimento na prática médica. Objetivo: O presente trabalho teve por objetivo avaliar a ABC como abordagem pedagógica no processo de ensino-aprendizagem de genética para o curso de Medicina de uma instituição pública. Método: Aplicou-se um protocolo de método ativo composto por nove casos clínicos a 46 estudantes de Medicina da Universidade de Brasília que, posteriormente, foram divididos em nove grupos. Por meio de questionários, avaliaram-se o desempenho e as percepções em relação ao método. Os resultados quantitativos foram analisados por meio do teste t de Student. Resultado: O rendimento do trabalho em grupo foi estatisticamente maior em oito dos nove casos em comparação ao trabalho individual. A atividade foi considerada boa ou muito boa por 76% dos estudantes, e 90% mencionaram que houve aumento da motivação. Além disso, 71,4% destes demonstraram interesse em estudar mais sobre o assunto após a aula, 20% se consideraram capazes de ensinar o assunto a outras pessoas, e 42% avaliaram que acertariam todas ou a maioria das questões caso fossem submetidos a uma nova avaliação. Com relação ao trabalho em equipe, 38% relataram se sentir mais motivados. Por fim, 86% consideraram relevante ou muito relevante a discussão de casos clínicos para a formação profissional. Conclusão: Os resultados demostraram sucesso no uso do método ABC na abordagem de genética, porém apontaram que há dificuldades na utilização de métodos de ensino alternativos à aula expositiva. Apesar disso, fica explícito que a estratégia adotada pode levar à mobilização de conhecimentos prévios em situações da prática profissional.
Abstract Introduction: The pressing need to train autonomous and proactive professionals demands new ways of mediating content. In this context, the use of active teaching and learning methods can improve the profile of the new professional. Case-Based Learning (CBL) is a strategy based on the student's ability to relate theory and practice, with autonomy and decision-making. The discipline of Genetics addresses contents that may seem distant from everyday life and future professional practice, so it is necessary to use teaching strategies that facilitate the understanding of the application of this knowledge in medical practice. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the CBL as a pedagogical approach in the teaching-learning process of Genetics for Medicine courses in a public institution. Methods: An active methodology protocol that consisted of nine clinical cases was applied to 46 medical students from Universidade de Brasília, who were later divided into nine groups. The performance and perceptions regarding the methodology were evaluated by questionnaires. Quantitative results were analyzed using Student's t test. Results: The performance of group work was statistically higher in 8 of 9 cases compared to individual work. Most students considered the activity good or very good (76%), but approximately half reported no increase in motivation. Moreover, 71.4% felt motivated to learn more about the subject after class and 20% considered they were able to teach the subject to others and 42% assessed they would get all or most of the questions correct if they were submitted to a new assessment. Regarding teamwork, 38% reported feeling more motivated. Finally, 86% considered the discussion of clinical cases relevant or very relevant for professional training. Final considerations: The results show, in general, success in the use of CBL on the study of genetic diseases but point out that there are difficulties in the use of alternative teaching methods to the lecture. Despite this, it is clear that learning based on clinical cases can lead to the mobilization of previous knowledge in situations of professional practice.
RESUMO
RESUMO Introdução: Os recursos tecnológicos digitais, a exemplo dos jogos, podem ser usados de forma eficiente e colaborativa no processo de ensino-aprendizagem, principalmente pela facilidade de serem inseridos no contexto acadêmico, uma vez que significativa parte dos estudantes tem acesso à internet e faz uso desses mecanismos em seu cotidiano. Tais recursos podem ser utilizados para aprimorar o conhecimento acerca de uma área específica, como a otorrinolaringologia, que envolve habilidades clínicas essenciais na formação do médico generalista, sendo destaque entre os agravos frequentes na atenção primária. Objetivo: Nesta pesquisa, objetiva-se o desenvolvimento de uma ferramenta didática que possa auxiliar na aquisição de conhecimentos específicos pertinentes à prática clínica de médicos egressos. Método: Trata-se de um estudo descritivo, de caráter experimental de um aplicativo denominado ORLearning, baseado em competências previamente definidas em um consenso Delphi, a ser usado em estudantes de Medicina a respeito da otorrinolaringologia. Resultado: Construiu-se o protótipo com interfaces próprias destinado a discentes de Medicina. Conclusão: Frisamos a importância do uso dessas ferramentas tecnológicas no processo de ensino-aprendizagem da especialidade para graduandos e recém-formados em Medicina, de modo a tornar esse processo lúdico e inovador.
ABSTRACT Introduction: Digital technological resources, such as games, can be used efficiently and collaboratively in the teaching-learning process, mainly due to the ease with which they can be inserted into the academic context, since a significant number of students have access to the Internet and use these mechanisms in their daily lives. These resources can be used to improve knowledge about a specific area, such as Otorhinolaryngology, which involves essential clinical knowledge and skills in the training of general practitioners and is one of the most common problems in primary care. Objective: The aim of this research is to develop a teaching tool that can help graduate physicians acquire specific knowledge relevant to clinical practice. Research Methodology: The method is a descriptive, experimental study of an application called "ORLearning", based on competencies previously defined in a Delphis consensus, to be used with medical students in the field of otorhinolaryngology. Main Results: The result was the construction of a prototype with its own interfaces, aimed at medical students. Conclusion: We highlight the importance of using these technological tools in the teaching-learning process of the specialty, both for undergraduates and recent medical graduates, making this process playful and innovative.
RESUMO
RESUMO Introdução: No processo de ensino, as estratégias de ensino, como as metodologias ativas, desempenham um papel fundamental na promoção da construção do conhecimento dos alunos, especialmente em disciplinas com temáticas e conteúdos científicos de difícil assimilação. Objetivo: Este estudo teve como objetivo avaliar a percepção dos alunos sobre as metodologias ativas usadas na disciplina de Genética Humana nos cursos de saúde de uma universidade pública do Amazonas. Método: Neste estudo, alunos de Enfermagem, Medicina e Odontologia responderam a um questionário com alternativas de respostas em escalas Likert sobre seis metodologias ativas na sala de aula: construção de modelo didático, gamificação, aprendizagem baseada em equipe, sala de aula invertida, estudo de casos clínicos e aprendizagem baseada em vídeo. Avaliou-se a confiabilidade das respostas, e testes qui-quadrado, Mann-Whitney e Kruskal-Wallis foram usados para análises de associação com nível de confiança de 95%. Resultado: Os participantes, em sua maioria mulheres, tinham uma média de idade de 20,4 ± 3,5 anos. Os alunos de Medicina foram os mais representativos em quatro das seis metodologias ativas usadas. Observou-se uma associação significativa entre o sexo feminino e a preferência pela metodologia de construção de modelo didático, enquanto o sexo masculino tendeu a avaliar mais positivamente a aprendizagem baseada em vídeo. Além disso, a análise individual revelou que a aprendizagem baseada em vídeo foi mais associada ao curso de Odontologia em comparação com Enfermagem, enquanto o estudo de casos clínicos foi mais favorecido pelos alunos de Medicina em comparação com Enfermagem. Isso sugere uma preferência dos estudantes de Odontologia e Medicina por essas metodologias, respectivamente. Quanto ao entendimento do conceito de metodologias ativas, a palavra "aluno" foi a mais frequentemente mencionada. Conclusão: Os alunos reconhecem o envolvimento direto das metodologias ativas, mas têm compreensão parcial dos benefícios. Metodologias ativas em genética humana motivaram e despertaram interesse. Docentes devem considerar a diversidade de competências e preferências dos alunos ao usarem tais metodologias, bem como compartilhar suas experiências e buscar uma educação permanente.
ABSTRACT Introduction: In the education process, learning strategies such as active methodologies play a fundamental role in promoting the construction of students' knowledge, especially in subjects with challenging scientific themes and content. Objective: To evaluate how students perceive active methodologies used in the discipline of human genetics in health courses at a public university in the state of Amazonas. Method: In this study, nursing, medicine, and dentistry students responded to a questionnaire with Likert scale response options relating to six active methodologies in the classroom: construction of didactic models, gamification, team-based learning, flipped classroom, clinical case studies, and video-based learning. The reliability of the responses was assessed, and Chi-square, Mann-Whitney, and Kruskal-Wallis tests were used for association analyses with a confidence level of 95%. Results: The participants, mostly women, had an average age of 20.4±3.5 years. Medicine students were the most representative in four of the six active methodologies used. A significant association was observed between female gender and preference for the didactic model construction methodology, while the male gender tended to evaluate video-based learning more positively. Additionally, individual analysis revealed that video-based learning was more associated with the dentistry course compared to nursing, while clinical case studies were more favoured by medicine students compared to nursing. This suggests a preference of dentistry and medicine students for these methodologies, respectively. As for understanding the concept of active methodologies, the word "student" was the most frequently mentioned. Conclusion: Students acknowledge the direct involvement of active methodologies but have a partial understanding of the benefits. Active methodologies in human genetics have motivated and sparked interest. Educators should consider the diversity of students' skills and preferences when using such methodologies, as well as share their experiences and pursue ongoing education.
RESUMO
Screener, a board game supplemented with online resources, was introduced and distributed by the Brazilian Society of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics to postgraduate programs as an instructional tool for the process of drug discovery and development (DDD). In this study, we provided a comprehensive analysis of five critical aspects for evaluating the quality of educational games, namely: 1) description of the intervention; 2) underlying pedagogical theory; 3) identification of local educational gaps; 4) impact on diverse stakeholders; and 5) elucidation of iterative quality enhancement processes. We also present qualitative and quantitative assessments of the effectiveness of this game in 11 postgraduate courses. We employed the MEEGA+ online survey, comprising thirty-three close-ended unipolar items with 5-point Likert-type response scales, to assess student perceptions of the quality and utility of Screener. Based on 115 responses, the results indicated a highly positive outlook among students. In addition, we performed a preliminary evaluation of learning outcomes in two courses involving 28 students. Pre- and post-quizzes were applied, each consisting of 20 True/False questions directly aligned with the game's content. The analysis revealed significant improvement in students' performance following engagement with the game, with scores rising from 8.4 to 13.3 (P<0.0001, paired t-test) and 9.7 to 12.7 (P<0.0001, paired t-test). These findings underscore the utility of Screener as an enjoyable and effective tool for facilitating a positive learning experience in the DDD process. Notably, the game can also reduce the educational disparities across different regions of our continental country.
RESUMO
ABSTRACT Objective: to develop a teaching resource for use in the classroom, involving smartphones and focused on Nursing students. Method: this is an applied technological production research aimed at teachers and students of undergraduate and postgraduate Nursing courses. The study was structured based on the health product and service design model, which includes briefing, data collection, problem analysis, concept, generation of alternatives, selection of the best alternative, solution refinement, prototype, tests, modifications, and implementation. The project was developed in the second semester of 2022 by four doctoral students, a master's student and two PhDs in Nursing, during the discipline of Technologies and Management in Education and Work in Health and Nursing of the Graduate Program in Nursing at the Federal University of Santa Catarina. Results: an educational technology was developed to assists in learning and interactions in the classroom. "Cola na Profe!" was created as a didactic and technological strategy. The objective was to integrate students and encourage their participation and attention in classes through the use of smartphones in the virtual learning environment. Conclusion: the use of the teaching resource "Cola na Profe!" contributes to the teaching-learning process, linking the virtual world to the classroom and contributing to the interaction of those involved, which makes students protagonists of their own learning.
RESUMEN Objetivo: desarrollar un recurso didáctico para ser usado en salones de clase, con utilización de smartphones y centrado en estudiantes de Enfermería. Método: investigación aplicada de producción tecnológica dirigida a docentes y estudiantes de la carrera de grado y cursos de postgrado en Enfermería. El estudio se estructuró a partir del modelo de diseño de productos y servicios de salud, que contempla lo siguiente: briefing, sondeo de datos, análisis del problema, concepto, generación de opciones, selección de la mejor opción, refinamiento de la solución, prototipo, pruebas, modificaciones e implementación. El proyecto fue desarrollado en el segundo semestre de 2022 por cuatro estudiantes de Doctorado, un estudiante de Maestría y dos Doctoras en Enfermería, durante la disciplina académica de Tecnologías y Gestión en Educación y Trabajo en Salud y Enfermería de un programa de postgrado en Enfermería de la Universidad Federal de Santa Catarina. Resultados: se desarrolló una tecnología educativa que asiste en el aprendizaje y en las interacciones en salones de clase. "Cola na Profe!" se creó como una estrategia didáctica y tecnológica. El objetivo es integrar a los alumnos y estimular su participación y atención en la clase recurriendo al uso de smartphones en el ambiente virtual de aprendizaje. Conclusión: utilizar el recurso didáctico "Cola na Profe!" contribuye al proceso de enseñanza-aprendizaje, vinculando el mundo virtual con el salón de clase y facilitando la interacción de todas las personas involucradas, lo que convierte a los alumnos en los protagonistas de su propio proceso de aprendizaje.
RESUMO Objetivo: desenvolver um recurso didático para uso em sala de aula, envolvendo smartphones e centrado nos estudantes de enfermagem. Método: trata-se de uma pesquisa aplicada de produção tecnológica voltada aos docentes e discentes do curso de graduação e pós-graduação em Enfermagem. Estruturou-se o estudo a partir do modelo de projeto de produtos e serviços em saúde, que contempla: briefing, levantamento de dados, análise do problema, conceito, geração de alternativas, seleção da melhor alternativa, refino da solução, protótipo, testes, modificações e implementação. O projeto foi desenvolvido no segundo semestre de 2022, por quatro doutorandas, uma mestranda e duas doutoras em Enfermagem, durante a disciplina de Tecnologias e Gestão na Educação e Trabalho em Saúde e Enfermagem de um programa de pós-graduação em Enfermagem da Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina. Resultados: desenvolveu-se uma tecnologia educacional que auxilia na aprendizagem e na interação em sala de aula. O "Cola na Profe!" foi criado como uma estratégia didática e tecnológica. O objetivo é integrar os alunos e estimular a participação e atenção deles em sala, por meio do uso do smartphone no ambiente virtual de aprendizagem. Conclusão: o uso do recurso didático "Cola na Profe!" contribui com o processo de ensino-aprendizagem, vinculando o mundo virtual à sala de aula e contribuindo para a interação dos envolvidos, o que torna o estudante, protagonista do seu aprendizado.
RESUMO
Introduction: Higher education institutions have implemented active learning approaches, such as the Flipped Classroom, to promote the education of their students. Nevertheless, there is conflicting evidence regarding the benefits derived from its implementation. Objective: To determine the effectiveness of the Flipped Classroom application in the education of university students from Health Sciences undergraduate programs. Materials and methods: A systematized narrative review of the literature published between 2012 and 2022. Pubmed, SciELo, Scopus y Web of Science were used as sources of primary articles. A revised version of the Kirkpatrick model was used to assess the effectiveness of the Flipped Classroom. Results: 34 out of the 1020 retrieved articles reached the quantitative synthesis phase. Students value positively this didactic model and acknowledge its contributions in the development of attitudes, knowledge and skills. In contrast, some studies show an increase in the workload and stress levels of students. Conclusions: The evidence suggests that Flipped Classroom is a valid didactic model for the education of Health Sciences students. Future studies should consider the effectiveness of its implementation at a long term organizational level.
Introduction: Higher education institutions have implemented active learning approaches, such as the Flipped Classroom, to promote the education of their students. Nevertheless, there is conflicting evidence regarding the benefits derived from its implementation. Objective: To determine the effectiveness of the Flipped Classroom application in the education of university students from Health Sciences undergraduate programs. Materials and methods: A systematized narrative review of the literature published between 2012 and 2022. Pubmed, SciELo, Scopus y Web of Science were used as sources of primary articles. A revised version of the Kirkpatrick model was used to assess the effectiveness of the Flipped Classroom. Results: 34 out of the 1020 retrieved articles reached the quantitative synthesis phase. Students value positively this didactic model and acknowledge its contributions in the development of attitudes, knowledge and skills. In contrast, some studies show an increase in the workload and stress levels of students. Conclusions: The evidence suggests that Flipped Classroom is a valid didactic model for the education of Health Sciences students. Future studies should consider the effectiveness of its implementation at a long term organizational level.
Introducción: Las instituciones de educación superior han implementado enfoques activos de aprendizaje como el Aula Invertida para favorecer la formación de sus estudiantes. Sin embargo, existe evidencia diversa respecto de los beneficios derivados de su implementación. Objetivo: Determinar la efectividad de la aplicación del Aula Invertida en la formación de estudiantes universitarios de carreras de pregrado de las Ciencias de la Salud. Materiales y métodos: Se realizó una revisión narrativa sistematizada de la literatura publicada entre 2012 y 2022, utilizando Pubmed, SciELo, Scopus y Web of Science como fuentes de artículos primarios. Se utilizó la versión revisada del modelo de Kirkpatrick para valorar la efectividad del Aula Invertida. Resultados: Se obtuvieron 1020 artículos, 34 de ellos ingresaron a la fase de síntesis cuantitativa. Los estudiantes valoran positivamente este modelo didáctico y reconocen su aporte en el desarrollo de actitudes, conocimientos y habilidades. Algunos estudios mencionan un aumento de la carga de trabajo y niveles de estrés en los estudiantes. Conclusiones: La evidencia sugiere que Aula Invertida es un modelo didáctico válido para la formación de estudiantes de las Ciencias de la Salud. Futuros estudios deberían considerar la efectividad de su implementación a nivel organizacional y a largo plazo.
Assuntos
Humanos , Masculino , Feminino , Adulto Jovem , Fenômenos Psicológicos , Educação , Instituições Acadêmicas , Ensino , Universidades , Aprendizagem , Processos MentaisRESUMO
Ante la pandemia del coronavirus, hubo que reinventar la forma de hacer las actividades prácticas de laboratorio de anatomía humana, la necesidad de que sean exclusivamente virtual, elevó la exigencia. La imposibilidad de trabajar con material orgánico demandó que al menos las imágenes a utilizar fueran de alta calidad. Para lo anterior, se usaron fotografías de disecciones del laboratorio de anatomía, más digitalizaciones de estructuras humanas de nuestro laboratorio en formato 3D disponibles en la plataforma web https://anatomiahumana3d.com. No obstante lo anterior, se detectó cierto grado de desidia por parte de los estudiantes y escasa participación en las actividades prácticas. Para resolver esto se implementó una modalidad de Aprendizaje Activo, específicamente de Aula Invertida, con el fin de que sea el propio estudiante quien genere su conocimiento. Una vez terminado el proceso de enseñanza aprendizaje bajo la nueva modalidad, se realizó un estudio descriptivo, a fin de detectar falencias y proponer mejoras respecto a la metodología aplicada. Los resultados arrojaron un nivel de satisfacción por sobre el 80 %, en tanto, que solo el 5 % de los estudiantes contestó como aceptable las diferentes dimensiones evaluadas, demostrando como el sistema de aula inversa fue bien recibida por los estudiantes. Sin embargo es prudente generar futuros estudios que ayuden a mejorar este tipo de metodología, como también seguir innovando en las estrategias didácticas que aporten a la comprensión de la anatomía humana.
SUMMARY: In the context of the COVID-19 pandemic it was necessary to reinvent the way of doing practical activities in the human anatomy laboratory and the need for these to be exclusively online, raised the requirement. Due to the impossibility of using organic samples, high-quality images had to be used. Therefore, photographs of dissections from our human anatomy laboratory were used, as well as digitalization of human structures from our laboratory in a three-dimensional (3D) format available on the web platform https://anatomiahumana3d.com. However, a certain degree of laziness on the part of the students and low participation in the practical activities was detected. To solve this problem, an Active Learning modality was implemented, specifically the Flipped Classroom, so that the students themselves generate their knowledge. Once the teaching-learning process was completed under the new modality, a descriptive study was carried out to detect shortcomings and propose improvements to the methodology applied. The results showed a level of satisfaction above 80 % and only 5 % of the students evaluated the different dimensions as acceptable demonstrating how the Flipped Classroom system was well received by the students. To conclude, it is prudent to generate future studies that help to improve this type of methodology, as well as to continue innovating in didactic strategies that contribute to the understanding of human anatomy.
Assuntos
Humanos , Masculino , Feminino , Adolescente , Adulto Jovem , Estudantes/psicologia , Aprendizagem Baseada em Problemas , Educação a Distância , Anatomia/educação , Percepção , Universidades , Inquéritos e QuestionáriosRESUMO
Stress and anxiety caused by assessments are often related to the student's insecurity regarding the knowledge to be evaluated, while teaching strategies that increase effective learning can assist in reducing it. The aim of this study was to evaluate the hypothesis that the use of an active methodology, associated to formative assessment, could reduce students' anxiety and stress, when compared to the traditional method, by promoting greater learning. New students enrolled in the same discipline of a Dentistry course were invited to participate in the study and were divided into two groups: traditional method and active methodology. The traditional method group received two lectures, delivered orally. The active methodology group received a lecture about cardiac cells and the autonomic control of cardiac function, with home study of the cardiac cycle using a textbook. In the second class, an individual formative assessment was applied. Afterwards, a group activity was performed with an educational game about the cardiac cycle, followed by a group formative assessment. After applying the traditional or active methodology, test 1 was carried out. Immediately before this test, saliva samples were collected for determination of the concentrations of the stress biomarkers cortisol and α-amylase. The students also answered the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory questionnaire, used for anxiety level determination. The score obtained in the test 1 was significantly higher for the active methodology group, compared to the traditional method group. No significant differences between the groups were observed for baseline cortisol and salivary α-amylase concentrations, or for anxiety scores. Before test 1, traditional method group presented higher concentrations of salivary cortisol and α-amylase, compared to the respective baseline values, while the active methodology group showed no difference between the baseline and test 1 levels. Before test 1, there were increases in anxiety levels, relative to the respective baseline values, regardless of the teaching methodology used, but this increase was greater for the traditional method group, compared to the active methodology group. These results showed that the active methodology, associated to formative assessment, decreased test stress and anxiety, with improved student performance in comparison to traditional lectures.
RESUMO
El objetivo principal de la presente investigación es determinar la influencia entre las habilidades de pensamiento crítico, técnicas de oratoria y argumentación en las dinámicas de debates en el ámbito educativo, las cuales integran dentro de sus ambientes y herramientas de aprendizaje grupos de debates y el desarrollo de procesos cognitivos de orden superior. La metodología utilizada fue de corte mixta. Dentro de los resultados, existen hallazgos significativos que avalan el desarrollo de destrezas en la metodología de debate, permitiendo concluir su influencia en la potenciación de habilidades cognoscitivas, interpersonales y académicas.
The main objective of the present research is to determine the influence between critical thinking skills, public speaking techniques, and argumentation on the dynamics of debates in the educational environment, which integrate within their environments and learning tools debate groups and the development of higher order cognitive processes. The methodology used was mixed. Within the results, there are significant findings that support the development of skills in the debate methodology, by allowing to conclude its influence on the enhancement of cognitive, interpersonal, and academic skills.
RESUMO
An undergraduate online course on Applied Biochemistry and Molecular Biology was developed through different formats of case study that included lecture, class discussion, small-groups discussion, and individual work. Cases covering health, biotechnology, agriculture, and other issues were developed or adapted from the literature to reach the desired learning goals. Multiple web resources were employed for information integration that were presented and discussed in the synchronous sessions and assignments. Formative and summative assessment was achieved through multiple-choice questionnaires, exams, and homework assignments.
Assuntos
Aprendizagem , Estudantes , Humanos , Bioquímica/educação , Currículo , Biologia MolecularRESUMO
Here is our proposal to improve learning in biomedical sciences for graduate and undergraduate courses with a broad vision integrating disciplines such as molecular cell biology, biochemistry, and biophysics around concepts of pathogen interaction within vertebrate and invertebrate hosts. Our paradigm is based on the possibility offered by the pandemic to have remote activities that give access to students and researchers from different places in Brazil and Latin American countries to discuss science. A multidisciplinary view of host-pathogen interaction allows us to understand better the mechanisms involved in the pathology of diseases, as well as to formulate broad strategies for the diagnosis, treatment, and control of thereof. The approach to integrating heterogeneous groups in science involves the critical analysis of national scientific resource distribution, where only some have the possibilities to conduct competitive scientific research. Solid theoretical training, contact, collaboration with groups of excellence, and training within a multidisciplinary network are our proposals for a permanent platform of scientific strengthening and dissemination for Latin America. Here we will review the concept of host-pathogen interaction, the type of institutions where it is taught and researched, new trends in active teaching methodologies, and the current political context in science.
RESUMO
Resumo: Introdução: A aprendizagem autorregulada (self-regulated learning - SRL) é o processo ativo que o aluno realiza para atingir seus objetivos de aprendizagem. No ensino médico, pelo fato de o ambiente clínico ser propício para o desenvolvimento da SRL, há potencial benefício na aplicação dessa ferramenta no processo de ensino-aprendizado, embora as diferenças em seus cenários de aplicação exijam uma análise mais aprofundada. Objetivo: Este artigo apresenta uma revisão da literatura sobre o histórico do desenvolvimento da SRL, sua aplicabilidade e avaliação em estudantes de Medicina por meio de escala validada, além dos fatores que a influenciam, como métodos de ensino e questões demográficas e socioculturais. Método: Realizou-se uma busca com o descritor self-regulated learning nas plataformas PubMed e SciELO e na revista Medical Education Online para artigos em inglês publicados entre 2010 e 2021. Resultado: A busca nas bases de dados resultou em 198 artigos, dos quais foram selecionados 100 para a análise crítica. Desses 100 artigos, selecionaram-se 31 que preenchiam os critérios desta revisão. Conclusão: A SRL é um conceito contemporâneo considerado pilar no processo educacional. Trata-se de ferramenta de grande valor em psicologia educacional. A aplicabilidade da SRL no contexto do ensino médico demonstra-se efetiva e traz consigo especificidades sobre a autorregulação do estudante de Medicina. Contudo, são necessários novos estudos acerca do tema, de modo a permitir o desenvolvimento de métodos instrucionais eficazes com sua utilização.
Abstract: Introduction: Self-regulated learning (SRL) is the active process that students perform to achieve their learning goals. In medical education, the development of SRL is favoured by the clinical environment, hence there is potential benefit in applying this tool in the teaching-learning process, although the differences in its application scenarios require deeper analysis. Objective: The aim of this article is to present a literature review on the development of SRL, its applicability and evaluation in medical students using a validated scale, and the factors that influence it, such as teaching methods and demographic and sociocultural issues. Method: A search was performed on the Pub-med and Scielo platforms and the online Medical Education Journal for articles in English published between 2010 and 2021 using the descriptors "Self-regulated learning". Results: The database search resulted in 198 articles, of which 100 were selected for critical analysis. Of these, 31 articles were selected based on meeting the criteria of this review. Conclusions: SRL is a contemporary educational concept and considered a pillar in the educational process. It is a valuable tool in educational psychology. Its applicability in the context of medical education proves to be effective and brings with it specificities in relation to the self-regulation of medical students. However, further studies on the subject are necessary to allow for the development of effective instructional methods to support its use.
RESUMO
Resumo: Introdução: Em 2020, a fim de conter a progressão da pandemia do coronavírus, determinou-se o distanciamento social por redução da interação entre as pessoas. As instituições de ensino foram fechadas, e adotou-se o ensino-aprendizagem a distância aplicado por tecnologias digitais para a continuidade do estudo. O fechamento de uma universidade comunitária em Santa Catarina, no curso de Medicina, implicou uma situação disruptiva quanto ao formato de ensino, visto que se utilizam metodologias ativas que não haviam sido aplicadas digitalmente até o momento. Dessa circunstância, pergunta-se como o corpo docente percebe e vivencia essa nova realidade. Objetivo: Pretendeu-se conhecer a experiência de professores do primeiro ao quarto ano de graduação médica com metodologias ativas durante as atividades do ensino remoto no advento da pandemia do coronavírus para entender as repercussões na aprendizagem. Método: Trata-se de uma pesquisa de campo, com objetivo exploratório e abordagem quanti-qualitativa. O trabalho passou por apreciação do Comitê de Ética em Pesquisa. Os participantes foram contatados eletronicamente para responder, na plataforma Google Forms, a um questionário dividido em duas etapas com perguntas objetivas e descritivas relativas à vivência deles no ensino remoto. A exploração de dados ocorreu por estatísticas, análise temática de conteúdo e análise de correlação, confrontando-se os resultados com o referencial teórico. Resultado: Responderam à pesquisa 29 professores. A maioria deles se sentiu ao menos parcialmente preparada para atuar no ensino remoto, e orientações e busca por auxílio não se correlacionaram com o preparo. Facilidades e fragilidades relacionadas à tecnologia foram observadas. Computador, celular e Google Meet foram os recursos mais utilizados. Materiais do presencial necessitaram de adaptações, não sendo satisfatórias em alguns casos. As atividades pedagógicas foram cumpridas dentro do proposto, entretanto, para dois terços dos docentes, houve prejuízo na qualidade do ensino, e metade deles mudou de conduta para mediação de aulas virtuais. Conclusão: A passagem para o ensino digital foi um desafio para professores. A aprendizagem foi comprometida, porém observaram-se benefícios e potencialidades. Como há um processo de mudança na sociedade com o propósito de consolidar a educação digital, são essenciais as devidas capacitações para apoiar esse processo em metodologias ativas.
Abstract: Introduction: In 2020, aiming to contain the progression of the Coronavirus pandemic, social distancing was determined by reducing interactions between people. The educational institutions were closed and distance teaching-learning was applied using digital technologies for study continuity. The closing of a community university in Santa Catarina, in the medical course, implied in a disruptive situation regarding the teaching format, since they use active methodologies and these had not been applied digitally up to that moment. From these circumstances, one asks how the faculty perceives and experiences this new reality. Objective: This study aimed to understand the experiences of educators teaching from the first to the fourth year of medical school using active methodologies during the remote education activities at the emergence of the Coronavirus pandemic aiming at understanding the impacts on learning. Method: This is a field research with an exploratory objective and a quantitative-qualitative approach. This study has been analyzed by the Research Ethics Committee. The participants were contacted by electronics means and were invited to answer a two-step questionnaire using the Google Forms platform, containing objective and descriptive questions regarding their experience with remote teaching. Data analysis was performed by statistics, by thematic content analysis and by correlation analysis, and the findings were compared using the theoretical reference. Result: Twenty-nine teachers answered the survey. Most of them felt, at least, partially prepared to work in the remote education and guidance and requests for help were not related to the preparation. Facilities and weaknesses related to the technology were observed. Computers, cell phones and Google Meet were the recourses most often used. Adaptations for the materials used in face-to-face classes were necessary, but in some cases, they were not satisfactory. The pedagogical activities were accomplished within the proposed ones, but two-thirds of the teachers believed there were losses related to study quality and half of them adjusted their behavior to virtual class mediation. Conclusion: The transition to the digital teaching format constituted a challenge for the teachers. The learning process was compromised; however, benefits and potentials were observed. A change is occurring in society and digital teaching is being solidified and training is essential to support this process in active methodologies.