Biomechanical comparison of static and dynamic cervical plates in terms of the bone fusion, tissue degeneration, and implant behavior.

INTRODUCTION: Using an anterior cervical fixation device in the anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) has evolved to various systems of static and dynamic cervical plates (SCP and DCP). Dynamic cervical plates have been divided into three categories: the rotational (DCP-R), translational (DCP-T), and hybrid (DCP-H) joints. However, little studies have been devoted to systematically investigate the biomechanical differences of dynamic cervical plates. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The biomechanical tests of load-deformation properties and failure modes between the SCP and DCP systems are implemented first by using the UHMWPE blocks as the vertebral specimens. The CT-based C2-C7 model simulates the strategies of cervical plate in ACDF surgery is developed with finite-element analyses. One intact, one SCP and two DCP systems are evaluated for their biomechanical properties of bone fusion and tissue responses. RESULTS: In the situation of biomechanical test, The mean values of the five ACDSP constructs are 393.6% for construct stiffness (p < 0.05) and 183.0% for the first yielding load (p < 0.05) less than those of the SCP groups, respectively. In the situation of finite-element analysis, the rigid-induced ASD is more severe for the SCP, followed by the DCP-H, and the DCP-R is the least. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: Considering the degenerative degree of the adjacent segments and osteoporotic severity of the instrumented segments is necessary while using dynamic system. The mobility and stability of the rotational and translational joints are the key factors to the fusion rate and ASD progression. If the adjacent segments have been degenerative, the more flexible system can be adopted to compensate the constrained mobility of the ACDF segments. In the situation of the osteoporotic ACDF vertebrae, the stiffer system is recommended to avoid the cage subsidence.

Follow-up of a new titanium cervical plate for fusion of the cervical spine.

Cervical plates are in use since the 1990ies for anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF). The latest step in development was a dynamic plate that allows sliding of the screws facilitating the natural settling of the bone after surgery. We investigated the clinical and radiological results of such a dynamic plate in a patient cohort that underwent single or multi-level ACDF for various cervical degenerative indications, including revision cases, from 2014 to 2019. Clinical and radiological outcome were assessed in 60 eligible patients after a mean of 2.9 years. The assessed neck disability index (NDI), and the visual analogue scale (VAS) of neck and arm pain show comparable results to the literature of ACDF, and specifically other plate designs. Forty-eight Adverse and Serious Adverse Events do not show a link to the product used. Clinical and radiological outcomes of ACDF with dynamic, third generation cervical plates show comparable results to the literature. Careful reporting of all Adverse Events revealed a variety of concomitant diseases, but could not be correlated to the implant used.

Finite Element Analysis of the Effect of Dynamic Plating on Two-Level Anterior Cervical Discectomy Fusion Biomechanics.

BACKGROUND: The limitations of anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) are related to mechanical failure of the construct after recurring subsidence and migration. In the present study, we evaluated the effect of the maximum rotation of variable angle screws on the range of motion (ROM), cage migration, and subsidence. METHODS: Five finite element models were developed from a C2-C7 cervical spine model. The first model was an intact C2-C7 spine model, and the second model was an altered C2-C7 model with C4-C6 cage insertion and a 2-level static plate. The other three models were altered C2-C7 models with the same C4-C6 cage insertion and a 2-level dynamic plate. RESULTS: The ROM of C4-C6 in the static plate model was reduced by ∼14° from the intact model but only reduced by ∼9° in the dynamic plate models. The maximum migration and subsidence at the cage-endplate interface in the dynamic plate models were lower than those in the static plate model for all moments. The von Mises stress of the C3-C4 and C6-C7 discs in the dynamic plate models was lower than that in the static plate model. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that dynamic plating has promising potential (greater ROM and lower von Mises stress of discs) for stabilization in multilevel anterior cervical discectomy and fusion than static plating, although both dynamic and static plates showed lower ROM than the intact model. A lower screw rotational angle resulted in superior biomechanical performance (lower incidence of migration and subsidence) compared with a higher rotational angle in multilevel applications, regardless of loading.

Does Dynamic Anterior Plate Fixation Provide Adequate Stability for Traumatic Subaxial Cervical Spine Fractures at Mid-Term Follow-Up?

BACKGROUND: It remains questionable if the treatment of cervical fractures with dynamic plates in trauma surgery provides adequate stability for unstable fractures with disco-ligamentous injuries. The primary goal of this study was to assess the radiological and mid-term patient-reported outcome of traumatic subaxial cervical fractures treated with different plate systems. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Patients, treated with anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) between 2001 and 2015, using either a dynamic plate (DP: Mambo™, Ulrich, Germany) or a rigid locking plate (RP: CSLP™, Depuy Synthes, USA), were identified. For radiological evaluation, the sagittal alignment, the sagittal anterior translation and the bony consolidation were evaluated. After at least two years, the patient-reported outcome measures (PROM) were evaluated using the German Short-Form 36 (SF-36), Neck Disability Index (NDI) and the EuroQol in 5 Dimensions (EQ-5D) scores. RESULTS: 33 patients met the inclusion criteria (DP: 13; RP:20). Twenty-six patients suffered from AO Type B or C fractures. Both the sagittal alignment and the sagittal translation could be sufficiently improved in both groups (p ≥ 0.05). No significant loss of reduction could be observed at the follow-up in both groups (p ≥ 0.05). Bony consolidation could be observed in 30 patients (DP: 12/13 (92%); RP: 18/20 (90%); (p ≥ 0.05)). In 20 patients, PROMs could be evaluated (follow-up: 71.2 ± 25.5 months). The whole cohort showed satisfactory PROM results (EQ-5D: 72.0 ± 4.9; SF-36 PCS: 41.9 ± 16.2, MCS: 45.4 ± 14.9; NDI: 11.0 ± 9.1). without significant differences between the DP and RP group (p ≥ 0.05) Conclusion: The dynamic plate concept provides enough stability without a difference in fusion rates in comparison to rigid locking plates in a population that mostly suffered fragile fractures.

A novel adjustable locking plate (ALP) for segmental bone fracture treatment.

A novel Ti6Al4V adjustable locking plate (ALP) is designed to provide enhanced bone stability for segmental bone fractures and to allow precise positioning of disconnected segments. The design incorporates an adjustable rack and pinion mechanism to perform compression, distraction and segment transfer during plate fixation surgery. The aim of this study is to introduce the advantages of the added feature and computationally characterize the biomechanical performance of the proposed design. Structural strength of the novel plate is analyzed using numerical methods for 4-point bending and fatigue properties, following ASTM standards. An additional mechanical failure finite element test is also conducted on the rack and pinion to reveal how much torque can be safely applied to the mechanism by the surgeon. Simulation results predict that the new design is sufficiently strong to not fail under regular anatomical loading scenarios with close bending strength and fatigue life properties to clinically used locking compression plates. The novel ALP design is expected to be a good candidate for addressing problems regarding fixation of multi-fragmentary bone fractures.

Preliminary Surgical Result of Cervical Spine Reconstruction with a Dynamic Plate and Titanium Mesh Cage

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to validate the effects of a titanium mesh cage and dynamic plating in anterior cervical stabilization after corpectomy. METHODS: A retrospective study was performed on 31 consecutive patients, who underwent anterior cervical reconstruction with a titanium mesh cage and dynamic plating, from March 2004 to February 2006. Twenty-four patients had 1-level and 7 had 2-level corpectomies. Ten patients underwent surgery with a cage of 10-mm diameter and 21 with 13-mm diameter. Neurological status and outcomes were assessed according to Odom's criteria. Sagittal angle, coronal angle, settling ratio, sagittal displacement, and cervical lordosis were used to evaluate the radiological outcomes. RESULTS: In overall, 26 (83.9%) of 31 showed excellent or good outcomes. Thirteen percent (4 cases) of the patients developed surgical complications, such as hoarseness, transient dysphagia, or nerve root palsy. Seven (22.6%) patients had reconstruction failure : 5 (20.8%) in the 1-level corpectomy group and 2 (28.5%) in the 2-level corpectomy group. Revisions were required in 2 patients with plate pullout due to significant instability. However, none of 5 patients who demonstrated cage displacement or screw pullout, underwent a revision. Radiographs revealed bony consolidation in 96.3% of the patients, including 6 patients with implantation failure during the follow-up period. CONCLUSION: Based on our preliminary results, the titanium mesh cage and dynamic plating was effective for cervical reconstruction after corpectomy. The anterior cervical reconsrtruction performed with dynamic plates is considered to reduce stress shielding and greater graft compression that is afforded by the unique plate design.