A biomechanical study on the laminate stacking sequence in composite bone plates for vancouver femur B1 fracture fixation.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Composite bone plates are proposed for fracture fixation in periprosthetic femoral fracture. Metallic plates, having high stiffness compared to bone lead to stress shielding, reduce the compression force in the fracture site, affectthe healing process. Reduction of stiffness in the axial direction due to above reason without lowering the stiffness in transverse to avoid much of shear strain and thus avoiding instability at the fracture site leads to selective stress shielding. This can only be achieved through meticulously designed fiber reinforced composite. In the present work varied fiber orientations in the stacked laminates with varied fiber types are employed in a post-operative femur fixation for the in-silico analyses of their effectiveness using finite element analysis. METHODS: In this study a Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) model is constructed with composite bone plates. Three-dimensional narrow type metal plate is modeled with 12 holes and length of 194 mm. Three different types of composite bone plates are modeled with 12 holes of different size for the analysis i.e. Type 1 (5.6 mm thickness and 16 mm width), Type 2 (6 mm thickness and 16 mm width) and Type 3(6 mm thickness and 18 mm width). Anatomical 3D FE models of THA with composite bone plates are constructed to find out the interfacial stresses and strains. The finite element software ANSYS is used to perform the analysis. RESULTS: A three-dimensional FE model of immediately post-operative femur fixation is developed and studied the maximum stress distribution, strain and movement in axial/shear direction in the metal and composite bone plate near to the fracture site. In the present study, the metal and composite plate (carbon/epoxy, glass/epoxy and flax/epoxy) used for most common Vancouver type B1 fracture to observe the biomechanical behavior of different models in IPO condition using FEA. CONCLUSIONS: Optimizing the fiber orientations of composite bone plates of Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) model by controlling the biomechanical stresses could be a favorable approach. The finite element analysis approach gives a viable solution to design the composite bone plate and for designing future models that preserves the biomechanical function of THA with composite bone plate.

On optimization of a composite bone plate using the selective stress shielding approach.

Bone fracture plates are used to stabilize fractures while allowing for adequate compressive force on the fracture ends. Yet the high stiffness of conventional bone plates significantly reduces compression at the fracture site, and can lead to subsequent bone loss upon healing. Fibre-reinforced composite bone plates have been introduced to address this drawback. However, no studies have optimized their configurations to fulfill the requirements of proper healing. In the present study, classical laminate theory and the finite element method were employed for optimization of a composite bone plate. A hybrid composite made of carbon fibre/epoxy with a flax/epoxy core, which was introduced previously, was optimized by varying the laminate stacking sequence and the contribution of each material, in order to minimize the axial stiffness and maximize the torsional stiffness for a given range of bending stiffness. The initial 14×4(14) possible configurations were reduced to 13 after applying various design criteria. A comprehensive finite element model, validated against a previous experimental study, was used to evaluate the mechanical performance of each composite configuration in terms of its fracture stability, load sharing, and strength in transverse and oblique Vancouver B1 fracture configurations at immediately post-operative, post-operative, and healed bone stages. It was found that a carbon fibre/epoxy plate with an axial stiffness of 4.6 MN, and bending and torsional stiffness of 13 and 14 N·m(2), respectively, showed an overall superiority compared with other laminate configurations. It increased the compressive force at the fracture site up to 14% when compared to a conventional metallic plate, and maintained fracture stability by ensuring the fracture fragments' relative motions were comparable to those found during metallic plate fixation. The healed stage results revealed that implantation of the titanium plate caused a 40.3% reduction in bone stiffness, while the composite plate lowered the stiffness by 32.9% as compared to the intact femur. This study proposed a number of guidelines for the design of composite bone plates. The findings suggest that a composite bone plate could be customized to allow for moderate compressive force on the fracture ends, while remaining relatively rigid in bending and torsion and strong enough to withstand external loads when a fracture gap is present. The results indicate that the proposed composite bone plate could be a potential candidate for bone fracture plate applications.