Vision on gyrate atrophy: why treat the eye?

In the April issue of this Journal, Boffa and coworkers put forward a new therapeutic approach for Gyrate Atrophy of the Choroid and Retina (GACR; OMIM 258870) (Boffa et al, 2023). The authors propose to apply gene therapy to the liver for GACR, a metabolic disease primarily affecting eyesight due to retinal degeneration. Their vision is enthusiastically supported by a News and Views comment in the same issue (Seker Yilmaz and Gissen, 2023). However, based on disease pathology, patient's needs, ethical considerations, therapeutic developmental time lines, and current state of the art of gene therapy for liver and eye, we have a different view on this issue: We argue below that local treatment of the eye is the preferred option for GACR.

Gyrate Atrophy of the Choroid and Retina: A Review.

Gyrate atrophy (GA) of the choroid and retina is a rare autosomal recessive genetic condition characterized by elevation of the plasma level of the amino acid ornithine due to deficiency of the enzyme ornithine ketoacid aminotransferase. Accumulation of ornithine occurs in various body tissues but leads primarily to characteristic ophthalmic manifestations including myopia, cataract, progressive chorioretinal atrophy, and macular changes. Patients usually present with night blindness that starts in the first decade of life followed by visual field constriction and eventually diminution of the central visual acuity and blindness. The condition has been reported worldwide and its differential diagnosis is broad and includes choroideremia and retinitis pigmentosa. Treatment currently depends on life-long dietary modifications including restriction of the amino acid arginine in diet. This article describes in detail the pathogenesis, clinical features, multimodal imaging findings, and treatment options for GA of the choroid and retina and its complications.

Gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina: a case report.

Gyrate atrophy is a rare metabolic disease characterized by hyperornithinemia, typical retinal and choroidal lesions, high myopia with marked astigmatism, early cataract formation, and autosomal recessive inheritance pattern. In this paper, we describe a 12-year-old boy presenting with high myopia and gyrate fundus lesions, in addition to 10-times elevated serum ornithine level.

Genetic correction and analysis of induced pluripotent stem cells from a patient with gyrate atrophy.

Gene-corrected patient-specific induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells offer a unique approach to gene therapy. Here, we begin to assess whether the mutational load acquired during gene correction of iPS cells is compatible with use in the treatment of genetic causes of retinal degenerative disease. We isolated iPS cells free of transgene sequences from a patient with gyrate atrophy caused by a point mutation in the gene encoding ornithine-δ-aminotransferase (OAT) and used homologous recombination to correct the genetic defect. Cytogenetic analysis, array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH), and exome sequencing were performed to assess the genomic integrity of an iPS cell line after three sequential clonal events: initial reprogramming, gene targeting, and subsequent removal of a selection cassette. No abnormalities were detected after standard G-band metaphase analysis. However, aCGH and exome sequencing identified two deletions, one amplification, and nine mutations in protein coding regions in the initial iPS cell clone. Except for the targeted correction of the single nucleotide in the OAT locus and a single synonymous base-pair change, no additional mutations or copy number variation were identified in iPS cells after the two subsequent clonal events. These findings confirm that iPS cells themselves may carry a significant mutational load at initial isolation, but that the clonal events and prolonged cultured required for correction of a genetic defect can be accomplished without a substantial increase in mutational burden.

Occipital porencephaly in a child with gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina.

A 4-year-old girl was hospitalized for psychomotor delay, low vision, and horizontal nystagmus. She was found to have bilateral chorioretinal atrophic scars and 2 large occipital porencephalic cavities. High plasma ornithine levels led to the presumed diagnosis of gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina. After 6 months of arginine-restricted diet and high-dose pyridoxine (300 mg/d), there was no change of plasma ornithine level or ocular findings. To our knowledge, this is the first report showing an association of porencephaly with gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina.

Vitamin B6-responsive ornithine aminotransferase deficiency with a novel mutation G237D.

Ornithine aminotransferase (OAT) deficiency (MIM: 258870) is a rare congenital metabolic disorder characterized by gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina. Here, we report a 37-year-old male with gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina who has been treated for 18 years. At the age of 7 years, the patient consulted an ophthalmologist due to progressive loss of vision. A large atrophied area was observed in his retina, and OAT deficiency was suspected. At the age of 19 years, amino acid analysis revealed high serum ornithine levels (1,140 nmol/ml), with the normal range being 40-100 nmol/ml. He was treated with vitamin B(6) 300 mg/day for 6 months, which successfully reduced his serum ornithine levels by 20-30%. For 18 years since, his serum ornithine levels have been maintained with vitamin B(6) medication. There was no further impairment of vision or increase in the atrophied area, as judged by ophthalmoscopic examination. OAT activity was undetected in white blood cells of the patient and was 105% and 45% of normal values in his wife and son, respectively. OAT gene analysis revealed a novel mutation of Gly237Asp in exon 7 (710G > A) in both alleles of the patient, while his son was a heterozygote for the mutation. Notably, this novel mutation is associated with a vitamin B6-responsive phenotype. Therefore, early diagnosis and treatment with vitamin B(6) may prevent loss of vision in some patients with OAT deficiency.

[Gyrate atrophy and craniopharyngioma: a case report]. / Atrophie gyrée et craniopharyngiome: à propos d'un cas.

We report the case of a 13-year-old girl who developed a craniopharyngioma and a gyrate atrophy. No genetic link between these two diseases has ever been reported. This case recalls the characteristic features of gyrate atrophy.

Assessment of visual function in patients with gyrate atrophy who are considered candidates for gene replacement.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the course of change of visual function outcome variables in 5 patients with gyrate atrophy before a gene replacement therapy clinical trial. METHODS: The outcome variables selected were visual field sensitivity and electroretinogram amplitude. The course of change of these outcome variables was determined by calculation of their half-lives. RESULTS: In the 4 to 6 years during which each patient was followed up for this study, median visual field half-lives were 17.0 years (static perimetry) and 11.4 years (kinetic perimetry). Median electroretinogram half-lives were 16.0 years (maximal response) and 10.7 years (flicker response). CONCLUSIONS: The course of the decline of visual function outcome variables is frequently slow. Thus, a long-term clinical trial would be required to assess the efficacy of the intervention in the preservation of visual function.

[Gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina: a case report]. / Atrophie gyrée choriorétinienne: a propos dún cas.

BACKGROUND: Gyrate atrophy of the retina and choroid is a rare disease, with recessive autosomal transmission, characterized by progressive chorioretinal atrophy causing blindness. It results from a congenital deficit in aminotransferase ornithine. CASE REPORT: The authors present the case of a young patient aged 15 years old consulting for a progressive fall of visual acuity with hemeralopia. Eye funduscopy showed regions of confluent rounded chorioretinal atrophy. The visual field, the electroretinogram and the retinal angiography were all alterated. Gyrate atrophy of the retina and choroid was evocated. DISCUSSION: It is a systemic and rare metabolic disease where ocular features are dominating. Differencial diagnosis are pigmentary retinopathies. Cataract and/or myopia are often joined to the retinal lesions. General signs could consist in muscular weakness, thin and rare hairs and mental retardation. More than; visual fields, electroretinogram, retinal angiography that are alterated; the plasmatic dosage of the ornithine is often high. The treatment is based on the dietetics with uncertain results. The genic therapy would be the treatment of future.

Retrovirus-mediated gene transfer of ornithine-delta-aminotransferase into keratinocytes from gyrate atrophy patients.

Gyrate atrophy is a progressive blindness associated with deficiency of ornithine aminotransferase (OAT). The strategy of using an autologous keratinocyte graft, modified to express high levels of OAT as an ornithine-catabolizing skin-based enzyme sink, is investigated. Two OAT-containing retroviral vectors were constructed with or without a resistance gene. When packaged in a retroviral vector particle generated with the gibbon ape leukemia (GALV) virus envelope (PG13), these vectors could readily transduce >50% of target keratinocytes. The transduced keratinocytes in culture expressed up to 75-fold more OAT than normal control keratinocytes and these gene-modified cells extracted [14C]ornithine more efficiently than controls. The vector prepared without neo transduced cells more efficiently and led to higher levels of OAT expression than the neo-containing vector. Ornithine catabolism was maintained at high levels when the transduced patient keratinocytes were differentiated in vitro as a multilayered cutaneous organoid.

Ornithine-delta-aminotransferase expression and ornithine metabolism in cultured epidermal keratinocytes: toward metabolic sink therapy for gyrate atrophy.

There is now strong evidence that the chorioretinal degeneration associated with ornithine-delta-aminotransferase (OAT) deficiency is a consequence of hyperornithinemia. Therefore development of a metabolic system for clearing ornithine from the circulation is being pursued as a potential treatment. The skin is considered an attractive location for such a metabolic system because autologous cells can be safely and easily utilized. This study was undertaken to determine the ornithine metabolizing capacity of epidermal keratinocytes expressing normal and superphysiologic amounts of OAT. The data show that overexpression of OAT in keratinocytes cultured from a gyrate atrophy patient restores ornithine metabolism and results in a rate of ornithine disappearance from the medium that is significantly higher than the rate of disappearance from the medium bathing normal keratinocytes. In addition, OAT activity determined in soluble protein prepared from sonicates suggests that the capacity to maintain plasma ornithine within the normal range is contained within an accomplishable graft of keratinocytes overexpressing OAT. However, the actual rate of ornithine disappearance from the media was significantly less than predicted from enzyme activity assays. Following ornithine metabolite production by intact cells suggests that ornithine metabolism is limited primarily by clearance of downstream metabolites, as opposed to substrate delivery.

Correction of ornithine-delta-aminotransferase deficiency in a Chinese hamster ovary cell line mediated by retrovirus gene transfer.

Gyrate atrophy (GA) of the choroid and retina is an autosomal recessive chorioretinal degeneration, caused by deficiency of the mitochondrial matrix enzyme ornithine-delta-aminotransferase (OAT). This deficiency results in the accumulation of ornithine in the body fluids and leads to hyperornithinemia. Although the clinical phenotype is largely confined to the eye, OAT deficiency is a systemic disorder. With the final goal of applying gene therapy to this human genetic disease, we have established an in vitro model to test the correction of OAT enzymatic deficiency in mammalian cells, using OAT recombinant retroviruses. We report the construction of several Moloney murine leukemia virus (MoMLV)-based recombinant retrovirus vectors, in which the human OAT cDNA was placed under the transcriptional control of the mouse phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) promoter or under the enhancer-promoter regulatory element derived from the MoMLV long terminal repeat (LTR). The retrovirus constructs were packaged in the PG13-GALV cell line and used to transduce C9, an OAT deficient cell line derived from Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO-K1). We show that the recombinant retrovirus transfers the human OAT (hOAT) gene into C9. Expression of the hOAT gene in the transduced C9 deficient cell line exceeded the OAT mRNA level and enzymatic activity of endogenous human fibroblasts.