Paradoxical effects on ice nucleation are intrinsic to a small winter flounder antifreeze protein.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) bind to ice in solutions, resulting in non-colligative freezing point depression; however, their effects on ice nucleation are not well understood. The predominant plasma AFP of winter flounder (Pseudopleuronectes americanus) is AFP6, which is an amphiphilic alpha helix. In this study, AFP6 and modified constructs were produced as fusion proteins in Escherichia coli, subjected to proteolysis when required and purified prior to use. AFP6 and its recombinant fusion precursor generated similar thermal hysteresis and bipyramidal ice crystals, whereas an inactive mutant AFP6 produced hexagonal crystals and no hysteresis. Circular dichroism spectra of the wild-type and mutant AFP6 were consistent with an alpha helix. The effects of these proteins on ice nucleation were investigated alongside non-AFP proteins using a standard droplet freezing assay. In the presence of nucleating AgI, modest reductions in the nucleation temperature occurred with the addition of mutant AFP6, and several non-AFPs, suggesting non-specific inhibition of AgI-induced ice nucleation. In these experiments, both AFP6 and its recombinant precursor resulted in lower nucleation temperatures, consistent with an additional inhibitory effect. Conversely, in the absence of AgI, AFP6 induced ice nucleation, with no other proteins showing this effect. Nucleation by AFP6 was dose-dependent, reaching a maximum at 1.5 mM protein. Nucleation by AFP6 also required an ice-binding site, as the inactive mutant had no effect. Furthermore, the absence of nucleation by the recombinant precursor protein suggested that the fusion moiety was interfering with the formation of a surface capable of nucleating ice.

The ice-binding site of antifreeze protein irreversibly binds to cell surface for its hypothermic protective function.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) are multifunctional polypeptides that adsorb onto ice crystals to inhibit their growth and onto cells to protect them from nonfreezing hypothermic damage. However, the mechanism by which AFP exerts its hypothermic cell protective (HCP) function remains uncertain. Here, we assessed the HCP function of three types of fish-derived AFPs (type I, II, and III AFPs) against human T-lymphoblastic lymphoma by measuring the survival rate (%) of the cells after preservation at 4 °C for 24 h. All AFPs improved the survival rate in a concentration-dependent manner, although the HCP efficiency was inferior for type III AFP compared to other AFPs. In addition, after point mutations were introduced into the ice-binding site (IBS) of a type III AFP, HCP activity was dramatically increased, suggesting that the IBS of AFP is involved in cell adsorption. Significantly, high HCP activity was observed for a mutant that exhibited poorer antifreeze activity, indicating that AFP exerts HCP- and ice-binding functions through a different mechanism. We next incubated the cells in an AFP-containing solution, replaced it with pure EC solution, and then preserved the cells, showing that no significant reduction in the cell survival rate occurred for type I and II AFPs even after replacement. Thus, these AFPs irreversibly bind to the cells at 4 °C, and only tightly adsorbed AFP molecules contribute towards the cell-protection function.

Droplet freezing assays using a nanoliter osmometer.

The ability to accurately record the temperature at which ice nucleation occurs is critical for studying biological ice nucleators. Several instruments have been designed and custom built to make such measurements, but they are not yet on the market. Here we reproducibly measure ice nucleation temperatures down close to the homogeneous nucleation temperature of -38 °C with a commercially available nanoliter osmometer, which we routinely use to assay the thermal hysteresis activity of antifreeze proteins. This instrument has both a wide operating temperature range and fine temperature control, while the oil immersion format on 12-well grids prevents droplet evaporation and surface nucleation events. The results obtained are consistent with those reported on other instruments in common use.

Brassica juncea leaf cuticle contains xylose and mannose (xylomannan) which inhibit ice recrystallization on the leaf surface.

MAIN CONCLUSION: Conjugated sugars showed antifreeze activity in the cuticle by ice recrystallization inhibition rather than thermal hysteresis, enhancing freezing capacity at the surface of B. juncea leaves. Antifreeze biomolecules play a crucial role in mitigating the physical damage from frost by controlling extracellular ice crystal growth in plants. Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) are reported from the apoplast of different plants. Interestingly, there is no report about antifreeze properties of the cuticle. Here, we report the potential antifreeze activity in the Brassica juncea (BJ) leaf cuticle. Nano LC-MS/MS analysis of a cuticle protein enriched fraction (CPE) predicted over 30 putative AFPs using CryoProtect server and literature survey. Ice crystal morphology (ICM) and ice recrystallization inhibition (IRI) analysis of ABC supernatant showed heat and pronase-resistant, non-protein antifreeze activities as well as hexagonal ice crystals with TH of 0.17 °C and IRI 46%. The ZipTip processed ABC supernatant (without peptides) had no effect on TH activity, confirming a non-protein antifreeze molecule contributing to activity. To understand the origin and to confirm the source of antifreeze activity, cuticular membranes were isolated by pectinase and cellulase hydrolysis. FTIR analysis of the intact cuticle showed xylose, mannose, cellulose, and glucose. Xylanase and cellulase treatments of the ZipTip processed ABC supernatant led to an increase in sugar content and 50% loss in antifreeze activity. UV spectroscopy and NMR analysis supported the finding of FTIR and enzyme hydrolysis suggesting the contribution of xylose and mannose to antifreeze activity. By TLC analysis, conjugated sugars were found in the cuticle. This work has opened up a new research area where the antifreeze capacity needs to be established with regard to complete characterization and mechanism of action of the antifreeze carbohydrates (conjugated sugars) on the leaf surface.

Engulfment Avalanches and Thermal Hysteresis for Antifreeze Proteins on Supercooled Ice.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) bind to the ice-water surface and prevent ice growth at temperatures below 0 °C through a Gibbs-Thomson effect. Each adsorbed AFP creates a metastable depression on the surface that locally resists ice growth, until ice engulfs the AFP. We recently predicted the susceptibility to engulfment as a function of AFP size, distance between AFPs, and supercooling [ J. Chem. Phys. 2023, 158, 094501]. For an ensemble of AFPs adsorbed on the ice surface, the most isolated AFPs are the most susceptible, and when an isolated AFP gets engulfed, its former neighbors become more isolated and more susceptible to engulfment. Thus, an initial engulfment event can trigger an avalanche of subsequent engulfment events, leading to a sudden surge of unrestrained ice growth. This work develops a model to predict the supercooling at which the first engulfment event will occur for an ensemble of randomly distributed AFP pinning sites on an ice surface. Specifically, we formulate an inhomogeneous survival probability that accounts for the AFP coverage, the distribution of AFP neighbor distances, the resulting ensemble of engulfment rates, the ice surface area, and the cooling rate. We use the model to predict thermal hysteresis trends and compare with experimental data.

Chilling injury in human kidney tubule cells after subzero storage is not mitigated by antifreeze protein addition.

By preventing freezing, antifreeze proteins (AFPs) can permit cells and organs to be stored at subzero temperatures. As metabolic rates decrease with decreasing temperature, subzero static cold storage (SZ-SCS) could provide more time for tissue matching and potentially lead to fewer discarded organs. Human kidneys are generally stored for under 24 h and the tubule epithelium is known to be particularly sensitive to static cold storage (SCS). Here, telomerase-immortalized proximal-tubule epithelial cells from humans, which closely resemble their progenitors, were used as a proxy to assess the potential benefit of SZ-SCS for kidneys. The effects of hyperactive AFPs from a beetle and Cryostasis Storage Solution were compared to University of Wisconsin Solution at standard SCS temperatures (4 °C) and at -6 °C for up to six days. Although the AFPs helped guard against freezing, lower storage temperatures under these conditions were not beneficial. Compared to cells at 4 °C, those stored at -6 °C showed decreased viability as well as increased lactate dehydrogenase release and apoptosis. This suggests that this kidney cell type might be prone to chilling injury and that the addition of AFPs to enable SZ-SCS may not be effective for increasing storage times.

Engineered Compounds to Control Ice Nucleation and Recrystallization.

One of the greatest concerns in the subzero storage of cells, tissues, and organs is the ability to control the nucleation or recrystallization of ice. In nature, evidence of these processes, which aid in sustaining internal temperatures below the physiologic freezing point for extended periods of time, is apparent in freeze-avoidant and freeze-tolerant organisms. After decades of studying these proteins, we now have easily accessible compounds and materials capable of recapitulating the mechanisms seen in nature for biopreser-vation applications. The output from this burgeoning area of research can interact synergistically with other novel developments in the field of cryobiology, making it an opportune time for a review on this topic.

Improving the cryoprotective effect of antifreeze proteins from Daucus carota on plant-based meat by eliminating N-glycosylation.

As a novel animal meat alternative, plant-based meat (PBM) frequently suffers from quality problems as a result of freeze-thaw cycles in commercial transportation and household storage. There is a need to reduce the deterioration of PBM attributes, such as water holding capacity, as a result of these freeze-thaw cycles. In this study, Daucus carota antifreeze protein (DcAFP) and its deglycosylated mutant DcAFP-N294G were heterologously expressed in Komagataella phaffii X33. The effects of pretreatment with recombinant AFPs (rAFPs) on the microstructure, rheological properties, water mobility, and water distribution of PBM were assessed. The rDcAFP-N294G-treated PBM samples had superior viscoelasticity and water distribution features compared to the rDcAFP-treated group because the complex N-linked oligosaccharides did not interfere with the binding of rAFPs to ice molecules. In addition, rAFP pretreatment resulted in a smoother and flatter surface of the high-moisture protein extrudate matrix compared to the commercial cryoprotectant trehalose. Deglycosylated DcAFP has potential applications as a new effective cryoprotectant in meat alternatives.

Evaluation of corn steep liquor as fermentation media for recombinant Lactococcus lactis producing antifreeze proteins.

BACKGROUND: Corn processing byproducts corn steep liquor (CSL), and thin stillage were evaluated as growth media for recombinant Lactococcus lactis modified to produce antifreeze proteins (AFPs) that could have important food and non-food applications. The AFP III sequence from ocean pout was cloned into a shuttle vector to make an expression vector that facilitated the production of recombinant AFP III in Lactococcus lactis. Light CSL from yellow dent corn and thin stillage from the industrial corn bioethanol process were optimized as fermentation media with a combination of the following additives and trace elements: disodium-ß-glycerophosphate (DG), tryptone (T), ascorbic acid (AA), iron (Fe), zinc (Zn), and magnesium (Mg). The growth of wild-type and recombinant Lactococcus lactis strains were compared over a 72 h period in 96-well plates and 250 mL shake flasks. RESULTS: The corn coproducts media consisting of 50% (v/v) light steep in water supplemented with DG-5 g L-1 , T-5 g L-1 , AA-0.5 g L-1 , and Zn-4 ppm resulted in best growth and was considered as the best-optimized media. The addition of additives and trace elements better supported the growth of both wild-type and recombinant Lactococcus lactis strains compared to control media without any additives. Respective fermentation supernatants were frozen to -20 °C, and the time to supercool and freeze was compared. A distinct supercooling effect was observed for the supernatants from recombinant strains thus, extending the time and temperature of supercooling and freezing. The maximum time of supercooling extended was 17.55 ± 4.45 min for thin stillage followed by M17 media (17.25 ± 4.45 min), Kent Corporation CSL (10.80 ± 2.12 min), and yellow dent CSL (6.9 ± 0.85 min) when fermented with recombinant Lactococcus lactis strains. CONCLUSION: The supplemented corn coproduct-based media enhanced the growth of both wild-type and recombinant Lactococcus lactis strains. These optimized media can replace or supplement more expensive media (e.g. M17), potentially reducing cost. The fermentation supernatants exhibited longer times to supercool, and freeze compared to control supernatants, indicating potential use as antifreeze compounds in frozen food and non-food applications. © 2023 The Authors. Journal of The Science of Food and Agriculture published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Society of Chemical Industry.

Immunotargeting of Gram-Positive Pathogens via a Cell Wall Binding Tick Antifreeze Protein.

Immunological agents that supplement or modulate the host immune response have proven to have powerful therapeutic potential, although this modality is less explored against bacterial pathogens. We describe the application of a bacterial binding protein to re-engage the immune system toward pathogenic bacteria. More specifically, a hapten was conjugated to a protein expressed by Ixodes scapularis ticks, called I. scapularis antifreeze glycoprotein (IAFGP), that has high affinity for the d-alanine residue on the bacterial peptidoglycan. We showed that a fragment of this protein retained high surface binding affinity. Moreover, conjugation of a hapten to this peptide led to the display of haptens on the cell surface of vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecalis. Hapten display then induced the recruitment of antibodies and promoted uptake of bacterial pathogens by immune cells. These results demonstrate the feasibility in using cell wall binding agents as the basis of a class of bacterial immunotherapies.

Protein engineering of antifreeze proteins reveals that their activity scales with the area of the ice-binding site.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) protect organisms from freezing by binding to ice crystals to prevent their growth. Here, we have investigated how the area of an AFP's ice-binding site (IBS) changes its antifreeze activity. The polyproline type II helical bundle fold of the 9.6-kDa springtail (Collembola) AFP from Granisotoma rainieri (a primitive arthropod) facilitates changes to both IBS length and width. A one quarter decrease in area reduced activity to less than 10%. A one quarter increase in IBS width, through the addition of a single helix, tripled antifreeze activity. However, increasing IBS length by a similar amount actually reduced activity. Expanding the IBS area can greatly increase antifreeze activity but needs to be evaluated by experimentation on a case-by-case basis.

New insight into the mechanism by which antifreeze peptides regulate the physiological function of Streptococcus thermophilus subjected to freezing stress.

INTRODUCTION: Antifreeze peptides regulate the physiological functions of frozen cells and even their apoptosis; however, the mechanisms by which antifreeze peptides regulate these processes remain unclear, although the interactions between cell membranes and ice are well known to be important in this process. OBJECTIVES: Our study aims to investigate how antifreeze peptides regulate cell physiological functions during the freezing process. METHODS: We investigated the cryoprotective effect of rsfAFP on the physiological functions of S. thermophilus under freezing stress by measuring cellular metabolism activity, intracellular enzyme activity, cell membrane characterization, and cell apoptosis. The mechanism by which rsfAFP impacts S. thermophilus physiological functions under freezing stress was investigated using multispectral techniques and cryo-TEM. RESULTS: We show that a recombinant antifreeze peptide (rsfAFP) interacts with the extracellular capsular polysaccharides and peptidoglycan of Streptococcus thermophilus and ice to cover the outer layer of the membrane, forming a dense protective layer that regulates the molecular structure of extracellular ice crystals, which results in reduced extracellular membrane damage, depressed apoptosis and increased intracellular metabolic activity. This interaction mechanism was indicated by the fact that S. thermophilus better maintained its permeability barrier, membrane fluidity, membrane structural integrity, and cytoplasmic membrane potential during freezing stress with rsfAFP treatment. CONCLUSION: These results provide new insights into the mechanism by which rsfAFP regulates frozen cellphysiological functionsand apoptosis under freezing stress.

The Effects of Different Doses of ROCK Inhibitor, Antifreeze Protein III, and Boron Added to Semen Extender on Semen Freezeability of Ankara Bucks.

In the presented study, the effects of ROCK inhibitor Y-27632, antifreeze protein III, and boron at two different doses were investigated on the spermatological parameters of Ankara buck semen after freeze−thawing. Ejaculates were collected from bucks using an electroejaculator during the breeding season. The ejaculates that showed appropriate characteristics were pooled and used in the dilution and freezing of semen. The extender groups were formed by adding two different doses of three different additives (ROCK inhibitor Y-27632, 5 and 20 µM; antifreeze protein III, 1 and 4 µg/mL; boron, 0.25 and 1 mM) to the control extender. The semen was diluted with the different extenders at 35−37 °C and loaded into straws. Sperm samples frozen in liquid nitrogen vapors, following equilibration, were stored in liquid nitrogen. It was observed that extender supplementation improved post-thaw motility of Ankara buck semen after freeze−thawing. Differences were significant (p < 0.01) for 5 and 10 µM doses of ROCK inhibitor (71.82% and 74.04 % motility), as well as for 0.25 and 1 mM doses of boron (76.36% and 72.08% motility), compared to the control group (66.15% motility). With respect to the evaluation of acrosomal integrity and mitochondrial activity after freeze−thawing, although supplementation provided protection at all doses, the efficacy was not statistically significant (p > 0.05). It was observed that DNA damage was improved by antifreeze protein III at 1 µg/mL (1.23% ± 0.23%) and by boron at all doses (0.25 mM: 1.83% and 1 mM: 1.18%) compared to the control group (3.37%) (p < 0.01), following the thawing process. In the present study, it was determined that some additives added to the extender provided significant improvements in buck spermatozoa motility and DNA damage after thawing.

A mutation to a fish ice-binding protein synthesized in transgenic Caenorhabditis elegans modulates its cold tolerance.

A cryoprotectant known as ice-binding protein (IBP) is thought to facilitate the cold survival of plants, insects, and fungi. Here, we prepared a genetically modified Caenorhabditis elegans strain to synthesize fish-derived IBPs in its body wall muscles and examined whether the antifreeze activity modification of this IBP by point mutation affects the cold tolerance of this worm. We chose a 65-residue IBP identified from notched-fin eelpout, for which the replacement of the 20th alanine residue (A20) modifies its antifreeze activity. These mutant proteins are denoted A20L, A20G, A20T, A20V, and A20I along with the wild-type (WT) protein. We evaluated the survival rate (%) of the transgenic C. elegans that synthesized each IBP mutant following 24 h of preservation at -5, +2, and +5 °C. Significantly, a dramatic improvement in the survival rate was detected for the worms synthesizing the activity-enhanced mutants (A20T and A20I), especially at +2 °C. In contrast, the rate was not improved by the expression of the defective mutants (A20L, A20G, WT and A20V). The survival rate (%) probably correlates with the antifreeze activity of the IBP. These data suggest that IBP protects the cell membrane by employing its ice-binding mechanism, which ultimately improves the cold tolerance of an IBP-containing animal.

Control on moisture distribution and protein changes of Antarctic krill meat by antifreeze protein during multiple freeze-thaw cycles.

Control on the moisture distribution, protein structure changes, and protein degradation of Antarctic krill meat during freeze-thaw (F-T) cycles by presoaking with antifreeze protein (AFP) was investigated. The results from the thawing loss rate and cooking loss rate indicated that 0.1% was the optimal AFP concentration. Magnetic resonance imaging and low-field nuclear magnetic resonance results showed that AFP inhibited the changes in moisture distribution and maintained the moisture in Antarctic krill meat. The contents of nonprotein nitrogen and trichloroacetic acid-soluble peptides indicated that AFP reduced protein degradation. Further, SDS-PAGE showed that AFP reduced the degradation of actin, troponin T, and myosin light chain. The results of fluorescence spectra, circular dichroism, and chemical bond contents indicated that AFP reduced the damage of the protein tertiary and secondary structures of Antarctic krill meat by holding it in a weak polar environment. This study supplied basic theory for the quality control of Antarctic krill meat. PRACTICAL APPLICATION: Protein degradation, moisture distribution, and protein structure changes occurred to Antarctic krill meat during freeze-thaw cycles due to ice crystal growth and recrystallization, which leads to the decrease in quality. Antifreeze protein has been proven to avoid ice crystals' growth and inhibit ice recrystallization. During freeze-thaw cycles, the moisture distribution of Antarctic krill meat treated with antifreeze protein was more uniform, the degree of protein degradation was lower, and the protein structure was protected. This study demonstrated the potential of antifreeze protein as a water and protein protectant of Antarctic krill meat during freeze-thaw cycles.

Preparation, Characterization, and Mechanism of Antifreeze Peptides from Defatted Antarctic Krill (Euphausia superba) on Lactobacillus rhamnosus.

Defatted Antarctic krill powder is the main by-product in the manufacturing of krill oil. Exploring a high value-added approach for utilizing this protein-rich material has received much attention in research and industry. Given this, the preparation and primary characterization of antifreeze peptides from defatted Antarctic krill (AKAPs) were carried out in this study. The cryoprotective effect of AKAPs on Lactobacillus rhamnosus ATCC7469 was also investigated. The results showed that Protamex was the optimum protease for AKAP preparation from defatted Antarctic krill. AKAPs were found to be rich in short peptides, with the MW ranging from 600 to 2000 Da (69.2%). An amino acid composition analysis showed that AKAPs were rich in glutamic acid (18.71%), aspartic acid (12.19%), leucine (7.87%), and lysine (7.61%). After freezing, the relative survival rate of Lactobacillus rhamnosus in the 1.0 mg/mL AKAP-treated group (96.83%) was significantly higher than in the saline group (24.12%) (p < 0.05). AKAPs also retarded the loss of acidifying activity of L. rhamnosus after freezing. AKAPs showed even better cryoprotective activity than three commercial cryoprotectants (sucrose, skim milk, and glycerol). In addition, AKAPs significantly alleviated the decrease in ß-galactosidase and lactic dehydrogenase activities of L. rhamnosus (p < 0.05). Furthermore, AKAPs effectively protected the integrity of L. rhamnosus cell membranes from freezing damage and alleviated the leakage of intracellular substances. These findings demonstrate that AKAPs can be a potential cryoprotectant for preserving L. rhamnosus, providing a new way to use defatted Antarctic krill.

Origin of an antifreeze protein gene in response to Cenozoic climate change.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) inhibit ice growth within fish and protect them from freezing in icy seawater. Alanine-rich, alpha-helical AFPs (type I) have independently (convergently) evolved in four branches of fishes, one of which is a subsection of the righteye flounders. The origin of this gene family has been elucidated by sequencing two loci from a starry flounder, Platichthys stellatus, collected off Vancouver Island, British Columbia. The first locus had two alleles that demonstrated the plasticity of the AFP gene family, one encoding 33 AFPs and the other allele only four. In the closely related Pacific halibut, this locus encodes multiple Gig2 (antiviral) proteins, but in the starry flounder, the Gig2 genes were found at a second locus due to a lineage-specific duplication event. An ancestral Gig2 gave rise to a 3-kDa "skin" AFP isoform, encoding three Ala-rich 11-a.a. repeats, that is expressed in skin and other peripheral tissues. Subsequent gene duplications, followed by internal duplications of the 11 a.a. repeat and the gain of a signal sequence, gave rise to circulating AFP isoforms. One of these, the "hyperactive" 32-kDa Maxi likely underwent a contraction to a shorter 3.3-kDa "liver" isoform. Present day starry flounders found in Pacific Rim coastal waters from California to Alaska show a positive correlation between latitude and AFP gene dosage, with the shorter allele being more prevalent at lower latitudes. This study conclusively demonstrates that the flounder AFP arose from the Gig2 gene, so it is evolutionarily unrelated to the three other classes of type I AFPs from non-flounders. Additionally, this gene arose and underwent amplification coincident with the onset of ocean cooling during the Cenozoic ice ages.

Design and Analysis of a Mutant form of the Ice-Binding Protein from Choristoneura fumiferana.

Ice-binding proteins are expressed in the cells of some cold adapted organisms, helping them to survive at extremely low temperatures. One of the problems in studying such proteins is the difficulty of their isolation and purification. For example, eight cysteine residues in the cfAF (antifreeze protein from the eastern spruce budworm Choristoneura fumiferana) form intermolecular bridges during the overexpression of this protein. This impedes the process of the protein purification dramatically. To overcome this issue, in this work, we designed a mutant form of the ice-binding protein cfAFP, which is much easier to isolate that the wild-type protein. The mutant form named mIBP83 did not lose the ability to bind to ice surface. Besides, observation of the processes of freezing and melting of ice in the presence of mIBP83 showed that this protein affects the process of ice melting, increasing its melting temperature, and does not decrease the water freezing temperature.

Control of ice crystal nucleation and growth during the food freezing process.

Freezing can maintain a low-temperature environment inside food, reducing water activity and preventing microorganism growth. However, when ice crystals are large, present in high amounts, and/or irregularly distributed, irreversible damage to food can occur. Therefore, ice growth is a vital parameter that needs to be controlled during frozen food processing and storage. In this review, ice growth theory and control are described. Macroscopic heat and mass transfer processes, the relationship between the growth of ice crystals and macroscopic heat transfer factors, and nucleation theory are reviewed based on the reported theoretical and experimental approaches. The issues addressed include how heat transfer occurs inside samples, variations in thermal properties with temperature, boundary conditions, and the functional relationship between ice crystal growth and freezing parameters. Quick freezing (e.g., cryogenic freezing) and unavoidable temperature fluctuations (e.g., multiple freeze-thaw cycles) are both taken into consideration. The approaches for controlling ice crystal growth based on the ice morphology and content are discussed. The characteristics and initial mechanisms of ice growth inhibitors (e.g., antifreeze proteins (AFPs), polysaccharides, and phenols) and ice nucleation agents (INAs) are complex, especially when considering their molecular structures, the ice-binding interface, and the dose. Although the market share for nonthermal processing technology is low, there will be more work on freezing technologies and their theoretical basis. Superchilling technology (partial freezing) is also mentioned here.