Genomic and morphological characterization of a new Thiothrix species from a sulfide hot spring of the Zmeinaya bay (Northern Baikal, Russia).

A survey for bacteria of the genus Thiothrix indicated that they inhabited the area where the water of the Zmeiny geothermal spring (northern basin of Lake Baikal, Russia) mixed with the lake water. In the coastal zone of the lake oxygen (8.25 g/L) and hydrogen sulfide (up to 1 mg/L) were simultaneously present at sites of massive growth of these particular Thiothrix bacteria. Based on the analysis of the morphological characteristics and sequence of individual genes (16S rRNA, rpoB and tilS), we could not attribute the Thiothrix from Lake Baikal to any of the known species of this genus. To determine metabolic capabilities and phylogenetic position of the Thiothrix sp. from Lake Baikal, we analyzed their whole genome. Like all members of this genus, the bacteria from Lake Baikal were capable of organo-heterotrophic, chemolithoheterotrophic, and chemolithoautotrophic growth and differed from its closest relatives in the spectrum of nitrogen and sulfur cycle genes as well as in the indices of average nucleotide identity (ANI < 75-94%), amino acid identity (AAI < 94%) and in silico DNA-DNA hybridization (dDDH < 17-57%), which were below the boundary of interspecies differences, allowing us to identify them as novel candidate species.

Metagenomics Revealed a New Genus 'Candidatus Thiocaldithrix dubininis' gen. nov., sp. nov. and a New Species 'Candidatus Thiothrix putei' sp. nov. in the Family Thiotrichaceae, Some Members of Which Have Traits of Both Na+- and H+-Motive Energetics.

Two metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs), GKL-01 and GKL-02, related to the family Thiotrichaceae have been assembled from the metagenome of bacterial mat obtained from a sulfide-rich thermal spring in the North Caucasus. Based on average amino acid identity (AAI) values and genome-based phylogeny, MAG GKL-01 represented a new genus within the Thiotrichaceae family. The GC content of the GKL-01 DNA (44%) differed significantly from that of other known members of the genus Thiothrix (50.1-55.6%). We proposed to assign GKL-01 to a new species and genus 'Candidatus Thiocaldithrix dubininis' gen. nov., sp. nov. GKL-01. The phylogenetic analysis and estimated distances between MAG GKL-02 and the genomes of the previously described species of the genus Thiothrix allowed assigning GKL-02 to a new species with the proposed name 'Candidatus Thiothrix putei' sp. nov. GKL-02 within the genus Thiothrix. Genome data first revealed the presence of both Na+-ATPases and H+-ATPases in several Thiothrix species. According to genomic analysis, bacteria GKL-01 and GKL-02 are metabolically versatile facultative aerobes capable of growing either chemolithoautotrophically or chemolithoheterotrophically in the presence of hydrogen sulfide and/or thiosulfate or chemoorganoheterotrophically.

History of the Study of the Genus Thiothrix: From the First Enrichment Cultures to Pangenomic Analysis.

Representatives of the genus Thiothrix are filamentous, sulfur-oxidizing bacteria found in flowing waters with counter-oriented sulfide and oxygen gradients. They were first described at the end of the 19th century, but the first pure cultures of this species only became available 100 years later. An increase in the number of described Thiothrix species at the beginning of the 21st century shows that the classical phylogenetic marker, 16S rRNA gene, is not informative for species differentiation, which is possible based on genome analysis. Pangenome analysis of the genus Thiothrix showed that the core genome includes genes for dissimilatory sulfur metabolism and central metabolic pathways, namely the Krebs cycle, Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas pathway, glyoxylate cycle, Calvin-Benson-Bassham cycle, and genes for phosphorus metabolism and amination. The shell part of the pangenome includes genes for dissimilatory nitrogen metabolism and nitrogen fixation, for respiration with thiosulfate. The dispensable genome comprises genes predicted to encode mainly hypothetical proteins, transporters, transcription regulators, methyltransferases, transposases, and toxin-antitoxin systems.

Adding an anaerobic step can rapidly inhibit sludge bulking in SBR reactor.

Activated sludge from wastewater treatment plants was seeded into a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) in which synthetic wastewater was used as the influent. The sludge was bulked by decreasing the concentration of dissolved oxygen (DO). By adding a 30 min step of anaerobic stirring after the water inflow, the sludge bulking was rapidly inhibited after 10 running cycles, and the sludge volume index (SVI) decreased from 222 to 74 mL·g-1. The results of high-throughput sequencing showed that the relative abundance of bacteria Thiothrix, bacteria norank_o_Sphingobacteriales and fungi Trichosporon was increased by 6.3, 4.3 and 81.2%, after initial SBR stages, but these bacteria were inhibited by the addition of an anaerobic step, as their relative abundances decreased by 0.7, 0.8 and 14.7%, respectively. The proliferation of Thiothrix, norank_o_Sphingobacteriales and Trichosporon was the primary reason for the observed sludge bulking in the reactor. After the anaerobic step was added, the sludge extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) concentration was increased from 84.4 to 104.0 mg·(gMLSS)-1 (grams of mixed liquor suspended solids). Thus, the addition of an anaerobic step can inhibit the growth of filamentous bacteria, increasing the sludge EPS concentration and promoting the precipitation of activated sludge.

Identification and characterization of the S-layer formed on the sheath of Thiothrix nivea.

Thiothrix nivea is a filamentous sulfur-oxidizing bacterium common in activated sludge and its filament is covered with a polysaccharide layer called sheath. In this study, we found that T. nivea aggregates under acidic conditions. A hexagonal lattice pattern, a typical morphological feature of proteinaceous S-layers, was newly observed on the surface of the sheath by transmission electron microscopy. The pattern and the acid-dependent aggregation were not observed in T. fructosivorans, a relative sheath-forming bacterium of T. nivea. The putative S-layer of T. nivea was detached by washing with unbuffered tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane base (Tris) solution and a protein of 160 kDa was detected by electrophoresis. Based on partial amino acid sequences of the protein, its structural gene was identified. The gene encodes an acidic protein which has a putative secretion signal and a Ca2+-binding domain. The protein was solubilized with urea followed by dialysis in the presence of calcium. A hexagonal lattice pattern was observed in the aggregates formed during dialysis, revealing that the protein is responsible for S-layer formation. Biosorption ability of copper, zinc, and cadmium onto the T. nivea filament decreased upon pretreatment with Tris, demonstrating that the S-layer was involved in metal adsorption. Moreover, aggregation of Escherichia coli was promoted by acidification in the presence of the S-layer protein, suggesting that the protein is potentially applicable as an acid-driven flocculant for other bacteria.

Remediation of Thiothrix spp. associated bulking problems by raw wastewater feeding: A full-scale experience.

An industrial wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) in Australia has long suffered from bulking problems associated with the proliferation of Thiothrix spp. The WWTP consists of a covered anaerobic lagoon (CAL) followed by a sequencing batch reactor (SBR). The CAL functions as both an anaerobic digester and surge lagoon for the irregular flow of wastewater generated from the production of seasonal products. Chemical analysis of the raw influent showed it was composed of a mixture of organic acids, phenols and alcohols. The CAL effluent was characterised by high acetic acid and phenolic concentrations. An attempt was made to manipulate the SBR microbial community to improve settling by direct feeding small volumes of raw influent into the SBR. After raw feeding, the plant ceased bulking as the settled sludge volume reduced from 930 to 200mLL-1. 16S rRNA gene profiling and biovolumes of SBR samples revealed major changes in the microbial community. The Thiothrix spp. population decreased from 36.8% to 0.2%, and Zoogloea spp. dominated all samples after raw feeding. Therefore, direct feeding is proposed as a control method for industrial plants with surge/anaerobic lagoons in order to manage the bulking problems caused by Thiothrix spp. in downstream SBRs.

Filamentous bulking caused by Thiothrix species is efficiently controlled in full-scale wastewater treatment plants by implementing a sludge densification strategy.

Filamentous bulking caused by Thiothrix species is responsible for sludge washout and loss of performance in dairy wastewater treatment plants. A long-term study was conducted over 1.5 years to test three different mitigation strategies in a full-scale plant composed of two parallel sequential batch reactors (SBR1 and 2). Strategies based on polyaluminium chloride addition and volatile fatty acids reduction were ineffective to permanently solve the problem. On the contrary, modification of the reactor cycle based on the implementation of a periodic starvation proved efficient to solve the biomass wash-out and drastically reduce the sludge volume index in both reactors. Bacterial diversity analysis using 16S amplicon sequencing and quantitative PCR indicated a reduction of Thiothrix abundance from 51.9 to 1.0% in SBR1 and from 71.8 to 0.6% in SBR2. Simultaneously, the abundance of the glycogen-accumulating bacterium Candidatus Competibacter increased in both reactors. Microscopy analysis confirmed the transition between a bulking sludge towards a granular-like sludge. This study confirms the applicability of a periodic starvation to (1) solve recurring Thiothrix bulking, (2) convert loose aggregates into dense and compact granular-like structures and (3) considerably reduce energy demand for aeration.

Diverse sulfur metabolisms from two subterranean sulfidic spring systems.

In sulfidic environments, microbes oxidize reduced sulfur compounds via several pathways. We used metagenomics to investigate sulfur metabolic pathways from microbial mat communities in two subterranean sulfidic streams in Lower Kane Cave, WY, USA and from Glenwood Hot Springs, CO, USA. Both unassembled and targeted recA gene assembly analyses revealed that these streams were dominated by Epsilonproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria, including groups related to Sulfurovum, Sulfurospirillum, Thiothrix and an epsilonproteobacterial group with no close cultured relatives. Genes encoding sulfide:quinone oxidoreductase (SQR) were abundant at all sites, but the specific SQR type and the taxonomic affiliation of each type differed between sites. The abundance of thiosulfate oxidation pathway genes (Sox) was not consistent between sites, although overall they were less abundant than SQR genes. Furthermore, the Sox pathway appeared to be incomplete in all samples. This work reveals both variations in sulfur metabolism within and between taxonomic groups found in these systems, and the presence of novel epsilonproteobacterial groups.

Identification and quantification of Thiothrix eikelboomii using qPCR for early detection of bulking incidents in a full-scale water reclamation plant.

This study found that the ratio of Thiothrix eikelboomii to total bacterial concentrations (TH/TB) (%) was a better indicator of bulking incidents affecting effluent quality compared to absolute T. eikelboomii abundance alone. This was determined using a genus-specific Thiothrix quantitative PCR primer and probe set, which was developed in this study to monitor specific Thiothrix populations over a 1-year period. T. eikelboomii was identified as the source of bulking incidents based on sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene at a nitrifying-denitrifying wastewater treatment plant. Peak T. eikelboomii concentrations observed in March, April, and July 2009 were 2.32 × 10(10), 2.64 × 10(10), and 1.84 × 10(10) cells/l, respectively. The highest fraction of T. eikelboomii to total bacterial population was measured at 0.24% in March, and a ratio >0.19% caused increases of suspended solids and biochemical oxygen demand in the secondary effluent. Additionally, food/mass ratios, dissolved oxygen concentrations in the anoxic selector, and ammonium ion concentrations in the primary effluent were three parameters displaying statistically significant correlations (r = 0.40, r = 0.50, and r = 0.32, respectively) to Thiothrix spp. abundance in an aeration tank. No bulking events caused by T. eikelboomii occurred when the dissolved oxygen concentrations in the anoxic selector was maintained at lower than 0.12 mg/l and the TH/TB ratios were <0.10%.

Expansion of ability of denitrification within the filamentous colorless sulfur bacteria of the genus Thiothrix.

Filamentous sulfur bacteria of the genus Thiothrix are able to respire nitrate (NO3-→NO2-) under anaerobic growth. Here, Thiothrix caldifontis (G1(T), G3), Thiothrix unzii (A1(T), TN) and Thiothrix lacustris AS were shown to be capable of further reduction of nitrite and/or nitrous oxides (denitrification). In particular, in the genomes of these strains, excluding T. unzii TN, the nirS gene encoding periplasmic respiratory nitrite reductase was detected, and for T. lacustris AS the nirS expression was confirmed during anaerobic growth. The nirK gene, coding for an alternative nitrite reductase, and the nrfA gene, encoding nitrite reduction to ammonia, were not found in any investigated strains. All Thiothrix species capable of denitrification possess the cnorB gene encoding cytochrome c-dependent NO reductase but not the qnorB gene coding for quinol-dependent NO reductase. Denitrifying capacity ('full' or 'truncated') can vary between strains belonging to the same species and correlates with physical-chemical parameters of the environment such as nitrate, hydrogen sulfide and oxygen concentrations. Phylogenetic analysis revealed the absence of recent horizontal transfer events for narG and nirS; however, cnorB was subjected to gene transfer before the separation of modern species from a last common ancestor of the Thiothrix species.

Biodiversity and monitoring of colorless filamentous bacteria in sulfide aquatic systems of North Caucasus region.

Bacterial mats in sulfide aquatic systems of North Caucasus are basically composed by the species of genera Thiothrix and Sphaerotilus. Additionally, several non-filamentous sulfur-oxidizing bacteria were isolated from the mats and several minor 16S rRNA phylotypes were found in clone libraries from these mats. The minor components were affiliated with Proteobacteria, Chlorobia, Cyanobacteria and Firmicutes. Even in an individual mat population heterogeneity of Thiothrix spp. was revealed by analysis of 16S rRNA gene and RAPD-PCR. Five Thiothrix isolates were described as new species Thiothrix caldifontis sp. nov. and Thiothrix lacustris sp. nov. In the Thiothrix-Sphaerotilus type of bacterial mat the proportion of dominant organisms might be influenced by sulfide concentration in the spring water. The higher sulfide concentration (more than 10 mg/l) in the spring water is more favorable for the development of bacterial mats with dominant Thiothrix organisms than for Thiothrix-Sphaerotilus type of sulfur mat.

Dominance of epiphytic filamentous Thiothrix spp. on an aquatic macrophyte in a hydrothermal vent flume in Sedge Bay, Yellowstone Lake, Wyoming.

Sublacustrine hydrothermal vents, geysers, and fumaroles impart regions of Yellowstone Lake with distinctive chemical compositions that generate unique freshwater habitats and support diverse microbial life. Some microbial communities within Sedge Bay manifest themselves as accumulations of white-colored films on the surfaces of aquatic macrophytes located within the hydrothermal flow of vents. It was hypothesized that the white films were the product of microbial growth, particularly sulfur-oxidizing bacteria. An investigation of the relevant biological compounds in the vent waters was conducted. Microscopy, non-culture molecular techniques, and phylogenetic analysis were used to assay the bacterial diversity associated with the films. Microscopic analysis of the white films revealed the presence of long filaments (>200 µm) that contained sulfur granules. Filaments with these characteristics were not detected on the normal macrophyte samples. Nucleic acids were extracted from the surface of macrophyte coated with the white film (SB1, SB2) and from the surface of an uncoated macrophyte (SC). 16S ribosomal (rRNA) genes were amplified with the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and cloned. Amplified ribosomal DNA restriction analysis (ARDRA) was used to examine 100 clones from each library and identify unique phylotypes. S(Chao1) and the Shannon Index, mathematical measures of richness and heterogeneity, were employed to assess the ARDRA pattern diversity of each sample. The SC community contained 50 unique phylotypes, predominantly cyanobacteria and proteobacteria, and was the most heterogeneous. SB1 and SB2 communities were less heterogeneous and dominated by Thiothrix. Dilution to extinction PCR conducted with specific primers indicated that the relative abundance of Thiothrix 16S rRNA gene copies in all three samples were similar. However, reduced sulfur compounds from the vent resulted in a more narrow habitat that supported the sulfur-oxidizing Thiothrix in the white film to the exclusion of cyanobacteria and other proteobacteria found on the normal macrophyte. The majority of 16S rRNA gene sequences obtained in this study displayed similarities ≤98% to any known sequence in public data bases which suggests an abundance of new bacterial species in Sedge Bay.

Thiothrix caldifontis sp. nov. and Thiothrix lacustris sp. nov., gammaproteobacteria isolated from sulfide springs.

Five strains of filamentous, sulfur-oxidizing bacteria were isolated from sulfur mats of different sulfide springs from various regions of the Northern Caucasus, Russia. A phylogenetic analysis based on 16S rRNA gene sequence comparison showed that all of the isolates are affiliated with the filamentous, colourless, sulfur-oxidizing bacteria of the genus Thiothrix within the Gammaproteobacteria and are closely related to Thiothrix fructosivorans. All strains are capable of growing heterotrophically, lithoautotrophically with thiosulfate or sulfide as the sole energy source and mixotrophically. Strains G1(T), G2, P and K2 are able to fix molecular nitrogen, but strain BL(T) is not. Randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD)-PCR analysis was used to assess the level of genetic relationships among the Thiothrix isolates. The Nei and Li similarity index revealed high genetic similarity among strains G1(T), G2, P and K2 (above 75 %), indicating that they are closely related. In combination with physiological and morphological data, strains G1(T), G2, P and K2 can be considered as members of the same species. The lowest genetic similarity (approx. 20 %) was reached between strain BL(T) and the other isolated Thiothrix strains. Strains BL(T) and G1(T) shared 35 % DNA-DNA relatedness and showed 51 and 53 % relatedness, respectively, to Thiothrix fructosivorans ATCC 49749. On the basis of this polyphasic analysis, strains G1(T), G2, P and K2 represent a novel species within the genus Thiothrix, for which the name Thiothrix caldifontis sp. nov. is proposed, with strain G1(T) (=DSM 21228(T) =VKM B-2520(T)) as the type strain. In addition, strain BL(T) represents a second novel species, Thiothrix lacustris sp. nov., with strain BL(T) (=DSM 21227(T) =VKM B-2521(T)) as the type strain.

A novel symbiosis between chemoautotrophic bacteria and a freshwater cave amphipod.

Symbioses involving animals and chemoautotrophic bacteria form the foundation of entire ecosystems at deep-sea hydrothermal vents and cold seeps, but have so far not been reported in terrestrial or freshwater environments. A rare example of a terrestrial ecosystem sustained by chemoautotrophy is found within the sulfide-rich Frasassi limestone cave complex of central Italy. In this study, we report the discovery of abundant filamentous bacteria on the exoskeleton of Niphargus ictus, a macroinvertebrate endemic to Frasassi. Using 16S rDNA sequencing and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), we show that N. ictus throughout the large cave complex are colonized by a single phylotype of bacteria in the sulfur-oxidizing clade Thiothrix. The epibiont phylotype is distinct from Thiothrix phylotypes that form conspicuous biofilms in the cave streams and pools inhabited by N. ictus. Using a combination of 13C labeling, FISH, and secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS), we show that the epibiotic Thiothrix are autotrophic, establishing the first known example of a non-marine chemoautotroph-animal symbiosis. Conditions supporting chemoautotrophy, and the N. ictus-Thiothrix association, likely commenced in the Frasassi cave complex between 350,000 and 1 million years ago. Therefore, the N. ictus-Thiothrix symbiosis is probably significantly younger than marine chemoautotrophic symbioses, many of which have been evolving for tens to hundreds of million years.

[Phylogenetic in situ/ex situ analysis of a sulfur mat microbial community from a thermal sulfide stream in the North Caucasus].

A phylogenetic in situ/ex situ analysis of a sulfur mat formed by colorless filamentous sulfur bacteria in a thermal sulfide stream (northern spur of the main Caucasian ridge) was carried out. Nine phylotypes were revealed in the mat. Thiothrix sp. and Sphaerotilus sp. were the dominant phylotypes (66.3% and 26.3%, respectively). The 16S rRNA gene nucleotide sequence of Spahaerotilus sp. phylotype from the clone library was identical to the sequences of the seven Sphaerotilus strains isolated from the same source. A very high degree of similarity of Sphaerotilus strains revealed by ERIC-PCR fingerprints indicated little or no population diversity of this species in the mat. Thiothrix phylotype from the clone library and two Thiothrix strains isolated from the same mat sample differed in one to three nucleotides of 16S rRNA genes; this is an indication of this organism's population variability in the mat. 16S rRNA genes of the strains and clones of Thiothrix sp. exhibited the highest similarity (ca. 99%) with Thiothrix unzii; the strains and clones of Sphaerotilus had 99% similarity with the type species Sphaerotilus natans (the only species of this genus) and therefore can be assigned to this species. The minor seven components belong to the phylotypes from the Proteobacteria (3%), as well as the Chlorobia, Cyanobacteria, Clostridia, and Bacteroidetes phylogenetic groups, each of them constituting not more than 1%. Intracellular accumulation of elemental sulfur by Sphaerotilus similar to other filamentous sulfur bacteria was demonstrated for the first time (both in the population of the sulfur spring and in cultures with sulfide). Although mass growth of Sphaerotilus and Thiothrix is typical of bacterial populations of anthropogenic ecosystems (the activated sludge of treatment facilities), stable communities of these bacteria have not been previously found in the sulfur mats or "threads" of natural sulfide springs.

Molecular analysis of the distribution and phylogeny of dissimilatory adenosine-5'-phosphosulfate reductase-encoding genes (aprBA) among sulfur-oxidizing prokaryotes.

Dissimilatory adenosine-5'-phosphosulfate (APS) reductase (AprBA) is a key enzyme of the dissimilatory sulfate-reduction pathway. Homologues have been found in photo- and chemotrophic sulfur-oxidizing prokaryotes (SOP), in which they are postulated to operate in the reverse direction, oxidizing sulfite to APS. Newly developed PCR assays allowed the amplification of 92-93 % (2.1-2.3 kb) of the APS reductase locus aprBA. PCR-based screening of 116 taxonomically divergent SOP reference strains revealed a distribution of aprBA restricted to photo- and chemotrophs with strict anaerobic or at least facultative anaerobic lifestyles, including Chlorobiaceae, Chromatiaceae, Thiobacillus, Thiothrix and invertebrate symbionts. In the AprBA-based tree, the SOP diverge into two distantly related phylogenetic lineages, Apr lineages I and II, with the proteins of lineage II (Chlorobiaceae and others) in closer affiliation to the enzymes of the sulfate-reducing prokaryotes (SRP). This clustering is discordant with the dissimilatory sulfite reductase (DsrAB) phylogeny and indicates putative lateral aprBA gene transfer from SRP to the respective SOB lineages. In support of lateral gene transfer (LGT), several beta- and gammaproteobacterial species harbour both aprBA homologues, the DsrAB-congruent 'authentic' and the SRP-related, LGT-derived gene loci, while some relatives possess exclusively the SRP-related apr genes as a possible result of resident gene displacement by the xenologue. The two-gene state might be an intermediate in the replacement of the resident essential gene. Collected genome data demonstrate the correlation between the AprBA tree topology and the composition/arrangement of the apr gene loci (occurrence of qmoABC or aprM genes) from SRP and SOP of lineages I and II. The putative functional role of the SRP-related APS reductases in photo- and chemotrophic SOP is discussed.

Transient development of filamentous Thiothrix species in a marine sulfide oxidizing, denitrifying fluidized bed reactor.

In this study, microscopic and molecular microbial analyses were integrated to characterize rapidly developing white filamentous tufts in a fluidized bed reactor used for nitrate removal from a marine recirculating fish culture system. Formation and rapid elongation of the tufts (often exceeding 50 mm day (-1)) was strongly correlated to transient elevated sulfide concentrations (>50 microM) in the reactor. The dominant bacterial constituents of these tufts were filamentous gram-negative bacteria with densely packed intracellular sulfur granules. Using 16S rRNA gene analysis and fluorescence in situ hybridization it was found that these filamentous bacteria represented a novel Thiothrix phylotype closely related (97% sequence identity) to a previously identified Thiothrix strain endogenous to the marine crustacean Urothoe poseidonis. In addition to filamentous morphotypes, rosette-shaped morphotypes of Thiothrix were also detectable within the tufts.