RESUMO
In this study, nine commercial ice creams and four prototypes were assessed. For the sensory analysis, quantitative descriptive analysis (QDA), and temporal dominance of sensations (TDS) methodology were used. According to the QDA results, full-composition ice cream showed significantly higher differences (p < .05) in terms such as vanilla and sweet flavors, brightness, creamy texture and appearance, and viscosity, exhibiting longer melting times. Functional ice creams showed significantly higher differences (p < .05) in terms like viscosity, creamy texture, and appearance. On the other hand, agave fructans in prototype ice creams were found to be able to reduce fat, but not fat and sugar simultaneously, showing a significant decrease (p < .05) in terms such as hardness, crystallized texture, gummy texture, and porosity. Based on the PCA results, the analysis accounted for 75.28% of data variability. Full-composition ice creams and one functional ice cream were related to terms such as viscosity, fatty sensation, creamy texture and appearance, dense, gummy, among others. The rest of the commercial ice creams were related to vanilla and caramel flavor and smell, artificial aftertaste, aerated, porosity, among others. Prototype ice creams were related to hard texture, salty and milk flavor, and crystallized texture. Based on the results of the TDS method, all formulations were found to be significantly dominant (5%) in terms such as vanilla flavor and sweet flavor at the beginning of the test. Formulations containing butyric fat and/or vegetable fat, or agave fructans were significantly dominant (5%) in fatty sensation.
Assuntos
Sorvetes , Paladar , Sorvetes/análise , Viscosidade , Humanos , Aromatizantes , Agave/química , Frutanos/química , Vanilla/químicaRESUMO
Vanilla planifolia is native to the Mexican tropics. Despite its worldwide economic importance as a source of vanilla for flavoring and other uses, almost all vanilla is produced by expensive hand-pollination, and minimal documentation exists for its natural pollination and floral visitors. There is a claim that vanilla is pollinated by Melipona stingless bees, but vanilla is more likely pollinated by orchid bees. Natural pollination has not been tested in the Yucatán region of Mexico, where both vanilla and potential native bee pollinators are endemic. We document for the first time the flowering process, nectar production and natural pollination of V. planiflora, using bagged flower experiments in a commercial planting. We also assessed the frequency and visitation rates of stingless bees and orchid bees on flowers. Our results showed low natural pollination rates of V. planifolia (~ 5%). Only small stingless bees (Trigona fulviventris and Nannotrigona perilampoides) were seen on flowers, but no legitimate visits were witnessed. We verified that there were abundant Euglossa and fewer Eulaema male orchid bees around the vanilla plants, but neither visited the flowers. The introduction of a colony of the stingless bee Melipona beecheii and the application of chemical lures to attract orchid bees failed to induce floral visitations. Melipona beecheii, and male orchid bees of Euglossa viridissima and E. dilemma may not be natural pollinators of vanilla, due to lack of attraction to flowers. It seems that the lack of nectar in V. planifolia flowers reduces the spectrum of potential pollinators. In addition, there may be a mismatch between the attractiveness of vanilla floral fragrances to the species of orchid bees registered in the studied area. Chemical studies with controlled experiments in different regions would be important to further elucidate the potential pollinators of vanilla in southern Mexico.
Assuntos
Flores , Polinização , Vanilla , Animais , Abelhas/fisiologia , México , Flores/fisiologia , Comportamento Animal/fisiologia , Néctar de PlantasRESUMO
The market value of vanilla beans (Vanilla planifolia) is constantly increasing due to their natural aroma and flavor properties that improve after a curing process, where bacteria colonization plays a critical role. However, a few publications suggest that bacteria play a role in the curing process. Hence, this study aimed to isolate Bacillus sp. that could be used for fermenting V. planifolia while analyzing their role in the curing process. Bacillus velezensis ZN-S10 identified with 16S rRNA sequencing was isolated from conventionally cured V. planifolia beans. A bacteria culture solution of B. velezensis ZN-S10 (1 mL of 1 × 107 CFU mL-1) was then coated on 1 kg of non-cured vanilla pods that was found to ferment and colonize vanilla. PCA results revealed distinguished bacterial communities of fermented vanilla and the control group, suggesting colonization of vanilla. Phylogenetic analysis showed that ZN-S10 was the dominant Bacillus genus member and narrowly correlated to B. velezensis EM-1 and B. velezensis PMC206-1, with 78% and 73% similarity, respectively. The bacterial taxonomic profiling of cured V. planifolia had a significant relative abundance of Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, Cyanobacteria, Planctomycetes, and Bacteroidetes phyla according to the predominance. Firmicutes accounted for 55% of the total bacterial sequences, suggesting their colonization and effective fermentation roles in curing vanilla.
Assuntos
Bacillus , Filogenia , RNA Ribossômico 16S , Vanilla , Bacillus/genética , Bacillus/isolamento & purificação , Bacillus/metabolismo , Bacillus/classificação , Vanilla/microbiologia , Vanilla/metabolismo , RNA Ribossômico 16S/genética , Fermentação , Microbiologia de AlimentosRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Rhizosphere bacterial community and endophytes are now known to influence plant health and response to environmental stress. Very few studies have reported the diversity of endophytic bacterial communities of Vanilla planifolia and their potential roles in promoting plant growth or contributing to aromatic quality. RESULTS: In this study, the composition and diversity of the Vanilla rhizosphere bacterial community were explored by analyzing rhizosphere soil and root tissue samples as well as green pods of three accessions of Vanilla planifolia grown on different types of substrates (compost and leaf litter). In addition, the endophytic bacterial diversity of roots and green pods as well as the evolution of endophytic bacteria after the curing process of vanilla green pods were analyzed based on a metabarcoding approach. The results showed that bacterial species richness and diversity were higher in the compost. The analysis of the soil bacterial composition displayed that Halomonas, Pseudoalteromonas, Enterobacter and Bradyrhizobium were the most abundant genera. Moreover, the results indicated that the soil bacterial community structure was linked to the host plant genotype. Regarding the roots endophytic bacteria composition, the genera Halomonas, Pseudoalteromonas, Bacillus and Carboxydocella genera were present in all samples, independently from the substrate nature. Several genera including Bacillus, Bradyrhizobium, Burkholderia and Halomonas were transmitted internally from the roots to the green pods. The curing process reduced the bacterial richness and bacterial diversity associated with the green pods. Halomonas, Pseudoalteromonas, Bacillus, and Carboxydocella are the dominant genera in the pods after the curing process. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides an overview of changes of the bacterial communities dynamics especially endophytic in the roots and the green pods. It highlighted bacterial genera (Halomonas, Pseudoalteromonas, Bacillus, and Carboxydocella) potentially implicated in the formation of aroma compounds of vanilla beans.
Assuntos
Bactérias , Biodiversidade , Endófitos , Raízes de Plantas , Rizosfera , Microbiologia do Solo , Vanilla , Endófitos/classificação , Endófitos/genética , Endófitos/isolamento & purificação , Bactérias/classificação , Bactérias/genética , Bactérias/isolamento & purificação , Raízes de Plantas/microbiologia , Vanilla/microbiologia , RNA Ribossômico 16S/genética , Filogenia , Microbiota/genética , DNA Bacteriano/genéticaRESUMO
The natural vanilla market, which generates millions annually, is predominantly dependent on Vanilla planifolia, a species characterized by low genetic variability and susceptibility to pathogens. There is an increasing demand for natural vanilla, prized for its complex, authentic, and superior quality compared to artificial counterparts. Therefore, there is a necessity for innovative production alternatives to ensure a consistent and stable supply of vanilla flavors. In this context, vanilla crop wild relatives (WRs) emerge as promising natural sources of the spice. However, these novel species must undergo toxicity assessments to evaluate potential risks and ensure safety for consumption. This study aimed to assess the non-mutagenic and non-carcinogenic properties of ethanolic extracts from V. bahiana, V. chamissonis, V. cribbiana, and V. planifolia through integrated metabolomic profiling, in vitro toxicity assays, and in silico analyses. The integrated approach of metabolomics, in vitro assays, and in silico analyses has highlighted the need for further safety assessments of Vanilla cribbiana ethanolic extract. While the extracts of V. bahiana, V. chamissonis, and V. planifolia generally demonstrated non-mutagenic properties in the Ames assay, V. cribbiana exhibited mutagenicity at high concentrations (5000 µg/plate) in the TA98 strain without metabolic activation. This finding, coupled with the dose-dependent cytotoxicity observed in WST-1 (Water Soluble Tetrazolium) assays, a colorimetric method that assesses the viability of cells exposed to a test substance, underscores the importance of concentration in the safety evaluation of these extracts. Kaempferol and pyrogallol, identified with higher intensity in V. cribbiana, are potential candidates for in vitro mutagenicity. Although the results are not conclusive, they suggest the safety of these extracts at low concentrations. This study emphasizes the value of an integrated approach in providing a nuanced understanding of the safety profiles of natural products, advocating for cautious use and further research into V. cribbiana mutagenicity.
Assuntos
Metabolômica , Extratos Vegetais , Vanilla , Extratos Vegetais/química , Extratos Vegetais/toxicidade , Brasil , Vanilla/química , Humanos , Florestas , Salmonella typhimurium/efeitos dos fármacos , Salmonella typhimurium/genética , Testes de Mutagenicidade , Simulação por ComputadorRESUMO
Despite being the second largest family of flowering plants, orchids represent community structure variation in plant-microbial associations, contributes to niche partitioning in metacommunity assemblages. Yet, mycorrhizal communities and interactions remain unknown for orchids that are highly specialized or even obligated in their associations with their mycorrhizal partners. In this study, we sought to compare orchid mycorrhizal fungal (OMF) communities of three co-occurring hemiepiphytic Vanilla species (V. hartii, V. pompona, and V. trigonocarpa) in tropical forests of Costa Rica by addressing the identity of their OMF communities across species, root types, and populations, using high-throughput sequencing. Sequencing the nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer (nrITS) yielded 299 fungal Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs) from 193 root samples. We showed distinct segregation in the putative OMF (pOMF) communities of the three coexisting Vanilla hosts. We also found that mycorrhizal communities associated with the rare V. hartii varied among populations. Furthermore, we identified Tulasnellaceae and Ceratobasidiaceae as dominant pOMF families in terrestrial roots of the three Vanilla species. In contrast, the epiphytic roots were mainly dominated by OTUs belonging to the Atractiellales and Serendipitaceae. Furthermore, the pOMF communities differed significantly across populations of the widespread V. trigonocarpa and showed patterns of distance decay in similarity. This is the first report of different pOMF communities detected in roots of wild co-occurring Vanilla species using high-throughput sequencing, which provides evidence that three coexisting Vanilla species and their root types exhibited pOMF niche partitioning, and that the rare and widespread Vanilla hosts displayed diverse mycorrhizal preferences.
Assuntos
Micorrizas , Orchidaceae , Raízes de Plantas , Vanilla , Micorrizas/classificação , Micorrizas/genética , Micorrizas/fisiologia , Costa Rica , Orchidaceae/microbiologia , Raízes de Plantas/microbiologia , Vanilla/microbiologia , Micobioma , FilogeniaRESUMO
Vanilla production in Guadeloupe is expanding. The main species grown is Vanilla planifolia, but other species such as Vanilla pompona are also present and required by industries. To upgrade the value of vanilla production on this Caribbean Island, this study was performed to evaluate the aromatic specifies of these vanilla species according to the length of the post-harvest period (2 months and 9 months). For this purpose, Vanilla planifolia and Vanilla pompona were compared through scald and scarification transformation processes, as well as two different refining times (T1 and T2). For chemical characterization, 0.1 g of vanilla bean seeds was used for SMPE/GC-MS measurements, while 0.05 g of vanilla samples was subjected to infusion in milk (0.15%) for sensory evaluation. The latter involved generation of terms of aroma through olfaction and gustation sessions. The chemical results showed a significant difference between the two species, where vanillin was mostly present in Vanilla planifolia, unlike Vanilla pompona, where it was mainly rich in 4-methoxybenzyl alcohol. Interestingly, the second refining time was characterized by the appearance of two major components, 1,3-octadien and acetic acid. For sensory analysis, all the vanillas exhibited a high diversity of aromas including "sweet", "gourmand", "spicy" flavors and so on. The application of factorial correspondence analysis (FAC) as well as the agglomerative hierarchical clustering (AHC) showed differences between the vanilla samples according to both the species and refining time. The combination of these analyses makes it possible to establish a chemical and organoleptic profile of vanillas. Varietal and processing factors both have a major impact on the aroma profile of vanillas.
Assuntos
Vanilla , Vanilla/química , Sensação , Paladar , Olfato , Cromatografia Gasosa-Espectrometria de MassasRESUMO
The cultivation of vanilla (Vanilla planifolia) is of economic interest because vanillin is extracted from the fruits of this species. Vanillin is a natural flavoring highly valued in the food market. However, there is a short supply of propagules available for establishing commercial plantations and good-quality plants with phytosanitary certification. Plant tissue culture represents a viable option to supply large amounts of healthy plants to vanilla producers. In addition, the use of temporary immersion systems will allow commercial scale-up and the establishment of biofactories dedicated to in vitro vanilla propagation. This chapter describes a large-scale micropropagation protocol for vanilla using temporary immersion bioreactors (TIB).
Assuntos
Benzaldeídos , Vanilla , Imersão , Reatores Biológicos , FrutasRESUMO
Targeting bioactive compounds to prevent lipid droplet accumulation in the liver, we explored an antioxidative extract from vanilla bean (Vainilla planifolia) after chemo-selective derivatization through heating and acid modification. The chemical analysis of vanilla bean extract through chemoselective derivatization resulted in the identification of sixteen compounds (34-50) using LC-MS/MS analysis. A ß-carboline alkaloid with a piperidine C-ring and a vanillin moiety at C-1 (34) was identified by molecular networking and diagnostic fragmentation filtering approaches. ß-carboline alkaloid 34 exhibited significant inhibitory activity of lipid droplet accumulation (LDAI) in oleic acid-loaded hepatocellular carcinoma HepG2 cells. The LDAI activity was associated with both activation of lipolysis and suppression of lipogenesis in the cells. The study indicates that crude plant extracts, following chemoselective derivatization, may contain bioactive compounds that could be beneficial in preventing hepatosteatosis and could serve as a source of lead compounds for drug development. This approach may be useful to investigate other mixtures of natural products and food resources.
Assuntos
Alcaloides , Vanilla , Humanos , Vanilla/química , Cromatografia Líquida , Gotículas Lipídicas , Espectrometria de Massas em Tandem , Alcaloides/farmacologia , Extratos Vegetais/farmacologia , Extratos Vegetais/química , Células Hep G2 , Carbolinas/farmacologiaRESUMO
The first record of Vanilla labellopapillata is presented for the state of Amazonas, Brazil, in the region of Manaus, now the western limit of the species, which was previously known only from the type locality in the state of Pará. A brief description is provided and taxonomic and ecological aspects of the species are discussed in the light of this new finding. (AU)
Assuntos
Florestas , Classificação , Ecossistema Amazônico , VanillaRESUMO
Introducción: La vainilla (Vanilla planifolia Andrews) es una planta CAM de gran importancia económica en el mercado mundial de saborizantes y aromatizantes. Por ser una planta hemiepífita que inicialmente crece en el sotobosque sombreado y posteriormente asciende hasta el dosel, se aclimata a diferentes condiciones de radiación y humedad. La posibilidad de extender su cultivo a zonas secas donde sea menor la incidencia de enfermedades, dependerá de su respuesta a períodos prolongados de sequía. Objetivo: Evaluar los efectos de la interacción entre la radiación y la humedad sobre los parámetros de la fotosíntesis y funcionamiento del CAM de plantas de vainilla en sus fases iniciales de desarrollo vegetativo, y determinar si las condiciones de radiación en las que crece la planta pueden ayudar a moderar los efectos negativos de la sequía. Métodos: Se evaluaron plantas de vainilla que crecieron con riego durante 18 meses en casetas con iluminación relativa (IR) de 8, 17, 31 y 67 %; posteriormente se suspendió el riego y se fueron deshidratando durante 94 días hasta alcanzar un contenido de humedad crítico (contenido hídrico relativo, CHR ≤ 50 %), y finalmente se reinició el riego durante 22 días; se evaluó el efecto de estos procesos sobre la asimilación de CO2, la acidez titulable y la eficiencia cuántica del Fotosistema II (Fv/Fm). Resultados: Bajo condiciones intermedias de IR (17 % y 31 %), la asimilación de CO2 y laacumulación nocturna de ácidos orgánicos presentaron la menor afectación por el déficit hídrico, así como la mejor recuperación luego de la rehidratación. El CHR se vio más afectado por la disponibilidad de agua en el tejido vegetal, mientras que Fv/Fm lo fue por el ambiente de radiación. Los efectos combinados de estrés hídrico y alta radiación ocasionaron daños irreversibles en la fotosíntesis para el tratamiento de IR de 67 %. Conclusiones: En las plantas de vainilla, el impacto negativo de la sequía sobre los parámetros de la fotosíntesis fue mayor en alta radiación; sin embargo, en condiciones de baja radiación también aumentó la susceptibilidad de las plantas a la sequía, en comparación con los ambientes de radiación intermedia, en los cuales la densidad de flujo de fotones media fue de 340 μmol m-2 seg-1 (17 % de IR) y 620 μmol m-2 seg-1 (31 % de IR). Estos resultados sugieren el potencial de cultivar vainilla en zonas con sequía estacional bajo sistemas productivos de baja tecnificación, manteniendo estas condiciones de radiación.
Introduction: Vanilla planifolia Andrews is a CAM plant of economic importance in the global market of flavorings and essences. Being a hemiepiphyte which initially grows in the shady understory and later climbs to the canopy, it acclimates to different conditions of radiation and humidity. The possibility of extending this crop to dry areas where the incidence of diseases is lower will depend on the response to prolonged periods of drought. Objective: To evaluate the effects of the interaction of radiation and humidity on the parameters of photosynthesis and operation of CAM of vanilla plants, and to determine if the radiation environment could help to moderate the negative effects of drought. Methods: We evaluated well-watered vanilla plants grown for 18 months in relative illumination (RI) of 8, 17, 31 and 67 %, which underwent dehydration for 94 days until reaching critical water content (relative water content, RWC < 50 %) and then rehydration for 22 days; variables evaluated were: CO2 assimilation, titratable acidity, and quantum efficiency of Photosystem II (Fv / Fm). Results: Under intermediate conditions of radiation (17 % and 31 % RI), CO2 assimilation and nocturnal accumulation of organic acids were less affected by water deficit and also showed the best recovery after rehydration. The RWC was most affected by the water available in plant tissue, while Fv / Fm was affected by radiation. The combined effects of water stress and high radiation caused irreversible damage to photosynthesis for the 67 % RI treatment. Conclusions: In vanilla plants, the negative impact of drought on photosynthetic parameters was greater in high radiation; however, in low radiation conditions the susceptibility of plants to drought also increased, as compared to intermediate radiation environments, which were under a mean photon flux density of 340 µmol m-2 s-1 (17 % IR) and 620 µmol m-2 s-1 (31 % IR). These results suggest the potential for growing vanilla in areas with seasonal drought under low-tech production systems, maintaining these radiation conditions.
Assuntos
Fotossíntese , Vanilla/crescimento & desenvolvimento , Clorofila , Colômbia , Índices de SecaRESUMO
ResumenLos especímenes silvestres de Vanilla planifolia G. Jack forman parte del acervo genético primario, los cuales solo se han reportado en Oaxaca, México. Por ello se evaluó la distribución de esta especie con el objetivo de ubicar y describir características ecológicas en zonas potenciales de distribución. La metodología empleada consistió de cuatro etapas: 1) Elaboración de una base de datos con registros de herbario;2) Construcción de la distribución potencial basado en los registros históricos de herbario para la especie, mediante el modelo de máxima entropía (Maxent), con el uso de 22 variables bioclimáticas como predictoras; 3) Realización de búsquedas sistemáticas de individuos in situ con base en los registros de herbario y las áreas de distribución potencial en 24 municipios, para conocer la situación y la distribución del hábitat actual, y 4) Descripción mediante factores ambientales de los nichos ecológicos potenciales generados por MaxEnt. La revisión de las colecciones de herbarios reportó un total de 18 registros de V. planifolia, comprendidos entre 1939 y 1998.La búsqueda sistemática de individuos en campo ubicó 28 plantas distribuidas en 12 sitios sobre 95 364 Km2. Las variables que contribuyeron con mayor valor porcentual para determinar la estimación del modelo de distribución potencial en vainilla son precipitación del periodo más lluvioso (61.9 %), régimen de humedad del suelo (23.4 %) y precipitación del cuatrimestre más lluvioso (8.1 %). El hábitat potencial de la especie se distribuyó en cuatro zonas; trópico húmedo del golfo de México, templado húmedo, trópico húmedo y templado húmedo del pacifico. La precipitación anual osciló de 2 500 a 4 000 mm, con lluvias en verano y porcentaje de precipitación invernal de 5 a 10 %. El régimen de humedad y clima predominantes fueron údico tipo I (330 a 365 días de humedad) y cálido húmedo (Am/A(C) m). Las plantas se ubicaron en altitudes de 200 a 1 190 msnm, en laderas accidentadas, que por lo general están al pie de sistemas montañosos de 1 300 a 2 500 metros de altitud. En condiciones naturales la distribución de la especie no se limita a selva alta perennifolia, dado que se ubicó en bosque mesófilo de montaña y bosque tropical perennifolio. La ubicación de nuevos especímenes de V. planifolia en condiciones silvestres reduce un 66 % del área potencial de distribución, y la fragmenta, al pasar de ser una zona continua a convertirse en tres zonas geográficamente separadas. La reducción del hábitat se debió a un aumento en el número de plantas ubicadas, lo que define las condiciones ambientales a un nivel más exacto. Por lo anterior, se pueden emprender o diseñar acciones de conservación enfocadas a áreas más específicas dentro del estado de Oaxaca, México.
AbstractWild specimens of Vanilla planifolia represent a vital part of this resource primary gene pool, and some plants have only been reported in Oaxaca, Mexico. For this reason, we studied its geographical distribution within the state, to locate and describe the ecological characteristics of the areas where they have been found, in order to identify potential areas of establishment. The method comprised four stages: 1) the creation of a database with herbarium records, 2) the construction of the potential distribution based on historical herbarium records for the species, using the model of maximum entropy (MaxEnt) and 22 bioclimatic variables as predictors; 3) an in situ systematic search of individuals, based on herbarium records and areas of potential distribution in 24 municipalities, to determine the habitat current situation and distribution; 4) the description of the environmental factors of potential ecological niches generated by MaxEnt. A review of herbarium collections revealed a total of 18 records of V. planifolia between 1939 and 1998. The systematic search located 28 plants distributed in 12 sites in 95 364 Km2. The most important variables that determined the model of vanilla potential distribution were: precipitation in the rainy season (61.9 %), soil moisture regime (23.4 %) and precipitation during the four months of highest rainfall (8.1 %). The species potential habitat was found to be distributed in four zones: wet tropics of the Gulf of Mexico, humid temperate, humid tropical, and humid temperate in the Pacific. Precipitation oscillated within the annual ranges of 2 500 to 4 000 mm, with summer rains, and winter precipitation as 5 to 10 % of the total. The moisture regime and predominating climate were udic type I (330 to 365 days of moisture) and hot humid (Am/A(C) m). The plants were located at altitudes of 200 to 1 190 masl, on rough hillsides that generally make up the foothills of mountain systems, with altitudes of 1 300 to 2 500 masl. In natural conditions, distribution of the species is not limited to high evergreen forests, since it was also found in mountain mesophyll and tropical evergreen forests. The location of new specimens of V. planifolia in its wild condition reduces the potential distribution area by 66 %. This area is fragmented into three geographically separated areas. Habitat reduction was due to the increased number of located plants that define the environmental conditions into a more accurate level. Conservation actions can thus be designed and implemented, focusing on more specific areas within the state of Oaxaca, Mexico.
Assuntos
Vanilla/classificação , Estações do Ano , Biodiversidade , Geografia , MéxicoRESUMO
This review aims at providing an overview on the microbial production of vanillin, a new alternative method for the production of this important flavor of the food industry, which has the potential to become economically competitive in the next future. After a brief description of the applications of vanillin in different industrial sectors and of its physicochemical properties, we described the traditional ways of providing vanillin, specifically extraction and chemical synthesis (mainly oxidation) and compared them with the new biotechnological options, i.e., biotransformations of caffeic acid, veratraldehyde and mainly ferulic acid. In the second part of the review, emphasis has been addressed to the factors most influencing the bioproduction of vanillin, specifically the age of inoculum, pH, temperature, type of co-substrate, as well as the inhibitory effects exerted either by excess substrate or product. The final part of the work summarized the downstream processes and the related unit operations involved in the recovery of vanillin from the bioconversion medium.