Female epispadias management: perineal urethrocervicoplasty versus classical Young-Dees procedure.

ABSTRACT

PURPOSE: We compared the functional results of 1-stage perineal urethrocervicoplasty and vulvoplasty vs the classic Young-Dees procedure for incontinent female epispadias. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We treated 14 female patients with incontinent epispadias between 1997 and 2007, of whom 7 each underwent the Young-Dees procedure until 2004 (group 1) and 1-stage urethrocervicoplasty with vulvoplasty through a perineal subsymphyseal approach (group 2). We retrospectively compared patient age at surgery, bladder capacity, continence outcome and postoperative morbidity. RESULTS: The groups were comparable except for age at procedure. In group 1 vs 2 surgery was performed at a median age of 6 vs 4 years. In groups 1 and 2 median preoperative bladder capacity was 120 and 100 cc, and mean followup was 8 and 2.5 years, respectively. Six group 1 patients achieved continence, including 5 with overnight continence, but 5 required additional surgery to enhance continence or voiding, including pericervical injections of bulking agents (3), cervicotomy or urethral calibration (4) and enterocystoplasty (1). Two patients required long-term clean intermittent catheterization, 4 underwent upper tract dilation postoperatively and 4 had a total of 8 episodes of febrile urinary tract infection. Six group 2 patients were continent, including 3 with overnight continence (p = 1). None required clean intermittent catheterization even temporarily or any additional surgery (p = 0.02). Only 2 patients had a febrile urinary tract infection (p = 0.25). CONCLUSIONS: Reconstructing the bladder neck and urethra via a perineal approach for female epispadias is promising. Surgery may be performed earlier with similar continence results, less postoperative morbidity and less need for additional surgery. Long-term studies are needed to confirm these preliminary results.