Multimodal assessment of early tumor response to chemotherapy: comparison between diffusion-weighted MRI, 1H-MR spectroscopy of choline and USPIO particles targeted at cell death.

ABSTRACT

The aim of this study was to determine the value of different magnetic resonance (MR) protocols to assess early tumor response to chemotherapy. We used a murine tumor model (TLT) presenting different degrees of response to three different cytotoxic agents. As shown in survival curves, cyclophosphamide (CP) was the most efficient drug followed by 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), whereas the etoposide treatment had little impact on TLT tumors. Three different MR protocols were used at 9.4 Tesla 24 h post-treatment diffusion-weighted (DW)-MRI, choline measurement by (1) H MRS, and contrast-enhanced MRI using ultrasmall iron oxide nanoparticles (USPIO) targeted at phosphatidylserine. Accumulation of contrast agent in apoptotic tumors was monitored by T(2) -weighted images and quantified by EPR spectroscopy. Necrosis and apoptosis were assessed by histology. Large variations were observed in the measurement of choline peak areas and could not be directly correlated to tumor response. Although the targeted USPIO particles were able to significantly differentiate between the efficiency of each cytotoxic agent and best correlated with survival endpoint, they present the main disadvantage of non-specific tumor accumulation, which could be problematic when transferring the method to the clinic. DW-MRI presents a better compromise by combining longitudinal studies with a high dynamic range; however, DW-MRI was unable to show any significant effect for 5-FU. This study illustrates the need for multimodal imaging in assessing tumor response to treatment to compensate for individual limitations.