Vaccine effectiveness against emerging COVID-19 variants using digital health data.

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Participatory surveillance of self-reported symptoms and vaccination status can be used to supplement traditional public health surveillance and provide insights into vaccine effectiveness and changes in the symptoms produced by an infectious disease. The University of Maryland COVID Trends and Impact Survey provides an example of participatory surveillance that leveraged Facebook's active user base to provide self-reported symptom and vaccination data in near real-time. METHODS: Here, we develop a methodology for identifying changes in vaccine effectiveness and COVID-19 symptomatology using the University of Maryland COVID Trends and Impact Survey data from three middle-income countries (Guatemala, Mexico, and South Africa). We implement conditional logistic regression to develop estimates of vaccine effectiveness conditioned on the prevalence of various definitions of self-reported COVID-like illness in lieu of confirmed diagnostic test results. RESULTS: We highlight a reduction in vaccine effectiveness during Omicron-dominated waves of infections when compared to periods dominated by the Delta variant (median change across COVID-like illness definitions -0.40, IQR[-0.45, -0.35]. Further, we identify a shift in COVID-19 symptomatology towards upper respiratory type symptoms (i.e., cough and sore throat) during Omicron periods of infections. Stratifying COVID-like illness by the National Institutes of Health's (NIH) description of mild and severe COVID-19 symptoms reveals a similar level of vaccine protection across different levels of COVID-19 severity during the Omicron period. CONCLUSIONS: Participatory surveillance data alongside methodologies described in this study are particularly useful for resource-constrained settings where diagnostic testing results may be delayed or limited.

Surveys that are sent out to users of social media can be used to supplement traditional methods to monitor the spread of infectious diseases. This has the potential to be particularly useful in areas where other data is unavailable, such as areas with less surveillance of infectious disease prevalence and access to infectious disease diagnostics. We used data from a survey available to users of the social media platform Facebook to collect information about any potential symptoms of COVID-19 infection and vaccines received during the COVID-19 pandemic. We found a potential reduction in vaccine effectiveness and change in symptoms when the Omicron variant was known to be circulating compared to the earlier Delta variant. This method could be adapted to monitor the spread of COVID-19 and other infectious diseases in the future, which might enable the impact of infectious diseases to be recognized more quickly.