Comparison of the effects of phenylephrine and norepinephrine in patients with restrictive transfusion / 中国基层医药

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare the effects of phenylephrine and norepinephrine in patients with restrictive transfusion.Methods 65 patients undergoing laparoscopic resection of rectal cancer were selected.According to the random number table method,the patients were randomly divided into 32 cases of observation group (phenylephrine composite restriction infusion) and 33 cases of control group(norepinephrine combined restrictive transfusion).The operation and hemodynamics of the two groups at different time points were compared.At T0,T1,T2,the central venous blood and arterial blood were collected,the central venous blood saturation (ScvO2),arterial blood lactate (Lac),central venous oxygen partial pressure (PcvO2),PaO2,Hb concentrations,venous oxygen content (CcvO2),arterial oxygen content(CaO2),arteriovenous oxygen content difference (Ca-cvO2) and oxygen uptake rate (ERO2) were compared between the two groups.Results The ASA levels (Ⅰ / Ⅱ grade) of the observation group and the control group were 11 cases/21 cases and 13 cases/20 cases,respectively,the difference was not statistically significant(x2 =5.298,P =0.052).The BMI of the observation group and the control group were (20.61 ± 1.65) kg/m2,(21.57 ± 1.42) kg/m2,respectively,the difference was not statistically significant (t =0.652,P =1.980).The fluid replacement of the observation group and the control group were (1 162 ± 113) mL,(1171 ± 104) mL,respectively,the difference was not statistically significant (t =1.734,P =0.065).The blood loss of the observation group and the control group were (276 ± 41) mL,(294 ± 42) mL,respectively,the difference was not statistically significant (t =0.083,P =1.023).The urine volume of the observation group and the control group were (524 ± 113) mL,(532 ± 109) mL,respectively,the difference was not statistically significant(t =1.834,P =0.053).The operation time of the observation group and the control group were (192 ± 24) min,(197 ± 21) min,respectively,the difference was not statistically significant(t =1.367,P =0.073).The MAP at T1-T2 of the two groups increased,the CVP of the two groups was significantly higher at T1,the HR of the two groups was significantly higher at T2.The MAP,CVP,HR between the two groups had no significant differences (all P ＞ 0.05).The levels of ScvO2,PcvO2 and PaO2 at T1 were significantly higher than those at T0,on the contrary,the levels of ScvO2,PcvO2 and PaO2 at T2 were significantly lower than those at T0,and the Hb in the observation group was significantly lower at T1-T2,the Hb in the control group was significantly lower at T,-T2,which in the observation group was lower than the control group,the differences were statistically significant(all P ＜ 0.05).There was no statistically significant difference in Lac between the two groups (P ＞ 0.05).There were statistically significant differences in CcvO2,CaO2,Ca-cvO2 and ERO2 between the two groups at different time points (all P ＜ 0.05).Conclusion Phenylephrine is more effective than norepinephrine in limiting infusion in elderly patients,and it has more obvious effects on tissue oxygen metabolism.