Spatially resolved diagnostics for optimization of large ion beam sources.

Giant negative ion sources for neutral beam injectors deliver huge negative ion currents, thanks to their multi-beamlet configuration. As the single-beamlet optics defines the transmission losses along the beamline, the extraction of a similar current for all beamlets is extremely desirable, in order to facilitate the beam source operation (i.e., around perveance match). This Review investigates the correlation between the vertical profile of beam intensity and the vertical profiles of plasma properties at the extraction region of the source, focusing on the influence of increasing cesium injection. Only by the combined use of all available source diagnostics, described in this Review, can beam features on the scale of the non-uniformities be investigated with a sufficient space resolution. At RF power of 50 kW/driver, with intermediate bias currents and a filter field of 2.4 mT, it is found that the central part of the four vertical beam segments exhibits comparable plasma density and beamlet currents; at the edges of the central segments, both the beam and electron density appear to decrease (probably maintaining fixed electron-to-ion ratio); at the bottom of the source, an increase of cesium injection can compensate for the vertical drifts that cause a much higher presence of electrons and a lower amount of negative ions.

Development and first operation of a cavity ring down spectroscopy diagnostic in the negative ion source SPIDER.

The neutral beam injectors of the ITER experiment will rely on negative ion sources to produce 16.7 MW beams of H/D particles accelerated at 1 MeV. The prototype of these sources was built and is currently operated in the SPIDER (Source for the Production of Ions of Deuterium Extracted from a Radio frequency plasma) experiment, part of the Neutral Beam Test Facility of Consorzio RFX, Padua. In the SPIDER, the H-/D- ion source is coupled to a three grid, 100 kV acceleration system. One of the main goals of the experimentation in SPIDER is to uniformly maximize the extracted current density; to achieve this, it is important to study the density of negative ions available in the proximity of the ion acceleration system. In SPIDER, line-integrated measurements of negative ion density are performed by a cavity ring down spectroscopy diagnostic. Its principle of operation is based on the absorption of the photons of a laser beam pulse by H-/D- photo-detachment; the absorption detection is enhanced by trapping the laser pulse in an optical cavity, containing the absorbing medium (i.e., negative ions). This paper presents and discusses the CRDS diagnostic setup in the SPIDER, including the first measurements of negative ion density, correlated with the main source parameters.

Visible cameras as a non-invasive diagnostic to study negative ion beam properties.

Beam tomography is a non-invasive diagnostic that allows us to reconstruct the beam emission profile by measuring the light emitted by the beam particles interacting with the background gas, along an elevated number of lines of sight, which is related to the beam density by assuming a uniform background gas. In the framework of the heating and current drive of future nuclear fusion reactors, negative ion beams of hydrogen and deuterium are required for neutral beam injectors (NBIs) due to their elevated neutralization efficiency at high energy (in the MeV range). Beside the beam energy, beam divergence and homogeneity are two critical aspects in the design of future NBIs. In this paper, the characterization of the negative ion beam of the negative ion source NIO1 (a small-sized radio-frequency driven negative ion source, with 130 mA of total extracted H- current and 60 kV of maximum acceleration) using the tomographic system composed of two visible cameras is presented. The Simultaneous Algebraic Reconstruction Technique (SART) is used as an inversion technique to reconstruct the 3 × 3 matrix of the extracted beamlets, and the beam divergence and homogeneity are studied. The results are compared with the measurements of the other diagnostics and correlated with the source physics. The suitability of visible cameras as a diagnostics system for the characterization of the NIO1 negative ion beam is a small-scale experimental demonstration of the possibility to reconstruct more complicated multi-beamlet profiles, resulting in a powerful diagnostic for large NBIs.

Analysis of current-voltage characteristics for Langmuir probes immersed in an ion beam.

Movable electrical probes were used to diagnose the beam flux profile and potential of ion beams since the early 1960s. Experimental measurements of beam plasmas can provide essential data related to the space charge neutralization, but the current-voltage characteristics obtained from such electrical probes are dominated by beam ion impact and ion-induced secondary emission. In this work, we present an analysis of the Langmuir characteristics obtained in a negative ion beam. We identify and discuss separately the contributions to the collected current given by secondary plasma ions and electrons, stripped electrons, beam ions, and ion-induced secondary electron emission. We present the beam plasma parameters obtained at different beam energies in NIO1.

Interpreting the dynamic equilibrium during evaporation in a cesium environment.

The cesium ovens for the prototype source of the ITER neutral beam injectors are currently tested in the CAesium Test Stand (CATS) facility, with a background pressure of 10-6 mbar. Different diagnostics are here installed: two Langmuir-Taylor detectors allow us to determine the Cs vapour evaporation rate from the oven and the Cs density at different positions in the vacuum chamber; and laser absorption spectroscopy is used to measure the density integrated over a line of sight and a quartz crystal microbalance to detect the cesium mass deposited in time over a surface. In this paper, we present a model to describe the dynamic equilibrium in the evaporation chamber of CATS with the first oven tested in order to gain information about the Cs sticking coefficient at the walls. The model hence includes sticking and energy accommodation of the Cs atoms to the walls, calculates the flux density at the surfaces, and provides the Cs atom density at any location in the volume. By this model, we simulate the Cs evaporation and the equilibrium density, comparing the modeled results with the experimental data. As a result, a sticking coefficient of 2% is obtained.

Beam energy recovery for fusion and collector design for tests on compact sources.

The next fusion project DEMO, which will be the evolution of the experimental fusion reactor [International Tokamak Experimental Reactor (ITER)], would require a high efficient energy production. As in ITER, DEMO will use fast Neutral Beam (NB) injectors to increase the plasma temperature needed for the fusion reaction. A way to recover the electric energy production efficiency in DEMO could be the beam energy recovery in the NB production, which is produced by a D- beam, neutralized by a gas cell with 60% efficiency. A compact energy recovery device with an axisymmetric cylindrical ion collector that uses only decelerating electric fields combined with the beam space charge effect has been recently proposed. It can be used for a test on the beam of the NIO1 (Negative Ion Optimization 1) source, a compact ion source (scaled down from ITER size sources) that has been developed at INFN-LNL and Consorzio RFX (Padua). The detailed collector design to be used on one of the beamlets of the NIO1 source within typical space limitation is presented and discussed here. Furthermore, a preliminary trajectory simulation for a beam with a rectangular geometry similar to the beam used in ITER to verify the beam recovery for a nonaxial symmetric geometry is also shown.

Simulation of the gas density distribution in the accelerator of the ELISE test facility.

In multiaperture electrostatic accelerators of negative ion sources, the plasma discharge is sustained by injecting gas in the plasma source, in a dynamic equilibrium with the gas flowing out through the accelerator. In this work, we present a three-dimensional numerical simulation of the gas flow inside the accelerator system of the large negative ion source ELISE at Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik Garching. ELISE has 640 apertures per electrode and lateral gaps between the electrode support structures that also contribute to the total gas conductance. Assuming molecular regime, we estimated the gas conductance, the gas density profile along the path of the ion beams from upstream of the plasma grid to downstream of the ground grid, and the transverse nonuniformities in the accelerator. The simulation included the most relevant geometrical features, while the results are compared to analytical results.

CRISP: A compact RF ion source prototype for emittance scanner testing.

A movable Allison type emittance scanner is being developed to characterize the phase-space distribution of the beamlets of spectral phase interferometry for direct electric-field reconstruction, the prototype RF negative ion source of the ITER heating neutral beam injector. To test the electronics and verify the capability of the device to resolve nearby beamlets, a compact RF ion source prototype has been set up, capable of accelerating 1 mA of helium ions up to a voltage of 2 kV. A commercial 100 W RF generator creates a plasma inside a Pyrex tube, with a density between 1015 and 1016 m-3 and an electron temperature up to 15 eV. Three multi-aperture grids in accel-decel configuration extract and accelerate the ions, which are measured with a Faraday cup. We present in this paper the characterization of the ion source and its first operation, showing that it is suitable for the commissioning of the Allison scanner.

Beamlet scraping and its influence on the beam divergence at the BATMAN Upgrade test facility.

For the ITER fusion experiment, two neutral beam injectors are required for plasma heating and current drive. Each injector supplies a power of about 17 MW, obtained from neutralization of 40 A (46 A), 1 MeV (0.87 MeV) negative deuterium (hydrogen) ions. The full beam is composed of 1280 beamlets, formed in 16 beamlet groups, and strict requirements apply to the beamlet core divergence (<7 mrad). The test facility BATMAN Upgrade uses an ITER-like grid with one beamlet group, which consists of 70 apertures. In a joint campaign performed by IPP and Consorzio RFX to better assess the beam optics, the divergence of a single beamlet was compared to a group of beamlets at BATMAN Upgrade. The single beamlet is measured with a carbon fiber composite tile calorimeter and by beam emission spectroscopy, whereas the divergence of the group of beamlets is measured by beam emission spectroscopy only. When increasing the RF power at low extraction voltages, the divergence of the beamlet and of the group of beamlets is continuously decreasing and no inflection point toward an overperveant beam is found. At the same time, scraping of the extracted ion beam at the second grid (extraction grid) takes place at higher RF power, supported by the absence of the normally seen linear behavior between the measured negative ion density in the plasma close to the extraction system and the measured extracted ion current. Beside its influence on the divergence, beamlet scraping needs to be considered for the determination of the correct perveance and contributes to the measured coextracted electron current.

Beam and installation improvements of the NIO1 ion source.

The NIO1 (Negative Ion Optimization phase 1) source can provide continuous beam operation, which is convenient for systematic parameter and equipment studies. Even in the pure volume production regime, the source yield was found to depend on conditioning procedures. Magnetic configuration tests continued adding magnets to the existing setup; the filter field component Bx has been progressively extended to span the -12 to 5 mT range, and as a trend, source performances improved with |Bx|. The progress of camera beam diagnostics and of the quality of the volume-produced H- beam is also shown. The status, off-line results, and reliability of a first NIO1 cesium oven are discussed; other upgrades in preparation (cavity ring down spectrometer, the end calorimeter, and conceptual tests of the energy recovery system) are also listed.

First operation in SPIDER and the path to complete MITICA.

The requirements of ITER neutral beam injectors (1 MeV, 40 A negative deuterium ion current for 1 h) have never been simultaneously attained; therefore, a dedicated Neutral Beam Test Facility (NBTF) was set up at Consorzio RFX (Padova, Italy). The NBTF includes two experiments: SPIDER (Source for the Production of Ions of Deuterium Extracted from Rf plasma), the full-scale prototype of the source of ITER injectors, with a 100 keV accelerator, to investigate and optimize the properties of the ion source; and MITICA, the full-scale prototype of the entire injector, devoted to the issues related to the accelerator, including voltage holding at low gas pressure. The present paper gives an account of the status of the procurements, of the timeline, and of the voltage holding tests and experiments for MITICA. As for SPIDER, the first year of operation is described, regarding the solution of some issues connected with the radiofrequency power, the source operation, and the characterization of the first negative ion beam.

Simulation of diatomic gas-wall interaction and accommodation coefficients for negative ion sources and accelerators.

Particle-wall interactions determine in different ways the operating conditions of plasma sources, ion accelerators, and beams operating in vacuum. For instance, a contribution to gas heating is given by ion neutralization at walls; beam losses and stray particle production-detrimental for high current negative ion systems such as beam sources for fusion-are caused by collisional processes with residual gas, with the gas density profile that is determined by the scattering of neutral particles at the walls. This paper shows that Molecular Dynamics (MD) studies at the nano-scale can provide accommodation parameters for gas-wall interactions, such as the momentum accommodation coefficient and energy accommodation coefficient: in non-isothermal flows (such as the neutral gas in the accelerator, coming from the plasma source), these affect the gas density gradients and influence efficiency and losses in particular of negative ion accelerators. For ideal surfaces, the computation also provides the angular distribution of scattered particles. Classical MD method has been applied to the case of diatomic hydrogen molecules. Single collision events, against a frozen wall or a fully thermal lattice, have been simulated by using probe molecules. Different modelling approximations are compared.

Background gas density and beam losses in NIO1 beam source.

NIO1 (Negative Ion Optimization 1) is a versatile ion source designed to study the physics of production and acceleration of H- beams up to 60 keV. In ion sources, the gas is steadily injected in the plasma source to sustain the discharge, while high vacuum is maintained by a dedicated pumping system located in the vessel. In this paper, the three dimensional gas flow in NIO1 is studied in the molecular flow regime by the Avocado code. The analysis of the gas density profile along the accelerator considers the influence of effective gas temperature in the source, of the gas temperature accommodation by collisions at walls, and of the gas particle mass. The calculated source and vessel pressures are compared with experimental measurements in NIO1 during steady gas injection.

Particle transport and heat loads in NIO1.

NIO1 is a compact radio frequency ion source designed to generate a 60 kV-135 mA hydrogen negative ion beam and it aims at continuous operation, which implies a detailed thermo-mechanical analysis of the beam-facing components, in particular, the accelerator grids. A 3D analysis of the entire NIO1 beam has been performed for the first time with a fully 3D version of EAMCC, a relativistic particle tracking code for the calculation of the grid power deposition induced by particle impacts. According to the results presented in this paper, secondary and co-extracted electrons cause a non-negligible heat load on the grids, where different high-power density regions, within reasonable sustainable standard limits, are calculated.

Multi-beamlet investigation of the deflection compensation methods of SPIDER beamlets.

SPIDER (Source for Production of Ions of Deuterium Extracted from a Rf plasma) is an ion source test bed designed to extract and accelerate a negative ion current up to 40 A and 100 kV whose first beam is expected by the end of 2016. Two main effects perturb beamlet optics during the acceleration stage: space charge repulsion and the deflection induced by the permanent magnets (called co-extracted electron suppression magnets) embedded in the EG. The purpose of this work is to evaluate and compare benefits, collateral effects, and limitations of electrical and magnetic compensation methods for beamlet deflection. The study of these methods has been carried out by means of numerical modeling tools: multi-beamlet simulations have been performed for the first time.

Preliminary results concerning the simulation of beam profiles from extracted ion current distributions for mini-STRIKE.

The Radio Frequency (RF) negative hydrogen ion source prototype has been chosen for the ITER neutral beam injectors due to its optimal performances and easier maintenance demonstrated at Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik, Garching in hydrogen and deuterium. One of the key information to better understand the operating behavior of the RF ion sources is the extracted negative ion current density distribution. This distribution-influenced by several factors like source geometry, particle drifts inside the source, cesium distribution, and layout of cesium ovens-is not straightforward to be evaluated. The main outcome of the present contribution is the development of a minimization method to estimate the extracted current distribution using the footprint of the beam recorded with mini-STRIKE (Short-Time Retractable Instrumented Kalorimeter). To accomplish this, a series of four computational models have been set up, where the output of a model is the input of the following one. These models compute the optics of the ion beam, evaluate the distribution of the heat deposited on the mini-STRIKE diagnostic calorimeter, and finally give an estimate of the temperature distribution on the back of mini-STRIKE. Several iterations with different extracted current profiles are necessary to give an estimate of the profile most compatible with the experimental data. A first test of the application of the method to the BAvarian Test Machine for Negative ions beam is given.

Simulation of space charge compensation in a multibeamlet negative ion beam.

Ion beam space charge compensation occurs by cumulating in the beam potential well charges having opposite polarity, usually generated by collisional processes. In this paper we investigate the case of a H(-) ion beam drift, in a bi-dimensional approximation of the NIO1 (Negative Ion Optimization phase 1) negative ion source. H(-) beam ion transport and plasma formation are studied via particle-in-cell simulations. Differential cross sections are sampled to determine the velocity distribution of secondary particles generated by ionization of the residual gas (electrons and slow H2 (+) ions) or by stripping of the beam ions (electrons, H, and H(+)). The simulations include three beamlets of a horizontal section, so that multibeamlet space charge and secondary particle diffusion between separate generation regions are considered, and include a repeller grid biased at various potentials. Results show that after the beam space charge is effectively screened by the secondary plasma in about 3 µs (in agreement with theoretical expectations), a plasma grows across the beamlets with a characteristic time three times longer, and a slight overcompensation of the electric potential is verified as expected in the case of negative ions.

Analysis of diagnostic calorimeter data by the transfer function technique.

This paper describes the analysis procedure applied to the thermal measurements on the rear side of a carbon fibre composite calorimeter with the purpose of reconstructing the energy flux due to an ion beam colliding on the front side. The method is based on the transfer function technique and allows a fast analysis by means of the fast Fourier transform algorithm. Its efficacy has been tested both on simulated and measured temperature profiles: in all cases, the energy flux features are well reproduced and beamlets are well resolved. Limits and restrictions of the method are also discussed, providing strategies to handle issues related to signal noise and digital processing.

Study of a high power hydrogen beam diagnostic based on secondary electron emission.

In high power neutral beams for fusion, beam uniformity is an important figure of merit. Knowing the transverse power profile is essential during the initial phases of beam source operation, such as those expected for the ITER heating neutral beam (HNB) test facility. To measure it a diagnostic technique is proposed, based on the collection of secondary electrons generated by beam-surface and beam-gas interactions, by an array of positively biased collectors placed behind the calorimeter tubes. This measurement showed in the IREK test stand good proportionality to the primary beam current. To investigate the diagnostic performances in different conditions, we developed a numerical model of secondary electron emission, induced by beam particle impact on the copper tubes, and reproducing the cascade of secondary emission caused by successive electron impacts. The model is first validated against IREK measurements. It is then applied to the HNB case, to assess the locality of the measurement, the proportionality to the beam current density, and the influence of beam plasma.

Preliminary design of electrostatic sensors for MITICA beam line components.

Megavolt ITER Injector and Concept Advancement, the full-scale prototype of ITER neutral beam injector, is under construction in Italy. The device will generate deuterium negative ions, then accelerated and neutralized. The emerging beam, after removal of residual ions, will be dumped onto a calorimeter. The presence of plasma and its parameters will be monitored in the components of the beam-line, by means of specific electrostatic probes. Double probes, with the possibility to be configured as Langmuir probes and provide local ion density and electron temperature measurements, will be employed in the neutralizer and in the residual ion dump. Biased electrodes collecting secondary emission electrons will be installed in the calorimeter with the aim to provide a horizontal profile of the beam.