DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries: A Selection System Based on Endowing Organic Compounds with Amplifiable Information.

The discovery of organic ligands that bind specifically to proteins is a central problem in chemistry, biology, and the biomedical sciences. The encoding of individual organic molecules with distinctive DNA tags, serving as amplifiable identification bar codes, allows the construction and screening of combinatorial libraries of unprecedented size, thus facilitating the discovery of ligands to many different protein targets. Fundamentally, one links powers of genetics and chemical synthesis. After the initial description of DNA-encoded chemical libraries in 1992, several experimental embodiments of the technology have been reduced to practice. This review provides a historical account of important milestones in the development of DNA-encoded chemical libraries, a survey of relevant ongoing research activities, and a glimpse into the future.

Affinity Selections of DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries on Carbonic Anhydrase IX-Expressing Tumor Cells Reveal a Dependence on Ligand Valence.

DNA-encoded chemical libraries are typically screened against purified protein targets. Recently, cell-based selections with encoded chemical libraries have been described, commonly revealing suboptimal performance due to insufficient recovery of binding molecules. We used carbonic anhydrase IX (CAIX)-expressing tumor cells as a model system to optimize selection procedures with code-specific quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) as selection readout. Salt concentration and performing PCR on cell suspension had the biggest impact on selection performance, leading to 15-fold enrichment factors for high-affinity monovalent CAIX binders (acetazolamide; KD =8.7 nM). Surprisingly, the homobivalent display of acetazolamide at the extremities of both complementary DNA strands led to a substantial improvement of both ligand recovery and enrichment factors (above 100-fold). The optimized procedures were used for selections with a DNA-encoded chemical library comprising 1 million members against tumor cell lines expressing CAIX, leading to a preferential recovery of known and new ligands against this validated tumor-associated target. This work may facilitate future affinity selections on cells against target proteins which might be difficult to express otherwise.

A DNA-Encoded Chemical Library Based on Peptide Macrocycles.

The synthesis and characterization of a novel DNA-encoded library of macrocyclic peptide derivatives are described; the macrocycles are based on three sets of proteinogenic and non-proteinogenic amino acid building blocks and featuring the use of copper(I)-catalyzed alkyne-azide cycloaddition (CuAAC) reaction for ring closure. The library (termed YO-DEL) which contains 1 254 838 compounds, was encoded with DNA in single-stranded format and was screened against target proteins of interest using affinity capture procedures and photocrosslinking. YO-DEL selections yielded specific binders against serum albumins, carbonic anhydrases and NKp46, a marker of activated Natural Killer cells.

Novel irreversible covalent BTK inhibitors discovered using DNA-encoded chemistry.

Libraries of DNA-Encoded small molecules created using combinatorial chemistry and synthetic oligonucleotides are being applied to drug discovery projects across the pharmaceutical industry. The majority of reported projects describe the discovery of reversible, i.e. non-covalent, target modulators. We synthesized multiple DNA-encoded chemical libraries terminated in electrophiles and then used them to discover covalent irreversible inhibitors and report the successful discovery of acrylamide- and epoxide-terminated Bruton's Tyrosine Kinase (BTK) inhibitors. We also demonstrate their selectivity, potency and covalent cysteine engagement using a range of techniques including X-ray crystallography, thermal transition shift assay, reporter displacement assay and intact protein complex mass spectrometry. The epoxide BTK inhibitors described here are the first ever reported to utilize this electrophile for this target.

An assessment of the mutational load caused by various reactions used in DNA encoded libraries.

DNA encoded libraries have become an essential hit-finding tool in early drug discovery. Recent advances in synthetic methods for DNA encoded libraries have expanded the available chemical space, but precisely how each type of chemistry affects the DNA is unstudied. Available assays to quantify the damage are limited to write efficiency, where the ability to ligate DNA onto a working encoded library strand is measured, or qPCR is performed to measure the amplifiability of the DNA. These measures read signal quantity and overall integrity, but do not report on specific damages in the encoded information. Herein, we use next generation sequencing (NGS) to measure the quality of the read signal in order to quantify the truthfulness of the retrieved information. We identify CuAAC to be the worst offender in terms of DNA damage amongst commonly used reactions in DELs, causing an increase of G â†’ T transversions. Furthermore, we show that the analysis provides useful information even in fully elaborated DELs; indeed we see that vestiges of the synthetic history, both chemical and biochemical, are written into the mutational spectra of NGS datasets.

Comparative evaluation of DNA-encoded chemical selections performed using DNA in single-stranded or double-stranded format.

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DEL) are increasingly being used for the discovery and optimization of small organic ligands to proteins of biological or pharmaceutical interest. The DNA fragments, that serve as amplifiable identification barcodes for individual compounds in the library, are typically used in double-stranded DNA format. To the best of our knowledge, a direct comparison of DEL selections featuring DNA in either single- or double-stranded DNA format has not yet been reported. In this article, we describe a comparative evaluation of selections with two DEL libraries (named GB-DEL and NF-DEL), based on different chemical designs and produced in both single- and double-stranded DNA format. The libraries were selected in identical conditions against multiple protein targets, revealing comparable and reproducible fingerprints for both types of DNA formats. Surprisingly, selections performed with single-stranded DNA barcodes exhibited improved enrichment factors compared to double-stranded DNA. Using high-affinity ligands to carbonic anhydrase IX as benchmarks for selection performance, we observed an improved selectivity for the NF-DEL library (on average 2-fold higher enrichment factors) in favor of single-stranded DNA. The enrichment factors were even higher for the GB-DEL selections (approximately 5-fold), compared to the same library in double-stranded DNA format. Collectively, these results indicate that DEL libraries can conveniently be synthesized and screened in both single- and double-stranded DNA format, but single-stranded DNA barcodes typically yield enhanced enrichment factors.

Using a PCR-Based Method To Analyze and Model Large, Heterogeneous Populations of DNA.

The study of populations of large size and high diversity is limited by the capability of collecting data. Moreover, for a pool of individuals, each associated with a unique characteristic feature, as the pool size grows, the possible interactions increase exponentially and quickly go beyond the limit of computation and experimental studies. Herein, the design of DNA libraries with various diversity is reported. By using a facile analytical method based on real-time PCR, the diversity of a pool of DNA can be evaluated to allow extraordinarily high heterogenicity (e.g., >1 trillion). It is demonstrated that these DNA libraries can be used to model heterogeneous populations; these libraries exhibit functions such as self-protection, suitability for biased expansion, and the possibility to evolve into amorphous structures. The method has shown the remarkable power of parallel computing with DNA, since it can resemble an analogue computer and be applied in selection-based biotechnology methods, such as DNA-encoded chemical libraries. As a chemical approach to solve problems traditionally for genetic and statistical analysis, the method provides a quick and cost-efficient evaluation of library diversity for intermediate steps through a selection process.

Integrating DNA-encoded chemical libraries with virtual combinatorial library screening: Optimizing a PARP10 inhibitor.

Two critical steps in drug development are 1) the discovery of molecules that have the desired effects on a target, and 2) the optimization of such molecules into lead compounds with the required potency and pharmacokinetic properties for translation. DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) can nowadays yield hits with unprecedented ease, and lead-optimization is becoming the limiting step. Here we integrate DECL screening with structure-based computational methods to streamline the development of lead compounds. The presented workflow consists of enumerating a virtual combinatorial library (VCL) derived from a DECL screening hit and using computational binding prediction to identify molecules with enhanced properties relative to the original DECL hit. As proof-of-concept demonstration, we applied this approach to identify an inhibitor of PARP10 that is more potent and druglike than the original DECL screening hit.

Quantitative Assessment of Affinity Selection Performance by Using DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries.

DNA-encoded chemical libraries are often used for the discovery of ligands against protein targets of interest. These large collections of DNA-barcoded chemical compounds are typically screened by using affinity capture methodologies followed by PCR amplification and DNA sequencing procedures. However, the performance of individual steps in the selection procedures has been scarcely investigated, so far. Herein, the quantitative analysis of selection experiments, by using three ligands with different affinity to carbonic anhydrase IX as model compounds, is described. In the first set of experiments, quantitative PCR (qPCR) procedures are used to evaluate the recovery and selectivity for affinity capture procedures performed on different solid-phase supports, which are commonly used for library screening. In the second step, both qPCR and analysis of DNA sequencing results are used to assess the recovery and selectivity of individual carbonic anhydrase IX ligands in a library, containing 360 000 compounds. Collectively, this study reveals that selection procedures can be efficient for ligands with sub-micromolar dissociation constants to the target protein of interest, but also that selection performance dramatically drops if 104 copies per library member are used as the input.

Quantitative PCR is a Valuable Tool to Monitor the Performance of DNA-Encoded Chemical Library Selections.

Phage-display libraries and DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) represent useful tools for the isolation of specific binding molecules from large combinatorial sets of compounds. With both methods, specific binders are recovered at the end of affinity capture procedures by using target proteins of interest immobilized on a solid support. However, although the efficiency of phage-display selections is routinely quantified by counting the phage titer before and after the affinity capture step, no similar quantification procedures have been reported for the characterization of DECL selections. In this article, we describe the potential and limitations of quantitative PCR (qPCR) methods for the evaluation of selection efficiency by using a combinatorial chemical library with more than 35 million compounds. In the experimental conditions chosen for the selections, a quantification of DNA input/recovery over five orders of magnitude could be performed, revealing a successful enrichment of abundant binders, which could be confirmed by DNA sequencing. qPCR provided rapid information about the performance of selections, thus facilitating the optimization of experimental conditions.

Hit-Validation Methodologies for Ligands Isolated from DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries.

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) are large collections of compounds linked to DNA fragments, serving as amplifiable barcodes, which can be screened on target proteins of interest. In typical DECL selections, preferential binders are identified by high-throughput DNA sequencing, by comparing their frequency before and after the affinity capture step. Hits identified in this procedure need to be confirmed, by resynthesis and by performing affinity measurements. In this article we present new methods based on hybridization of oligonucleotide conjugates with fluorescently labeled complementary oligonucleotides; these facilitate the determination of affinity constants and kinetic dissociation constants. The experimental procedures were demonstrated with acetazolamide, a binder to carbonic anhydrase IX with a dissociation constant in the nanomolar range. The detection of binding events was compatible not only with fluorescence polarization methodologies, but also with Alphascreen technology and with microscale thermophoresis.

A Specific and Covalent JNK-1 Ligand Selected from an Encoded Self-Assembling Chemical Library.

We describe the construction of a DNA-encoded chemical library comprising 148 135 members, generated through the self-assembly of two sub-libraries, containing 265 and 559 members, respectively. The library was designed to contain building blocks potentially capable of forming covalent interactions with target proteins. Selections performed with JNK1, a kinase containing a conserved cysteine residue close to the ATP binding site, revealed the preferential enrichment of a 2-phenoxynicotinic acid moiety (building block A82) and a 4-(3,4-difluorophenyl)-4-oxobut-2-enoic acid moiety (building block B272). When the two compounds were joined by a short PEG linker, the resulting bidentate binder (A82-L-B272) was able to covalently modify JNK1 in the presence of a large molar excess of glutathione (0.5 mm), used to simulate intracellular reducing conditions. By contrast, derivatives of the individual building blocks were not able to covalently modify JNK1 in the same experimental conditions. The A82-L-B272 ligand was selective over related kinases (BTK and GAK), which also contain targetable cysteine residues in the vicinity of the active site.

DNA-Encoded Dynamic Combinatorial Chemical Libraries.

Dynamic combinatorial chemistry (DCC) explores the thermodynamic equilibrium of reversible reactions. Its application in the discovery of protein binders is largely limited by difficulties in the analysis of complex reaction mixtures. DNA-encoded chemical library (DECL) technology allows the selection of binders from a mixture of up to billions of different compounds; however, experimental results often show low a signal-to-noise ratio and poor correlation between enrichment factor and binding affinity. Herein we describe the design and application of DNA-encoded dynamic combinatorial chemical libraries (EDCCLs). Our experiments have shown that the EDCCL approach can be used not only to convert monovalent binders into high-affinity bivalent binders, but also to cause remarkably enhanced enrichment of potent bivalent binders by driving their in situ synthesis. We also demonstrate the application of EDCCLs in DNA-templated chemical reactions.

Elucidating the Unconventional Binding Mode of a DNA-Encoded Library Hit Provides a Blueprint for Sirtuin 6 Inhibitor Development.

Sirtuin 6 (Sirt6), an NAD+-dependent deacylase, has emerged as a promising target for aging-related diseases and cancer. Advancing the medicinal chemistry of Sirt6 modulators is crucial for the development of chemical probes aimed at unraveling the intricate biological functions of Sirt6 and unlocking its therapeutic potential. A proprietary DNA-encoded library yielded Sirt6 inhibitor 2-Pr, displaying remarkable inhibitory activity and isoform-selectivity, and featuring a chemical structure distinct from reported Sirt6 modulators. In this study, we explore the inhibitory mechanism of 2-Pr, evaluating the impact of chemical modifications and presenting a crystal structure of the Sirt6/ADP-ribose/2-Pr complex. Notably, co-crystal structure analysis reveals an unexpected and unprecedented binding mode of Sirt6, with 2-Pr spanning the acyl channel of the enzyme, extending into the acetyl-lysine binding pocket, and reaching toward the C-site. This unique binding mode guides potential avenues for developing potent and selective Sirt6 inhibitors.

Advancing ASMS with LC-MS/MS for the discovery of novel PDCL2 ligands from DNA-encoded chemical library selections.

BACKGROUND: A safe, effective, and reversible nonhormonal male contraceptive drug is greatly needed for male contraception as well as for circumventing the side effects of female hormonal contraceptives. Phosducin-like 2 (PDCL2) is a testis-specific phosphoprotein in mice and humans. We recently found that male PDCL2 knockout mice are sterile due to globozoospermia caused by impaired sperm head formation, indicating that PDCL2 is a potential target for male contraception. Herein, our study for the first time developed a biophysical assay for PDCL2 allowing us to screen a series of small molecules, to study structure-activity relationships, and to discover two PDCL2 binders with novel chemical structure. OBJECTIVE: To identify a PDCL2 ligand for therapeutic male contraception, we performed DNA-encoded chemical library (DECL) screening and off-DNA hit validation using a unique affinity selection mass spectrometry (ASMS) biophysical profiling strategy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We employed the screening process of DECL, which contains billions of chemically unique DNA-barcoded compounds generated through individual sequences of reactions and different combinations of functionalized building blocks. The structures of the PDCL2 binders are proposed based on the sequencing analysis of the DNA barcode attached to each individual DECL compound. The proposed structure is synthesized through multistep reactions. To confirm and determine binding affinity between the DECL identified molecules and PDCL2, we developed an ASMS assay that incorporates liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). RESULTS: After a screening process of PDCL2 with DECLs containing >440 billion compounds, we identified a series of hits. The selected compounds were synthesized as off-DNA small molecules, characterized by spectroscopy data, and subjected to our ASMS/LC-MS/MS binding assay. By this assay, we discovered two novel compounds, which showed good binding affinity for PDCL2 in comparison to other molecules generated in our laboratory and which were further confirmed by a thermal shift assay. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION AND RELEVANCE: With the ASMS/LC-MS/MS assay developed in this paper, we successfully discovered a PDCL2 ligand that warrants further development as a male contraceptive.

Development of On-DNA Thiophene Synthesis for DEL Construction.

Thiophene and its substituted derivatives are a highly important class of heterocyclic compounds, with noteworthy applications in pharmaceutical ingredients. In this study, we leverage the unique reactivity of alkynes to generate thiophenes on-DNA, using a cascade iodination, Cadiot-Chodkiewicz coupling and heterocyclization. This approach, tackling on-DNA thiophene synthesis for the first time, generates diverse, and unprecedented structural and chemical features, which could be significant motifs in DEL screening as molecular recognition agents for drug discovery.

Combining pharmacophore models derived from DNA-encoded chemical libraries with structure-based exploration to predict Tankyrase 1 inhibitors.

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) interrogate the interactions of a target of interest with vast numbers of molecules. DECLs hence provide abundant information about the chemical ligand space for therapeutic targets, and there is considerable interest in methods for exploiting DECL screening data to predict novel ligands. Here we introduce one such approach and demonstrate its feasibility using the cancer-related poly-(ADP-ribose)transferase tankyrase 1 (TNKS1) as a model target. First, DECL affinity selections resulted in structurally diverse TNKS1 inhibitors with high potency including compound 2 with an IC50 value of 0.8 nM. Additionally, TNKS1 hits from four DECLs were translated into pharmacophore models, which were exploited in combination with docking-based screening to identify TNKS1 ligand candidates in databases of commercially available compounds. This computational strategy afforded TNKS1 inhibitors that are outside the chemical space covered by the DECLs and yielded the drug-like lead compound 12 with an IC50 value of 22 nM. The study further provided insights in the reliability of screening data and the effect of library design on hit compounds. In particular, the study revealed that while in general DECL screening data are in good agreement with off-DNA ligand binding, unpredictable interactions of the DNA-attachment linker with the target protein contribute to the noise in the affinity selection data.

Advancing small-molecule drug discovery by encoded dual-display technologies.

DNA-encoded chemical library technology (DECL or DEL) has become an important pillar for small-molecule drug discovery. The technology rapidly identifies small-molecule hits for relevant target proteins at low cost and with a high success rate, including ligands for targeted protein degradation (TPD). More recently, the setup of DNA- or peptide nucleic acid (PNA)-encoded chemical libraries based on the simultaneous display of ligand pairs, termed dual-display, allows for more sophisticated applications which will be reviewed herein. Both stable and dynamic dual-display DEL technologies enable innovative affinity-based selection modalities, even on and in cells. Novel methods for a seamless conversion between single- and double-stranded library formats allow for even more versatility. We present the first candidates emerging from dual-display technologies and discuss the future potential of dual-display for drug discovery.

Chemical Ligation of Oligonucleotide Tags to Support Encoded Chemical Library Synthesis.

Chemical ligation can be used to install encoding tags during the synthesis of DNA-encoded chemical libraries and can present a number of advantages. Here we describe methods to generate polymerase-readable oligonucleotide junctions and for the polymerase-mediated amplification of oligonucleotides ligated with these chemistries, including triazole junctions generated from 2'-ribo-3'-propargyl and 5'-azido oligonucleotides and from 2'-deoxy-3'-propargyl and 5'-azido oligonucleotides. We also present methods for the synthesis of phosphorothioate junctions from 3'-thiophospho and 5'-iodo oligonucleotides and for the synthesis of phosphodiester junctions from both 3'-hydroxy and 5'-phospho- and 3'-phospho and 5'-hydroxy oligonucleotides using 1-cyanoimidazole.

Isolation of a Natural Killer Group 2D Small-Molecule Ligand from DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries.

Natural Killer Group 2D (NKG2D) is a homo-dimeric transmembrane protein which is typically expressed on the surface of natural killer (NK) cells, natural killer T (NKT) cells, gamma delta T (γδT) cells, activated CD8 positive T-cells and activated macrophages. Bispecific molecules, capable of bridging NKG2D with a target protein expressed on the surface of tumor cells, may be used to redirect the cytotoxic activity of NK-cells towards antigen-positive malignant T-cells. In this work, we report the discovery of a novel NKG2D small molecule binder [KD =(410±60) nM], isolated from a DNA-Encoded Chemical Library (DEL). The discovery of small organic NKG2D ligands may facilitate the generation of fully synthetic bispecific adaptors, which may serve as an alternative to bispecific antibody products and which may benefit from better tumor targeting properties.