RESUMEN
Most basic studies directed at how immune responses are regulated employ chemically "simple antigens", usually purified proteins. The target antigens in many clinical situations, such as in autoimmunity, infectious diseases and cancer, are chemically "complex", consisting of several distinct molecules, and they often are part of a replicating entity. We examine here the relationships between how immune responses to complex and simple antigens are regulated. This examination provides a context for considering how immune responses are regulated in those clinical situations involving complex antigens. I have proposed and discuss here a mechanism by which immune responses to the envisaged complex target antigen in remitting/relapsing multiple sclerosis go back and forth between inflammatory and non-inflammatory modes, potentially accounting for the course of this disease. This proposal makes predictions that can be tested by non-invasive means. It also leads to a suggestion for simple, non-invasive treatment.
Asunto(s)
Esclerosis Múltiple Recurrente-Remitente , Esclerosis Múltiple , Humanos , AutoinmunidadRESUMEN
The clinical pattern in relapsing/remitting multiple sclerosis may be accounted for if an autoreactive immune response can transition back and forth between inflammatory, pathogenic, and non-inflammatory, non-pathogenic modes. Such 'back-and-forth' immune responses are rare. I speculate how such back-and-forth immune responses may arise. Understanding the nature of these different modes, and what controls their mutual transition, may help in designing strategies to favour the nonpathogenic mode, thus constituting treatment. Antigen dose is known to be critical in determining the class/subclass of primary immune responses. Observations have led us to suggest the level of antigen also similarly influences the class/subclass of on-going immune responses. I propose the relapsing, inflammatory and the remitting modes are respectively sustained by relatively low and high amounts of the responsible autoantigens, as is the case, for example, for Th1 and Th2 responses to foreign antigens. In addition, I propose more self-antigens are released during an inflammatory than during a remitting mode. The decrease in the amount of antigen released, as the response transitions from an inflammatory to a remitting mode, results in time in a decreased level of antigen and so the response again evolves towards the inflammatory mode. The inflammatory mode then leads to an increased release of antigen and so, in time, to remission. This model thus explains the transition between different modes. I outline non-invasive, testable predictions of the hypothesis. If confirmed, it may be ethical to examine whether the non-inflammatory mode can be sustained by administering myelin antigens during the remitting phase.
Asunto(s)
Esclerosis Múltiple Recurrente-Remitente , Animales , Humanos , Autoantígenos/inmunología , Autoinmunidad/inmunología , Inflamación/inmunología , Modelos Inmunológicos , Esclerosis Múltiple Recurrente-Remitente/inmunología , Esclerosis Múltiple Recurrente-Remitente/terapia , Células TH1/inmunología , Células Th2/inmunologíaRESUMEN
This is a report from a one-week workshop held in Athens, Greece in July of 2022. The workshop aimed to identify emerging concepts relevant to the fundamentals of immune regulation and areas for future research. Theories of immune regulation emphasize the role of T cell help or co-stimulation (signal 2). The workshop participants considered how new data on the characteristics of agonist antigens, the role of the antigen receptor signals (signal 1) in driving fate decisions, the effect of energetics on immunity and a better understanding of class-control in the immune response, may impact theories of immune regulation. These ideas were discussed in the context of tumour immunology, autoimmunity, pregnancy and transplantation. Here we present the discussions as a narrative of different viewpoints to allow the reader to join the conversation. These discussions highlight the evolving understanding of the nature of specific antigen recognition and how both antigen-specific and non-specific mechanisms impact immune responses.
Asunto(s)
Antígenos , Linfocitos T , Humanos , AutoinmunidadRESUMEN
Rational vaccination against and immunotherapy of any infectious disease requires knowledge of how protective and non-protective immune responses differ, and how immune responses are regulated, so their nature can be controlled. Strong Th1 responses are likely protective against M tuberculosis. Understanding how immune class regulation is achieved is pertinent to both vaccination and treatment. I argue that variables of infection, other than PAMPs, primarily determine the class of immunity generated. The alternative, non-PAMP framework I favour, allows me to propose strategies to achieve efficacious vaccination, transcending host and pathogen genetic variability, to prevent tuberculosis, and personalised protocols to treat disease.
Asunto(s)
Mycobacterium tuberculosis , Tuberculosis , Humanos , Tuberculosis/prevención & control , Mycobacterium tuberculosis/genética , Vacunación , InmunoterapiaRESUMEN
Acumulation of oxidized membrane lipids ultimately results in ferroptotic cell death, which can be prevented by the selenoenzyme glutathione peroxidase 4 (Gpx4). In vivo conditions promoting ferroptosis and susceptible cell types are still poorly defined. In this study, we analyzed the conditional deletion of Gpx4 in mice specifically in the myeloid cell lineages. Surprisingly, development and maintenance of LysM+ macrophages and neutrophils, as well as CD11c+ monocyte-derived macrophages and dendritic cells were unaffected in the absence of Gpx4. Gpx4-deficient macrophages mounted an unaltered proinflammatory cytokine response including IL-1ß production following stimulation with TLR ligands and activation of several inflammasomes. Accordingly, Gpx4fl/fl LysM-cre mice were protected from bacterial and protozoan infections. Despite having the capacity to differentiate to alternatively activated macrophages (AAM), these cells lacking Gpx4 triggered ferroptosis both in vitro and in vivo following IL-4 overexpression and nematode infection. Exposure to nitric oxide restored viability of Gpx4-deficient AAM, while inhibition of iNOS in proinflammatory macrophages had no effect. These data together suggest that activation cues of tissue macrophages determine sensitivity to lipid peroxidation and ferroptotic cell death.
Asunto(s)
Ferroptosis , Activación de Macrófagos/inmunología , Macrófagos/inmunología , Macrófagos/metabolismo , Animales , Biomarcadores , Supervivencia Celular/genética , Supervivencia Celular/inmunología , Modelos Animales de Enfermedad , Susceptibilidad a Enfermedades , Ferroptosis/genética , Ferroptosis/inmunología , Inflamación/etiología , Inflamación/metabolismo , Inflamación/patología , Peroxidación de Lípido , Ratones , Ratones Transgénicos , Especificidad de Órganos/inmunología , Fosfolípido Hidroperóxido Glutatión Peroxidasa/genética , Fosfolípido Hidroperóxido Glutatión Peroxidasa/metabolismoRESUMEN
Burnet envisaged the early presence of self-antigens in development, or 'the history' of an animal, ablates the animal's ability to immunologically respond against them. Lederberg added the idea that the continuous presence of self-antigens is required to maintain tolerance throughout life. We refer to Lederberg's proposal as 'The Historical Postulate'. The mechanism of central tolerance, as now understood, is consistent with The Historical Postulate. Some observations, reflecting peripheral tolerance, appear inconsistent with this postulate. For example, some foreign peripheral tissues, grafted onto an animal before the immune system develops, can be rejected as the immune system matures. The original two-signal model of lymphocyte activation was proposed in part because it accounted for peripheral tolerance in a manner consistent with The Historical Postulate. We proposed that lymphocyte activation required antigen-mediated lymphocyte cooperation, whereas antigen would inactivate lymphocytes when insufficient in number to achieve activation. We argue here that the exceptions to The Historical Postulate can be explained by the two-signal model of lymphocyte activation: they reflect the existence of greater numbers of lymphocytes specific for these antigens than for natural peripheral antigens, and so are outside the physiological limits important in selecting through evolution this mechanism of peripheral tolerance. We argue that a consideration of whether The Historical Postulate is valid is important, even if only valid within certain understandable limits. The currently popular DAMP model of CD4 T cell activation is, strictly speaking and in a manner we discuss, in violation of this postulate.
Asunto(s)
Linfocitos T CD4-Positivos/inmunología , Sistema Inmunológico/inmunología , Animales , Antígenos/inmunología , Humanos , Activación de Linfocitos/inmunología , Autotolerancia/inmunologíaRESUMEN
We propose a treatment of HIV-1+ individuals designed to harness protective immunity, lead to viral containment, and so render the individual minimally infectious. A few HIV-infected individuals, 'elite controllers', generate a stable Th1, cytotoxic T lymphocyte response that contains the virus. Most infected individuals, in the absence of therapy, first generate a similarly protective response that evolves with time a Th2 component, associated with antibody production and loss of viral control. Cessation of anti-retroviral treatment after three years results in viral rebound in most, but about one in seven individuals contains the virus, so-called post-treatment controllers. We suggest an understanding, of how the Th1/Th2 phenotype of immune responses is controlled, can explain these different outcomes and leads us to propose a non-invasive, personalized strategy of immunotherapy. We propose that monitoring the relative prevalence of HIV-1 specific IgG1 and IgG2 antibodies can provide a biomarker for deciding when to interrupt/withdraw anti-retroviral therapy to optimally harness protective immunity.
Asunto(s)
Antirreumáticos/uso terapéutico , Infecciones por VIH/tratamiento farmacológico , VIH-1/fisiología , Linfocitos T Citotóxicos/inmunología , Células TH1/inmunología , Células Th2/inmunología , Anticuerpos Antivirales/sangre , Biomarcadores , Resistencia a la Enfermedad , Humanos , Inmunoglobulina G/sangre , Modelos Inmunológicos , Medicina de Precisión , Balance Th1 - Th2 , Privación de TratamientoRESUMEN
We propose a framework to explain how T cells achieve specificity and sensitivity, how the affinity of the TcR peptide/MHC interaction controls positive and negative thymic selection and mature T cell survival, and whether antigen-dependent activation and inactivation takes place. Two distinct types of signalling can lead to mature T cell multiplication. One requires the TcR to recognize with a certain affinity an antigen-derived peptide, an agonist peptide, bound to an MHC molecule. The other, the tonic signal, leads to naïve T cell survival and modest proliferation if the T cell successfully competes for endogenous, self-peptide/MHC ligands, involving lower affinity TCR/ligand interactions. Many suggest lymphopenia contributes to autoimmunity by increasing the strength of TcR-tonic signalling, and so activation of anti-self T cells. We suggest T cell activation requires antigen-mediated cooperation between T cells. Increased tonic signalling under lymphopenic conditions facilitates T cell proliferation and so antigen-dependent cooperation and activation of anti-self T cells.
Asunto(s)
Linfopenia/inmunología , Especificidad del Receptor de Antígeno de Linfocitos T , Linfocitos T/inmunología , Animales , Presentación de Antígeno , Autoantígenos/inmunología , Autoantígenos/metabolismo , Autoinmunidad , Comunicación Celular , Diferenciación Celular , Supervivencia Celular , Antígenos de Histocompatibilidad/metabolismo , Humanos , Activación de Linfocitos , Modelos Inmunológicos , Fragmentos de Péptidos/inmunología , Fragmentos de Péptidos/metabolismo , Receptores de Antígenos de Linfocitos T/metabolismo , Transducción de SeñalRESUMEN
Recent reports suggest a quorum of T cells is required to activate T lymphocytes and that this requirement may help explain why scarce lymphocytes, specific for peripheral self-antigen, are rarely activated by Ag. This proposal runs counter to the commonly held framework that the Ag-dependent, but CD4 T lymphocyte-independent, activation of CD8 T lymphocytes, and the activation of CD4 T lymphocytes themselves, can occur when a single CD8 or CD4 T lymphocyte encounters Ag under appropriately dangerous circumstances. We argue that a review of older literature often ignored, as well as of contemporary studies, supports the quorum concept and is difficult to reconcile with the Danger Model.
Asunto(s)
Activación de Linfocitos/inmunología , Linfocitos T/inmunología , Animales , HumanosRESUMEN
The first ideas leading to The Two-Signal Model of lymphocyte activation were published 50 years ago, but the model was not realized in one sitting. I describe the three phases that led to its contemporary formulations. A motivation underlying all these models was to generate a minimal description of what is required for antigen to inactivate and activate mature lymphocytes that, at the same time, accounts for how peripheral tolerance is achieved. I suggest the two signal model has not only provided a substantiated framework for understanding how antigen interacts differently with B cells and CD8 T cells, to result in their inactivation and activation, but its postulates are pertinent to contemporary issues concerning the inactivation and activation of CD4 T cells.
Asunto(s)
Linfocitos B/inmunología , Linfocitos T CD8-positivos/inmunología , Activación de Linfocitos/inmunología , Transducción de Señal/inmunología , Historia del Siglo XX , Autotolerancia/inmunologíaRESUMEN
Antigen-specific molecules of the immune system, namely antibodies, the membrane immunoglobulins (mIgs) of B cells and T cell receptors (TcRs), can all signal their interaction with antigen. There are different mechanisms by which this signalling could occur. These mechanisms can be divided into two general categories: allosteric and non-allosteric. In allosteric mechanisms, the monovalent binding of the antigen to the receptor triggers a conformational change at the binding site that is propagated to an invariant part of the receptor, a change recognized by a sensing unit. We argue allosteric mechanisms are implausible. Non-allosteric mechanisms depend on steric effects due to the antigen's size and/or multivalency. We consider two non-allosteric mechanisms by which the mIg of B cells has been envisaged to signal its interaction with antigen: the popular cross-linking model and the dissociation activation model. We argue, on the basis of both experimental observations and physiological considerations, that the dissociation activation model, developed by Reth and his colleagues, is uniquely plausible.
Asunto(s)
Anticuerpos/inmunología , Antígenos/inmunología , Linfocitos B/inmunología , Sistema Inmunológico/inmunología , Receptores de Antígenos de Linfocitos B/inmunología , Transducción de Señal/inmunología , Humanos , Receptores de Antígenos de Linfocitos T/inmunologíaRESUMEN
Cohn has developed the tritope model to describe how distinct domains of the T cell receptor (TcR) recognize peptide/self-MHC complexes and allo-MHC. He has over the years employed this model as a framework for considering how the TcR might mediate various signals [1-5]. In a recent publication [5], Cohn employs the Tritope Model to propose a detailed mechanism for the T cell receptor's involvement in positive thymic selection [5]. During a review of this proposal, I became uneasy over the plausibility of the underlying framework of the Tritope Model. I outline here the evolutionary considerations making me question this framework. I also suggest that the proposed framework underlying the Tritope Model makes strong predictions whose validity can most probably be assessed by considering observations reported in the literature.
Asunto(s)
Selección Clonal Mediada por Antígenos , Receptores de Antígenos de Linfocitos T/metabolismo , Linfocitos T/inmunología , Animales , Autoantígenos/inmunología , Diferenciación Celular , Antígenos de Histocompatibilidad/metabolismo , Humanos , Isoantígenos/inmunología , Activación de Linfocitos , Modelos Inmunológicos , Péptidos/metabolismoRESUMEN
Our previous in vivo studies show that both the amount of Ag and the number of available naive CD4 T cells affect the Th1/Th2 phenotype of the effector CD4 T cells generated. We examined how the number of OVA-specific CD4 TCR transgenic T cells affects the Th1/Th2 phenotype of anti-SRBC CD4 T cells generated in vivo upon immunization with different amounts of OVA-SRBC. Our observations show that a greater number of Ag-dependent CD4 T cell interactions are required to generate Th2 than Th1 cells. We established an in vitro system that recapitulates our main in vivo findings to more readily analyze the underlying mechanism. The in vitro generation of Th2 cells depends, as in vivo, upon both the number of responding CD4 T cells and the amount of Ag. We demonstrate, using agonostic/antagonistic Abs to various costimulatory molecules or their receptors, that the greater number of CD4 T cell interactions, required to generate Th2 over Th1 cells, does not involve CD40, OX40, or ICOS costimulation, but does involve B7/CD28 interactions. A comparison of the level of expression of B7 molecules by APC and CD4 T cells, under different conditions resulting in the substantial generation of Th1 and Th2 cells, leads us to propose that the critical CD28/B7 interactions, required to generate Th2 cells, may directly occur between CD4 T cells engaged with the same B cell acting as an APC.
Asunto(s)
Antígenos/inmunología , Antígeno B7-1/inmunología , Antígenos CD28/inmunología , Células TH1/inmunología , Células Th2/inmunología , Animales , Células Presentadoras de Antígenos/citología , Células Presentadoras de Antígenos/inmunología , Antígenos/genética , Linfocitos B/citología , Linfocitos B/inmunología , Antígeno B7-1/genética , Antígenos CD28/genética , Antígenos CD40/genética , Antígenos CD40/inmunología , Relación Dosis-Respuesta Inmunológica , Proteína Coestimuladora de Linfocitos T Inducibles/genética , Proteína Coestimuladora de Linfocitos T Inducibles/inmunología , Ratones Endogámicos BALB C , Receptores OX40/genética , Receptores OX40/metabolismo , Células TH1/citología , Células Th2/citologíaRESUMEN
Epoxyisoprostanes EI (1) and EC (2) are effective inhibitors of the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines IL-6 and IL-12. In detailed studies toward the investigation of the molecular mode of action of these structures, a highly potent lactone (3) derived from 1 was identified. The known isoprostanoids 1 and 2 are most likely precursors of 3, the product of facile intramolecular reaction between the epoxide with the carboxylic acid in 2.
Asunto(s)
Antiinflamatorios/metabolismo , Descubrimiento de Drogas , Isoprostanos/metabolismo , Lactonas/metabolismo , Antiinflamatorios/química , Isoprostanos/química , Lactonas/química , Estructura MolecularRESUMEN
Different frameworks, which are currently employed to understand how immune responses are regulated, can account for different observations reported in the classical literature. I have argued that the predominant frameworks, employed over the last two/three decades to analyze the circumstances that determine whether an immune response is generated or this potential is ablated, and that determine the class of immunity an antigen induces, are inconsistent with diverse classical observations. These observations are "paradoxical" within the context of these frameworks and, consequently, tend to be ignored by most contemporary researchers. One such observation is that low and high doses of diverse types of antigen result, respectively, in cell-mediated and IgG antibody responses. I suggest these paradoxes render these frameworks implausible. An alternative framework, The Threshold Hypothesis, accounts for the paradoxical observations. Some frameworks are judged more plausible when found to be valuable in understanding findings in fields beyond their original compass. I explore here how the Threshold Hypothesis, initially based on studies with chemically well-defined and "simple antigens", most often a purified protein, can nevertheless shed light on diverse classical and more recent observations in the fields of immunity against cancer and against infectious agents, thus revealing common, immune mechanisms. Most cancers and some pathogens are best contained by cell-mediated immunity. The success of the Threshold Hypothesis has encouraged me to employ it as a basis for proposing strategies to prevent and to treat cancer and those infectious diseases caused by pathogens best contained by a cell-mediated attack.
RESUMEN
Many observations bear upon the cellular and molecular requirements for CD4 T cell activation. The interaction of CD4 T cells with dendritic cells (DC), central to the induction of most immune responses, is the most studied. However, leukocytes other than DC can dramatically affect the induction and differentiation of CD4 T cells into effector cells. We recently provided indirect evidence that in vivo CD4 T cooperation facilitates the activation of CD4 T cells. Here, we demonstrate that the activation of CD4 T cells, specific for the hen egg lysozyme (HEL)(105) (-120) peptide, is optimally achieved when BALB/c mice are immunized with additional MHC class II-binding HEL peptides in incomplete Freund's adjuvant. This cooperation cannot be mimicked by the coadministration of LPS or of an agonistic antibody to CD40, at the time of immunization. In contrast, OX40-OX40L interactions are necessary for CD4 T cell cooperation in that an OX40 agonistic antibody can replace, and an OX40L-blocking antibody can abrogate, CD4 T cell cooperation in situations where such cooperation would otherwise enhance the activation of CD4 T cells.
Asunto(s)
Linfocitos T CD4-Positivos/inmunología , Comunicación Celular/inmunología , Activación de Linfocitos/inmunología , Animales , Ratones , Ratones Endogámicos BALB C , Muramidasa/inmunología , Ligando OX40/inmunología , Receptores OX40/inmunologíaRESUMEN
Activated CD4 T helper cells are required to activate B cells to produce antibody and CD8 T cells to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes. In the absence of such help, antigens inactivate B cells and CD8 T cells. Thus, the activation or inactivation of CD4 T cells determines whether immune responses are generated, or potentially ablated. Most consider that the activation of CD4 T cells requires an antigen-dependent signal, signal 1, as well as a critical costimulatory signal, initiated when a pattern recognition receptor (PRR) engages with a danger- or pathogen-associated molecular pattern (DAMP or PAMP). Most also envisage that the nature of the DAMP/PAMP signal determines the Th subset predominantly generated and so the class of immunity predominantly induced. I argue that this framework is implausible as it is incompatible with diverse observations of the variables of immunization affecting the class of immunity induced. An alternative framework, the threshold hypothesis, posits that different levels of antigen mediated CD4 T cell interactions lead to the generation of different Th subsets and so different classes of immunity, that it is compatible with these observations. This alternative supports a rational approach to preventing and treating diverse clinical conditions associated with infectious disease and, more speculatively, with cancer.
RESUMEN
The majority of in vitro studies investigating the activation of naïve TCR transgenic T cells routinely employ an artificially high frequency of such cells. To assess whether employing high frequencies of TCR transgenic cells in vitro accurately reflects the in vivo activation of a normal number of T cells, we cultured between 300 and 3×10(6) Rag2(-/-) DO11.10 T cells per well under otherwise identical conditions. We find that those T cells cultured at low frequencies proliferate more and are more potently activated, as assessed by the expression of CD44 and CD62L, each giving rise to a much larger number of cytokine producing cells, comparable to the number generated in vivo when a normal number of CD4(+) T cells are activated. The effect of T cell frequency on the level of their activation was not due to differences in MHCII or CD80/86 expression by B cells, the major APC population present, nor to increased death of B cells in high frequency cultures. Taken together, our observations illustrate the necessity of culturing naïve TCR transgenic CD4(+) T cells at a physiological frequency if one is to more accurately recapitulate the in vivo activation of naïve CD4(+) T cells.
Asunto(s)
Linfocitos T CD4-Positivos/inmunología , Activación de Linfocitos/inmunología , Animales , Células Presentadoras de Antígenos/inmunología , Antígeno B7-1/biosíntesis , Antígeno B7-2/biosíntesis , Técnicas de Cultivo de Célula , Células Cultivadas , Citocinas/biosíntesis , Receptores de Hialuranos/biosíntesis , Selectina L/biosíntesis , Ratones , Ratones Endogámicos BALB C , Ratones Transgénicos , Receptores de Antígenos de Linfocitos T/genética , Receptores de Antígenos de Linfocitos T/inmunologíaRESUMEN
There is considerable interest in whether increased investment in science, made by society, pays dividends. Some plausibly argue the increased rate of production of information results in an ossification of the canon. Reports, challenging the canon, fall by the wayside. The field thus becomes increasingly complex, reflecting not so much the reality of nature but how we investigate the subject. I suggest that focusing on and resolving the paradoxes evident within a canon will free the logjam, resulting in more resilient research. Immunology is among the fastest growing of biological sciences and is, I suggest, an appropriate case study. I examine the commonly accepted frameworks employed over the last three decades to address two major, related immunological questions: what determines whether antigen activates or inactivates CD4 T cells, and so whether immune responses are initiated or this potential ablated; secondly, what determines the Th subset to which the activated Th cells belong, thus determining the class of immunity generated. I show there are major paradoxes within these frameworks, neglected for decades. I propose how research focused on resolving paradoxes can be better fostered, and so support the evolution of the canon. This perspective is pertinent in facing critical issues on how immune responses are regulated, and to more general issues of both the philosophy of science and of science policy.The last section is in response to questions and comments of the reviewers. It brings together several considerations to express my view: the same frameworks, formulated in response to the two questions, are useful in understanding the regulation of the immune response against model antigens, against self and foreign antigens, those of tumors and of pathogens.