Unresolved questions regarding human hereditary deafness.

Human hearing loss is a common neurosensory disorder about which many basic research and clinically relevant questions are unresolved. This review on hereditary deafness focuses on three examples considered at first glance to be uncomplicated, however, upon inspection, are enigmatic and ripe for future research efforts. The three examples of clinical and genetic complexities are drawn from studies of (i) Pendred syndrome/DFNB4 (PDS, OMIM 274600), (ii) Perrault syndrome (deafness and infertility) due to mutations of CLPP (PRTLS3, OMIM 614129), and (iii) the unexplained extensive clinical variability associated with TBC1D24 mutations. At present, it is unknown how different mutations of TBC1D24 cause non-syndromic deafness (DFNB86, OMIM 614617), epilepsy (OMIM 605021), epilepsy with deafness, or DOORS syndrome (OMIM 220500) that is characterized by deafness, onychodystrophy (alteration of toenail or fingernail morphology), osteodystrophy (defective development of bone), mental retardation, and seizures. A comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted roles of each gene associated with human deafness is expected to provide future opportunities for restoration as well as preservation of normal hearing.

Dominant modifier DFNM1 suppresses recessive deafness DFNB26.

More than 50% of severe childhood deafness is genetically determined, approximately 70% of which occurs without other abnormalities and is thus termed nonsyndromic. So far, 30 nonsyndromic recessive deafness loci have been mapped and the defective genes at 6 loci, DFNB1, DFNB2, DFNB3, DFNB4, DFNB9 and DNFB21, have been identified, encoding connexin-26 (ref. 3), myosin VIIA (ref. 4), myosin XV (ref. 5), pendrin, otoferlin and alpha-tectorin, respectively. Here we map a new recessive nonsyndromic deafness locus, DFNB26, to a 1.5-cM interval of chromosome 4q31 in a consanguineous Pakistani family. A maximum lod score of 8.10 at theta=0 was obtained with D4S1610 when only the 8 affected individuals in this family were included in the calculation. There are seven unaffected family members who are also homozygous for the DFNB26-linked haplotype and thus are non-penetrant. A dominant modifier, DFNM1, that suppresses deafness in the 7 nonpenetrant individuals was mapped to a 5.6-cM region on chromosome 1q24 with a lod score of 4.31 at theta=0 for D1S2815.

Mutations in COL11A2 cause non-syndromic hearing loss (DFNA13).

We report that mutation of COL11A2 causes deafness previously mapped to the DFNA13 locus on chromosome 6p. We found two families (one American and one Dutch) with autosomal dominant, non-syndromic hearing loss to have mutations in COL11A2 that are predicted to affect the triple-helix domain of the collagen protein. In both families, deafness is non-progressive and predominantly affects middle frequencies. Mice with a targeted disruption of Col11a2 also were shown to have hearing loss. Electron microscopy of the tectorial membrane of these mice revealed loss of organization of the collagen fibrils. Our findings revealed a unique ultrastructural malformation of inner-ear architecture associated with non-syndromic hearing loss, and suggest that tectorial membrane abnormalities may be one aetiology of sensorineural hearing loss primarily affecting the mid-frequencies.

Do mutations of the Pendred syndrome gene, SLC26A4, confer resistance to asthma and hypertension?

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Mutations of SLC26A4 cause Pendred syndrome, an autosomal recessive disorder comprising goitre and deafness with enlarged vestibular aqueducts (EVA). Recent studies in mouse models implicate Slc26a4 in the pathogenesis of asthma and hypertension. We hypothesise that asthma and hypertension are less prevalent among humans with SLC26A4 mutations. METHODS: We reviewed medical histories and SLC26A4 genotypes for 80 individuals with EVA and 130 of their unaffected family members enrolled in a study of EVA. We used Fisher's exact test to compare the prevalence of asthma and hypertension among groups of subjects with zero, one, or two mutant alleles of SLC26A4. RESULTS: Although none of the 21 subjects with two mutant alleles of SLC26A4 had asthma or hypertension, there were no statistically significant differences in the prevalence of asthma or hypertension among subjects with zero, one, or two mutant alleles. CONCLUSION: There might be a protective effect of SLC26A4 mutations for asthma and hypertension but our study is statistically underpowered to detect this effect. Study sizes of at least 1125 and 504 individuals will be needed for 80% power to detect an effect at alpha = 0.05 for asthma and hypertension, respectively. Our hypothesis merits a larger study since it has implications for potential strategies to treat hearing loss by manipulating SLC26A4 expression or function.

Segregation of enlarged vestibular aqueducts in families with non-diagnostic SLC26A4 genotypes.

BACKGROUND: Hearing loss with enlarged vestibular aqueduct (EVA) can be inherited as an autosomal recessive trait caused by bi-allelic mutations of SLC26A4. However, many EVA patients have non-diagnostic SLC26A4 genotypes with only one or no detectable mutant alleles. METHODS AND RESULTS: In this study, the authors were unable to detect occult SLC26A4 mutations in EVA patients with non-diagnostic genotypes by custom comparative genomic hybridisation (CGH) microarray analysis or by sequence analysis of conserved non-coding regions. The authors sought to compare the segregation of EVA among 71 families with two (M2), one (M1) or no (M0) detectable mutant alleles of SLC26A4. The segregation ratios of EVA in the M1 and M2 groups were similar, but the segregation ratio for M1 was significantly higher than in the M0 group. Haplotype analyses of SLC26A4-linked STR markers in M0 and M1 families revealed discordant segregation of EVA with these markers in eight of 24 M0 families. CONCLUSION: The results support the hypothesis of a second, undetected SLC26A4 mutation that accounts for EVA in the M1 patients, in contrast to non-genetic factors, complex inheritance, or aetiologic heterogeneity in the M0 group of patients. These results will be helpful for counselling EVA families with non-diagnostic SLC26A4 genotypes.

Identities and frequencies of mutations of the otoferlin gene (OTOF) causing DFNB9 deafness in Pakistan.

Mutations in OTOF, encoding otoferlin, cause non-syndromic recessive hearing loss. The goal of our study was to define the identities and frequencies of OTOF mutations in a model population. We screened a cohort of 557 large consanguineous Pakistani families segregating recessive, severe-to-profound, prelingual-onset deafness for linkage to DFNB9. There were 13 families segregating deafness consistent with linkage to markers for DFNB9. We analyzed the genomic nucleotide sequence of OTOF and detected probable pathogenic sequence variants among all 13 families. These include the previously reported nonsense mutation p.R708X and 10 novel variants: 3 nonsense mutations (p.R425X, p.W536X, and p.Y1603X), 1 frameshift (c.1103_1104delinsC), 1 single amino acid deletion (p.E766del) and 5 missense substitutions of conserved residues (p.L573R, p.A1090E, p.E1733K, p.R1856Q and p.R1939W). OTOF mutations thus account for deafness in 13 (2.3%) of 557 Pakistani families. This overall prevalence is similar, but the mutation spectrum is different from those for Western populations. In addition, we demonstrate the existence of an alternative splice isoform of OTOF expressed in the human cochlea. This isoform must be required for human hearing because it encodes a unique alternative C-terminus affected by some DFNB9 mutations.

A locus for autosomal dominant progressive non-syndromic hearing loss, DFNA27, is on chromosome 4q12-13.1.

We ascertained a large North American family, LMG2, segregating progressive, non-syndromic, sensorineural hearing loss. A genome-wide scan identified significant evidence for linkage (maximum logarithm of the odds (LOD) score = 4.67 at theta = 0 for D4S398) to markers in a 5.7-cM interval on chromosome 4q12-13.1. The DFNA27 interval spans 8.85 Mb and includes at least 61 predicted and 8 known genes. We sequenced eight genes and excluded them as candidates for the DFNA27 gene.

Haplogroup analysis supports a pathogenic role for the 7510T>C mutation of mitochondrial tRNA(Ser(UCN)) in sensorineural hearing loss.

We ascertained a large North American family, LMG309, with matrilineal transmission of non-syndromic, progressive sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL). There was no history of aminoglycoside exposure, and penetrance was complete. We sequenced the entire mitochondrial genome and identified the previously reported 7510T>C transition in the tRNA(Ser(UCN)) gene. The 7510T>C was homoplasmic in all affected members. The LMG309 mitochondrial sequence belongs to an unnamed subgroup of mitochondrial haplogroup H. We demonstrate that the previously reported Spanish family S258 carries 7510T>C on a different mitochondrial sub-haplogroup, H1. We did not detect 7510T>C among 79 Caucasian haplogroup H control samples, including 11 from sub-haplogroup H1 and one from the same sub-haplogroup as LMG309. Our results provide strong genetic evidence that 7510T>C is a pathogenic mutation that causes non-syndromic SNHL.

Mutations of ESPN cause autosomal recessive deafness and vestibular dysfunction.

We mapped a human deafness locus DFNB36 to chromosome 1p36.3 in two consanguineous families segregating recessively inherited deafness and vestibular areflexia. This phenotype co-segregates with either of two frameshift mutations, 1988delAGAG and 2469delGTCA, in ESPN, which encodes a calcium-insensitive actin-bundling protein called espin. A recessive mutation of ESPN is known to cause hearing loss and vestibular dysfunction in the jerker mouse. Our results establish espin as an essential protein for hearing and vestibular function in humans. The abnormal vestibular phenotype associated with ESPN mutations will be a useful clinical marker for refining the differential diagnosis of non-syndromic deafness.

Origins and frequencies of SLC26A4 (PDS) mutations in east and south Asians: global implications for the epidemiology of deafness.

Recessive mutations of SLC26A4 (PDS) are a common cause of Pendred syndrome and non-syndromic deafness in western populations. Although south and east Asia contain nearly one half of the global population, the origins and frequencies of SLC26A4 mutations in these regions are unknown. We PCR amplified and sequenced seven exons of SLC26A4 to detect selected mutations in 274 deaf probands from Korea, China, and Mongolia. A total of nine different mutations of SLC26A4 were detected among 15 (5.5%) of the 274 probands. Five mutations were novel and the other four had seldom, if ever, been identified outside east Asia. To identify mutations in south Asians, 212 Pakistani and 106 Indian families with three or more affected offspring of consanguineous matings were analysed for cosegregation of recessive deafness with short tandem repeat markers linked to SLC26A4. All 21 SLC26A4 exons were PCR amplified and sequenced in families segregating SLC26A4 linked deafness. Eleven mutant alleles of SLC26A4 were identified among 17 (5.4%) of the 318 families, and all 11 alleles were novel. SLC26A4 linked haplotypes on chromosomes with recurrent mutations were consistent with founder effects. Our observation of a diverse allelic series unique to each ethnic group indicates that mutational events at SLC26A4 are common and account for approximately 5% of recessive deafness in south Asians and other populations.

Progressive irreversible hearing loss is caused by stria vascularis degeneration in an Slc26a4-insufficient mouse model of large vestibular aqueduct syndrome.

Hearing loss of patients with enlargement of the vestibular aqueduct (EVA) can fluctuate or progress, with overall downward progression. The most common detectable cause of EVA is mutations of SLC26A4. We previously described a transgenic Slc26a4-insufficient mouse model of EVA in which Slc26a4 expression is controlled by doxycycline administration. Mice that received doxycycline from conception until embryonic day 17.5 (DE17.5; doxycycline discontinued at embryonic day 17.5) had fluctuating hearing loss between 1 and 6 months of age with an overall downward progression after 6 months of age. In this study, we characterized the cochlear functional and structural changes underlying irreversible hearing loss in DE17.5 mice at 12 months of age. The endocochlear potential was decreased and inversely correlated with auditory brainstem response thresholds. The stria vascularis was thickened and edematous in ears with less severe hearing loss, and thinned and atrophic in ears with more severe hearing loss. There were pathologic changes in marginal cell morphology and gene expression that were not observed at 3 months. We conclude that strial dysfunction and degeneration are the primary causes of irreversible progressive hearing loss in our Slc26a4-insufficient mouse model of EVA. This model of primary strial atrophy may be used to explore the mechanisms of progressive hearing loss due to strial dysfunction.

The murine gene encoding the highly conserved Sm B protein contains a nonfunctional alternative 3' splice site.

The cDNA and partial genomic nucleotide (nt) sequences were derived for the mouse Sm B polypeptide and compared to the cDNA and genomic sequences encoding human Sm B. The deduced amino acid (aa) sequences from the mouse and human genes are identical with the exception of a single conserved aa substitution, accounting for the ability of anti-Sm antibodies to recognize the Sm polypeptides from a broad range of species. The genomic sequence of mouse B gene is similar to the human B genomic locus that extends from exon 6 to exon 7. These loci include conservation of both 3' alternative splice sites and putative branch points required to process B and B' mRNAs in human cells. However, the nt sequence downstream from the putative distal 3' splice junction and single nt flanking the 3' splice site consensus sequence, differ between mouse and human B. This results in a murine mRNA with a different predicted secondary structure around the distal 3' splice site when compared to humans. Thus, secondary structural constraints in the mRNA or changes in the exon sequence might prevent recognition of this alternative splice site to form B' mRNA in murine tissues.

Familial large vestibular aqueduct syndrome.

The large vestibular aqueduct syndrome (LVAS) is a distinct clinical entity characterized by stepwise progressive sensorineural hearing loss associated with isolated enlargement of the vestibular aqueduct. A correlative clinical, audiologic, vestibular, cytogenetic, and radiographic analysis of a family with inherited LVAS was performed. The male proband and his affected brother are offspring of unaffected parents, and have no other abnormalities. Pedigree analysis suggests autosomal recessive or X-linked inheritance with variable expressivity of LVAS in this family. This study is the first description of familial inheritance of LVAS. LVAS may account for a significant number of patients with nonsyndromal, genetic sensorineural hearing loss. Future molecular analyses of this study family may identify the causative gene(s) in LVAS.

Familial Mondini dysplasia.

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: To determine the mode of inheritance of familial nonsyndromic Mondini dysplasia. STUDY DESIGN: Correlative clinical genetic analysis of a single kindred. METHODS: Clinical history, physical examination, audiologic analysis, computed tomography of the temporal bones, and cytogenetic analysis. RESULTS: The male proband, three affected sisters, and an affected brother are offspring of unaffected parents. The mother and an unaffected brother have audiologic findings suggestive of heterozygous carrier status for a recessive hearing loss gene. CONCLUSIONS: Pedigree analysis indicates autosomal recessive inheritance in this family. The observed inheritance and clinical, audiologic, and radiologic findings are different from those previously described for another family with nonsyndromic Mondini dysplasia. The phenotype in this study family therefore represents a distinct subtype, indicating clinical and genetic heterogeneity of this disorder. This information should facilitate future molecular linkage analyses and genetic counselling of patients with inner ear malformations.

Audiovestibular phenotype associated with a COL11A1 mutation in Marshall syndrome.

BACKGROUND: Marshall syndrome is a dominant disorder characterized by craniofacial and skeletal abnormalities, sensorineural hearing loss, myopia, and cataracts, and is associated with splicing mutations in COL11A1. OBJECTIVE: To determine the auditory and vestibular phenotypes associated with a COL11A1 splicing. DESIGN: Clinical otolaryngologic, audiologic, vestibular, and radiologic evaluations of the auditory and vestibular systems. SUBJECTS: Three affected individuals from a family cosegregating Marshall syndrome and a COL11A1 splice site mutation. RESULTS: The study subjects have progressive sensorineural hearing loss that is predominantly cochlear in origin and asymptomatic dysfunction of the central and peripheral vestibular systems. Computed tomography detected no malformations of temporal bone structures. CONCLUSIONS: The observed auditory and vestibular abnormalities are not caused by defective morphogenesis of the osseous labyrinth, but by more direct effects of the COL11A1 mutation on the membranous labyrinth and the central nervous system. The onset and degree of hearing loss associated with COL11A1 mutations are useful clinical features to differentiate Marshall syndrome from the phenotypically similar Stickler syndrome.

Auditory dysfunction in Stickler syndrome.

OBJECTIVES: To characterize the natural history and possible mechanisms of hearing loss in Stickler syndrome (OMIM 108300; or hereditary progressive arthro-ophthalmopathy) and to determine if the auditory phenotype is a useful discriminating feature for the differential diagnosis of this group of disorders. DESIGN: Multifamily study. SETTING: Outpatient audiology and otolaryngology clinics at the Warren Grant Magnuson Clinical Center of the National Institutes of Health, Rockville, Md. SUBJECTS: Forty-six affected individuals from 29 different families segregating Stickler syndrome. INTERVENTIONS: Clinical audiologic and otolaryngological examinations were performed on all individuals, including pure-tone audiometry, speech audiometry, and middle ear immittance testing. Otoacoustic emissions, auditory brainstem response, infrared video electronystagmography, and temporal bone computed tomography were performed on a subset of participants. RESULTS: The hearing loss was most often sensorineural in adults, and approximately 28 (60%) of the 46 adult patients had 2 or more thresholds greater than the corresponding 95th percentile values for an age-matched, otologically normal population. The hearing loss most often affected high frequencies (4000-8000 Hz) and was generally no more progressive than that due to age-related hearing loss. Type A(D) tympanograms (classification using the Jerger model), indicating hypermobile middle ear systems, were observed in 21 (46%) of the 46 affected individuals. Computed tomography of the temporal bones revealed no inner ear malformations in 19 affected individuals. CONCLUSIONS: The hypermobile middle ear systems observed in ears with normal-appearing tympanic membranes represent a novel finding for Stickler syndrome and are likely to be a useful diagnostic feature for this disorder. The overall sensorineural hearing loss in type I Stickler syndrome is typically mild and not significantly progressive. It is less severe than that reported for types II and III Stickler syndrome linked to COL11A2 (OMIM 120290) and COL11A1 (OMIM 120280) mutations, respectively, or the closely related Marshall syndrome. This difference will be a useful discriminatory feature in the differential diagnosis of this group of disorders.