Previous Experience Seems Crucial to Eliminate the Sex Gap in Geometry Learning When Solving a Navigation Task in Rats (Rattus norvegicus).

There is much evidence, both in humans and rodents, that while navigating males tend to use geometric information whereas females rely more on landmarks. The present work attempts to alter the geometry bias in female rats. In Experiment 1 three groups of female rats were trained in a triangular-shaped pool to find a hidden platform, whose location was defined in terms of two sources of information, a landmark outside the pool and a particular corner of the pool. On a subsequent test trial with the triangular pool and no landmark, females with prior experience with two other pool shapes-with a kite-shaped pool and with a rectangular-shaped pool (Group Long Previous Experience, LPE), were significantly more accurate than control rats without such prior experience (Group No Previous Experience, NPE). Rats with a short previous experience-with the rectangular-shaped pool only (Group Short Previous Experience, SPE) did not differ from Group NPE. These results suggest that the previous experience with different shaped-pools could counteract the geometry bias in female rats. Then, Experiment 2A directly compared the performance of LPE males and females of Experiment 1, although conducting several test trials (i.e., shape, landmark, and preference). The differences between males and females disappeared in the three tests. Moreover, in a final test trial both males and females could identify the correct corner in an incomplete pool by its local, instead of global, properties. Finally, Experiment 2B compared the performance of NPE rats, males and females, of Experiment 1. On the test trial with the triangular pool and no landmark, males were significantly more accurate than females. The results are explained in the framework of selective attention.

Directional cues and landmark configurations: The effect of rotating one set of landmarks relative to another.

In this article we addressed the question whether rats can use distal landmarks as directional cues that are used in combination with other proximal landmark configurations. The animals were trained with an A, B, C, and D landmark configuration in the Morris pool, where B and C are the near (to platform) landmarks and A and D the far ones. We also added another more distal "directional" cue Z (a white strip attached to the black curtain surrounding the pool). Experiment 1a shows a robust detrimental effect on the time spent by the rats swimming in the platform quadrant when the location of all landmarks was "Inverted" (rotated by 180 degrees) with respect to Z. A similar detrimental effect was found when, after the inversion manipulation, the locations of the near and far landmarks were "Flipped" (B swapped with C and A with D). Rats in both Inverted and Flipped tests spent more time in the Z quadrant compared to the platform quadrant (BC). Experiment 1b provided evidence distinguishing between alternative explanations of how the directional cue Z acts in combination with the other landmarks. The results from both experiments show that Z operates differently to the standard landmarks. It can function as a beacon in its own right. It can also combine with the other landmarks to produce a high level of search performance, in a way that we hypothesize to be distinct from that described by the configural analysis often applied to multiple landmarks. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).

What makes a landmark effective in adolescent and adult rats? Sex and age differences in a navigation task.

In three experiments, rats of different ages were trained in a circular pool to find a hidden platform whose location was defined in terms of a single landmark, a cylinder outside the pool. Following training, two main components of the landmark, its shape and pattern, were tested individually. Experiment 1 was performed by adolescent and adult rats (Exp. 1a, males; Exp. 1b, females). Adult rats always learned faster than the adolescent animals. On test trials, interesting tendencies were found-mainly, one favoring males on the shape test trial, and another favoring females on the pattern test trial. Experiment 2 was conducted only with adolescent rats, and these males and females did not differ when learning the task. However, on test trials the males learned more about the landmark shape component than about the landmark pattern component, while the females learned equally about the two components of the landmark. Finally, Experiment 3 was conducted only with adult rats, and again the males and females did not differ when learning the task. However, on test trials the males learned equally about the two components of the landmark (shape and pattern), but the females learned more about the landmark pattern component than about the landmark shape component. This set of experiments supports the claim that male and female rats can learn rather different things about a landmark that signals the location of the platform, with age being a critical variable.

Environmental enrichment in the absence of wheel running produces beneficial behavioural and anti-oxidative effects in rats.

The effects of early environmental enrichment (EE) when solving a simple spatial task in adult male rats were assessed. After weaning, rats were housed in pairs in enriched or standard cages (EE and control groups) for two and a half months. Then the rats were trained in a triangular-shaped pool to find a hidden platform whose location was defined in terms of two sources of information, a landmark outside the pool and a particular corner of the pool. As expected, enriched rats reached the platform faster than control animals. Enriched rats also performed better on a subsequent test trial without the platform with the geometry cue individually presented (in the absence of the landmark). Most importantly, the beneficial effects of the present protocol were obtained in the absence of wheel running. Additionally, the antioxidative effects in the hippocampus produced by the previous protocol are also shown.

Sex differences after environmental enrichment and physical exercise in rats when solving a navigation task.

The effects of early environmental enrichment (EE) and voluntary wheel running on the preference for using a landmark or pool geometry when solving a simple spatial task in adult male and female rats were assessed. After weaning, rats were housed in same-sex pairs in enriched or standard cages (EE and control groups) for two and a half months. Then the rats were trained in a triangular-shaped pool to find a hidden platform whose location was defined in terms of these two sources of information, a landmark outside the pool and a particular corner of the pool. As expected, enriched rats reached the platform faster than control animals, and males and females did not differ. Enriched rats also performed better on subsequent test trials without the platform with the cues individually presented (either pool geometry or landmark). However, on a preference test without the platform, a clear sex difference was found: Females spent more time in an area of the pool that corresponded to the landmark, whereas males spent more time in the distinctive corner of the pool. The present EE protocol did not alter females' preference for the landmark cue. The results agree with the claim that environmental enrichment is a consequence of a reduced anxiety response (measured by thigmotaxis) during cognitive testing. A possible implication of ancestral selection pressures is discussed.

What makes a landmark effective? Sex differences in a navigation task.

In Experiment 1, two groups of female rats were trained in a triangular pool to find a hidden platform whose location was defined in terms of a single a landmark, a cylinder outside the pool. For one group, the landmark had only a single pattern (i.e., it looked the same when approached from any direction), while for the other, the landmark contained four different patterns (i.e., it looked different when approached from different directions). The first group learned to swim to the platform more rapidly than the second. Experiment 2 confirmed this difference when female rats were trained in a circular pool but found that male rats learned equally rapidly (and as rapidly as females trained with the single-pattern landmark) with both landmarks. This second finding was confirmed in Experiment 3. Finally, in Experiment 4a and 4b, male and female rats were trained either with the same, single-pattern landmark on all trials or with a different landmark each day. Males learned equally rapidly (and as rapidly as females trained with the unchanged landmark) whether the landmark changed or not. We conclude that male and female rats learn rather different things about the landmark that signals the location of the platform.

Landmark vs. geometry learning: explaining female rats' selective preference for a landmark / Aprendizaje basado en un punto de referencia vs.aprendizaje de la geometría: explicando la preferencia selectiva de las ratas hembra por un punto de referencia

Rats were trained in a triangular-shaped pool to find a hidden platform, whose location was defined in terms of two sources of information, a landmark outside the pool and a particular corner of the pool. Subsequent test trials without the platform pitted these two sources of information against one another. In Experiment 1 this test revealed a clear, although selective, sex difference. As in previous experiments, females spent more time in an area of the pool that corresponded to the landmark, but here only when it was a cone but not when it was a pyramid. Males, on the other hand, always spent more time in the distinctive corner of the pool. Experiments 2 and 3 were only with female rats. In Experiment 2 two identical shaped cylinders were used as landmark cues (one plain white and the other vertically patterned with four different patterns). The results of the preference test revealed that only the females trained and tested with the plain cylinder spent more time in the area of the pool that corresponded to the landmark than in the distinctive corner of the pool. Finally, Experiment 3 replicated the results of Experiment 2 while eliminating an alternative explanation in terms of differential contrast between the two cylinders and the black curtain (AU)

Se entrenó a unas ratas en una piscina con forma triangular a que encontrasen una plataforma oculta, cuya ubicación estaba definida en base a dos fuentes de información, un punto de referencia y una parte de la piscina con una forma distintiva. Ensayos de prueba posteriores, sin la plataforma, enfrentaron la forma y el punto de referencia. En el Experimento 1 esta prueba reveló una diferencia de sexo clara, aunque selectiva. Como en experimentos anteriores, las hembras pasaron más tiempo en el área de la piscina que se correspondía con el punto de referencia, aunque sólo cuando este era un cono no cuando era una pirámide. Por otro lado, los machos siempre pasaron más tiempo en el área de la piscina que se correspondía con la forma distintiva. Los Experimentos 2 y 3 se llevaron a cabo sólo con ratas hembra. En el Experimento 2 se emplearon como puntos de referencia dos formas cilíndricas idénticas (una de color blanco y la otra verticalmente dividida en cuatro segmentos con trama diferente). Los resultados de las pruebas de preferencia revelaron que solamente las hembras entrenadas y puestas a prueba con el cilindro blanco pasaron más tiempo en el área de la piscina que se correspondía con el punto de referencia que en el área de la piscina que se correspondía con la forma distintiva. Por último, el Experimento 3 replicó los resultados de los Experimentos 1 y 2 eliminando una explicación alternativa basada en el contraste diferente de los dos cilindros respecto a las cortinas negras (AU)

Do hormonal changes that appear at the onset of puberty determine the strategies used by female rats when solving a navigation task?

The present set of experiments evaluated the possibility that the hormonal changes that appear at the onset of puberty might influence the strategies used by female rats to solve a spatial navigation task. In each experiment, rats were trained in a triangular shaped pool to find a hidden platform which maintained a constant relationship with two sources of information, one individual landmark and one corner of the pool with a distinctive geometry. Then, three test trials were conducted without the platform in counterbalanced order. In one, both the geometry and the landmark were simultaneously presented, although in different spatial positions, in order to measure the rats' preferences. In the remaining test trials what the rats had learned about the two sources of information was measured by presenting them individually. Experiment 1, with 60-day old rats, revealed a clear sex difference, thus replicating a previous finding (Rodríguez et al., 2010): females spent more time in an area of the pool that corresponded to the landmark, whereas males spent more time in the distinctive corner of the pool even though the remaining tests revealed that both sexes had learned about the two sources of information. In Experiment 2, 30-day old female rats, unlike adults, preferred to solve the task using the geometry information rather than the landmark (although juvenile males behaved in exactly the same way as adults). Experiment 3 directly compared the performance of 90- and 30-day old females and found that while the adult females preferred to solve the task using the landmark, the reverse was true in juvenile females. Experiment 4 compared ovariectomized and sham operated females and found that while sham operated females preferred to solve the task using the landmark, the reverse was true in ovariectomized females. Finally, Experiment 5 directly compared adult males and females, juvenile males and females, and ovariectomized females and found that adult males, juvenile males and females, and ovariectomized females did not differ among them in their preferred cue, but they all differed from adult females.

Gender differences in landmark learning for virtual navigation: the role of distance to a goal.

We used a new virtual program in two experiments to prepare subjects to perform the Morris water task (www.nesplora.com). The subjects were Psychology students; they were trained to locate a safe platform amidst the presence of four pinpoint landmarks spaced around the edge of the pool (i.e., two landmarks relatively near the platform and two landmarks relatively distant away from it). At the end of the training phase, we administered one test trial without the platform and recorded the amount of time that the students had spent in the platform quadrant. In Experiment 1, we conducted the test trial in the presence of one or two of the distant landmarks. When only one landmark was present during testing, performance fell to chance. However, the men outperformed the women when the two distant landmarks were both present. Experiment 2 replicated the previous results and extended it by showing that no sex differences exist when the searching process is based on the near landmarks. Both the men and the women had similarly good performances when the landmarks were present both individually and together. When present together, an addition effect was found. Far landmark tests favor configural learning processes, whereas near landmark tests favor elemental learning. Our findings suggest that other factors in addition to the use of directional cues can underlie the sex differences in the spatial learning process. Thus, we expand upon previous research in the field.

Overshadowing and blocking between landmark learning and shape learning: the importance of sex differences.

Rats were trained in a triangular-shaped pool to find a hidden platform that maintained a constant relationship with two sources of information, an individual landmark and one part of the pool with a distinctive shape. In Experiment 1, shape learning overshadowed landmark learning but landmark learning did not overshadow shape learning in males, while landmark learning overshadowed shape learning but shape learning did not overshadow landmark learning in females. In Experiment 2, rats were pretrained either with the single landmark relevant or with the shape relevant, in the absence of the alternative cue. Final test trials, without the platform, revealed reciprocal blocking only in females; in males, shape learning blocked landmark learning, but not viceversa (Experiment 2a). In Experiment 2b, male rats received a longer pretraining with the single landmark relevant, and now landmark learning blocked shape learning. The results thus confirm the claim that males and females partially use different types of spatial information when solving spatial tasks. These results also agree with the suggestion that shape learning interacts with landmark learning in much the same way as does learning about any pair of stimuli in a Pavlovian conditioning experiment.

Landmark learning in a navigation task is not affected by the female rats’ estrus cycle

En dos experimentos en piscina circular se entrenó a unas ratas a encontrar una plataforma invisible que estaba localizada siempre en el mismo lugar en relación a una configuración de dos puntos de referencia (X e Y), que se encontraban relativamente lejos y equidistantes de la plataforma. El entrenamiento se llevó a cabo durante días consecutivos (Experimento 1) o cada 4 días (Experimento 2). Ensayos de prueba posteriores, sin la plataforma, mostraron que las ratas preferían buscar en el cuadrante correcto de la piscina. En el Experimento 1 la ejecución en el ensayo de prueba fue idéntica en dos grupos de hembras, uno puesto a prueba con altos niveles hormonales (es decir, en la fase de proestro) y el otro con bajos niveles hormonales (concretamente, en la fase de estro, metaestro o diestro); además, ambos grupos de hembras difirieron de un tercer grupo de machos (los machos ejecutaron mejor la tarea que las hembras). El Experimento 2 replicó los datos anteriores obtenidos por las hembras, con un procedimiento mejorado. El experimento comparó la ejecución de dos grupos de hembras que fueron entrenados y puestos a prueba siempre en la misma fase del ciclo estral, un grupo en la fase de proestro y el segundo en la fase de estro. La implicación de estos resultados es que el ciclo estral tiene muy poco impacto en el aprendizaje basado en puntos de referencia en una tarea de navegación espacial(AU)

In two experiments rats were required to escape from a circular pool by swimming to an invisible platform that was located in the same place relative to one configuration of two landmarks (X and Y). The two landmarks were placed relatively far and equidistant from the hidden platform. Training could be either on consecutive days (Experiment 1) or every fourth day (Experiment 2). Subsequent test trials, without the platform, revealed a preference for searching in the correct quadrant of the pool. In Experiment 1 such a test performance was identical in two groups of females, one tested with high hormonal levels (i.e., in the proestrus phase) and the second one tested with low hormonal levels (i.e., either in the estrus, metaestrus or diestrus phase); in addition, these two groups differed from a third group of male rats (i.e., males had a better performance than females). Experiment 2 replicated the females’ previous results with a better procedure. The experiment compared the performance of two groups of female rats which were both trained and tested always in the same estrus phase, one group in the proestrus phase, and the second group in the estrus phase. The implication of these results is that the estrus cycle has little impact on the performance of female rats when landmark learning in a navigation task(AU)

Sex differences in the strategies used by rats to solve a navigation task.

Rats were trained in a triangular-shaped pool to find a hidden platform, whose location was defined in terms of two sources of information, a landmark outside the pool and a particular corner of the pool. Subsequent test trials without the platform pitted these two sources of information against one another. This test revealed a clear sex difference. Females spent more time in an area of the pool that corresponded to the landmark, whereas males spent more time in the distinctive corner of the pool even though further tests revealed that both sexes had learned about the two sources of information by presenting cues individually. The results agree with the claim that males and females use different types of information in spatial navigation.

Conditioned inhibition in the spatial domain.

Using a variation on the standard procedure of conditioned inhibition (Trials A+ and AX-), rats (Rattus norvegicus) in a circular pool were trained to find a hidden platform that was located in a specific spatial position in relation to 2 individual landmarks (Trials A --> platform and B --> platform; Experiments 1a and 1b) and to 2 configurations of landmarks (Trials ABC --> platform and FGH --> platform; Experiment 2a). The rats also underwent inhibitory trials (Experiment 1: Trials AZ --> no platform; Experiment 2a: Trials CDE --> no platform) interspersed with these excitatory trials. In both experiments, subsequent test trials without the platform showed both a summation effect and retardation of excitatory conditioning, and in Experiment 2a rats learned to avoid the CDE quadrant over the course of the experiment. Two further experiments established that these results could not be attributed to any difference in salience between the conditioned inhibitors and the control stimuli. All these results contribute to the growing body of evidence consistent with the idea that there is a general mechanism of learning that is associative in nature.

Similarity and discrimination learning in humans.

In an experiment involving a new behavioural preparation the role played by similarity in discrimination learning was examined using visual patterns (i.e., paintings) that might share common elements (specifically, A, BC, and ABC). A-C were small stars of three specific colours (target colours), which were intermixed with other stars of two different colours (distracting colours). The target colours were balanced through A-C. Students received discrimination training in which a fictitious painter was the author of paintings A and BC, while paintings ABC were assigned to a second fictitious painter. During training, the students had to make a choice, in the presence of each pattern, between two response keys, each of them indicating one of the painters. The time taken to respond was also measured. Feedback was always given after each key-press. The results showed that while at times the A+ ABC- discrimination was acquired more readily than was the BC+ ABC- discrimination, on other occasions the reverse was also true, the critical factor being the way in which the colours were combined.

The influence of landmark salience in a navigation task: an additive effect between its components.

In 2 experiments, rats were trained in a Morris pool to find a hidden platform in the presence of 1 landmark. After acquisition, the rats were tested without the platform. Experiment 1 tested whether the size of a landmark and its relative distance from the platform are additive effects. On test, the rats' best performance was with a near and big landmark; intermediate performance was with either a near and small landmark or a far and big one; and the worst performance was with a far and small landmark. The results of Experiment 2 suggested that the different distances from the goal of the 2 landmarks might not be sufficient to explain the previous results.

Competition between landmarks in spatial learning: the role of proximity to the goal.

In two experiments, rats were trained to find a hidden platform in a Morris pool in the presence of two landmarks. Landmark B was present on all training trials, on half the trials accompanied by landmark A, on the remainder by landmark C. For rats in Group Bn, B was near the location of the platform; for those in Group Bf, B was far from the platform. Group Bn performed better than Group Bf on test trials to B alone, but significantly worse on test trials to a new configuration formed by A and C. Thus, the spatial proximity of B to the platform affected not only how well it could be used to locate the platform, but also its ability to prevent learning about other landmarks.

Spatial integration with rats.

Rats were trained to find the hidden platform in a Morris pool, whose location was defined by reference to a small number of landmarks around the circumference of the pool. In each of three experiments, an experimental group was trained on alternate trials with two different subsets of three of the available landmarks, with the two subsets sharing one landmark in common. When tested with landmarks drawn from both of their training configurations, but without the landmark common to the two sets, they had no difficulty in locating the platform. In Experiment 1, they performed at least as well as a group trained with all the available landmarks present on every trial. In Experiment 2, they performed significantly better than a group trained with two different subsets of landmarks that shared no one landmark in common.

Area and peak shift effects in a navigation task with rats

En dos experimentos en una piscina de Morris a unas ratas se las entrenó mediante un procedimiento de discriminación sucesiva en presencia de dos objetos o puntos de referencia. La separación angular entre los dos puntos de referencia indicaba la presencia (0 grados, ensayos E+) o la ausencia (90 grados, ensayos E-) de la plataforma. Tras el entrenamiento, las ratas recibieron ensayos no reforzados en los que uno de los puntos de referencia se presentaba en un rango de localizaciones en relación con el segundo punto de referencia. El gradiente de generalización que se obtuvo en el Experimento 1 mostró más insistencia en la respuesta en el lado del E+ que estaba situado en dirección opuesta al E-. A este efecto se le ha denominado desplazamiento del área. En el Experimento 2, con un entrenamiento discriminativo ligeramente diferente, se obtuvo un efecto moderado de desplazamiento del máximo. Estos experimentos con ratas muestran por primera vez los efectos de desplazamiento del área y del máximo cuando se manipulan localizaciones espaciales trabajando en una tarea de navegación

In two experiments in a Morris pool rats were trained with a successive discrimination procedure in the presence of two objects or landmarks. The angular separation between the two landmarks signalled either the presence (0 degrees, S+ trials) or the absence (90 degrees, S- trials) of the platform. After training the rats received unrewarded test trials in which one of the landmarks was presented at a range of places in relation to the second landmark. The generalization gradient obtained in Experiment 1 showed higher responding on the side of S+ away from S-. This effect has been called area shift. In Experiment 2, with a slightly different discrimination training, a moderate peak shift effect was obtained. The present experiments show for the first time area and peak shift effects with rats across spatial locations when working with a navigation task

Blocking and unblocking in a navigation task

Rodrigo, Chamizo, McLaren, & Mackintosh (1997) demonstrated theblocking effect in a navigational task using a swimming pool: rats initiallytrained to use three landmarks (ABC) to find an invisible platform learnedless about a fourth landmark (X) added later than did rats trained from theoutset with these four landmarks (ABCX). The aim of the experimentreported here was to demonstrate unblocking using a similar procedure as inthe previous work. Three groups of rats were initially trained to find aninvisible platfom in the presence of three landmarks: ABC for the Blockingand Unblocking groups and LMN for the Control group. Then, all animalswere trained to find the platform in the presence of four landmarks, ABCX.In this second training, unlike animals in the Blocking group to which onlya new landmark (X) was added in comparison to the first training, theanimals in the Unblocking group also had a change in the platform position.In the Control group, both the four landmarks and the platform positionwere totally new at the beginning of this second training. As in Rodrigo etal. (1997) a blocking effect was found: rats in the Blocking group learnedless with respect to the added landmark (X) than did animals in the Controlgroup. However, rats in the Unblocking group learned about the addedlandmark (X) as well as did animals in the Control group. The results areinterpreted as an unblocking effect due to a change in the platform positionbetween the two phases of training, similarly to what is normal in classicalconditioning experiments, in which a change in the conditions ofreinforcement between the two training phases of a blocking design producean attenuation or elimination of this effect. These results are explainedwithin an error-correcting connectionist account of spatial navigation(McLaren, 2002)

No disponible

Acquisition of knowledge about spatial location: assessing the generality of the mechanism of learning.

A selection of studies in the last 20 years is reviewed. These studies show basic Pavlovian phenomena in the spatial domain (like blocking, overshadowing, latent inhibition, and perceptual learning) with nonhuman subjects, specifically with rats, both in the radial maze and in the circular pool. The generality of these phenomena with respect to other species and to other spatial preparations is also discussed. The conclusion is that the mechanism responsible for the acquisition of knowledge about spatial location seems to be associative in nature.