Training the next generation of genomic medicine providers: trends in medical education and national assessment.

PURPOSE: To assess the utilization of genetics on the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE®). METHODS: A team of clinical genetics educators performed an analysis of the representation of genetics content on a robust sample of recent Step 1, Step 2 Clinical Knowledge (CK), and Step 3 examination forms. The content of each question was mapped to curriculum recommendations from the peer reviewed Association of Professors of Human and Medical Genetics white paper, Medical School Core Curriculum in Genetics, and the USMLE Content Outline. RESULTS: The committee identified 13.4%, 10.4%, and 4.4% of Steps 1, 2 and 3 respectively, as having genetics content. The genetics content of the exams became less pertinent to the questions from Step 1 to 3, with decreasing genetics content by exam and increasing percentages of questions identified as having genetics content in the distractors only. CONCLUSION: The current distribution of genetics in USMLE licensing examinations reflects traditional curricular approaches with genetics as a basic science course in the early years of medical school and de-emphasizes clinical relevance of the field. These observations support the notion that further integration is required to move genetics into the clinical curriculum of medical schools and the clinical content of USMLE Step exams.

The Current State of Newborn Screening in the United States.

Newborn screening has evolved since its introduction in 1963. The disorders that are being screened for continue to evolve as new treatments and new technologies advance. In this review, the authors discuss the current state of newborn screening in the United States, including the disorders currently being screened for and how newborn screening is performed. They also discuss the special considerations and limitations of newborn screening in sick and premature infants and as well as some ethical issues related to newborn screening. Finally, new disorders being considered for testing and new technologies that may be used in the future of newborn screening are discussed.

Allelic spectrum of formiminotransferase-cyclodeaminase gene variants in individuals with formiminoglutamic aciduria.

BACKGROUND: Elevated plasma and urine formiminoglutamic acid (FIGLU) levels are commonly indicative of formiminoglutamic aciduria (OMIM #229100), a poorly understood autosomal recessive disorder of histidine and folate metabolism, resulting from formiminotransferase-cyclodeaminase (FTCD) deficiency, a bifunctional enzyme encoded by FTCD. METHODS: In order to further understanding about the molecular alterations that contribute to FIGLU-uria, we sequenced FTCD in 20 individuals with putative FTCD deficiency and varying laboratory findings, including increased FIGLU excretion. RESULTS: Individuals tested had biallelic loss-of-function variants in protein-coding regions of FTCD. The FTCD allelic spectrum comprised of 12 distinct variants including 5 missense alterations that replace conserved amino acid residues (c.223A>C, c.266A>G, c.319T>C, c.430G>A, c.514G>T), an in-frame deletion (c.1373_1375delTGG), with the remaining alterations predicted to affect mRNA processing/stability. These included two frameshift variants (c.990dup, c.1366dup) and four nonsense variants (c.337C>T, c.451A>T, c.763C>T, c.1607T>A). CONCLUSION: We observed additional FTCD alleles leading to urinary FIGLU elevations, and thus, providing molecular evidence of FTCD deficiency in cases identified by newborn screening or clinical biochemical genetic laboratory testing.

Recommendations for the integration of genomics into clinical practice.

The introduction of diagnostic clinical genome and exome sequencing (CGES) is changing the scope of practice for clinical geneticists. Many large institutions are making a significant investment in infrastructure and technology, allowing clinicians to access CGES, especially as health-care coverage begins to extend to clinically indicated genomic sequencing-based tests. Translating and realizing the comprehensive clinical benefits of genomic medicine remain a key challenge for the current and future care of patients. With the increasing application of CGES, it is necessary for geneticists and other health-care providers to understand its benefits and limitations in order to interpret the clinical relevance of genomic variants identified in the context of health and disease. New, collaborative working relationships with specialists across diverse disciplines (e.g., clinicians, laboratorians, bioinformaticians) will undoubtedly be key attributes of the future practice of clinical genetics and may serve as an example for other specialties in medicine. These new skills and relationships will also inform the development of the future model of clinical genetics training curricula. To address the evolving role of the clinical geneticist in the rapidly changing climate of genomic medicine, two Clinical Genetics Think Tank meetings were held that brought together physicians, laboratorians, scientists, genetic counselors, trainees, and patients with experience in clinical genetics, genetic diagnostics, and genetics education. This article provides recommendations that will guide the integration of genomics into clinical practice.Genet Med 18 11, 1075-1084.

Outcomes of referrals to Child Protective Services for medical neglect in patients with phenylketonuria: Experiences at a single treatment center.

Phenylketonuria (PKU) results in an accumulation of phenylalanine (phe) in the blood which can lead to multiple health consequences in affected individuals. Treatment for PKU is available; however adherence to medical management recommendations can be difficult. When recommendations are not followed and the health of a child is at risk, one intervention that may be necessary is a referral for medical neglect to the local child protective services (CPS) agency. This study summarizes the cases that were referred from our metabolic clinic at the Children's Hospital of Michigan to CPS, and the outcomes of that intervention. CPS referrals helped to improve adherence to medical management recommendations in the majority of cases, including a lower blood phe level for the child; however, at times that improvement did not occur until after a second referral and/or the child's temporary removal from the home.

Outcomes of individuals with profound and partial biotinidase deficiency ascertained by newborn screening in Michigan over 25 years.

PURPOSE: Biotinidase deficiency, if untreated, usually results in neurological and cutaneous symptoms. Biotin supplementation markedly improves and likely prevents symptoms in those treated early. All states in the United States and many countries perform newborn screening for biotinidase deficiency. However, there are few studies about the outcomes of the individuals identified by newborn screening. METHODS: We report the outcomes of 142 children with biotinidase deficiency identified by newborn screening in Michigan over a 25-year period and followed in our clinic; 22 had profound deficiency and 120 had partial deficiency. RESULTS: Individuals with profound biotinidase and partial deficiency identified by newborn screening were started on biotin therapy soon after birth. With good compliance, these children appeared to have normal physical and cognitive development. Although some children exhibited mild clinical problems, these are unlikely attributable to the disorder. Biotin therapy appears to prevent the development of neurological and cutaneous problems in our population. CONCLUSION: Individuals with biotinidase deficiency ascertained by newborn screening and treated since birth appeared to exhibit normal physical and cognitive development. If an individual does develop symptoms, after compliance and dosage issues are excluded, then other causes must be considered.Genet Med 17 3, 205-209.

Extra alleles in FMR1 triple-primed PCR: artifact, aneuploidy, or somatic mosaicism?

Triple-primed PCR assays have become the preferred fragile X syndrome testing method. Using a commercially available assay, we detected a reproducible extra peak(s) in 0.5% of 13,161 clinical samples. The objectives of this study were to determine the cause of these extra peaks; to identify whether these peaks represent an assay specific artifact, an underlying chromosome aneuploidy, or somatic mosaicism; and to ascertain their clinical relevance. The presence of an extra allele(s) was confirmed by a laboratory-developed PCR, with sequencing of the FMR1 5' UTR or Southern blot for some samples. The laboratory-developed procedure detected the extra allele(s) in 57 of 64 samples. Thus, we confirmed an extra peak, typically of lower abundance, in approximately 0.4% of all samples. Of these samples, 5 were from males and 52 were from heterozygous or homozygous females. Six patients likely had X chromosome aneuploidies. In 82.3% of samples, the extra allele had fewer repeats than the predominant allele(s). Additional alleles detected by FMR1 triple-primed PCR are not an assay-specific artifact and are likely due to X chromosome aneuploidies or somatic repeat instability. Additional normal alleles likely have no clinical significance for fragile X syndrome carrier or affected status. Extra alleles in individuals with normal karyotypes probably represent FMR1 somatic variation.

Results of the College of American Pathology/American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics external proficiency testing from 2006 to 2013 for three conditions prevalent in the Ashkenazi Jewish population.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to determine analytic performance of laboratories offering molecular testing for conditions such as Tay-Sachs disease, Canavan disease, and familial dysautonomia, which are prevalent in the Ashkenazi Jewish population. METHODS: The College of American Pathologists and the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics cosponsor molecular proficiency testing for these disorders. Responses from 2006 to 2013 were analyzed for accuracy (genotyping and interpretations). RESULTS: Between 11 and 36 laboratories participated in each Tay-Sachs disease distribution. Samples tested per month were constant (2,900) from 2006 to 2011 but recently increased. Participants reporting <10 samples tested per month had longer turnaround times (42 vs. 7%, longer than 14 days; P = 0.03). Analytic sensitivity and specificity for US participants were 97.2% (95% confidence interval: 94.7-98.7%) and 99.8% (95% confidence interval: 99.1-99.9%), respectively. Of 11 genotyping errors, 2 were due to sample mix-up. Analytic interpretations were correct in 99.3% of challenges (956/963; 95% confidence interval: 98.5-99.7%). Better performance was found for Canavan disease and familial dysautonomia. International laboratories performed equally well. CONCLUSION: These results demonstrated high analytic sensitivity and specificity along with excellent analytic interpretation performance, confirming the genetics community impression that laboratories provide accurate test results in both diagnostic and screening settings. Proficiency testing can identify potential laboratory issues and helps document overall laboratory performance.

Three-year experience of a CAP/ACMG methods-based external proficiency testing program for laboratories offering DNA sequencing for rare inherited disorders.

PURPOSE: Thousands of genetic tests are now offered clinically, but many are for rare disorders that are offered by only a few laboratories. The classic approach to disease-specific external proficiency testing programs is not feasible for such testing, yet calls have been made to provide external oversight. METHODS: A methods-based Sequencing Educational Challenge Survey was launched in 2010, under joint administration of the College of American Pathologists and the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics. Three sets of Sanger ABI sequence data were distributed twice per year. Participants were asked to identify, formally name, and interpret the sequence variant(s). RESULTS: Between 2010 and 2012, 117 laboratories participated. Using a proposed assessment scheme (e.g., at least 10 of 12 components correct), 98.3% of the 67 US participants had acceptable performance (235 of 239 challenges; 95% confidence interval: 95.8-99.5%) as compared with 88.9% (136 of 153; 95% confidence interval: 82.8-93.4%) for the 50 international participants. CONCLUSION: These data provide a high level of confidence that most US laboratories offering rare disease testing are providing consistent and reliable clinical interpretations. Methods-based proficiency testing programs may be one part of the solution to assessing genetic testing based on next-generation sequencing technology.

Opportunities to improve recruitment into medical genetics residency programs: survey results of program directors and medical genetics residents.

PURPOSE: Approximately 50% of medical genetics residency positions remain unfilled each year. This study was designed to assess current recruitment strategies used by program directors, to identify factors that influenced trainees to choose medical genetics as a career, and to use these results as a foundation to develop a strategic plan to address the challenges of recruitment. METHODS: Two surveys were created, one for program directors and one for current medical genetics residents, to evaluate current recruiting efforts and institutional support for programs and to identify factors that helped trainees choose genetics as a career. RESULTS: Program directors identified the most successful recruiting methods as "direct contact with residents or medical students" and "word of mouth" (80%). Residents listed having a mentor (50%), previous research in genetics (35%), and genetics coursework (33%) as the top reasons that influenced them to enter the field. CONCLUSION: Geneticists should become more proactive in providing resources to students to help them understand a career as a medical geneticist and mentor those students/residents who show true interest in the field. Results of these surveys spurred the development of the Task Force on Medical Genetics Education and Training of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics.

Verification of performance specifications of a molecular test: cystic fibrosis carrier testing using the Luminex liquid bead array.

CONTEXT: The number of clinical laboratories introducing various molecular tests to their existing test menu is continuously increasing. Prior to offering a US Food and Drug Administration-approved test, it is necessary that performance characteristics of the test, as claimed by the company, are verified before the assay is implemented in a clinical laboratory. OBJECTIVE: To provide an example of the verification of a specific qualitative in vitro diagnostic test: cystic fibrosis carrier testing using the Luminex liquid bead array (Luminex Molecular Diagnostics, Inc, Toronto, Ontario). DESIGN: The approach used by an individual laboratory for verification of a US Food and Drug Administration-approved assay is described. RESULTS: Specific verification data are provided to highlight the stepwise verification approach undertaken by a clinical diagnostic laboratory. CONCLUSIONS: Protocols for verification of in vitro diagnostic assays may vary between laboratories. However, all laboratories must verify several specific performance specifications prior to implementation of such assays for clinical use. We provide an example of an approach used for verifying performance of an assay for cystic fibrosis carrier screening.

Evaluation of the human fragile X mental retardation 1 polymerase chain reaction reagents to amplify the FMR1 gene: testing in a clinical diagnostic laboratory.

Fragile X syndrome (FXS) is caused by the absence of a functional fragile X mental retardation protein (FMRP). In most cases, the molecular mutation is an expansion and consequent methylation of the CGG trinucleotide repeat in the 5' end of the FMR1 gene. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based assays that overcome the limitations of amplifying >100-150 CGG repeats have been designed. One such product, Human FMR1 PCR Reagents, can detect expanded mutation alleles without determining methylation status. We used this assay to amplify 70 clinical samples previously tested in three clinical laboratories, including 28 full mutation alleles, 17 premutation alleles, 6 gray zone alleles, and 21 normal samples (51 normal alleles including 5 homozygous females). The results were concordant with previously reported results. All full and premutation alleles were identifiable: repeat sizes are not assigned when the CGG repeat number is >200 and all full and premutation alleles were scored in the same category using this assay. All normal and gray zone alleles were within 0-1 repeat of their previously reported allele sizes. This method identified a mosaic premutation/full mutation pattern in 12/21 samples previously identified as full mutation only and in 5/7 samples previously reported as mosaic premutation/full mutation. These results demonstrate that this assay provides comparable results to the combination of PCR/Southern blot methodologies. Additional issues such as technologist time, reagent costs, turnaround times, and sample requirements are comparable to the PCR/Southern blotting assays currently utilized; however, methylation status cannot be determined using this assay. It is likely that PCR-only based assays will eventually replace previous methods for FXS and that Southern blotting or another methylation assay will only be utilized when determination of methylation status is necessary. This type of assay may also be utilized for other nucleotide expansion disorders.

Hereditary breast and ovarian cancer due to mutations in BRCA1 and BRCA2.

Hereditary breast and ovarian cancer due to mutations in the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes is the most common cause of hereditary forms of both breast and ovarian cancer. The overall prevalence of BRCA1/2 mutations is estimated to be from 1 in 400 to 1 in 800 with a higher prevalence in the Ashkenazi Jewish population (1 in 40). Estimates of penetrance (cancer risk) vary considerably depending on the context in which they were derived and have been shown to vary within families with the same BRCA1/2 mutation. This suggests there is no exact risk estimate that can be applied to all individuals with a BRCA1/2 mutation. The likelihood of harboring a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation is dependent on one's personal and/or family history of cancer and can be estimated using various mutation probability models. For those individuals who have a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation, several screening and primary prevention options have been suggested, including prophylactic surgery and chemoprevention. Once a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation has been identified in a family, testing of at-risk relatives can identify those family members who also have the familial mutation and thus need increased surveillance and early intervention when a cancer is diagnosed.

An intergenerational contraction of a fully penetrant Huntington disease allele to a reduced penetrance allele: interpretation of results and significance for risk assessment and genetic counseling.

We report on a healthy 50-year-old woman who sought predictive testing due to a family history of Huntington disease (HD). Her 73-year-old mother had recently been confirmed to carry an HD allele of 42 CAG repeats, and started to show symptoms of HD at age 68. Clinically diagnosed HD is present in the maternal grandfather, maternal uncle, and three maternal cousins. Molecular analysis of the HD CAG repeat region identified an allele with 38 CAG repeats in the consultand, giving evidence of allele size contraction from the maternal 42 CAG repeat allele. Mitotic stability of the CAG repeat was demonstrated in DNA from a skin sample with the same allele size (38). In addition to sex of the parent and size of the repeat, recent data analysis of intergenerational stability of the CAG repeat size suggest a gender effect of the offspring on the likelihood of allele contraction or expansion. Discussion of these results with this patient presented challenges in providing appropriate risk assessment for developing the disease herself as well as the future risk to her offspring.

Technical standards and guidelines for reproductive screening in the Ashkenazi Jewish population.

DISCLAIMER: These Technical Standards and Guidelines were developed primarily as an educational resource for clinical laboratory geneticists to help them provide quality clinical laboratory genetic services. Adherence to these standards and guidelines is voluntary and does not necessarily assure a successful medical outcome. These Standards and Guidelines should not be considered inclusive of all proper procedures and tests or exclusive of other procedures and tests that are reasonably directed to obtaining the same results. In determining the propriety of any specific procedure or test, the clinical laboratory geneticist should apply his or her own professional judgment to the specific circumstances presented by the individual patient or specimen. Clinical laboratory geneticists are encouraged to document in the patient's record the rationale for the use of a particular procedure or test, whether or not it is in conformance with these Standards and Guidelines. They also are advised to take notice of the date any particular standard or guidelines was adopted, and to consider other relevant medical and scientific information that becomes available after that date.

Development of genomic reference materials for Huntington disease genetic testing.

PURPOSE: Diagnostic and predictive testing for Huntington disease requires an accurate measurement of CAG repeats in the HD (IT15) gene. However, precise repeat sizing can be technically challenging, and is complicated by the lack of quality control and reference materials (RM). The aim of this study was to characterize genomic DNA from 14 Huntington cell lines available from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences Human Genetic Cell Repository at the Coriell Cell Repositories for use as reference materials for CAG repeat sizing. METHODS: Fourteen Huntington cell lines were selected for study. The alleles in these materials represent a large range of sizes that include important diagnostic cutoffs and allele combinations. The allele measurement study was conducted by ten volunteer laboratories using a variety of polymerase chain reaction-based in-house developed methods and by DNA sequence analysis. RESULTS: The Huntington alleles in the 14 genomic DNA samples range in size from 15 to 100 CAG repeats. There was good agreement among the ten laboratories, and thus, the 95% confidence interval was small for each measurement. The allele size determined by DNA sequence analysis agreed with the laboratory developed tests. CONCLUSION: These DNA materials, which are available from Coriell Cell Repositories, will facilitate accurate and reliable Huntington genetic testing.

Cystic Fibrosis testing among Arab-Americans.

PURPOSE: Limited data regarding the cystic fibrosis carrier frequency and mutation detection rate is available for Arab-Americans. We retrospectively determined the frequency of carriers among Arab-Americans undergoing preconception and prenatal carrier screening in our laboratories. METHODS: Between October, 2001 and June, 2005, we performed carrier screening on 805 Arab-Americans, testing for at least the original 25 mutations recommended by the American College of Medical Genetics. We compared our results to previously published studies among Arabic cystic fibrosis patients. We also performed diagnostic testing on seven individuals. RESULTS: Seven carriers were identified, with an observed carrier frequency of 1 in 115. The most common mutation we identified was W1282X (57% of the mutations detected), followed by DeltaF508 and R117H. Three of 7 patients with a known or suspected diagnosis had two identifiable mutations, including 1548delG, DeltaF508, W1282X, 2789 + 5G>A and R170H. CONCLUSION: The current recommended carrier screening panel includes only six mutations reported among Arabic cystic fibrosis patients, accounting for 37.1% of the mutations identified among this group. The addition of 1548delG, I1234V, H139L and 4010del4 as part of an extended screening panel would increase the detection rate to 66.3%, similar to the mutation detection rates in other races/ethnic groups.

Preconception and prenatal cystic fibrosis carrier screening of African Americans reveals unanticipated frequencies for specific mutations.

PURPOSE: It is recommended that cystic fibrosis (CF) carrier screening be made available to African Americans who are either pregnant or planning a pregnancy. We analyzed the carrier and mutant allele frequencies for African Americans undergoing CF carrier screening in our laboratories. METHODS: Between December 2001 and September 2003, we performed carrier screening for 2189 African Americans, testing for at least the 25 recommended mutations. RESULTS: A total of 33 CF carriers were identified. The most common mutations detected were deltaF508, G622D, R117H/7T, and G551D. The G622D allele frequency among African Americans was 0.18%. We did not detect any 3120 + 1G --> A carriers, although 4 were expected (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: When considering only the 25 recommended CF mutations, 1 in 75 African Americans screened in our laboratories were carriers (within the expected range, given a 69% mutation detection rate). The addition of 2 mutations, G622D and Q98R (incidentally identified while screening for ACOG/ACMG mutations), increased the observed carrier frequency to 1 in 66, which is not significantly different from the known African American carrier frequency of 1 in 65. The frequencies of several specific mutations detected were unanticipated, as was the absence of 3120 + 1G --> A carriers. Further studies on African American patients with classic CF are needed to examine the incidence of CF mutations that are not part of the current panel, such as G622D.